Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Oak Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Oak Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

161 Views

Having made it to the furthest reaches of the world trying out different varieties of pizza, I thought it only right that I tried my hand at finding the best in Oak Park.

After tasting 12 different pizzas, I think I can safely tell you what’s worth your time (and money)! But before we move onto the best of the bunch, just a quick disclaimer – everyone’s tastes are different so what I may love, you may not.

Without further ado, here are my picks for the best pizza in Oak Park.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Da Pizza Company

I had heard good things about the place, but I have to say I was truly impressed when my first bite arrived! The thin crust was perfectly cooked with just enough crunch and sweetness. Topped with quality ingredients like juicy tomatoes, savory salami, and ooey-gooey cheese, it’s a heavenly combination!

The atmosphere at Da Pizza Company is great too. Not only do they serve up delicious pies in the restaurant, but they also offer takeout and delivery. With friendly staff and a cozy setting, you can count on a wonderful experience no matter how you choose to get your pizza fix.

Adding to the wonderful experience were astounding sides such as homemade focaccia bread that added a nice contrast to heavy slices of pizza. Who could forget the colossal calzones? They’ve really got something for everyone here!

All in all, I am beyond satisfied with the great food and even better service that Da Pizza Company provides. Whether you’re looking for the best pizza in Oak Park or just some good Italian food in general, this is definitely the place for you!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Chicago!

#2 Cucina Paradiso

The dough is perfectly crisp, without being too hard. The tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese blend together in a wonderfully unique flavor that’s unlike anything I’ve ever tasted before. The toppings are generous and fresh – the pepperoni is especially delicious!

I’m also impressed with the restaurant itself. It’s welcoming and laid-back, but still has an air of sophistication. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, which makes it easy to find something satisfying for everyone.

Overall, Cucina Paradiso serves up some of the best pizza in Oak Park! If you’re looking for a great pizza experience, then this is definitely the place to go.

#3 Sorrento’s

I had the pleasure of dining at Sorrento’s recently and let me tell you – it was a delight! The atmosphere of this modest pizza joint is welcoming and inviting. I loved that they took such care in presentation – it made a great first impression!

And then, of course, there was the pizza. Wow! What can I say? It was delicious–no, sublime. The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right crunchy texture that all good pizzas should have. The sauce was flavorful without being overwhelming and complemented the cheese and toppings nicely. And speaking of toppings, this pizza had the perfect ratio of everything–not too much, not too little.

For an added bonus, Sorrento’s also offers fantastic service with friendliness and efficiency. All-in-all, it’s no wonder why this place has earned its reputation as one of the best pizza places in Oak Park. If you’re ever in town looking for some high-quality pizza that won’t disappoint, definitely check out Sorrento’s!

#4 Massa Cafe Italiano

The minute you walk in the door, your mouth starts to water. The delicious smells of freshly made pizza assaults your senses, and immediately you start to dream about all the different pizzas you’d like to try.

I decided on one of their specialty pies—their Rustica. It had a thin yet flavorful crust with tangy marinara sauce and plenty of nicely melted provolone and mozzarella cheese. Topping it off were thin slices of prosciutto, olives, mushrooms, peppers, and onions that added an amazing flavor combination with just the right amount of spice.

What really impressed me was how the flavors all worked together in harmony—each ingredient enhanced the taste of the others. The crust was cooked to perfection; light but crunchy and flavorful. It was almost like eating a bite out of Italy itself!

To top off my experience at Massa Cafe Italiano, I also tried their tiramisu which was scrumptious! The creamy texture coupled with the espresso cocoa powder made for a truly decadent dessert that kept me coming back for more.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Oak Park, look no further than Massa Cafe Italiano!

#5 Bertollis River Pizza

I decided to try it out during my visit here and I have to say, the pizza did not disappoint. The crust was thin and perfect, baked to a golden brown, with a nice crunchy texture.

The toppings were cooked to perfection as well. The pepperoni had just the right amount of salty flavor, while the cheese was melted perfectly across the entire pizza. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, providing a great balance between the other ingredients.

The staff at Bertollis River Pizza really went above and beyond to make sure my experience there was exceptional. They were friendly, helpful, and even threw in an extra topping for free!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Oak Park, Bertollis River Pizza should be your first stop. You won’t be disappointed!

