Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in New Port Richey (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in New Port Richey (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

331 Views

I’ve been all over the world, tasting pizza from famous pizza joints and mom-and-pop shops. After twelve visits to New Port Richey’s pizza places, I’m confident I’ve found the best of the best.

Let me take you on a journey with my reviews to help you find the perfect slice. Warning: this is a humorous journey, so if you’re looking for serious and formal critiques, look elsewhere!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Vinny D’s New Port Richey Pizza

At Vinny D’s, they have all the classic pizza toppings to choose from and even a few vegetarian options. The crust is perfection and the cheese is perfectly melted and bubbly. They also offer dessert pizzas with a variety of topping choices!

The only downside I found with Vinny D’s is that they don’t offer delivery so if you’re craving their great pizza, you’ll have to get up off the couch and pick it up yourself.

But when it comes down to it, I can confidently say that Vinny D’s New Port Richey Pizza has some of the best pizza in the city – so don’t miss out on this delicious experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Tarpon Springs!

#2 Brother’s pizza

At first glance, I was hesitant to enter the restaurant because it had a simple and unassuming façade. However, the aroma of freshly cooked pizza soon changed my mind. Upon entering the establishment, I was warmly welcomed by the friendly staff and smiling faces of customers indulging in their pizzas.

The interior was wonderfully decorated and themed with classic Italian influences that added to its charm. To begin my pizza journey at Brother’s, I decided to try their signature Meat Lovers Pizza. The crust was perfectly crisp without being too crunchy. The flavors of the meat were succulent, juicy, and full of flavor – all just blending together in perfect harmony.

If you’re looking for something a bit lighter, the Hawaiian Pizza is definitely worth a try! The combination of sweet pineapple with savory bacon was delightful and quite unique. The cheese ratio on this particular pizza was spot on as well, making it truly enjoyable.

Overall, Brother’s Pizza is easily one of the best places to get a slice in New Port Richey; not only is the atmosphere inviting but also the food lives up to expectations!

#3 Masa Sub and Grill with a Touch of Mediterranean

The first thing that struck me was the delicious aroma of freshly made dough wafting through the restaurant. It was immediately obvious that this place takes pride in their pizza! The crust was thin and crunchy, not too thick like some places I’ve been to. The tomato sauce was fresh and flavorful, and the cheese…oh man, it melted in my mouth!

In addition to their signature pizzas, they also have a variety of unique topping combinations that are sure to please any taste buds. My favorite combination was their Mediterranean veggie pizza-it had everything from artichoke hearts to feta cheese! I could swear there were Greek gods smiling down on me as I devoured this slice.

I am proud to say that Masa Sub and Grill with a Touch of Mediterranean has earned my highest rating for pizza. If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Port Richey – look no further than Masa Sub and Grill!

#4 Leaning Tower of Pizza

I arrived at the restaurant skeptical, but was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was welcoming and inviting; the staff were friendly and attentive. The real surprise was their menu – a delicious variety of classic Italian pizzas and unique specialties.

As for the pizza, well: it was simply divine! With its perfect blend of flavors, each bite tastes better than the last. From classic margherita to wild creations like the Big Bertha – they have something for everyone. Even more impressive is that their traditional Italian style pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven, giving them an authentic wood-fired flavor.

But what really sets Leaning Tower apart is their commitment to fresh ingredients and old-world traditions. Their passion for creating delicious pizzas shows in every bite!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Port Richey, then look no further than Leaning Tower of Pizza. Whether you’re feeling adventurous or just want some good ol’ fashioned comfort food, this place has something for everyone – all delivered with a smile!

#5 Rossi Ristorante Italiano

The first thing that struck me was the delicious aroma of freshly-baked pizza coming from their ovens. And it didn’t disappoint! The pizza here was simply divine, with a perfectly crispy crust, a generous blend of tangy tomato sauce and fragrant herbs, and all topped with an abundance of cheese.

The atmosphere at Rossi Ristorante Italiano is also charmingly rustic, with its wooden furniture and friendly staff. The service was top notch too – my server was friendly and knowledgeable about their menu and wine list.

Overall, if you’re in New Port Richey looking for the best pizza around, I’d recommend you head straight to Rossi Ristorante Italiano – you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Second City Eats

When I walked in, I was immediately charmed by the rustic feel of the place. The decor was simple yet inviting, with dark wood accents and cozy booths. It had all the hallmarks of a classic pizza joint, yet still managed to feel modern and inviting.

The menu was extensive but not overwhelming; there were plenty of options for those who are indecisive like myself. I decided on a classic margherita pizza, and it arrived at my table piping hot! The dough was perfectly light and fluffy on the inside, with just enough crunch from its thin crispy exterior – truly delicious!

