Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in New Tampa (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in New Tampa (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

86 Views

From extreme Pieology in the north, to Papa’s Pies in the south, I’ve got all your pizza bases covered. Through my travels around the world, I’ve tasted pizza from every corner and picked out twelve of the best for a showdown.

So come with me on an epic culinary journey to sample some of New Tampa’s savory slices and cheesy crusts. It promises to be a saucy adventure as we explore New Tampa’s best pizza places!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Napoli Pizza

I’ve been to all the major pizza paradises, and none of them compared to the mouth-watering delight that was Napoli’s. The crust was perfectly structured with a crispy, golden texture that made every slice irresistible. Each topping was fresh and flavorful – my personal favorite pizza was Napoli’s signature ‘Diablo’.

But what impressed me most about Napoli Pizza was the amazing selection of toppings they had on offer. From roasted pepperoni to garlic mushrooms, you’re sure to find something that’ll tantalize your taste buds! The staff were also incredibly friendly, taking time out of their day to ensure I had a great experience.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Tampa, look no further than Napoli Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Tampa!

#2 Sbarro

Their signature dishes really stand out, as each slice is cooked to perfection in their brick oven. The pizzas are topped with fresh vegetables, flavorful sauces and delicious cheeses that will tantalize your taste buds.

The best part is that Sbarro offers a variety of different toppings that you can mix and match to create your own unique pizza experience. Whether you’re looking for classic pepperoni or something more exotic like pineapple, they got it all!

The atmosphere of the restaurant is also top-notch. It’s spacious enough to accommodate large groups and there’s a cozy corner if you want to enjoy some privacy while indulging in pizza heaven. Plus, the wait staff is always friendly and attentive – what more can I ask for?

Sbarro has definitely earned its spot among the best pizza places in New Tampa – don’t miss this opportunity to sample some of the finest pizza around town!

#3 Pomodoro Pizza

From the moment I stepped in, the atmosphere had me hooked with its vintage charm. The walls were filled with old photographs and the smells of oregano and garlic hit my nose as soon as I walked through the door.

The staff was friendly and accommodating and let me choose from an impressive selection of pizzas. From traditional Margherita to more adventurous toppings like truffle oil and wild boar sausage – there was something for everyone!

I decided on a classic pepperoni pizza with a side of garlic knots. To say it blew me away would be an understatement! The crust was thin yet crunchy, light yet robust with flavor featuring a tomato sauce that was tangy and flavorful. The pepperoni was cooked to perfection, each bite bursting with juicy goodness. And who knew garlic knots could taste so delicious?

All in all, Pomodoro Pizza exceeded expectations and proved why it’s one of the best pizza spots in New Tampa. Highly recommended!

#4 The Grill At Morris Bridge

The pizza is cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven that gives it an amazing flavor. The crust is crispy on the outside and deliciously chewy on the inside, and the toppings are cooked just right.

I also loved their unique selection of toppings – from classic pepperoni, sausage and olives to some of the more unusual combinations like lemon, basil and prosciutto. They even do a dessert pizza with Nutella, strawberries and marshmallows – yum!

The atmosphere is relaxed and fun, making for a great night out with friends. The staff were all friendly and helpful, making sure our orders were served quickly.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in New Tampa then The Grill At Morris Bridge can’t be beaten. Delicious pizza with great service – what more could you want?

#5 Capri Pizza-N-More

The pizza here is truly a one-of-a-kind experience. From the first moment I stepped foot in the restaurant, I quickly noticed their signature “Capri” crust – light and airy yet still packed with flavor. But the real star of Capri Pizza-N-More is their sauce – it’s an incredible blend of herbs, spices, and cheese that’ll leave your mouth watering.

The toppings are just as impressive. The pepperoni was well cooked but still retained its delicious flavors. The mushrooms were fresh and flavorful as well! Ultimately though, it’s the overall combination that makes this place so special – they do an incredible job of blending all of these components together to create an outstanding pizza.

In addition to being incredibly tasty, the staff at Capri were friendly and welcoming too! It was clear that they take great pride in providing guests with top notch service. That alone makes them stand out from other pizza places in New Tampa.

To put it simply, Capri Pizza-N- More is my go-to spot for great pizza in New Tampa – I’d wholeheartedly recommend checking it out!

#6 Mei’s World Pizza Salads

This place had all the fixings of a great pizza joint – from the friendly staff to the delicious pies coming out of the oven.

The atmosphere was perfectly inviting: with bright colors and colorful decorations, it felt like I was stepping into some kind of culinary wonderland. It was clear that I was going to have a great meal!

