Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in New Haven Barstool (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Connecticut

Best Pizza in New Haven Barstool (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

214 Views

I’m a connoisseur when it comes to pizza, after sampling pies in all corners of the globe. So I jumped at the opportunity to review 12 different places that serve up slices in New Haven Barstool!

My pizza odyssey has been a lot of fun, but also somewhat daunting – there’s so many great pies out there! But fret not my fellow pizza lovers; I’ve sampled everything from basic Margherita to delectable artisanal pies so you can trust me for reliable recommendations.

So come with me as I seek out the best pizza in New Haven Barstool – you’re sure to find a pie that will tantalize your taste buds!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut

#1 Zeneli Pizzeria e cucina Napoletana

The atmosphere is great for tourists who want to get a feel of an Italian pizzeria. The restaurant also serves alcohol, which always adds another dimension to any meal!

In terms of food, the pizza is truly one-of-a-kind. They offer some vegetarian options, as well as dessert. I had a slice of their Margherita pizza and it was delicious! The crust was thin and crispy, with fresh tomatoes and cheese.

The only downside is that they don’t deliver, so you have to go there to get your pizza fix! But it’s definitely worth the trip! I highly recommend Zeneli Pizzeria e cucina Napoletana for its amazing pizza and Italian charm. It’s definitely one of the best places in New Haven Barstool for pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in West Haven!

#2 Pasta Eataliana Trattoria Napoletana

The first time I came to this restaurant, I was absolutely blown away. The Neapolitan-style pizza is what really got me excited. The crust is thin and light with an amazing crunch that’ll have you coming back for more. The dough has a perfect balance of sweetness and saltiness, making it irresistible.

The toppings are top notch too–everything from homemade sausage to artichoke hearts are included in their wide selection of choices. All the ingredients are incredibly fresh and flavorful, combining together to make a masterpiece of a pizza.

The staff at Pasta Eataliana Trattoria Napoletana has been nothing but friendly during my visits there. They take great care in ensuring that everyone enjoys the best pizza experience possible. The ambiance is also inviting and comfortable; it’s definitely a place you can relax after a long day of work or sightseeing around New Haven Barstool.

Simply put, if you’re looking for the best pizza in New Haven Barstool, Pasta Eataliana Trattoria Napoletana should be your go-to spot!

#3 Modern Apizza

I was instantly impressed when I stepped into Modern Apizza. The atmosphere is inviting and the restaurant has a pleasant vibe. I didn’t have to wait very long for my order either, which was great!

The pizza was amazing – it had a nice, crisp crust with just the right amount of charring from the oven. The cheese was flavorful and cooked perfectly. But the real winner here is the sauce – it had an irresistible hint of sweetness that set it apart from other pizzas I’ve had.

I can’t stress enough how great the pizza was at Modern Apizza. It’s so good that even some of my food critic friends were impressed! Additionally, it has something for everyone: there are vegetarian options and alcohol as well as dessert choices if you’re feeling sweet (which you definitely should be after eating such a delicious meal!).

The only downside to Modern Apizza is that they don’t offer delivery – although in this case, it’s worth going out of your way to try the best pizza in New Haven Barstool!

#4 Zuppardi’s Apizza

I love this spot – it has a great atmosphere for tourists, with cozy seating and a full bar. They even serve vegetarian options, which is great if you have dietary restrictions or are just trying to make healthier choices. And the best part is that they offer dessert! Now that’s something I can definitely get behind.

While I’m certainly no expert when it comes to pizza, I have to say that Zuppardi’s Apizza takes the cake when it comes to New Haven Barstool. The crust was deliciously crispy, the sauce was flavorful and just the right amount of spice, and you can choose from a variety of toppings to customize your pizza just how you want it.

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery – but this could be a blessing in disguise as we all know how soggy those delivered pizzas can get! So come on down and enjoy some of the best pizza in the city!

#5 One 6 Three

I had the chance to sample their Chicago-style deep dish, and it was awesome! The crust was crispy and flavorful and the cheese and sauce just melted in my mouth. It was delicious!

But that’s not all they offer – they also have some amazing thin-crust pizzas. Their Margherita pizza was heavenly! The hand-made dough is superb, and the marinara sauce they use adds a delightful flavor elemenent. Plus, the fresh mozzarella and basil were simply divine.

The atmosphere at One 6 Three is warm and inviting. From their inviting décor to their friendly staff, you’ll feel right at home here. And since there is plenty of seating – even a bar for those who want to sample some local craft beers – you won’t have any trouble finding a spot to enjoy your meal.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Haven Barstool, then you must stop by One 6 Three! Your taste buds will thank you for it!

#6 Casa Bianca Pizza New Haven

Upon walking into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a real treat. The decor perfectly encapsulated the classic Italian vibe with red-checkered tablecloths and a tiled oven visible from the counter. As soon as I took my seat, I got a whiff of the fresh dough baking in the oven and oh boy did it smell delicious!