And then there’s the tomato sauce: flavorful and herby, it really hit the spot. Topping off this magnificent creation were creamy burrata cheese and fresh basil leaves. Every bite was an explosion of flavor!

All in all, Second City Eats serves up some seriously good pizza – definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in New Port Richey!

#7 Slice of Life Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped inside, I was welcomed with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The walls were decorated with old-school Italian photographs, giving me a true feeling of being in Italy!

The waitstaff was friendly and knowledgeable, giving me great recommendations on how to best enjoy my pizza. When my pizza arrived at the table, it looked like it had been cooked by the patron saint of pizza himself! The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy while the tangy tomato sauce added just the right amount of zing.

I went with traditional toppings for my pie: pepperoni and sausage. But man – oh man – these toppings weren’t anything like your typical grocery store pepperonis and sausages! These were savory morsels of flavor that only an expert chef could create.

Overall, Slice of Life Pizzeria has my vote for best pizza in New Port Richey. Not only is the atmosphere inviting, but their pizzas are some of the most delicious I’ve ever had the pleasure to sink my teeth into!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Palm Harbor!

#8 Olivia’s Subs & Pizza

Now that I’ve made my declaration, let me explain what makes Olivia’s pizza so special. The crust is light and fluffy, with just the right crispiness. The sauce is not too sweet and not too acidic, it’s perfectly balanced! And their homemade cheese blend makes every bite an absolute delight – it’s the perfect combination of stretchy cheese and savory flavor.

But it doesn’t stop there! Olivia’s Subs & Pizza also offers a wide selection of toppings – from classic pepperoni to more exotic ingredients like artichoke hearts. It makes for a truly customizable experience that ensures no two slices are ever the same.

To top it all off, the service at Olivia’s Subs & Pizza is top-notch. The staff are friendly, attentive and always willing to answer any questions you may have. They make sure your order is hot and fresh when it hits your table – something I really appreciate after coming to so many pizzerias where they don’t seem to care about quality control.

In conclusion, I’d strongly recommend visiting Olivia’s Subs & Pizza if you’re looking for the best pizza in New Port Richey. The delicious food combined with great service has definitely earned them a spot on my list of favorite pizza places!

#9 Country Pizza & Italian Grill

The restaurant looks like a typical Italian restaurant with white table cloths and vintage decor, which I appreciate as a food critic. The staff was friendly and accommodating which just added to the ambiance.

When my pizza arrived out of the wood fired oven it looked so inviting that I had to snap a picture for my friends back at home. I was amazed at how flavorful the pizza was, especially considering that it only took moments to prepare. The crust was perfectly crisped with a hint of charring from the open flame and the ingredients were fresh and tasty- definitely not your standard frozen disc from a fast food joint!

In my opinion, Country Pizza & Italian Grill is one of the best places for pizza in New Port Richey. I give this place five stars for atmosphere, taste and quality ingredients!

#10 Angies pizza

I arrived at the restaurant and was immediately impressed with the atmosphere. The walls were adorned with photos of pizza from around the world, and I could smell the delicious aroma of freshly baked crust and melted cheese.

The menu had a great variety of options and I opted for a traditional margherita pizza – it certainly lived up to my expectations. The crust was wonderfully crunchy yet light, the tomatoes and cheese perfectly melted together, and there was just enough basil for flavor. Every bite was perfection!

To top it off, the service was friendly and efficient without sacrificing quality. They got me a fresh pizza in no time, which is important when you’re as hungry as I am!

There’s no doubt in my mind that Angies pizza is one of the best places to get pizza in New Port Richey – I highly recommend you try it out yourself!

#11 Morty’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped inside, I was impressed. The decor is bright and inviting, with plenty of comfortable seating. The staff were all very friendly and accommodating, which made me feel right at home.

When it comes to the food, Morty’s Pizza is simply outstanding! The crust is thin and crunchy, just like a good pizza should be. The toppings are generous and full of flavor – from their classic pepperoni to unique creations like their “Flaming Hot Fajita” pizza. Every bite was an absolute delight!

If you’re looking for great pizza in New Port Richey – look no further than Morty’s Pizza! Whether it’s for a special occasion or just a casual dinner, Morty’s has something for everyone – even picky eaters! So head on over to Morty’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Back Draughts

First of all, a huge benefit to Back Draughts is that they offer dessert. Wow, what a treat! I can never say no to a good dessert after devouring pizza.

Additionally, it is an awesome tourist spot. Everywhere you look there are people enjoying themselves and taking in the atmosphere. They have bright colors and great music which makes for an enjoyable time.

On the downside, this restaurant does not deliver so if you are looking for your pizza to come directly to your door, you will be disappointed!

Overall, I highly recommend Back Draughts as the best pizza destination in New Port Richey. You won’t regret it – I guarantee it!