Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Conway AR (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Arkansas

Best Pizza in Conway AR (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

95 Views

It’s been my job to traverse the world in search of pizza perfection, and I’m happy to report I’ve found some amazing pies in this small Arkansas city. After sampling twelve places in the area, I can confidently report that Conway AR has some delicious pizza options!

My taste buds have delighted in the wide range of toppings, sauces, cheeses and doughs that comprise each quintessential bite. Now it’s my pleasure to share these results with you so you may partake of my pizza-lover’s journey through Conway AR. Join me for a tour through the best pizza places the city has to offer!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arkansas

#1 Wicked Wood Fired Pizza

I stopped in one evening while I was in town and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food and atmosphere. The restaurant has a cozy yet modern feel that I immediately felt right at home in. I ordered a margarita pizza with some extra olives to try.

The minute the pizza arrived, my mouth started watering! The thin, wood-fired crust had that perfect crunchy texture and light smoky flavor. The cheese was gooey and delicious, perfectly complemented by a tangy marinara sauce. The extra olives added an extra layer of flavor that really put it over the top for me!

Overall, I can confidently say that Wicket Wood Fired Pizza is easily one of the best pizzas I’ve had in Nwa! They definitely get my highest recommendation for anyone looking for an excellent pizza experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Bentonville!

#2 The Odd Soul

Their selection of alcoholic beverages is quite impressive – from beer to hard liquor, you’ll definitely find something to go with your pizza. It’s also a great tourist spot with a lot of history! Plus, if you’re looking for a place with good vibes and great sports games on the tv, this is definitely the place for you.

I didn’t get to enjoy their pizza by delivery, unfortunately – there’s no delivery service at The Odd Soul. But that didn’t stop me from taking the trip and enjoying their delicious pies. The crust was just perfect and the toppings blew my mind – I recommend getting “The Bufalina King” or any of their specialty pizzas!

Overall, I highly recommend checking out The Odd Soul if you want to experience some of the best pizza in Nwa. Their beverages and atmosphere make it even better – a must-visit in my book!

#3 Tim’s Pizza

The first thing that stands out about Tim’s is their signature thin crust, which is hand-stretched every day. It’s definitely not your typical soggy frozen pizza crust! The sauce is flavorful, the cheese is rich and melted evenly.

To top it off, they offer a wide variety of topping options so you can customize your pizza any way you like it. I sampled a few different combinations and they were all delicious – the combination of flavors was well-balanced and each ingredient was fresh and flavorful.

The service at Tim’s Pizza is also outstanding – the staff are friendly and attentive, eager to help you get exactly what you want. Plus, the prices are very reasonable for the quality of food you’re getting.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in NWA then look no further than Tim’s Pizza!

#4 Blaze Pizza

The crust was thin and crispy, just the way I like it. The handmade dough was crafted with fresh ingredients, and definitely had a unique taste.

They have an impressive variety of toppings to choose from, so you can customize your pizza exactly to your liking. I went for the classic pepperoni and it didn’t disappoint!

The atmosphere of Blaze Pizza is definitely one of its best selling points. With the open-air kitchen, you get a great view of the chefs in action. It’s really enjoyable to watch them craft your pizza from start to finish with no barriers between you!

The service here was excellent too – friendly and knowledgeable staff made sure we were taken care off throughout our visit. You can tell they take pride in what they do!

Overall, Blaze Pizza is a great spot for anyone looking for some delicious ‘za. If you’re ever in Conway AR, this is definitely worth checking out – best pizza around!

#5 Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar

From the moment I walked in, I knew Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar was something special. The atmosphere was inviting, the staff friendly, and the aroma of freshly made pizza made my mouth water.

The pizza itself was a work of art! It had just the right amount of cheese, a perfectly crisp crust, and an array of delicious toppings that really brought out the flavor profile. The combination of flavors was both unexpected and delightful.

And let me tell you about Marley’s signature cocktails– they are simply divine! Whether it’s their signature margarita or their specialty daiquiri, they make sure to craft each drink with precision and attention to detail.

But what really makes Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar stand out is its commitment to customer service. From the moment I walked in until the time I left, their staff took extra care to ensure that my meal was perfect. Whether it was recommending a pizza topping or suggesting a tasty cocktail, they truly went above and beyond my expectations.

In short, Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar is top notch! In my opinion, it’s easily one of the best pizzas in NWA– if not all of Arkansas!

#6 Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville

During my visit, I tried the signature Mighty Meaty pizza and wow—it was amazing! The crust was perfectly crispy and the toppings were savory, yet not overwhelming. Plus, the presentation of this pizza was absolutely gorgeous!

