Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in New Jersey Barstool (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in New Jersey Barstool (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

94 Views

In my latest review, I’ve put on my pizza aficionado hat and sampled some of the best pizzas in the area. After carefully tasting twelve unique places, I’m now ready to share my findings with you.

My approach is lighthearted and humorous, but I take pizza seriously because after all, it’s one of life’s great pleasures. So join me as we embark on a tasty tour to find the best pizza in New Jersey Barstool.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Curioni’s Pizza

Unfortunately, they don’t have the widest selection of toppings, but what they do have is always incredibly fresh and delicious. The crust is absolutely perfect – thin and crisp without being too hard. And the sauce isn’t overly sweet; it’s just right.

The atmosphere at Curioni’s Pizza is relaxed and friendly. It has a nice family feel, and you can count on getting great service every time you come here.

I’m not sure if I can definitively say that Curioni’s makes the best pizza in New Jersey Barstool, but I definitely think it’s one of the best! If you’re ever in the area, make sure to give Curioni’s a try – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Paterson!

#2 Napoli Wood Fired Pizza & Bakery

The first time I went in to try a slice I was blown away. The freshness and flavor of the dough, the perfect combination of toppings, and especially the wood-fired taste all added up to an experience like no other. It was so good that I had to go back for more!

And the price point is unbeatable. For just a few more dollars than a regular pizza, you can get something that tastes like it was made in the heart of Italy!

The atmosphere is also great; it’s laid-back and casual yet still has an upscale vibe. The service is fast and friendly, too – my go-to servers always remember my order without me having to remind them what it was.

I’ve been everywhere tasting pizza, but Napoli Wood Fired Pizza & Bakery takes the crown as some of the best pizza in New Jersey Barstool! Visit them soon – you won’t regret it.

#3 Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza

Their signature coal-fired crust is simply divine, offering the perfect texture and flavor. Paired with their delicious toppings and fresh ingredients, it’s an absolute must-try for any pizza connoisseur. The pizzas here come with a crispy outer layer and chewy center that really gives you that authentic Italian pizzeria feel.

The friendly staff at Del Ponte’s are always sure to provide excellent service and make sure you have the best experience possible. Plus, they offer delivery if you don’t feel like coming in for a slice!

And let’s talk about the price: You can get a large pie for around $15, which is more than reasonable considering how tasty their pies are. I’m sure you won’t find better pizza anywhere else in New Jersey Barstool!

#4 Outta Hand Pizza

My experience at Outta Hand Pizza was nothing short of amazing. From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the friendly staff and their delicious smells. The atmosphere of the restaurant is so inviting and cozy, it almost feels like you’re at home – just with better pizza!

I had the pleasure of tasting their signature ‘Outta Hand’ specialty pizza. It was truly a work of art – with a freshly-rolled thin crust, plenty of cheese and toppings, it all came together to create one amazing flavor combination. The combination of flavors was out-of-this-world!

The pizza alone is worth coming back for, but Outta Hand Pizza offers much more than just great food. They also have a wide selection of beverages to choose from, including some really nice craft beers.

If you’re looking for great pizza in New Jersey Barstool, look no further than Outta Hand Pizza! A must try for any pizza lover!

#5 Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant

I was instantly taken back by the fantastic service I received when I visited. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and they even have a kid’s menu on offer. And don’t get me started on the offering of alcoholic drinks – not only do they serve beer but you can also get hard liquor too!

The star of the show, however, is their pizza. I tried both their classic margherita pizza and a more creative concoction called the “Garden Delight,” which was topped with fresh vegetables and feta cheese. Both were perfectly cooked and absolutely delicious.

The downside is that Patsy’s doesn’t offer delivery so you’ll have to go in person to enjoy their delicious pies. Fortunately, it’s definitely worth the trip! They even have a range of delicious desserts available afterwards if you’re still feeling peckish.

Overall, Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant is an absolute must-visit for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in New Jersey Barstool!

#6 Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria

I’ve been to some of the fanciest Italian eateries in Europe, but the pizza at this joint is right up there. The crust is perfectly thin and crunchy on the outside while still maintaining a soft center. The sauce is savory and spiced just enough to keep you wanting more. Topped off with generous portions of mozzarella cheese and a variety of toppings – from pepperoni to mushrooms – prepare for an unforgettable pizza experience!

The atmosphere at Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria adds to its charm; casual but charming. Greasy spoon vibes meet old-fashioned New Jersey charm and leave you feeling like part of the family. Whether you dine in or take out, you won’t be shortchanged on flavor or hospitality.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in New Jersey Barstool, Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria is your place!

#7 Federici’s Family Restaurant

I was impressed by the mouth-watering menu offering a variety of toppings, as well as vegetarian and kid’s options. Of course, the highlight for me was their delicious hard liquor. You can enjoy a pint or two of your favorite brew while munching on some of the best pizza in town!

The atmosphere is also quite inviting and perfect for tourists. The staff is friendly and attentive, ready to serve you at any time. As an added bonus, Federici’s Family Restaurant offers one of the most amazing desserts I’ve ever tasted—absolutely delicious!

Of course, there’s one minor issue – no delivery service. But that’s a small price to pay for the fantastic range of dining options here at Federici’s Family Restaurant.

Overall, I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for great pizza in New Jersey Barstool!

