I’ve been around the world tasting pizza, but there’s always something special about pizza from my home state. While there are many places that serve up a delicious slice, I wanted to find out which ones are the best. So I decided to embark on a mission to uncover the Best Pizza in Old Forge PA – and I’m ready to share my findings!
After visiting 12 different pizza places in Old Forge and trying every topping imaginable, I feel like an expert on all things cheesy and saucy. I’m here to tell you what stood out as the crème de la crème – so let’s get started!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania
#1 Calogero’s Pizza
I’ve had my share of soggy, flavorless pizzas, so when I stepped through the doors of Calogero’s Pizza, I was delighted with their delicious offerings.
The crust is just perfect – it’s thin and crispy enough to provide the right amount of crunch. The cheese is melted to perfection and nicely complements the savory toppings that are piled on generously. And the tomato sauce is fresh and flavorful – not too sweet or sour like some places I’ve tried.
To top it all off, the staff at Calogero’s Pizza were friendly and welcoming during my entire experience. They even gave me a free glass of soda for writing this review!
If you’re ever in Old Forge PA looking for pizza, make sure you stop by Calogero’s Pizza. It’s definitely one of the best pizzerias around!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Scranton!
#2 Mary Lou’s Pizza
- No delivery
I’m usually not one for small towns, but the moment I stepped foot into Mary Lou’s Pizza I knew something good was cooking in their kitchen! The aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese filled the air.
The pizza itself is simply heavenly. The crust is perfectly crunchy and just the right thickness to keep the toppings in place. The sauce is so flavorful that I could eat it straight from the jar. And lastly, the cheese – oh man, it’s so gooey! It’s like a blanket wrapping around all those delicious toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives.
It’s my favorite pizza place in Old Forge PA and I make sure to sample their creations every time I’m in town. My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery – if they did they’d have almost perfect service!
#3 That Guy With the Dough
- No delivery
It’s clear that the guy behind this pizza joint has an extreme passion for creating quality pies. The dough is perfectly chewy, the sauce is perfectly tangy and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. It’s all cooked to perfection in their wood-fired ovens, which definitely adds to the deliciousness of every bite.
The atmosphere at That Guy With The Dough is also great. The staff are so friendly, the decor is warm and inviting, and there’s a selection of craft beers to pair with your pizza. I couldn’t ask for more!
My only issue with this restaurant is that there is no delivery option available. Unfortunately, if you’re not able to go there in person, you won’t be able to partake in their pizza goodness. But trust me when I say it’s worth it!
I’m happy to award That Guy With The Dough 5 stars and declare them as having some of the best pizza in Old Forge PA.
#4 Colarusso’s Cafe
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
I’m not exaggerating when I say that their pizza was like a heavenly slice of heaven! The crust was so light and airy, yet sturdy enough to hold all the delicious toppings. Speaking of toppings, there were so many options available that it took me a few minutes to settle on my favorite. From peperoni to bacon and jalapeño, there really is something for everyone at Colarusso’s Cafe.
The waitstaff was also extremely friendly and helpful, which added a lot to the dining experience. On top of that, they even gave me a free dessert when I finished my meal! I must say that I could eat this pizza every day and never get bored.
Overall, Colarusso’s Cafe is the best place for pizza in Old Forge PA. If you’re ever in town and looking for a great slice of pizza (or more!), then you’ve got to check out Colarusso’s Cafe! You won’t regret it!
#5 Giuseppe’s Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
I was immediately drawn to the inviting atmosphere of Giuseppe’s. From the warm glow of the ovens, to the welcoming staff, I instantly felt at home.
When it came to the pizza, I knew it was going to be good just by looking at it. The dough was perfectly cooked and had a beautiful golden color. The sauce was flavorful and made with fresh ingredients. Every bite transported me back home with its classic, traditional flavor.
The toppings were generous and plentiful – a mix of Italian flavors and interesting combinations that added great taste and texture to each slice. And don’t even get me started on their delectable cheese! Smooth, creamy and full of a cheesy goodness that every pizza needs!