The decor of the restaurant was also quite enjoyable. It has a very retro feel to it and there are plenty of games and arcade machines to keep you occupied while you wait. The waitstaff were also incredibly friendly, which is always appreciated when eating out.

All in all, I highly recommend Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville for anyone looking for great pizza in NWA. The food is outstanding, the atmosphere is fun, and the staff is attentive—what more could you ask for?

#7 The Rail – A Pizza Company

This place has everything a foodie could want – great authentic Italian pizza, a good selection of beer and wine to pair it with, and even some delicious desserts. But best of all, it makes for a great tourist spot!

I loved the quality of their ingredients. The dough was made from scratch with locally sourced ingredients, and the sauces were flavorful and just the right amount of spicy. The toppings were piled high and I enjoyed trying out different combinations. My absolute favorite combination was the spicy sausage and pepperoni pizza!

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery. However, with an atmosphere like this one, you won’t want to eat anywhere else! So come on down to The Rail – A Pizza Company for some of the best pizza around Nwa!

#8 Geraldi’s

The atmosphere of the place is unique—it has a definite Italian flair. The staff was friendly and accommodating. I loved trying out the different sauces they had, especially the Alfredo sauce.

I started with a traditional pepperoni pizza and it was delicious! The thin crust held up well under the weight of all that cheese and pepperoni. It was cooked to perfection and unlike any other pepperoni pizza I have ever tried before.

Next, I decided to go bold and try their specialty — the “Geraldi’s Signature Experience.” This is a combination of three different pizzas topped with artichoke hearts, bacon, mushrooms, garlic, olives and more. Wow! The flavors blended together perfectly; it was truly an experience I won’t forget!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Nwa then Geraldi’s is definitely your spot! Whether you’re looking for something classic or something fancier, Geraldi’s has it all. Don’t miss out on this great experience—you won’t regret it!

#9 MJ Pizzeria SPRINGDALE

The first thing that caught my eye was the fact that they serve alcohol – even hard liquor! Talk about making a great pizza experience even better. As a bonus, they also have a kid’s menu so I can bring the whole family along on this amazing journey.

If you’re looking for something other than pizza, MJ Pizzeria SPRINGDALE has some awesome vegetarian options. In addition, they’ve got one of the best desserts I’ve ever tasted in all my travels. It’s absolutely out of this world and worth trying!

The only downside is that there’s no delivery, but that shouldn’t stop you from checking it out for yourself. Not only is it a great spot for tourists to explore the town, it’s also an excellent place to get your pizza fix. So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Nwa, head over to MJ Pizzeria SPRINGDALE!

#10 Guido’s Pizza – Tontitown

I first visited the restaurant, and was surprised to find that it not only offers great pizza, but also serves alcohol (along with hard liquor!) which put me in an excellent mood right away. The atmosphere is also really nice – it’s a great spot for tourists looking to relax.

The menu itself offers something for everyone. For kids, they offer a kid’s menu with some great options. Plus, they have some vegetarian options which is always a plus. As if the pizza isn’t enough, they also offer dessert options too!

However, there is one downside: no delivery. So if you’re looking for someone to bring you the pizza, you’ll have to come pick it up yourself. But fortunately Guido’s Pizza – Tontitown is worth the trip every time!

#11 U.S. Pizza Downtown Conway

The pizza crust was just perfect: crispy and crunchy, yet still chewy. The toppings were fresh and flavorful – the pepperoni was especially delicious. As for the sauce…well, let’s just say it surpassed my expectations!

The service at U.S. Pizza Downtown Conway was also top-notch – the staff were friendly, helpful and attentive. Plus, they even provided recommendations on different pizza flavors that I hadn’t considered before!

Overall, this restaurant definitely serves up some of the best pizza in Conway AR! So, if you’re ever in town and craving a slice of pizza perfection, then look no further than U.S. Pizza Downtown Conway!

#12 Hideaway Pizza

When I walked into Hideaway, I was pleasantly surprised by how nice it was. It’s a great spot for tourists and also a great place to watch sports with friends. Plus, they offer alcohol, even hard liquor!

The menu has something for everyone. There are kid’s options and even vegetarian options. But of course the pizza is the real draw here. The crust is chewy and lightly crispy, just like I love it! And the toppings? Whatever you’re craving – from classic pepperoni to creative creations – Hideaway Pizza has it.

And don’t forget about dessert! Somehow they manage to make their desserts insanely good. Don’t miss out on that!

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery service so you’ll have to pick up your food or dine in at Hideaway if you want their world-class pizza. But believe me, it’s worth the trip!