I had the pleasure of trying their signature pizza—a thin-crust classic Margherita pie loaded with mozzarella and tomato that was simply divine. Every bite was bursting with flavor and the crust was soft yet crispy at the same time. To top it off, they weren’t stingy on toppings either which is always important to me!

The service at Casa Bianca Pizza New Haven was also quite remarkable. Our waiter, Michael, really put an emphasis on making sure we had everything we needed and that our experience exceeded expectations. He definitely deserves some credit for his professionalism as well— something you don’t often find in other restaurants.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in New Haven Barstool, then you need to check out Casa Bianca Pizza New Haven! Their traditional Italian fare along with attentive service make this place unmissable!

#7 Family Mediterranean Pizza

From the moment I stepped through the door I felt like family. The owners, who are actually related, were warm and welcoming. As soon as I sat down at the table, they brought over a small plate of complimentary appetizers that were absolutely delicious.

The pizza menu had so many great choices that it was hard to decide what to order! Finally, I settled on a Mediterranean style pizza with feta cheese, olives, and artichokes. It was fantastic – crunchy crust cooked perfectly to golden perfection and toppings that were so fresh you could taste the difference. Each bite was even more flavorful than the last.

I’d have to say this is one of the best pizzas I’ve eaten anywhere in my travels! With its light atmosphere and great food, Family Mediterranean Pizza is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in New Haven Barstool looking for some of the best pizza around.

#8 RAWA Mediterranean Fusion, Middle Eastern Food, Pizza Place

I’ve never had anything like it before. The menu is filled with unique, flavorful ingredients like zaatar, sumac, and feta cheese that make the pizza truly stand out from the rest. The thin crust gives you an amazing crispy texture beneath the sweet and savory toppings that melt in your mouth.

The staff at RAWA are friendly and attentive, always looking for ways to make their customers happy. They also have great beer selection that pairs perfectly with their delicious pies.

Overall I’d definitely recommend this place if you’re looking for a unique pizza experience in New Haven Barstool! You won’t regret it – in fact, you’ll probably walk away quite satisfied!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Hamden!

#9 Ernie’s Pizzeria

I’ve been to a lot of pizza restaurants, but none can compare with the delicious pies served at Ernie’s. Their crust is always crispy, the cheese has a delightful flavor profile, and their wide range of toppings ensures there’s something for everyone.

The atmosphere at Ernie’s is always welcoming and pleasant. The staff is friendly and courteous, making sure your experience is top-notch. I especially enjoy sitting outside on their outdoor patio while munching on a slice or two!

Their menu items are unique and creative, offering up some truly unique flavor combinations that you won’t find anywhere else. From classic pepperoni pizzas to savory white truffle creations topped with olive oil, Ernie’s never fails to please!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Haven Barstool, look no further than Ernie’s Pizzeria! Trust me when I say this place will not disappoint!

#10 Grand Apizza New Haven

From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this place was special. The pizza-maker was already hard at work making fresh pies and there was a delicious smell of baked cheese in the air!

I used my food critic powers to sample a few slices of their signature Grand Apizza New Haven pizza. It was absolutely delicious – the crust was thin and crispy and the combination of toppings were perfection.

The service here was great too! Our waiter knew all about the menu items and gave helpful recommendations for drinks that paired well with our pizza. He even brought us large plates to share.

Overall, I highly recommend Grand Apizza New Haven for anyone looking for the best pizza in New Haven Barstool. From the amazing pizza to the friendly service, this place is top notch!

#11 Frisco’s Pizza

It’s just the perfect place for an evening of deliciousness. From the moment I stepped through their doors, I knew I was in for something special. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a cozy fireplace in the corner and pizza boxes stacked high on every wall.

The menu at Frisco’s is packed full of delicious options. They have classic red sauce pizzas, white pizzas, thin crust pies, Chicago-style deep dish pizzas, stuffed pies and more. Their toppings are fresh and flavorful – from the pepperoni to the sausage to their house-made mozzarella.

But it’s not just about the pizza—the service at Frisco’s is top notch too! Their staff is always friendly and helpful, ready to offer suggestions or answer any questions you might have. They take great care in preparing your order as well—each pizza is cooked to perfection before being served.

The best part? The prices are very reasonable! It’s definitely one of the most affordable pizza places around. So if you’re looking for delicious pizza that won’t break the bank, Frisco’s Pizza is definitely the place for you!

#12 Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

The crust is just the right combination of crunchy and chewy, and the tastes are out of this world – a perfect blend of savory umami flavor with hints of sweetness. The large selection of topping options means that everyone in my group could find something they love. And if you’re up for it, definitely try out the clam pies. It’s a unique experience that’s well worth it!

The atmosphere at Frank Pepe’s is relaxed but still lively enough to feel like you’re part of something special. The waitstaff are friendly and make ordering easy, which is always appreciated when it’s busy. And the prices? Let me tell you – you won’t break the bank here!

Overall, I would highly recommend Frank Pepe’s Pizzeria Napoletana to anyone looking for a great pizza experience in New Haven Barstool. It certainly lived up to my expectations as the best pizza in town!