Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Newtown CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Connecticut

Best Pizza in Newtown CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

129 Views

After extensive research—which involved visiting 12 different pizza places—I’m happy to say that I’ve identified the absolute best.

Throughout my pizza-seeking journey, I’ve experienced the good, the bad, and the cheesy—as well as slices of every shape and size. Along the way, I’ve come to understand that a great pizza is so much more than just melted cheese and tomato sauce on a crust.

So buckle up and follow me as I take you on an adventure to discover Newtown’s top spots for some of the tastiest pies around!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut

#1 Good Old Days Pizza & Cocktail Den

The atmosphere of the restaurant is great – a mix of classic and modern style with lots of neon lights. And their selection of craft cocktails was pretty impressive, too.

But for me, the biggest selling point at Good Old Days is definitely their pizza. They have some serious Neapolitan-style pies that are sure to satisfy even the pickiest pizza connoisseur! Their crust had a perfect crunch and their toppings were top-notch. I especially enjoyed the smoked pepperoni and spicy sausage pieces they added – a nice touch!

Their prices may seem a bit high compared to other local pizzerias, but they’re well worth it. The quality here is unbeatable. Plus, you get your money’s worth with plenty of leftovers (at least I did).

Overall, Good Old Days Pizza & Cocktail Den is an excellent choice if you’re looking for the best pizza in Newtown CT. Whether you’re on a date or just grabbing a quick bite, it’s an experience you won’t soon forget!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Danbury!

#2 Nick’s Catering

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I could tell this place was all about pizza. The tantalizing aromas of freshly prepared pies were everywhere, and the staff were friendly and excited to serve me.

I took my seat at a table near the back, and went right for their specialty – a large pepperoni pizza with garlic crust. As soon as it arrived, my mouth began to water – so much flavor in one little pie! The dough was thin and crispy around the edges, while still remaining soft and tender throughout. The generous amount of cheese was melted perfectly and complimented by just the right amount of sauce. Top that off with plump pepperoni slices arranged artistically on top – pure perfection!

And let’s not forget about side dish options like cheesesticks, salads and garlic breadsticks that take your meal from great to extraordinary!

It’s no wonder Nick’s Catering has become such a local favorite in Newtown CT – they really do have some of the best pizza around. Whether it’s a quick lunch or dinner with friends, Nick’s Catering is sure to hit the spot every time.

#3 Project Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and family-friendly. I had to fight the urge to linger too long, since I was there strictly for business! But it was just that good.

The pizza was simply divine. The crust was the perfect combination of crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The cheese was gooey and flavorful, with a hint of smokiness from their wood-fired oven. Toppings were fresh and plentiful—there was something for everyone!

I even got to try one of their signature pies: “The Donut Pie.” It’s a pizza crust made from doughnuts, cream cheese topping, bacon bits, and Italian sausage. Delicious! If you’re looking for something truly unique in taste and texture, this is definitely worth a try.

All in all, Project Pizza is well worth a visit if you find yourself in Newtown CT looking for an amazing slice of pie. I give it five stars (out of five), hands down the best pizza in town!

#4 Franco’s Pizza & Pasta

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, and the service excellent. Before I even had to ask, the hostess brought me a delicious sampling of their appetizers to whet my appetite while deciding what to order.

The pizza was cooked to perfection: the crust was crispy with just the right amount of charring on it, and the toppings were cooked through evenly. The sauce was robust and flavorful with just enough zing to wake up your taste buds.

My favorite part of Franco’s Pizza & Pasta though had to be the pasta dishes! All of them were packed full of flavor and had unique ingredients that I wouldn’t expect from a standard Italian restaurant. From my Shrimp Carbonara to my Chicken Parmigiana, everything was fantastic!

I’d recommend this place for a cozy evening indoors or for an affordable dining experience for groups. Whether you’re looking for a hearty meal or pizza night with friends, Franco’s Pizza & Pasta is sure to hit all the spots!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Ridgefield!

#5 Capri’s

This pizza joint has an authentic, Italian ambiance that instantly sets the mood – it’s perfect for a casual night out with friends or a romantic date night. The staff is always friendly and attentive, so you know your order will be correct! Plus, their incredibly quick turn-around time ensures that you won’t spend extra time waiting for your food.

The pizzas here are simply divine. Their dough is light and fluffy and absolutely loaded with flavor! They also use the freshest ingredients available and every pizza I’ve tried here has been perfectly cooked. Whether you’re looking for something classic like pepperoni or something more adventurous like spinach artichoke, Capri’s has a plethora of delicious options to choose from.

What really sets Capri’s apart from the rest of the pizza places in Newtown, however, is their incredible specialty pies. One of my personal favorites is the eggplant parmesan calzone – it takes traditional pizza to the next level!

Ultimately, if you’re searching for some of the best pizza in Newtown CT (which you should be!), make sure to head to Capri’s – you won’t regret it!

