Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in New Hyde Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in New Hyde Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

72 Views

I’m no stranger to the joys of a good slice. In my travels, I’ve tasted some of the best pizzas around the world, so when I heard about New Hyde Park, I was intrigued. After visiting 12 different pizza places in the area, I’m ready to declare which ones serve up the tastiest pies.

So let’s dive right in. Here are my picks for the best pizza in New Hyde Park!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City

The pizzas are cooked to perfection in their brick oven, giving the slices a nice crunchy crust that is light and airy. Inside, the cheese is meltingly delicious and generous helping of toppings ensures that each bite is full of flavor.

But what makes Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City stand out is the unique selection of topping choices. There’s an herby pesto sauce as well as a hot chili oil-infused version — both taste amazing! For something a bit lighter, there’s a white pizza featuring ricotta, mozzarella and garlic that is simple yet delicious. And then there are all the classic pizza toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms and onions for those who prefer traditional flavors.

I would also be remiss not to mention the staff at Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City — they are friendly and always willing to recommend their favorite pies or help you create your own unique slice. The prices are reasonable too; you won’t break the bank by eating here!

All in all, I’m happy to declare Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City as having some of the best pizza in New Hyde Park. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience with plenty of topping options, look no further than this restaurant!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Queens!

#2 Green Olive Kosher Pizza and Falafel

My recommendation for anyone looking for a top-notch pizza experience is to order the Super Supreme pizza. I was thoroughly impressed with the combination of flavors and textures – it was delicious! The crust was crispy and the cheese had just the right amount of melty goodness.

I also tried their falafel, which was cooked perfectly. The texture of the falafel had just enough crunchiness on the outside, but still remained moist on the inside.

The atmosphere of Green Olive Kosher Pizza and Falafel is also a treat – it’s like stepping into a warm embrace! The staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming, making you feel like part of the family. Plus, their prices are more than reasonable – even better when they have promotions going on.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Hyde Park, look no further than Green Olive Kosher Pizza and Falafel! It’s guaranteed to bring a smile to your face with every bite.

#3 Eddie’s Pizza

I love how the owner, Eddie, is always at the restaurant and he always gives me a special welcome. He takes the time to explain the different types of pizzas and help me choose the one that’s just right for me. Plus, he’s even taught me a few cooking tips and tricks!

The pizza itself is amazing too! The crust has the perfect balance between crunchy and chewy, and each topping is fresh. Eddie puts a unique spin on every pizza I have tried so far; he adds complementary ingredients that combine to create tastes that are as complex as they are delicious!

Plus, if there’s anything else you need while you’re there, Eddie has got it covered. He serves up sides such as garlic knots, salads and wings – which go great with his signature ‘Eddie Special’ pizza.

If you’re ever in New Hyde Park looking for some of the best pizza around, definitely check out Eddie’s Pizza. You won’t regret it!

#4 Piccolo Gourmet

The interior is small and cozy, giving it a true Italian feel. The staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming. The secret to the amazing pizza lies with their delicious homemade sauce. The sauce is infused with herbs, garlic, and other ingredients that create an unforgettable flavor.

The crust is light and crunchy and adds the perfect foundation for everything else that goes into the pies they make. My personal favorite was the Pepperoni Pizza, which had a generous helping of pepperoni making it one of the most flavorful pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or an entire pie (or two!), Piccolo Gourmet won’t disappoint! The prices are fair, making it even more enjoyable. This definitely ranks as one of New Hyde Park’s best pizza spots… don’t take my word for it though – come try it for yourself!

#5 Village Pizzeria and Restaurant

I’ve tasted pizza in Italy, France, and even China, and Village Pizzeria and Restaurant ranks right up there with them. The thin crust has just the right amount of crunchiness – not too hard, but not soggy either. And the perfect combination of spices, herbs and other ingredients make for a truly delicious slice.

The atmosphere at Village Pizzeria is also spot-on. The decor isn’t overly fancy or showy – just an inviting, relaxed setting that’s perfect for taking your time over a lovely meal. Plus, the waitstaff are friendly and attentive!

Overall, I rate Village Pizzeria and Restaurant 5 out of 5 stars for having some of the best pizza in New Hyde Park. If you’re ever in town looking for a great slice, I highly recommend checking this place out – you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Vaccaros Pizza

The crust was perfectly cooked with the perfect balance of crunch and softness. Toppings were fresh and flavorful, not to mention very generous in portion. The sauce was delicious, with just the right amount of spices to give it a subtle kick.

I’m usually picky when it comes to pizza, but Vaccaros Pizza exceeded my expectations! I highly recommend trying their most popular pie: The Grandma Pie! It’s topped with tomatoes, garlic and basil – a combination you won’t find anywhere else.

As for customer service? It was friendly and attentive – nothing short of what you would expect from one of the best pizza restaurants in New Hyde Park. They even offer catering services for special events and parties!