#6 Oak Park – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

First off, the atmosphere of this pizzeria is phenomenal. The walls are lined with pictures and memorabilia from the restaurant’s legendary history. Just stepping inside is enough to get your appetite going!

Next, let’s talk about their pizza. It’s delicious! Thin crust and just the right amount of cheese, with a good balance of toppings that compliments their amazing sauce perfectly. I’m not exaggerating when I say it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

The service at Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria was also great. The waitstaff was friendly and provided excellent customer service. My order came out quickly, which I really appreciated during my busy schedule.

Overall, my experience at Oak Park – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria was nothing short of extraordinary. From their incredible pizza to their outstanding service, they definitely deserve all the praise they get as being one of the best pizzerias in Oak Park!

#7 Tre Sorelle Ristorante by Mancini

My experience at Tre Sorelle was one to remember. The atmosphere was inviting and relaxed, with a cozy vibe that made you feel right at home. As soon as I stepped in, I was greeted warmly by the staff, setting the tone for what was going to be an amazing meal.

The menu had a variety of delicious pizzas – from classic items like margherita and pepperoni to the more creative options like pesto and eggplant. After pondering over my choices for a few minutes, I settled on the classic pepperoni pizza. When it arrived at our table, it felt like an event! The dough was perfectly crispy yet light and airy, with no shortage of flavor. The cheese was creamy and rich, while the tomatoes added a wonderful sweetness to each bite. And of course, there were plenty of pepperonis – just enough that you could taste them in every single bite!

Overall, I’d highly recommend Tre Sorelle Ristorante by Mancini for anyone looking for some really great pizza in Oak Park. It’s been my experience that this is definitely the best pizza in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Rosemont!

#8 Amato’s Pizza

I’ve never encountered a pizza quite like the one I had at Amato’s Pizza. First off, the crust was perfect – it was crispy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside. Then there were the toppings – an abundance of top-quality ingredients, all of which added to the flavor.

But what really made this pizza stand out from others I’ve tried was Amato’s original sauce. It was a delicious combination of herbs and spices that you won’t find anywhere else. I must say, it gave my pizza an amazing taste unlike anything else I’ve ever tasted before!

The atmosphere at Amato’s is also fantastic. The staff are friendly and accommodating, making sure you get exactly what you asked for. Plus, they even have an outdoor seating area where you can enjoy your meal while taking in the sights of Oak Park.

All in all, if you’re looking to try some of the best pizza in Oak Park, then head over to Amato’s Pizza – it’ll be an experience that you won’t soon forget!

#9 Spizzico Pizza & Pasta / Señor Jefé Mexican Grill

The pizza here is truly a work of art. They have all the classic toppings and some unique combinations as well. I tried their special with sausage, mushrooms, peppers, and sundried tomatoes – it was out of this world! The crust is thin but not too thin, and the sauce has the perfect balance of sweet and savory.

If you’re looking to mix things up a bit, Señor Jefé Mexican Grill has amazing burritos, tacos, and quesadillas. The chicken burrito is particularly amazing! It’s filled with slow-cooked pulled chicken, pickled onions, salsa verde lettuce salad, cheese and sour cream. So good!

Overall Spizzico Pizza & Pasta / Señor Jefé Mexican Grill is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Oak Park. Trust me – I’ve been everywhere!

#10 Salerno’s Pizza of Oak Park

I ventured into the cozy, family-run restaurant expecting nothing more than typical pizza joint fare. Boy, was I wrong!

The first thing that caught my eye was the extensive list of toppings – everything from traditional pepperoni and mushroom to more unconventional options like artichoke hearts and sundried tomatoes.

Next, I sampled the crust – it was light, fluffy, and perfectly cooked for a truly authentic Italian experience. The sauce was also outstanding: rich, savory, and made from only the freshest ingredients.

Finally, it came time to try the pizza itself. It was absolutely amazing – every bite was loaded with flavor! Even better yet, the prices were surprisingly affordable compared to other pizza joints in town.

All in all, Salerno’s Pizza of Oak Park is definitely a must-try for anyone looking for an incredible pizza experience. This place certainly lived up to its reputation as the best pizza in Oak Park!

