Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in New Paltz (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in New Paltz (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

208 Views

I’m here to report that after having tucked into 12 pizza places in the area, I’m ready to reveal the best of the bunch.

But before we get down to business, let me tell you a little about my standards for a really tasty pie. I’ve tasted pizzas from all over the world and have some pretty high expectations. That said, I think New Paltz will surprise you!

It’s time to slice it up and take a look at what this town has on offer – join me as I break down which of these 12 pizza spots are truly A-1.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Apizza!

The crust has a light crunchiness, and the sauce and cheese are cooked to perfection. Every bite is filled with delicious, gooey goodness! And they don’t skimp on the toppings. From pepperoni to mushrooms, each topping was cooked to perfection.

I have to say that the service was top-notch as well. I always felt welcomed, and the staff was more than happy to answer any of my questions about their process or ingredients. I also appreciated that they gave me recommendations for new pies to try out every time I visited!

Overall, Apizza! quickly became one of my favorite pizza joints in New Paltz. If you’re looking for great pizza in New Paltz, look no further than Apizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Poughkeepsie!

#2 Twin Star Orchards

I arrived hungry and ready for an adventure, but I wasn’t expecting the classic charm of this historic building. The red brick exterior really sets the tone for your pizza-eating experience.

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately impressed by the clean and inviting atmosphere. The staff was friendly, helpful and knowledgeable about the menu items. I ordered a special that included pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and peppers – a combination that is not featured on their regular menu. It was delicious! The crust was perfectly crisp and golden brown with just the right amount of sauce and cheese.

The highlight of my visit though was visiting their orchard outside in their backyard where they grow some of the freshest ingredients that go into making their pizza. It’s a great way to get back to nature while enjoying delicious food at the same time!

If you’re looking for top notch pizza in New Paltz then look no further than Twin Star Orchards. They have all the flavors you could want plus an outdoor atmosphere to enjoy it in – what more could you ask for? Here’s to hoping I can make it back soon to try even more of their amazing pizzas!

#3 Brooklyn Cider House

The atmosphere of the restaurant is really nice, with a comfortable rustic vibe. The pizzas were delicious, especially the Margherita with buffalo mozzarella – my favorite! What really sets Brooklyn Cider House apart from other pizza places is their unique cider-based dough. It was light, yet full of flavor and added something special to each slice.

The staff at Brooklyn Cider House was also a real pleasure. They’re so friendly and it was great to get some recommendations from them on what pizza to try. On top of that, they kindly accommodated me when I asked for extra toppings and ingredients on my pies – definitely a plus!

I’m sure I’ll be back to Brooklyn Cider House soon; after all, it’s the best pizza in New Paltz!

#4 Rino’s Pizza

The first time I visited this spot, I tried their signature pepperoni and sausage pizza. The combination of the spicy pepperoni and smoky sausage was simply out of this world. And the crust! Wow, it was perfectly thin and crispy with a nice charred flavor – definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had.

The atmosphere at Rino’s is great too. They have a relaxed, family-friendly vibe that makes it a great place to take the kids or catch up with friends over a few slices. Plus, they have some awesome specials like half-price pizza on Monday nights or buy one get one free deals on Tuesdays. What’s not to love?

Overall, my experience at Rino’s Pizza was top notch and I highly recommend it for anyone looking for the best pizza in New Paltz. It’ll be hard to find better than this!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Kingston!

#5 Village Pizza

I’ve tried some amazing pizzas in my travels, from New York to Rome, but nothing compares to the delicious slices served up at Village Pizza. The crust is thin and crispy perfection, and the toppings are always cooked to absolute perfection. The pizza sauce is savory without being too overpowering; it’s just enough to add flavor without masking the other taste elements.

And then there’s the cheese! Oh boy, this is some of the creamiest, most flavorful cheese I’ve ever tasted – no exaggeration! Combined with the sauce and toppings, it’s truly a divine experience that cannot be replicated elsewhere.

If pizza isn’t your thing, they also have a great selection of other Italian dishes such as lasagna and eggplant parmesan. But why would you bother with those when you could have their amazing pizza?

So if you’re ever in New Paltz or passing through town, make sure you stop by Village Pizza for the best pizza in town! You won’t regret it!

#6 Pasquale’s

The atmosphere of this place is great – old-school Italian charm with a rustic vibe. It’s definitely a hidden gem and one of the best spots to grab a slice!

Their menu has something for everyone, from classic cheese and pepperoni to creative options like goat cheese and fig pizza. No matter what you’re in the mood for, you’ll find it here!

The pizza itself is divine. The crust is perfectly cooked every time and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. For me, it was love at first bite. Everyone who visits Pasquale’s will be glad they did!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Paltz, make sure to stop by Pasquale’s – you won’t regret it!