To sum it up, if you’re looking for the best pizza in New Hyde Park, look no further than Vaccaros Pizza!

#7 Umberto’s Of New Hyde Park

The atmosphere of the restaurant is great. There’s a cozy and homey feel to it that makes you feel like you’re dining with family. Plus, it’s big enough for large groups!

The staff at Umberto’s are really friendly and helpful, which only adds to the experience.

As for pizza, they don’t disappoint! From their classic cheese pizzas to creative flavored pizzas like their “heavenly Hawaiian” pizza, there’s something here for everyone. Their pizzas have the perfect amount of sauce and cheese and those delicious toppings! Plus, they make all their own dough so it has that fresh-baked taste every time.

Overall, Umberto’s Of New Hyde Park is definitely worth a try if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in New Hyde Park. You won’t be disappointed!

#8 Previti Pizza & Papazzio Dining

As soon as I walked through the door, I knew I was in for a real treat. The aroma of fresh-baked dough filled the air and my mouth started to water. I sat down at a table and observed the chefs rolling out thin sheets of dough and tossing them high into the air with practiced grace. I knew this was going to be good!

I tried several different pies, from classic margherita to Sicilian-style slices with anchovies and capers. All of them were delicious, but my favorite was their signature ‘Previti Special’ which had a thin crust and lots of flavorful toppings like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and roasted peppers. It was truly heavenly!

The service at Previti Pizza & Papazzio Dining is consistently friendly and attentive too — nothing makes me happier than being surrounded by smiling faces when eating pizza! Plus, they offer all kinds of great deals like ‘Happy Hour’, where all pizzas are half price after 7 pm on Fridays.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in New Hyde Park then look no further than Previti Pizza & Papazzio Dining — it’s simply sublime!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Queens!

#9 Olivetto Pizzeria

They offer a wide variety of specialty pizzas that really stand out among others. Whether you’re craving roasted garlic and artichoke hearts, or Canadian bacon and pineapple, they have something for everyone! The crust is always delicious – crispy on the outside, soft and chewy inside – just the way I like it!

Best of all, Olivetto Pizzeria is family-run, which means you get a warm, welcoming atmosphere to enjoy your meal in. No matter how busy it gets, the staff is friendly and attentive – ready to help with whatever you need. And the prices are quite reasonable too; definitely worth your hard-earned money!

Overall, I would give this place 5 stars out of 5 for having some of the best pizza in New Hyde Park. If you’re ever in town looking for great food, make sure to stop by Olivetto Pizzeria!

#10 Positano Ristorante Pizza

I was so impressed with the quality of their pizza that I can confidently say it’s one of the best I’ve ever had. From their classic Margherita to their more adventurous ricotta and spinach, every bite is a flavor explosion. The crisp crust and fresh ingredients combine together perfectly in just the right proportions.

Their wood-fired oven ensures each pizza has an authentic texture and smoky flavor that you won’t find elsewhere. Plus, the staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about all their offerings, so you know you’re in good hands when ordering.

So if you’re looking for top-notch pizza in New Hyde Park, Positano Ristorante Pizza is the place to go! With fabulous flavors and cordial service, there’s no doubt you’ll be delighted with your meal.

#11 Rustica Brick Oven Cafe

Every bite of their pizzas is full of flavor and the crust is always hot and crispy — just how I like it. It definitely stands up to some of the best I’ve had in Italy! The toppings are also top notch as well. My favorite combo was the classic Margherita with burrata, which was truly heavenly.

Another great feature of Rustica Brick Oven Cafe is that they are open late on the weekends. That’s a lifesaver if you’re looking for a good slice after a night out.

Their prices are also reasonable, unlike some other places where you have to pay an arm and a leg for decent pizza.

Overall, I have no complaints about Rustica Brick Oven Cafe – they provide amazing pizzas at reasonable prices and their service is friendly too! If you’re ever looking for some great pizza in New Hyde Park, I highly recommend this place; it’s hands down the best pizza I’ve found around here.

#12 Luigi’s Pizzeria of Mineola

I’ll never forget the time I first set foot in Luigi’s – I was welcomed by the warm, inviting smell of freshly cooked pizza. It was like a little slice of heaven!

The menu is varied and surprisingly creative – they offer more than just your typical pepperoni and cheese! The specialty pizzas really showcase their culinary skills – there’s something for everyone, from the meat lovers to the veggie lovers.

But what really made me take notice of Luigi’s Pizzeria of Mineola were the crusts! Each pizza had its own unique flavor and texture, making them stand out from other places I’ve been to before. They weren’t too thick or too thin either – just perfect for a crust that holds up well to all those tasty toppings without getting soggy.

And we can’t forget about the delicious sauces – they have a great selection of traditional Italian flavors as well as some unique combinations for those looking to try something new.

In short, Luigi’s Pizzeria takes pride in creating amazing pies with fresh ingredients that will keep you coming back for more. As far as I’m concerned, it’s some of the best pizza in New Hyde Park – hands down!