Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Naples FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Naples FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

198 Views

I’ve had the privilege of tasting pizza in some of the world’s greatest cities, from Naples, Italy (of course!) to New York to Chicago. But you don’t have to cross an ocean to find a truly amazing slice – or more accurately, 12 delicious slices.

In this article, I’ll review the best pizzerias in Naples FL that I’ve had the fortune of visiting and tasting. Get ready for a wild ride as I share with you what makes these pizzas so good (and so bad). Whether you’re looking for a classic Italian-style pie or something more unique, I promise you’ll find something tasty here! Let’s get started.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Rio Pizzeria

I was skeptical when I first stepped in, but their ovens are blazingly hot and they take pride in the quality of their ingredients. The crust is perfectly cooked with a golden-brown char, the sauce is just right – not too sweet, not too spicy – and the ratio of cheese to toppings is spot on.

The menu also has a great selection of signature pies, each one better than the last! The White BBQ Chicken Pizza is definitely my favorite – it has just the right balance of flavors and always comes out of the oven hot and fresh.

The presentation at Rio Pizzeria is also top notch. Every pizza looks like a work of art with toppings that have been neatly arranged so that every bite delivers maximum flavor.

If you’re looking for phenomenal pizza in North Naples FL, look no further than Rio Pizzeria! They’ve got some of the best pizza around and I guarantee you won’t be disappointed.

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Bonita Springs!

#2 La Villa On 5th

The atmosphere is fantastic – it really feels like you’re in Europe (you know, minus the jet lag). But more importantly, the pizza is outstanding. They are perfect for those who appreciate a nice thin crust with just the right amount of melted cheese.

Plus, as a food critic, I can also vouch for their dessert – it’s worth getting your hands sticky for!

The only downside to La Villa On 5th? No delivery. So if you’re looking to have your pizza delivered to you by some friendly folks on scooters, this restaurant isn’t your best option.

But alas, don’t let that stop you from experiencing what might just be the best pizza in Naples FL!

#3 PIZZATA PIZZERIA + APERITIVO

I was especially impressed with their creative menu. I had the ‘Tropical Pizza’, which had pineapple, anchovies, and a blend of Italian herbs. The flavors were so bold that I almost couldn’t believe it! It was delicious.

The service was great too. From the moment I walked in, the staff was extremely friendly and helpful. They made sure to answer all my questions and gave some great recommendations on the different pizzas they make.

I must say the crust here is simply amazing – golden brown and slightly crispy, just like real Neapolitan pizza should be! It wasn’t too thick or thin; it even had a hint of sweetness that made it perfect for this particular style of pizza.

Overall, PIZZATA PIZZERIA + APERITIVO offers up some truly remarkable pies, making them one of the best pizza places in North Naples FL! If you’re ever in town, make sure to stop by; you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Naples

The first thing that struck me was the atmosphere—it’s cozy, inviting and warm. The staff are friendly and make you feel right at home.

The pizza itself is exquisite! I had the “grandma” style with a thin crust and tons of cheese, along with the classic marinara sauce. It was like tasting a piece of heaven on my tongue! The ingredients were fresh, flavorful and cooked to perfection—no one slice tasted better than another. It was literally finger-licking good!

In addition, the sides were delicious. The garlic knots were to die for and the salads were so crisp and flavorful I couldn’t help but go back for more.

To top it all off, their prices are extremely reasonable for what you get. You can easily feed two or three people with one pizza – definitely an amazing deal!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in North Naples FL then look no further than Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Naples! They have great food at great prices and an atmosphere that will make you feel right at home. What more could you ask for?

#5 ZZA BABY Pizza Bar Naples

The atmosphere was great – the restaurant is quaint and romantic, with rustic wooden tables and vintage lighting. The staff were super friendly and eager to help you through the menu.

I tried a variety of their pizzas – the Margherita, Marinara and Prosciutto – they were all delicious! The crust was light, crisp and fluffy, while still having a smoky, wood-fired char. The sauces were rich and flavorful without being too overpowering. And the toppings were fresh and generous in quantity.

And the best part? Their prices won’t break the bank! For what they offer it’s surprisingly affordable.

If you’re looking for an authentic pizza experience in North Naples FL, ZZA BABY Pizza Bar Naples is certainly worth a visit!