#7 Best Pizza

I’ve never been so impressed with a pizza joint in my life! From the moment I stepped in, I could tell this place was special. The atmosphere was inviting and the staff was friendly and helpful.

The pies were cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of charred edges and a nice bubbly crust. The toppings were fresh and delicious, and they had a great selection to choose from. My favorite topping combination had to be the sausage, mushrooms, and pepperoni – it was an explosion of flavor!

To top it off, their prices were very reasonable for such good quality food. For only $10 I got a medium-sized pie that would easily feed two people!

All in all, Best Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza places I have ever visited – it’s definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in New Paltz. Trust me when I say that you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 37 more pizza places in Hudson!

#8 Gourmet Pizza

When I walked into Gourmet Pizza, I was immediately impressed by the atmosphere. The decor was inviting and rustic, and I could tell they really put effort into making it a great experience. The friendly staff greeted me with a warm smile, which made it even better!

The pizza itself was outstanding! It had just the perfect amount of cheese and the crust was crunchy yet soft on the inside. The flavor of each topping was distinct but meshed together perfectly. By the time I finished my slice I wanted more.

If you’re in New Paltz looking for some great pizza, Gourmet Pizza is definitely your best bet! Their selection is vast and all of their pizzas are absolutely delicious. They’ve earned my seal of approval for being one of the best pizza places around. Enjoy!

#9 La Bella Pizza Bistro

The first thing that strikes me about this place is the atmosphere. It’s cozy, welcoming and absolutely perfect for an evening out with a few friends or a romantic dinner for two. The staff are friendly and really make you feel right at home as soon as you walk in the door.

Now onto the main event – the food! La Bella Pizza Bistro uses only the freshest ingredients and each pizza they serve is cooked to absolute perfection. I tried several different pizzas during my visit, including a classic margherita, an Italian-style veggie pizza and one topped with sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms – all delicious! Everything comes out quickly so you don’t have to wait long to enjoy your meal.

To top it off, La Bella Pizza Bistro offers some amazing desserts too – from tiramisu to cannoli, they’ve got it all.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Paltz then La Bella Pizza Bistro should be your first stop. Absolutely delicious pizza, great atmosphere and genuine hospitality make this place a must-visit for anyone looking for an unforgettable dining experience.

#10 Rocco’s Pizzeria

The first thing that struck me when I visited Rocco’s was the atmosphere—it’s a cozy little spot with a warm and inviting vibe. The menu is extensive, offering both traditional Italian pizzas as well as gourmet creations. The service was friendly and helpful, making sure to explain all the options thoroughly.

And then there’s the pizza itself—absolutely delicious! Every bite was bursting with flavor and had just the right amount of crunch. Whether it’s classic Margherita or something more inventive like their signature White Truffle pizza, they have something for everyone.

In short, Rocco’s Pizzeria has got some of the best pizza in New Paltz without question. Whether you’re looking for an intimate dinner with friends or just want to grab a slice on the go, this is definitely one spot you don’t want to miss out on!

If you’re willing to go an extra 17 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Newburgh!

#11 A Tavola Trattoria

The atmosphere is great for both locals and tourists, so no matter who you are, you’re sure to feel welcome. Even better, the restaurant serves alcohol – perfect for any occasions!

Then there are the pizzas themselves. They don’t skimp on quality ingredients – you get what you pay for. Plus, the crusts are cooked to perfection. Every bite is unbelievably delicious!

Unfortunately they don’t offer delivery service (which I’ve come to expect when it comes to pizza), but that’s a minor complaint overshadowed by all the positives! And what really seals the deal is their selection of insanely good desserts – definitely some of the best I’ve tried in my travels.

In conclusion, A Tavola Trattoria has earned my seal of approval for having some of the best pizza in New Paltz – and I’m not easily impressed when it comes to pizza!

#12 Original La Stazione

I’ve had pizza in many different countries, but none of them comes close to the deliciousness and quality of Original La Stazione. From their signature deep dish pies to their thin crust options, I was near overwhelmed by all of the mouth-watering possibilities.

The staff at Original La Stazione is also incredibly friendly and accommodating. Whether you want a unique creation or just the classic margherita pie, they take the time to make sure you get exactly what you’re looking for.

Of course, it wouldn’t be pizza without some excellent sides and beverages to accompany it. Original La Stazione offers an impressive selection of craft beers, wines, and other tasty drinks that pair perfectly with any pizza choice. They also offer traditional Italian desserts like cannoli and tiramisu for those with a sweet tooth.

Overall, there’s no doubt that Original La Stazione serves up some of the best pizza in New Paltz! If you live in the area and your taste buds are begging for some great slices, head on over to this gem. You won’t be disappointed!