#6 Newtown Pizza Palace

I was enticed by the delicious aroma of garlic, oregano and cheese that came wafting out of the restaurant when I opened the door. The interior had a cozy, old-fashioned feel that reminded me of a family gathering spot. The counters and tables were all nicely arranged with cheerful colors and decorations.

The staff was friendly and made me feel right at home as soon as I walked in. They asked questions about my pizza preferences while they quickly prepared my order of a classic pepperoni pizza.

When my pizza arrived, it looked almost too good to eat! The crust was perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunch on the outside – not too hard or soft. All the toppings were evenly distributed throughout the top, making for a delightful combination of flavors in each bite.

I can confidently say that Newtown Pizza Palace serves some of the best pizza in Newtown CT! From the tasty toppings to the perfect crust, this is definitely one you have to try for yourself – especially if you’re an avid food critic like myself.

#7 The Villa Restaurant & Pizza

From their delicious thin-crust Margherita to the classic pepperoni, I couldn’t help but be impressed by the sheer variety of pizzas on offer here. The crusts were perfectly crisp and crunchy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

And if you’re looking for something a little more special, they also have some vegetarian options! Plus, there’s even a kid’s menu so everyone will be happy.

What really sets The Villa Restaurant & Pizza apart from other pizza joints is that they serve alcohol – including hard liquor! And as an added bonus, they also offer dessert.

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery (which would make them even better!), but that doesn’t take away from the fact that it’s still one of the best pizza places in Newtown CT!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Shelton!

#8 Gino’s Parlor Of Sandy Hook

The service was great, the pizza was even better. The staff was attentive and helpful, providing us with all the information we needed to make an informed decision.

As for the pizza itself, I honestly can’t say enough good things about it. The crust was perfectly cooked, crispy on the bottom and still chewy on top. The toppings were generous, flavorful and creative – I had a delicious combo with sausage, onions and peppers that I would order again in a heartbeat.

To sum it up, Gino’s Parlor Of Sandy Hook is definitely worth checking out if you’re in Newtown CT looking for some of the best pizza around. Highly recommended!

#9 Carminuccio’s Pizza & Subs

I was really impressed with the options available for both meat-lovers and vegetarians alike – so everyone can enjoy a delicious slice. Not only did they offer great pizza, but they also had delicious dessert offerings too! It’s definitely a great spot for tourists to check out.

The only downside of this establishment is that they don’t offer delivery, so if you want to enjoy some of their amazing fare you’ll just have to visit the restaurant yourself. But trust me, it’s worth the trip!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Newtown CT, then look no further than Carminuccio’s Pizza & Subs. Highly recommended!

#10 Papa Al’s Pizza

I’m not one to mince words—Papa Al’s Pizza is simply the best pizza I have ever had. The crust was perfectly cooked, the perfect amount of cheese, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Plus, the sauces and seasonings added even more deliciousness to each tantalizing bite.

The atmosphere of Papa Al’s Pizza was also amazing! It wasn’t too loud or crowded like other pizza restaurants, it was just right. There was a relaxed vibe that made me feel comfortable and relaxed as soon as I walked in.

The service was top-notch too! From the moment I arrived, until when I left with my take-away box, every single person working there made sure that my experience was nothing less than memorable.

All in all, if you are looking for some seriously excellent pizza in Newtown CT then look no further than Papa Al’s Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Bridgeport!

#11 Lions Bleecker Street Pizza of Newtown

When I first arrived, I was skeptical. The restaurant had an unassuming exterior, but after tasting the pizza I quickly changed my mind. The crust was perfectly cooked and chewy; it held the topping in place without getting soggy. As for the toppings, they were heavenly! Every bite of pepperoni melted in my mouth like butter. The sauce was sweet and flavorful without being overwhelming – seriously, it’s some of the best sauce I’ve ever tasted!

I’m also impressed with their other menu options. They have an array of calzones, strombolis, salads, subs and more. And you can’t go wrong with dessert – try their giant apple pie or a slice of chocolate cake for something special.

Overall, Lions Bleecker Street Pizza is the best pizza joint in Newtown CT that I’ve visited in years. If you haven’t tried it yet – make sure you do! You won’t be disappointed.

#12 Tivoli Pizza & Trattoria

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting with a big stone oven in the corner, the perfect accompaniment to any meal. The service is friendly and attentive – no one ever rushes you out the door like at some pizzerias!

Now let’s talk pizza. They offer an impressive variety of recipes and toppings, so I had to try a few slices. The margherita was my favorite; it was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of cheese and tomato sauce. But don’t worry if you’re not into classic pizza – they also have some interesting combinations that will surprise your taste buds.

All in all, I can confidently say that Tivoli Pizza & Trattoria serves up some of the best pizza in Newtown CT! It’s definitely worth trying out if you’re ever in town – trust me, it’ll be love at first bite.