#6 Fabio’s pizza

I was so impressed with the pizza here that I’m still dreaming about it! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, yet still nice and chewy. The sauce tasted like it was made from fresh tomatoes and herbs straight from the garden. And the cheese…well let’s just say it was divine!

The toppings were also top-notch. They had a variety of different options to choose from, but I opted for salami, olives, anchovies and artichoke hearts – all of which were extremely flavorful. On top of that, there was a generous sprinkling of garlic and oregano which added some great depth of flavor to the pizza.

Overall, Fabio’s pizza is easily some of the best pizza in Naples FL. It exceeded my expectations in every way possible – from the incredible ingredients used to make the pizza to how well it was cooked. If you’re ever in Naples looking for an amazing slice (or two!), then Fabio’s should definitely be your first stop!

#7 Vesuvio’s Pizza

The pizza dough is light and airy with a delightful slightly crunchy crust, creating a perfect balance between texture and flavor. The toppings are hearty and flavorful, with a wide selection of meats and vegetables to choose from. The combination of fresh mozzarella cheese, homemade tomato sauce and unique ingredients such as artichoke hearts makes this pizza one-of-a-kind.

The atmosphere at Vesuvio’s Pizza is great too – lively yet relaxed, with cozy booths perfect for sharing slices of their delicious pies. The smiling waitstaff make sure that every customer leaves happy and always come back for more.

Overall, I’d highly recommend Vesuvio’s Pizza for anyone looking for the best pizza in Naples FL! Deliciously crafted pies with great service make it an unforgettable experience. If you haven’t tried it yet, what are you waiting for?

#8 Dominick Pizzeria

The ingredients are what make Dominick’s pizza stand out from the crowd. The dough is made fresh daily, you can taste the quality in every bite. They use the finest Italian ingredients and prepare them with skill and care. From the flavorful tomatoes to the savory cheeses and salmon-infused crust, this place knows how to make sure your pizza is one of a kind!

As far as toppings go, they have plenty to choose from! From traditional pepperoni and sausage to more exotic options like anchovies and smoked salmon, there’s something for every palate.

The atmosphere at Dominick Pizzeria is warm and inviting as well. The staff is friendly and helpful, making sure all customers have a wonderful experience. The restaurant itself has a rustic yet modern feel to it with exposed brick walls and dark leather booths that give it an industrial-chic vibe.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Naples FL, then Dominick Pizzeria needs to be on your list! Whether you’re going for a quick slice or a full meal for your family, you’ll be glad you visited. I know I am!

#9 Luigi’s Pizza

I stopped by this charming restaurant and was immediately taken in by the delicious smell of freshly cooked pies. Upon entering, I noticed that the decor was classic Italian – everything from checkered tablecloths to a big painting of the owner on the wall.

The service here is exceptional – Luigi takes care of each customer like they’re family. He even took the time to tell me about all of his different kinds of pizza such as his signature stuffed crust and his unique offering of a ricotta and bacon pie.

When my pizza arrived, I could tell that it had been cooked to perfection with just enough cheese, sauce and spices to make it absolutely mouth-watering. The crust was thin and crispy and each topping seemed to have been carefully chosen for each pie he made.

Luigi’s Pizza is an absolute must-visit for anyone in Naples FL looking for some great pizza! Not only will you get some of the best pizza in Naples FL, but you’ll also be given personalized service that can’t be beat.

#10 LowBrow

The restaurant itself has a charmingly eclectic atmosphere. From the hilarious décor to the mismatched furniture, this place looks like it was decorated by Tim Burton. And the staff are wonderfully friendly!

As for the pizza… oh my! The crust is light and crispy, with just the right amount of garlic and herbs. The cheese is savory and rich, making every bite delightful. The toppings are savory and fresh, with a generous portion of pepperoni on every slice.

I also tried a few of their gourmet pizzas. My favorite was the Tropical Paradise—it’s topped with mango salsa and grilled pineapple! So tasty you’ll want to come back for seconds!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Naples FL, your search is over: LowBrow is here to save the day. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town!

#11 Industry Pizza & Slice Shop

The restaurant is always vibrant and inviting with a casually chic atmosphere that lends itself to plenty of socializing. The menu features a variety of options including classic Italian-style pizzas, Sicilian-style pies, deep-dish Chicago-style pizzas and even some inventive creations with unique toppings like artichoke hearts, pears, and smoked gouda.

