I’ve tasted pizza in cities all over the world, but was pleasantly surprised to find that the best pizza in New Jersey was right here in Newark. In exploring Newark’s pizza scene, I tried 12 of the most popular pizza places and was super impressed with what I found.
In this article, I’ll share my findings – a humorous and lighthearted review of the best (and sometimes worst!) pizzas Newark has to offer. Bon appetit!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Ellie’s Bistro
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere of Ellie’s Bistro is fantastic – cozy but stylish, with plenty of comfy seating and a vibrant vibe. The staff are friendly, attentive, and helpful in finding the perfect pizza for your palate.
When it comes to the food, let me just say: wow! I tried their signature dish – the ‘Deluxe’, which was a classic topping combination of mushrooms, olives and pepperoni – it had that unmistakable wood fired oven taste that I so enjoy. Other pizzas I tried included their Chicago-style deep dish, which was deliciously cheesy and had a perfectly crispy crust.
For dessert, the Tiramisu was really something special – creamy, sweet and light as air. Every bite melted in my mouth!
Overall, dining at Ellie’s Bistro was a pleasure. Not only do they serve up some of the best pizza in Newark NJ, but all the other dishes were top-notch too! It’s definitely worth trying out if you’re ever in town!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Union!
#2 Queen Pizza II
I was truly blown away by the quality of their pies. The crust was the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy, and the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness and spice. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, making every bite savory and delicious.
The restaurant itself had a cozy, family-friendly vibe that made me feel right at home. Plus, the prices were quite affordable, making this an even better experience.
To top it all off, the service was some of the best I’ve ever experienced in a pizza restaurant. Everyone on staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating, which made for an enjoyable dining experience overall.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Newark NJ, you have to give Queen Pizza II a try! After trying their pies, I’m now convinced that it’s one of the best spots to get pizza in town!
#3 Blaze Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The smell of the wood-fired ovens combined with the sizzling sound of their custom-made dough creates a pizza experience unlike any other. From the moment you walk in the door, you know that you are in for something special.
Their menu offers a variety of innovative combinations and traditional favorites, sure to satisfy everyone’s cravings. I especially enjoyed their signature Blaze Pizza which features a classic three cheese blend and zesty sauce. The combination really brought out the flavors and created a delightful mix of sweetness and tanginess.
The crust was perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside with a soft center that had just the right amount of chewiness. Topped off with fresh ingredients, it was truly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!
Apart from great pizza, Blaze Pizza also offers an inviting atmosphere with friendly staff who are always happy to make suggestions or customize your order. In my opinion, this is what sets them apart from other pizza places. So if you’re looking for some great pizza in Newark NJ, be sure to check out Blaze Pizza!
#4 Mulberry Street Pizza
- Offers dessert
On my most recent visit to the restaurant, I started off with the classic cheese pizza. I was amazed at how fresh and flavorful it was. The crust was just the right thickness and wasn’t too doughy. The toppings were also really fresh and tasty.
Next, I tried their signature white pizza with garlic, ricotta cheese, mozzarella and basil. This was heavenly! All of the flavors combined perfectly and each bite tasted like a little piece of heaven.
The service at Mulberry Street Pizza is always friendly and accommodating. They make sure that you are happy every step of the way from ordering to enjoying your meal. It’s clear that they enjoy what they do!
Overall, Mulberry Street Pizza has some of the best pizza in Newark NJ. From their fresh-tasting pizzas to their friendly staff, this place is truly a gem in New Jersey’s culinary scene.
#5 Nico’s Pizzeria & Grill- Subs
- Nice tourist spot
Never have I experienced such an amazing combination of flavor, texture, and presentation. The pizza crust was perfectly crispy yet still had a fluffy interior that melted in my mouth. And the tomato sauce used to top it off was out of this world! Every bite was a flavor explosion.
I also ordered one of their specialty subs which was much better than any sub I’ve ever tasted before. The bread was soft with just the right amount of crunchiness, and the vegetables were so fresh they practically exploded with each bite!
The service at Nico’s was absolutely wonderful as well. From start to finish, everyone involved in my meal made sure that I had a great experience. They were friendly and helpful throughout the entire process and made me feel right at home.
Overall, I highly recommend Nico’s Pizzeria & Grill- Subs for anyone looking for the best pizza in Newark NJ!
#6 Vinny’s Restaurant & Pizza
At first, I was skeptical of their claim to fame. But after just one bite of the crusty, chewy crust and gooey cheese, my skepticism quickly melted away.
The toppings were incredibly fresh; the combinations were perfectly balanced and complemented each other nicely. The sausage was juicy and flavorful, the mushrooms had a unique flavor that added complexity to the dish overall. The peppers provided a nice kick of spiciness that made every bite even more delightful.
The customer service at Vinny’s Restaurant & Pizza is also top notch. From start to finish they went out of their way to ensure our dining experience was as good as it could be. The wait staff were friendly and knowledgeable, and made sure that everyone there enjoyed their meal.
Overall, my visit to Vinny’s Restaurant & Pizza was great – I would highly recommend it! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Newark NJ then look no further than Vinny’s!
#7 Pizza Village Cafe
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
From the moment I stepped inside, I could smell the tantalizing aroma of pizza wafting in the air. The atmosphere was lively and inviting, and it was clear that the staff here loves their job.