#8 Lodi Pizza Restaurant

When you walk into the restaurant, you can already smell the savory pies cooking in the oven. The atmosphere is vibrant, with friendly staff and a lively setting. Plus, there’s always something new on their rotating specialty menu.

The pizza here is top notch! Every bite provides a perfect balance of flavors with a golden-brown crust and gooey cheese. Any fan of pizza would be lucky to have a slice here! Plus, their sauces are some of the best I’ve ever tasted.

Their dessert menu has some nice surprises as well – my favorite being their cannoli cheesecake! I’m rarely able to find such an exciting combination that still meets all my expectations! If you’re looking for something unique, this is it.

Overall, Lodi Pizza Restaurant is an amazing place to grab a slice or two (or ten). Whether you’re looking for the best pizza in New Jersey Barstool or something unique – this place has it all!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Hackensack!

#9 Brooklyn Boys Pizza & Deli

From the moment I stepped in the door, I knew I was in the right place. The aromas coming out of their kitchen were absolutely heavenly! A variety of delicious pies filled the warmth and comfort of this cozy little pizzeria.

I decided to sample one of each type of pizza they had in store. Each one was incredibly delicious, bursting with flavor and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. My favorite was definitely their classic margherita — it was so fresh that it almost melted on my tongue!

The staff at Brooklyn Boys Pizza & Deli were also great. They were very friendly and knowledgeable about their menu items, which made for a great customer experience. From conversations with them, I learned that they take great pride in using only locally sourced ingredients for all their dishes.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza New Jersey Barstool has to offer, then look no further than Brooklyn Boys Pizza & Deli. Be sure to stop by if you ever get a chance — you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Renato’s Pizza Masters

I arrived at Renato’s Pizza Masters and my taste buds were immediately tantalized by the smells of authentic Italian-style pizza coming from their ovens. I was warmly greeted by the owners, Renato and Lola, who welcomed me with open arms and showed me around their establishment.

The atmosphere was upbeat and friendly, but more than anything it was the pizza that drew me in. Renato and Lola took extra care to explain each step in the process of creating their pizzas, from hand-rolling dough to choosing quality ingredients. I could tell they put a lot of passion into their craft, which made me all the more eager to dig in!

My order was an eggplant parmesan pizza; it was simply mouthwatering. The crust was perfectly crispy with a delightful chewiness—it was just like what I had tried in Naples! The toppings were incredibly fresh and flavorful; I could really taste that the tomatoes were ripened onsite. It truly can’t be beat.

All in all, my experience at Renato’s Pizza Masters left me feeling full and satisfied from eating some of the best pizza in New Jersey Barstool. Whether you’re looking for a cozy night out or an unforgettable meal that will stay with you long after you’ve left, Renato’s Pizza Masters is definitely worth a visit!

#11 Star Tavern

What makes Star Tavern unique is the fact they serve alcohol and hard liquor. That’s right – you can have an ice cold beer while enjoying your slice of pizza! If you’re looking for a great spot to watch the game, this definitely should be at the top of your list.

Plus, Star Tavern has something for everyone – if you’ve got kids, there’s a special kid’s menu available. And if you’re feeling like a sweet treat after your meal, they’ve got dessert options ready to go.

Real talk though – I do wish they had delivery so I wouldn’t have to leave the house whenever I’m craving this delicious pizza! Overall though, Star Tavern makes for a great tourist spot or local hangout. Try it out – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Nancy’s Towne House

I recently visited this restaurant and was amazed by the amount of dedication put into each pizza. From house-made dough to fresh ingredients, you can taste the care that goes into each pie. Plus, they offer a great selection of alcohol including hard liquor so you can enjoy a cold beverage with your meal.

On top of great pizza, Nancy’s Towne House also has a kid’s menu available, plus offers dessert! So if you’re looking for something satisfying after your meal or just trying to impress the little ones, this is definitely the place for you.

The atmosphere was also great during my visit. Being located in a tourist spot gives visitors an excellent view and experience while enjoying their delicious slices. Plus, if you’re looking for any kind of sports game going on at the moment, they have that covered too!

My only nitpick here would be that they don’t offer delivery service – however this doesn’t affect how tasty their pies are in-house! All in all I highly recommend checking out Nancy’s Towne House if you’re ever in New Jersey Barstool – hands down one of the best pizza spots around!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant

Let me tell you – this place is a hidden gem tucked away in the heart of the Garden State. As soon as I walked through the door, I was hit with the mouthwatering smell of bubbling cheese and crispy crust. My taste buds were practically doing cartwheels in anticipation!

As a traveling food critic, I’ve had my fair share of pizza. From the streets of Naples to the bustling pizzerias of New York City, I thought I had seen it all. But let me tell you, Patsy’s knows how to make a pizza that’ll make you weak at the knees.

The crust is thin, delicate, and perfectly crispy. I could have sworn I heard angels singing as I took my first bite. And the toppings? Oh, don’t even get me started. They piled on the fresh mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and an array of delicious toppings that made my taste buds do a happy dance.

But what really sets Patsy’s apart is their attention to detail. The staff is not only friendly but also incredibly efficient. They take your order with a smile and have your piping hot pizza on your table in no time. And the ambience? It’s like stepping into an Italian grandmother’s kitchen – cozy, warm, and filled with love.

So, if you find yourself in north jersey and craving a perfectly thin crust pizza, head on over to Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you, and you’ll be planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your last slice.