I ordered the signature Industry pie which was topped with generous portions of pepperoni, Canadian bacon and sausage. The crust was perfectly toasted with just the right amount of chewiness – not too thick or thin. The sauce had a lovely acidic note that really brought out the flavors in the cheese and toppings. To me it was perfect!

But here’s where Industry Pizza & Slice Shop really shines: their side dishes! I tried the zucchini sticks (lightly battered and fried to perfection) as well as their garlic knots (warm and buttery) which were absolutely delicious.

If you are looking for an amazing pizza experience in North Naples FL, then look no further than Industry Pizza & Slice Shop! Best pizza I’ve had in ages!

#12 Nunzio’s Taste Of Italy

I arrived at Nunzio’s and was immediately wowed by the incredible atmosphere. The restaurant is filled with authentic Italian décor, from the bustle of the staff to the traditional music playing in the background. It was like I had walked into an Italian family’s living room!

The pizza is amazing! Each pie is made with fresh ingredients sourced from local farms, providing flavors you can’t find anywhere else. I tried their speciality – the ‘Nunzio’s Classic’ – and it was pure perfection! Thin crust, just enough cheese, and zesty tomato sauce that sent my taste buds wild. It truly lived up to its reputation as one of the best pizzas around.

The service at Nunzio’s is top-notch too. The friendly staff greeted me warmly, answered all my questions about each dish, and cheerfully accommodated my requests for extra toppings or sides. It was like being taken care of by family!

I highly recommend Nunzio’s Taste Of Italy for anyone looking for a delicious pizza experience they won’t forget. Trust me when I say this place has some of the best pizza in North Naples FL!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Rosati’s Pizza

Upon entering Rosati’s, I immediately felt like I was in pizza paradise. The smell of bubbling cheese and freshly baked crusts permeated the air, instantly making my taste buds dance. The ambience was quaint and cozy, with red and white checkerboard tablecloths that transported me back to old-school pizza joints.

Now, let’s talk about their deep dish pizza. Oh mama mia! The crust was as thick as a novel and as fluffy as a cloud. It was golden brown and perfectly crispy on the outside, while remaining soft and pillowy on the inside. It had just the right amount of chewiness, making it a delight to sink my teeth into.

The cheese, oh the cheese! It was stretchy, gooey, and oozed with decadence. I felt like a cheesy superhero with each bite, as if I were saving the world one cheesy slice at a time. The toppings were generous and fresh, from the tangy tomato sauce to the savory meats and veggies. Each ingredient worked harmoniously to create a flavor explosion in my mouth.

And let’s not forget the size of these slices! They were bigger than my face, which is saying something because I have a pretty big face. Rosati’s isn’t just serving pizza, they’re serving pizza masterpieces.

So, if you’re in Naples, FL, and craving the best deep dish pizza in town, do yourself a favor and head to Rosati’s Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and you might even find yourself doing a cheesy victory dance.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Rosati’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped foot into this pizza paradise, I was greeted by the heavenly aroma of freshly baked pizza dough. It was like being embraced by a warm, cheesy hug that instantly put a smile on my face.

Not only does Rosati’s serve up a killer thin crust, but their toppings are out of this world. The sauce is the perfect blend of tangy and sweet, like a secret recipe passed down through generations. And let me tell you, they don’t skimp on the cheese. It’s like a blanket of melty goodness that cascades over each slice, making it impossible to resist grabbing another.

I must admit, I had a hard time choosing from their extensive menu. They have everything from classic margherita to unique combinations like pesto chicken with sun-dried tomatoes. Decisions, decisions! But fear not, my pizza-loving friends, because you simply can’t go wrong with any choice here.

The staff at Rosati’s are also top-notch. They’re friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about pizza. They even brought me a side of their homemade garlic knots, which were so good that I couldn’t help but shout, knot bad, not bad at all! I laughed. They cringed.

So whether you’re a pizza connoisseur like myself or just a cheesy enthusiast, Rosati’s Pizza is a must-visit in Naples. Trust me, once you take a bite of their mouth-watering thin crust, you’ll never want to eat pizza anywhere else. This place truly deserves the title of the best thin crust pizza in Naples. Bon appétit, my fellow pizza aficionados!