I must admit that I was a bit dubious at first. After all, there’s a lot of pizza to be had out there in the world, and I’ve tasted some truly exceptional pies during my travels. However, the range of pizzerias in New Rochelle certainly held its own against the competition.
With 12 places to choose from, I took it upon myself to conduct an exhaustive review process — after all, you should never skimp when it comes pizza!
What follows is my list for the best pizza in New Rochelle, illuminated with the peculiar wit only one who has tasted pizza on every continent can provide.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York
#1 Pizzeria La Rosa
- Serves alcohol
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The first thing that grabbed my attention when I arrived at Pizzeria La Rosa was the aroma of fresh mozzarella seeping out through the doors. I knew right away that this pizza joint was the real deal!
Once inside, I was in awe of the open kitchen and all of the delicious ingredients they had to offer. They even make their own house-made dough every day!
I decided to try two small slices of classic margherita pizza to get a sense for what they’re all about. Wow, these were some of the best slices of pizza I’ve ever encountered in my life. The crust was perfectly cooked and lightly crunchy around the edges. The sauce was slow-cooked with fresh herbs and just enough garlic kick that left me wanting more. And finally, the cheese—it was heavenly! Simply put, there’s no better tasting pizza than Pizzeria La Rosa’s!
The staff at Pizzeria La Rosa were also incredibly helpful and friendly throughout my visit, which is always a plus in my book. All in all, this place is a must-visit if you’re looking for some truly amazing pizza in New Rochelle.
If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Mt Vernon!
#2 Dantoni’s Pizza
The minute I walked in, the mouthwatering aroma of their homemade pizza dough made my taste buds dance. Every inch of the restaurant oozed charm and authentic Italian flavor. From the stone ovens to the rustic wooden tables, I felt like I was truly transported to Italy!
But let’s get down to business – what about the pizza? Oh, boy. It was heavenly! Each slice was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Their ingredients were fresh and flavorful – no microwaves used here! Even their sauce was top notch – one of their specialties is a blend of garlic and oregano that really adds a unique kick to their pies.
Overall, Dantoni’s Pizza is one of the best pizza places I have ever been to – definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in New Rochelle!
#3 4 Bros Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
The place has a welcoming atmosphere and the staff is super friendly. I was immediately impressed by their warm hospitality and knowledge of their ingredients.
I got to sample several kinds of pizza, including classic cheese and pepperoni, thin-crust white pizza, and one of 4 Bros Pizza’s signature pies. Let me tell you: all were outstanding! The crust had just the right amount of crunchiness and flavor, while the toppings were deliciously fresh and flavorful.
But what really set 4 Bros apart from other pizzerias was its commitment to quality. All ingredients are sourced locally whenever possible for maximum freshness, cooked with care and served piping hot to perfection. Some places cut corners with pre-made sauces or frozen ingredients — but not here!
If you’re looking for truly great pizza in New Rochelle – look no further than 4 Bros Pizza! Their delicious pies will have you coming back time again. Trust me – that’s something I know a lot about!
#4 Fratelli Pizza & Pasta
I had the pleasure of trying the Margherita pizza, and it was simply to die for. The crust was perfectly thin and crisp, with just the right amount of char. It was light and fluffy on the inside, just like it should be.
The topping combination was spot-on – fresh tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and fragrant basil leaves sprinkled over the top. It tasted like a dream! I couldn’t get enough of it.
The service here is phenomenal – everyone is friendly and eager to please. They took time to explain each dish in detail and made sure that my order arrived on time. As if that wasn’t enough, they even offer a loyalty program so you can save up points every time you come back!
Overall, Fratelli Pizza & Pasta has some of the best pizza in New Rochelle – no doubt about that! So why not treat yourself to a delicious slice or two (or ten!) during your next visit? You won’t regret it!
#5 Sal’s Pizza II
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The first time I visited Sal’s Pizza II, I was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a cozy pizzeria feel. The staff was friendly and accommodating, and the menu had something to satisfy everyone’s palate.
When it came to the pizza itself, I can honestly say that Sal’s Pizza II is one of the best places for pizza in New Rochelle. Their Neapolitan-style pies are cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven that gives them a unique smoky flavor.
I have to mention their homemade dough as well; it’s light and fluffy, with just the right amount of crunch on the outside. Toppings wise, they offer all sorts of unique combinations – from traditional favorites like pepperoni and mushrooms to specialty toppings like prosciutto and arugula pesto!
Overall, my experience at Sal’s Pizza II was nothing short of amazing. If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Rochelle, this is definitely the place for you!
#6 Posto 22
- Has insanely good dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
When I first stepped into Posto 22, the smells of freshly baked dough and homemade sauce filled my nostrils in the most delicious way. The wood-fired pizza oven was brightly lit, making me want to try one of their famous pies right away!
The menu is filled with classic Italian dishes like Margherita pizza and Fettuccine Alfredo, as well as unique combinations like Truffle Carbonara Pizza and Four Cheese Ravioli. The chefs at Posto 22 have really put a creative spin on traditional Italian cuisine.
When I finally tried one of their pizzas, it was truly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The thin crust had just the right amount of crunchiness to it that made every bite perfect. Toppings were generous yet well balanced, making sure that each slice was neither too heavy nor too light.
