Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Oahu (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Hawaii

Best Pizza in Oahu (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

404 Views

In my quest to discover the best pizza in Oahu, I visited twelve different places and tasted their creations. From authentic New York-style slices to unique Hawaiian flavors, I have discovered several extraordinary pizzas that are worth a visit.

And now with a full stomach and plenty of newfound knowledge, I’m ready to share my findings. I promise you don’t want to miss out on these delicious slices! So let’s dive into the ultimate guide of the Best Pizza in Oahu!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Hawaii

#1 Impossibles Pizza

At first glance, Impossibles Pizza looks like a typical tourist spot. But let me tell you, once I tasted the pizza – I was in pizza heaven! Not only do they have some great vegetarian options, but the traditional pizzas made with fresh ingredients are top-notch.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery. If you’re like me and don’t have a car on the island, it can be tough to get there. But it’s worth it for sure!

If you’re looking for a great spot for lunch or dinner, then you should definitely check out Impossibles Pizza – your taste buds won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 28 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Honolulu!

#2 Little G Cafe

It’s definitely worth the trip. From the moment you walk in, you’ll be welcomed by a friendly atmosphere and made to feel like part of the family. The smell of freshly baked pizza fills the air and entices your appetite with its promise of deliciousness.

The selection of specialty pizzas is impressive and unique – from their classic Margherita to their creative Hawaiian Pizza topped with pineapple chunks, bacon, and feta cheese! And no matter what you choose, you can be sure it will be cooked to perfection with a crispy golden crust.

My favorite part about Little G Cafe has to be their amazing dessert options! They have an extensive assortment of mouth-watering desserts including cannoli, tiramisu, gelato, and even chocolate pizza! Yum!

Unfortunately they don’t offer delivery services but trust me when I say that this pizza is good enough to drive for. So if you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Oahu then look no further than Little G Cafe – it’s simply the best!

#3 Floralia

I was impressed by their selection of vegetarian options, which is something many pizza restaurants lack. And if you’re looking for an even sweeter treat, they offer dessert!

Not only does Floralia have great food but it’s also a great spot for tourists to visit. The atmosphere is always bustling with energy and the staff are very friendly.

The only downside I can think of is that they don’t offer delivery service. So you’ll have to go there in person to get your hands on this delicious pizza!

But all in all, Floralia has the best pizza in Oahu and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a good slice.

#4 Pizza Mamo

My visit to Pizza Mamo was absolutely delightful. From the moment I walked in, the cheery atmosphere and classic Italian music set the tone for a great evening. I thoroughly enjoyed grabbing a seat right up at the bar where I could watch all of the hustle and bustle in the kitchen.

The menu was mouth-watering and filled with an array of topping options – it was tough to decide! In the end, I decided on a Margherita pie with parmesan cheese sprinkled lightly on top. When my pizza arrived at my table, it was hot off the press – quite literally! The dough had been prepared with care and cooked just long enough to get that perfectly crispy crust while the cheese melted just so. Every bite was pure perfection.

To make things even better, the staff at Pizza Mamo were friendly and accommodating. They gave me plenty of time to relax after my meal, which allowed me to take in all of the delicious details that made this spot one of Oahu’s best pizzerias.

If you’re looking for quality pizza on Oahu, then Pizza Mamo is certainly worth checking out!

#5 J. Dolans

The place itself is a tourist spot, with a nice atmosphere to sit down and enjoy your pizza while watching sports. As an added bonus, they serve alcohol – including hard liquor! What more could you want?

My favorite dish there is their Deluxe Pizza. It has everything on it, so you’re sure to be satisfied no matter what your preferences are. Everything is cooked to perfection, with the right amount of cheese and sauce. Plus the crust was just un-bake-able!

Unfortunately, delivery isn’t an option at J. Dolan’s, so if you’re not able to make it out there in person you’ll have to settle for another pizzeria. But trust me – this place will not disappoint!

#6 Jax Wood Fired Pizza

I’m not just saying this because it’s convenient to me—the pizza here is really good. The crust is a perfect balance of crispy and chewy, and the ingredients are fresh and flavorful. The toppings are all cooked to perfection, and even their most basic pies are worth writing home about (or in this case, writing a blog post about!).

The atmosphere at Jax Wood Fired Pizza is also great. The staff is friendly and helpful, always eager to recommend their favorite dishes or suggest additions or substitutions. Plus, they offer a variety of beers, wines, and other beverages that will make your mouth water while you wait for your pizza to come out of the wood-fired oven.

To sum up my experience: If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Oahu, Jax Wood Fired Pizza should top your list! I know I’ll be back soon for another delicious pie.

#7 Boston’s Pizza

I must admit, I was expecting another chain pizza joint when I walked in but I was pleasantly surprised to find a cozy spot with warm and welcoming staff. As soon as I stepped in, the inviting aromas of garlic and oregano wafted from the kitchen – it certainly stoked my appetite.

The menu had a good selection of both classic and innovative pies. After much deliberation, I decided on their signature ‘Boston’s Special’ which featured pepperoni, mushrooms, bell peppers and olives.