To start with, their menu had classic Italian staples that were cooked to perfection. From thin-crust New York-style pies to thick Sicilian-style slices, there’s something for everyone here. The combination pizzas and salads were also impressive – you can get creative with toppings!

But what really stole the show for me was the specialty pies. They had unique topping combinations like pineapple and bacon, mushrooms and garlic, or even jalapeño and sausage! The crusts were light and airy – definitely not too doughy – while the flavors were bold enough to stand up against any pizza in town.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in New Tampa then Mei’s World Pizza Salads is your best bet. I definitely recommend this place – it’s a must-try!

#7 Blaze Pizza

When I first stepped into Blaze Pizza, I was greeted by the smell of freshly-baked crust and bubbling cheese. From the moment I walked in, I knew I found a little slice of heaven for pizza lovers!

The staff was friendly and accommodating. After placing my order, they quickly got to work crafting the perfect pizza. They let me customize it with all sorts of goodies…pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, olives – you name it!

When my pizza finally arrived at my table, it looked better than anything else I had seen before. The crust was thin but crispy and golden brown on the edges. It was topped with just enough cheese – not too much to be overwhelming, but enough to make every bite ooze with deliciousness.

I also appreciate that everything at Blaze Pizza is made fresh with quality ingredients. The pepperoni wasn’t soggy or greasy like some places. You could actually see and taste the difference!

If you’re looking for truly great pizza in New Tampa, look no further than Blaze Pizza! It’s sure to satisfy even the pickiest of pizza critics like me!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Tampa!

#8 Taste of New York Pizzeria

Their crust is perfectly crispy and just firm enough to hold the wide range of toppings, like pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage and anchovies. The amount of cheese they use is just right – not so much that it overwhelms the flavor of the sauce, but just enough cheese to make it gooey and delicious. They also load up on herbs and spices in their sauce which really elevates the flavor.

I must admit I was a bit skeptical when I first walked in. The decor isn’t anything fancy and their prices are very reasonable. But after tasting one bite, I was a believer! Not only was this some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere but it’s also affordable to boot!

If you’re looking for good pizza at an even better price, Taste of New York Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out. It’s not going to win any awards for atmosphere or high-end ingredients but it certainly earns its title as having some of the best pizza in town!

#9 Via Italia wood fired pizza

For starters, the atmosphere of the restaurant is really inviting. The wood-fired oven in the corner is always churning out delicious creations, and the smells fill the room. You can practically taste it just from walking in! All of their toppings are fresh and flavorful too – you can tell they take a lot of pride in their ingredients.

The pizza itself is basically perfection. I’ve had so much pizza in my travels but this was something special. The crust was crunchy, yet still had a little that slight chewiness to it and the toppings were cooked to perfection – not too soft or charred. And every bite was as flavorful as the last! It’s no wonder why I think this spot has some of the best pizza in New Tampa.

I’d definitely recommend Via Italia wood fired pizza to anyone searching for great pizza – no matter where they are in the world!

#10 Cappy’s Pizzeria Tampa Palms

As soon as I entered this unassuming pizzeria, I could tell that it was special. From the cheery staff to the mouth-watering aroma of dough being prepped for pies, I knew I had stumbled upon something special.

The menu featured an impressive array of pizzas, ranging from classic pepperoni to more daring concoctions like smoked chicken, onion focaccia, and even alligator sausage! After settling on a few signature pies, I eagerly awaited my order.

What arrived at my table was nothing short of remarkable. The ingredients on the pizza were of supreme quality and the flavors combination was perfection in harmony – a testament to Cappy’s expertise and effort going into every pizza they craft. There were no skimping on shoddy toppings or stale crust here; this establishment clearly takes pride in what they serve up to their patrons.

A good meal deserves a good drink – and Cappy’s Pizzeria Tampa Palms certainly has you covered there as well! They offer an impressive selection of craft beers, wines and soft drinks. My favorite is the signature house beer crafted right here in New Tampa – it pairs wonderfully with their pizza!

I’m pleased to declare that Cappy’s Pizzeria Tampa Palms is indeed the best pizza in New Tampa. If you’re looking for first-rate pies done right without compromising quality for price then look no further than Cappy’s Pizzeria Tampa Palms!

#11 Bruno’s Pizza Pie Inc

I stopped in while traveling through the area, and one bite of Bruno’s pizza was all it took to convince me that I had found a real winner. From the freshly stretched dough to the perfectly balanced toppings, this pizza was a taste sensation!

That first bite led to another, and then another – before I knew it, my slice of pizza was long gone! But I was still craving more. Lucky for me, Bruno’s Pizza Pie Inc can whip up special orders if you tell them what you’re craving. So I put in an order with extra cheese and pepperonis – and WOW! Those few extra ingredients really made the flavor shine through.