The service here is also top notch – friendly and attentive waitstaff who make sure to take care of your needs. Prices are reasonable for the quality offered (though you might want to save room for dessert).
Overall, if you’re ever in New Rochelle looking for some great Italian food (and especially some amazing pizza), Posto 22 has got you covered!
#7 AJ’s Burgers
- Serves alcohol
- Has insanely good dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
When I arrived, I was delighted to see the restaurant oozing with vintage charm. The decor was delightful and kitschy, while still remaining classy. The smell of freshly cooked pizza filled the air and my mouth started watering in anticipation.
As soon as I sat down, my waiter greeted me and took my order. While patiently waiting for my food to arrive, I noticed the friendly atmosphere at AJ’s Burgers. Everyone sitting around me seemed to be having a great time!
When my pizza arrived, it exceeded all expectations! The crust was cooked perfectly and had a light crunch that melted away in your mouth. The toppings were fresh and flavorful and the cheese was deliciously gooey.
To top it off, AJ’s Burgers has some of the most affordable prices around town which is rare for high-quality pizza! All in all, you can’t go wrong with a visit to AJ’s Burgers if you’re looking for the best pizza in New Rochelle!
#8 Pizza Centre
The first thing that caught my eye was the selection of pizzas: from classic pies to gourmet creations, there’s something for everyone. The menu is always changing so I never get bored with the options. Next, I noticed how fresh the ingredients were. Each component was flavorful and not overwhelming, making for a well-balanced pizza.
Speaking of balance, I have to mention the crust. It’s cooked just right – crisp on the outside and light in the middle – and doesn’t overpower the toppings like lesser pizzas do. It’s almost like they make each one manually!
Aside from great pizza, Pizza Centre also has an impressive Italian food selection. From spaghetti to calzones, their kitchen really knows what it’s doing!
Lastly, what really impressed me about my experience at Pizza Centre was the service. Everyone who works there is personable and willing to answer any questions I had about their menu or cooking techniques. They even went out of their way to provide helpful suggestions about other restaurants in town!
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in New Rochelle, then look no further than Pizza Centre!
If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Yonkers!
#9 Modern Restaurant & Lounge
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
- Great place to watch sports
- Has insanely good dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere alone is worth the visit. From the modern decor to the sophisticated lighting, it’s one of those places that allows you to feel comfortable and sophisticated at the same time.
Of course, it’s the pizza that brings me back! The thin crusts are cooked to perfection and made with only the freshest ingredients. The cheese is rich and creamy, while the toppings are always flavorful and plentiful. And I can never get enough of their signature sauce; it’s simply divine!
The service is also top-notch; they’re always friendly and attentive. They even have a special feature where you can watch them make your pizza from scratch! It really adds to the experience. Plus, their staff always go out of their way to make sure you have a great time.
I would definitely recommend Modern Restaurant & Lounge for anyone looking for that perfect slice or two (or three!). It’ll undoubtedly be my go-to spot when I’m craving pizza in New Rochelle!
#10 Saccone’s Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere was great – the restaurant has a cool, Italian vibe and the staff were friendly and helpful. Plus, it’s located right off the main street so I didn’t have to trek too far out of my way.
When it came time for pizza, I was impressed. They use fresh ingredients and a delicious sauce that added great flavor to each bite. And I’m talking about thin crust pizzas here! The cheese melted in my mouth and had an excellent texture. It definitely takes ‘pizza’ to the next level!
I also got to try their garlic knots which were roasted to perfection with Parmesan on top – yum! Saccone’s Pizzeria really knows how to serve up some amazing food!
Overall, this place must be commended for its fantastic pizzas. Definitely the best pizza in New Rochelle – go try for yourself!
#11 Cestra’s Pizza 4
From the moment I stepped in, I knew this place was gonna be special. The atmosphere was so inviting, with the friendly staff smiling and welcoming me, and the tantalizing aromas from the kitchen were something else!
As for their pizza, it’s out of this world! They offer a wide variety of toppings, but their signature pies are delicious. The crust is thin yet crispy, topped with just the right amount of cheese and savory sauce. And let me tell you, every bite is worth savoring.
To top it off, Cestra’s Pizza 4 also offers delicious sides like garlic knots and salads that pair perfectly with their pies. Plus, their prices are more than reasonable.
In summary, no matter if you’re a local or a traveler passing through New Rochelle – Cestra’s Pizza 4 is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for the best pizza around!
#12 Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe
- Offers dessert
The ambiance of Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe is unbeatable. From the classic brick oven to the cozy feeling you get when you walk in, it’s an atmosphere like no other. But let’s be honest, I’m here for the food – and this place delivers!
The pies are always cooked to perfection with a perfect amount of tomato sauce and cheese. When it comes to toppings, they have anything you can think of, from sausage and pepperoni to roasted squash and even vegan options! No matter what your preference is, there’s something for everyone.
It’s clear that Alfredo takes great pride in what he makes – and it shows. The crust is just the right amount of crunchy yet still has that classic Italian flavor we all love. I was even more impressed with how quickly my pizza was delivered too – usually if I’m getting delivery from somewhere new, it takes forever; not here though!
Overall, if you’re looking for a great slice of pizza in New Rochelle – look no further than Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe! One bite and you’ll be hooked!