When the pizza arrived at my table, its golden brown crust puffed out invitingly and I could already taste how fresh the ingredients were. The first bite confirmed that this was some of the best pizza I’d ever tried! The crust had just the right amount of crunch while still being airy and light – not a common thing to find in takeout pizza nowadays.

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience – look no further than Boston’s Pizza! With generous portions and delicious food (not to mention friendly service!), it’s easy to see why this place is often seen as one of Oahu’s best pizzerias.

#8 Amina Pizzeria

The atmosphere at this restaurant is relaxed and inviting. They play relaxing music, the wait staff are accommodating, and the decor could make even the most sophisticated pizza connoisseur feel right at home.

The pizza here was simply divine. The thin crust was perfectly cooked, topped with just the right amount of cheese, flavorful seasoning, and a perfect blend of fresh vegetables. I had the Hawaiian flavor which was packed with pineapple and ham – delicious!

I can confidently say that Amina Pizzeria serves some of the best pizza in Oahu. Not many places have been able to create such an amazing combination of flavors like they have here. I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a truly outstanding pizza experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 28 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Honolulu!

#9 Big Kahuna’s Pizza

The atmosphere was great; the restaurant had an authentic Hawaiian vibe and the staff were super friendly. I felt right at home!

I tasted several of their pizzas and they were all delicious. The crust was just right, not too crunchy, not too soft. And the toppings? Oh my goodness they were so flavorful and perfectly cooked.

My favorite was the Hawaiian pizza, which featured a generous layer of ham, pineapple, mozzarella cheese, and a touch of BBQ sauce. The blended flavors were to die for!

Overall, Big Kahuna’s Pizza is a great place to grab some incredible pizza. I would highly recommend it if you’re ever in Oahu looking for some of the best pizza around!

#10 Brick Fire Tavern

Located in the heart of Honolulu, this cozy restaurant is the perfect spot for pizza aficionados. The brick oven-fired pizzas are cooked to perfection and have an incredible homemade taste that you won’t find elsewhere.

The menu offers a wide selection of gourmet pies from classic Margarita to more exotic creations like Smoked Salmon and Avocado as well as vegan options. No matter what your preference may be, you can be sure Brick Fire Tavern will have something amazing for you.

As for their toppings, they are fresh and flavorful with a delightful char from their wood-fired ovens. Plus, their prices are incredibly reasonable considering the quality of ingredients used!

To top it all off (pun intended), the service was fantastic! Our waiter was polite and knowledgeable while still providing us with great humor throughout our meal. All in all, my visit to Brick Fire Tavern was one of the best pizzeria experiences I’ve had in a long time.

If you find yourself on Oahu looking for some of the best pizza around, then you have to stop by Brick Fire Tavern!

#11 Pieology Pizzeria Aina Haina, Honolulu, HI

The atmosphere in Pieology Pizzeria Aina Haina is amazing. The staff is friendly and the restaurant is always spotless. But, most importantly, they make an incredible pizza.

The pizza at Pieology Pizzeria Aina Haina is cooked to perfection. The toppings are fresh, and the crust is just right – not too thick and not too thin. It’s by far the best pizza I’ve had in Oahu! And that’s saying something!

On my last visit I ordered a pepperoni and spinach pie with pineapple on top – it was delicious! I also tried some of their garlic knots and a house salad, which were both great too.

I highly recommend Pieology Pizzeria Aina Haina to anyone looking for the best pizza in Oahu. Trust me: you won’t be disappointed!

#12 The Pizza Press

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and comfortable. The staff are friendly and attentive, ensuring that all your needs are met. And, of course, the pizza is out of this world!

Their selection of pizzas is incredible – from classic Margherita to mouth-watering Mediterranean-style pies. They also offer a make-your-own option where you can choose your favorite toppings and create something totally unique. And don’t forget their amazing sides like garlic knots and cheesy breadsticks!

The Pizza Press also offers some delicious craft beers to pair with your meal, making it the perfect spot for date night or a girls’-night-out.

All in all, it’s no wonder why The Pizza Press is said to have some of the best pizza in Oahu! Whether you’re looking for a casual evening out or just something yummy to snack on while exploring the island, you won’t be disappointed with what they have to offer!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – La Pizza Rina

Let me start by saying that I’ve eaten my fair share of pizza, from the tiny pizzerias in Italy to the famous New York pizza joints. And let me tell you, La Pizza Rina holds its own against them all.

First of all, the crust is delightfully thin and crispy. I’m talking so thin that you can almost see through it. It’s like eating a delicate piece of art, except it’s edible and absolutely delicious. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is perfectly balanced, and the toppings are aplenty.

Now, I must warn you about the danger of these pizzas. They are so good that you’ll find yourself eating slice after slice, unable to stop. It’s like a magical spell has been cast upon you, making you crave more and more. I’ve witnessed people lose control, their faces covered in sauce, cheese stuck to their cheeks. It’s a sight to behold, let me tell you.

The ambiance of the restaurant is nothing to write home about, but who needs fancy decor when you have pizza this good? The staff is friendly enough, but let’s be honest, I’m here for the pizza, not the small talk.

So, if you find yourself in Honolulu and craving some outstanding thin crust pizza, head straight to La Pizza Rina. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. And if you do happen to lose yourself in a pizza-induced frenzy, just remember to wipe the sauce off your face before leaving.