The best part? The prices at Bruno’s Pizza Pie Inc are surprisingly affordable – so much so that I didn’t even think twice about ordering two additional slices. When you compare quality to cost, there really isn’t a better deal out there when it comes to finding good pizza in New Tampa.

In conclusion? If you’re ever in need of some truly delicious pizza in New Tampa, make sure you stop by Bruno’s Pizza Pie Inc. You won’t be disappointed – trust me!

#12 NY Times Square Pizza

Upon entering the restaurant, it’s simply a wonderful sight. The decorations make it feel like you’re actually in Times Square! The staff is friendly and inviting, and the atmosphere exudes a feeling of comfort.

The pizza itself was nothing short of amazing. All the ingredients are fresh, and there is something for everyone to choose from. Whether you like plain cheese or want to get creative with toppings, they have everything covered. The crust was cooked just right – crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside, just how I like it!

Overall, this place is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in New Tampa looking for pizza. In my opinion, NY Times Square Pizza has some of the best pizza around.

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Cappys Pizzeria

From the moment I walked into Cappys, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of freshly baked pizza dough mingled with the aroma of melted cheese and savory toppings. And let’s not forget the best part – they serve alcohol! Nothing pairs better with a delicious slice of pizza than a cold, refreshing beer. Cheers to that!

But the benefits don’t stop there. Cappys also offers a delectable selection of desserts. I mean, who can resist ending their pizza feast with a slice of tiramisu or a warm, gooey chocolate lava cake? It’s as if they knew I needed something sweet to balance out all that cheesy goodness.

And did I mention that Cappys is a nice tourist spot? With its cozy, rustic interior and friendly staff, it’s the perfect place to indulge in some local flavor. Plus, it’s located in the heart of Tampa, making it easily accessible to both locals and tourists alike.

However, there is one downside to Cappys. They don’t accept reservations. So, if you’re planning a pizza night with a large group of friends, be prepared to wait. But trust me, the wait is worth it. Just think about all that cheesy, deep-dish goodness waiting for you at the end of the line.

So, if you find yourself in Tampa and craving some mouthwatering deep dish pizza, look no further than Cappys Pizzeria. With its delightful combination of delicious pizza, refreshing drinks, and sweet treats, it’s sure to satisfy even the pickiest of pizza connoisseurs like myself. Bon appétit!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped foot into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of freshly baked dough wafted through the air, beckoning me to the nearest table. As I perused the menu, I couldn’t help but marvel at the variety of toppings available. They had everything from classic margherita to adventurous combinations like BBQ chicken and bacon.

Now, I consider myself somewhat of a pizza aficionado, so I take my crust very seriously. And let me tell you, Grimaldi’s knows how to do thin crust right. It had the perfect balance of crispy edges and a chewy center, with just the right amount of char from the wood-fired oven. It was like biting into a slice of heaven.

And let’s not forget about the toppings! Each ingredient was fresh and bursting with flavor. The tomato sauce was tangy and robust, the cheese was gooey and melty, and the meats were perfectly seasoned. Every bite was a delightful explosion of taste in my mouth.

The service at Grimaldi’s was equally as impressive. The waitstaff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that my glass of water never went empty. They even had a sense of humor, cracking jokes and engaging in lighthearted banter with the customers.

All in all, Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is a definite must-visit for any pizza lover in Tampa. Their thin crust pizza is a work of art, and their friendly atmosphere only adds to the experience. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Wood Fired Pizza Wine Bar

When I stepped into the restaurant, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly baked dough mixed with the smoky scent of a wood-fired oven. It was like walking into a pizza lover’s paradise.

I couldn’t help but chuckle at their clever names for pizzas. Who would have thought a pizza called The Woodchuck could be so delicious? It was loaded with toppings like caramelized onions, crispy bacon, and gooey mozzarella cheese. And the crust! It was thin, yet perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. I could almost hear the crust whispering, Eat me, Edward!

The service was just as entertaining as the food. The servers had a great sense of humor, cracking jokes and making my dining experience unforgettable. One server even juggled pizza dough while singing an Italian opera. It was truly a sight to behold.

But let’s not forget the wine bar. The selection was extensive, with options to suit every palate. I took the liberty of sampling a few different wines to enhance my pizza experience. Hey, it’s all in the name of research, right?

In conclusion, if you’re in Tampa and craving wood-fired pizza, Wood Fired Pizza Wine Bar is the place to be. From the mouthwatering pizzas to the lively atmosphere, you won’t be disappointed. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I think it’s time to book my next flight to Tampa for another slice of heaven.