The menu was extensive and included classic pizzas like pepperoni and Hawaiian as well as creative options such as eggplant parmesan pizza. When my order finally arrived, I couldn’t wait to take a bite! The pizza had a perfect thin crust that was crispy and deliciously golden brown on the outside but warm and soft on the inside. Topped with fresh cheese and high-quality ingredients, this pizza was truly mouthwatering.
Overall, Pizza Village Cafe provides an excellent experience with friendly service, an inviting atmosphere, and most importantly—some of the best pizza in Newark NJ! Highly recommended for all pizza lovers out there.
#8 Queen Pizza
- Offers dessert
The crust is perfectly baked and lightly crisped. The cheese is melted to perfection, and the toppings are always fresh as if they were picked yesterday. And don’t even get me started on the sauce–it’s like eating a cloud of flavor.
I’ve also gotta mention the atmosphere here. When you step through the door, it’s like stepping into a large Italian family gathering. Everyone seems so happy to be there, and you get greeted with a warm smile from everyone working in the kitchen.
The pricing is reasonable too, which is another bonus for Queen Pizza! You can get an individual pizza for around 10 dollars, or a small family size for only 30 dollars.
Queen Pizza offers consistently delicious food and unbeatable customer service at fantastic prices, making them by far the best pizza in Newark NJ!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Union!
#9 Brazilian Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
My first experience at Brazilian Pizza was nothing short of incredible. The pizza crust was light, airy, and cooked to perfection – a perfect foundation for the amazing toppings. Piled high with fresh vegetables and hearty meats, each bite was delicious. Even the cheese seemed like it had been specially crafted for this pizza!
The service at Brazilian Pizza is second-to-none. From friendly greetings to speedy delivery, they make sure you’re taken care of from the moment you order to when you take that last bite.
As a traveling food critic, I can confidently say that Brazilian Pizza truly has some of the best pizza in Newark NJ. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, be sure to check them out – your taste buds won’t regret it!
#10 Queen Pizza & Deli
- Has some vegetarian options
I’ve tried many pizzas — from tiny hole-in-the-wall places to fancy 5 star restaurants. But Queen Pizza & Deli has something special that the others don’t. The moment I walked in, I could tell this place was different.
The restaurant has a warm, inviting atmosphere and the staff are all friendly and helpful. But most importantly, their pizza is out of this world! The crust is thin and chewy, with just the right amount of crunch. The toppings are fresh and flavorful with unique combinations that will tantalize your taste buds. And their cheese? Oh man…it’s perfection – melted to perfection without being too greasy or oily.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Newark NJ, look no further than Queen Pizza & Deli. I highly recommend it – you won’t be disappointed!
#11 Robert’s Pizzeria
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere of the restaurant is charming, with an inviting interior, comfortable seating, and soft music playing in the background. The menu items range from traditional Italian favorites to unique creations. Even better: they offer delivery and catering services too!
When it comes to their pizza, Robert’s Pizzeria really takes things to another level. Their specialty pies are made with imported cheese and other high-quality ingredients that make for a truly delicious experience. From the crunchy crust to the perfectly balanced flavors, no detail has been overlooked — each slice is lip-smackingly good.
All in all, Robert’s Pizzeria is about as close as you can get to finding the best pizza in Newark NJ! I highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for an outstanding Italian meal.
#12 Mercato Tomato Pie
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere is laid back and inviting, and the staff are all friendly. The pizza dough was perfectly cooked – it had just the right amount of crunch and flavor to create a perfect bite each time. From the classic Margherita to an inventive Nutella-bacon combo, they have something for every palate.
My favorite part about Mercato Tomato Pie had to be their signature meatball pizza. It had a nice balance between sweet and savory that made it stand out from any other pizza I’ve ever had! And yes, they do have gluten-free options available as well.
Now for the best part: the price. Mercato’s prices are incredibly reasonable, so you don’t have to feel guilty splurging on their pizzas! You can get two large pies for $20 – a bargain compared to some other places in Newark NJ!
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Newark NJ, look no further than Mercato Tomato Pie! It’s hard not to crave their delicious pizzas after one bite! Make sure you try them out next time you’re in town – your taste buds will thank you later!
Best Thin Crust Pizza – Blaze Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Does not accept reservations
As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I must say that finding a pizza joint that makes a vegetarian drool is like finding a unicorn riding a rainbow. But Blaze Pizza did it! They have a fantastic menu with a variety of vegetarian options that will make even the most carnivorous among us reconsider their meaty ways.
Not only does Blaze Pizza offer mouth-watering thin crust pizzas, but they also have an array of delectable desserts to satisfy your sweet tooth. Who knew you could indulge in a heavenly Nutella pizza after devouring a whole Margherita pie? It’s like a food lover’s dream come true.
And speaking of dreams, Blaze Pizza is conveniently located in a prime tourist spot. So after satisfying your pizza craving, you can take a leisurely stroll and burn off those extra calories while exploring the charming town. It’s a win-win situation!
Now, let’s address the one downside of Blaze Pizza: they don’t accept reservations. As a food critic with a busy schedule, this was a bit of a letdown. But hey, who needs reservations when you can mingle with other pizza enthusiasts in the line and swap cheesy pizza jokes? Note to self: bring a book or make sure my phone is fully charged for those wait times.
So, if you’re on the hunt for the best thin crust pizza in central nj, look no further than Blaze Pizza. Just be prepared for the no-reservations policy and embrace it as an opportunity to bond with fellow pizza lovers. And don’t forget to leave room for dessert! Bon appétit!