#11 Trattoria 225

It’s so delicious, it almost makes me forget about the world famous pizzerias I’ve dined at in Italy and France. The crust is perfectly chewy and loaded with flavor, and the sauce is just the right blend of sweet and savory. The toppings are always fresh and plentiful, which definitely adds to the overall experience.

The atmosphere is casual yet cozy—perfect for a date or a relaxing evening out with friends. Plus, the prices are reasonable for such quality pizza.

But what really sets Trattoria 225 apart from other joints in town is their special homemade Italian sausage topping that’s made with love every day by their own chef! It adds a unique flavor to every pizza that can’t be found anywhere else.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Oak Park, Trattoria 225 should be your top choice! It’s delicious, affordable, and offers an experience like no other.

#12 Jimmy’s Place

From the moment I walked in, I was impressed. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the pizza-art pieces on the walls make it feel like a true Italian pizzeria. But of course, they don’t just serve great decor – they serve amazing food too!

I ordered their traditional Margherita pizza with extra cheese and mushrooms, and I was not disappointed. The ingredients were fresh and flavorful, cooked just right to give me that perfect combination of crunchy crust but soft toppings.

What sets Jimmy’s Place apart from other pizza restaurants is their attention to detail. Whether it’s hand-tossing their dough or carefully selecting the best cuts of meat for their toppings, they show an expertise rarely seen. Plus, their prices are reasonable and they offer delivery in case you don’t want to make the trip yourself.

So if you’re ever in Oak Park looking for a great pizza experience, look no further than Jimmy’s Place. It’s definitely my top recommendation when it comes to finding the best pizza in town!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Giordano’s

Now, let’s talk about their benefits. First off, they serve alcohol. And not just your run-of-the-mill beer and wine, my friends. No, no. They have a glorious selection of hard liquor, enough to make any cocktail connoisseur weak in the knees. So, if you’re feeling a little parched, fear not, Giordano’s has got you covered.

Now, I know what you’re thinking. Edward, I’m a vegetarian. Can I even eat here? Fear not, my herbivorous friends, for Giordano’s has a few vegetarian options. They may not have a gazillion choices, but who needs a gazillion when you can have a slice of their heavenly veggie-loaded deep dish pizza? Trust me, it’s worth it.

And if all that cheesy goodness isn’t enough to satisfy your sweet tooth, Giordano’s offers dessert. From rich chocolate lava cakes to decadent ice cream sundaes, they’ve got your post-pizza cravings covered.

Now, before you rush to book your spot, let’s address the downsides. Giordano’s does not accept reservations. Now, this might seem like a bummer, but think of it as an opportunity to mingle with your fellow pizza enthusiasts. Plus, it adds a thrilling element to your dining experience as you wait in anticipation for that cheesy masterpiece to arrive at your table.

So, my friends, if you’re looking for the best deep dish pizza in oak park il, head on over to Giordano’s. They’ve got everything you need for a memorable pizza adventure, and who knows, you might even become a regular tourist in their cheesy domain.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Salerno’s Pizza of Oak Park

Walking into Salerno’s is like stepping into a time machine that transports you back to the 1950s. The decor is delightfully retro, with checkered floors and red vinyl booths. From the moment I sat down, I couldn’t wait to sink my teeth into their famous thin crust pizza.

Now, I must confess that I’ve had pizza in Naples, New York, and even Tokyo. But nothing compares to the crispy, yet delicate crust at Salerno’s. It’s as thin as a sheet of paper, yet somehow manages to hold up under the weight of all the delicious toppings.

Speaking of toppings, Salerno’s is not shy when it comes to piling them on. From the traditional pepperoni to the more adventurous artichokes and goat cheese, they’ve got it all. And each bite is a mouthful of pure bliss.

The flavors are well-balanced, with just the right amount of tang in the tomato sauce and the perfect hint of smokiness from the wood-fired oven. It’s like a symphony on my taste buds with every bite.

And let’s not forget their generous portions! One slice is practically a whole meal. I had to be rolled out of the restaurant after my feast.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best thin crust pizza in oak park, look no further than Salerno’s. It’s a true gem in the pizza world, and my taste buds are eternally grateful.