All in all, this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted – certainly worthy of being called “the best pizza in Old Forge PA”. Whoever your secret pizza master is Giuseppe’s, keep up the good work and let me know when you open a shop in my neck of the woods!
If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Wilkes-Barre!
#6 Grande Pizza & Family Restaurant
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the friendly staff makes you feel right at home. The menu offers a variety of unique Italian entrees as well as classic favorites like calzones, strombolis, salads, subs, and of course…pizza!
I had the pleasure of trying their signature pizza: The Grande Pizza. This delectable creation is topped with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, peppers and onions. It was cooked to perfection with a fluffy crust that was both chewy and crispy. Every bite delivered an explosion of flavors that left me craving more!
The prices are reasonable and service is speedy – even on busy nights. My slice of Grande Pizza didn’t last long! All in all, Grande Pizza & Family Restaurant is one spot you definitely don’t want to miss out on when you’re in Old Forge PA. I highly recommend it – I guarantee your taste buds will be thanking you!
#7 Dino & Francesco’s Pizza-Pasta
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
I’ve never been to a pizza parlor quite like Dino & Francesco’s Pizza-Pasta. From the moment I stepped in, I was enchanted by the warm atmosphere and classic Italian decor. The staff greeted me with friendly smiles, and it was clear that they take customer service seriously here.
As for their pizza, let’s just say it lived up to expectations. The crust was thin and perfectly crunchy, while the sauce was flavorful and had just the right amount of spices. And they don’t skimp on the toppings! As an added bonus, they offer both traditional favorites as well as unique creations.
To top it off, the prices are fair for such amazing quality. I’d definitely recommend Dino & Francesco’s Pizza-Pasta if you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Old Forge PA!
#8 Arcaro’s Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- No delivery
I found the atmosphere friendly and inviting. They offer a full bar with hard liquor, as well as a kids menu for those visiting with little ones. As for the food, it was absolutely amazing! From thin-crust to deep dish, their selection is top-notch. I had their signature pizza and it was one of the best I’ve ever had!
The only downside is that they don’t deliver. But trust me when I say it’s worth the visit! After all, Arcaro’s Pizza makes an excellent tourist spot. Plus they even have dessert if you’re in the mood for something sweet afterwards.
If you’re in Old Forge PA and looking for some of the best pizza around, definitely check out Arcaro’s Pizza!
#9 Domino’s Pizza
From the first bite of their classic cheese pizza, I was hooked! The light yet crispy crust and the perfectly balanced amount of cheese and sauce were delightful.
My favorite part of Domino’s Pizza experience was their commitment to quality ingredients. All their toppings, from meats to vegetables, are locally sourced and fresh. Every bite has a burst of flavor that brings out all the deliciousness of every ingredient.
Not to mention the excellent customer service that Domino’s always provides! Every time I come in, they make sure to greet me with a smile and get my pizza order just right. They even went so far as to make sure my kids had plenty of coloring books and crayons while we waited for our food!
Overall, I think Domino’s Pizza is one of the best pizzas spots in Old Forge PA. Whether it’s for takeout or dine-in, you can expect great quality ingredients, friendly service and most important of all – delicious pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Wilkes-Barre!
#10 Salerno’s Cafe
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Great place to watch sports
- Offers dessert
- No delivery
The atmosphere at Salerno’s is great – it’s a great place for tourists to check out and see the sights of Old Forge. And if you’re looking for something more sporty, you can watch the games on their big-screen TVs.
One of the best features about Salerno’s is that they serve not only wine and beer, but also hard liquor! I mean, who doesn’t love pizza paired with a nice scotch?
Salerno’s Cafe has something for everyone – they have a kid’s menu and awesome desserts too! So if you have little ones in tow, they won’t miss out on the pizza party.
The only downside to Salerno’s is that they don’t offer delivery. But that just means you’ll need to make a night of it! Come join us at Salerno’s Cafe in Old Forge PA for some of the best pizza around!
#11 Augustine’s Club 17
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
I arrived at the restaurant feeling very hungry and my mouth was already watering just from the smell in the air. As soon as I stepped inside I was greeted by friendly staff who took great care of me from start to finish.
The atmosphere is cozy, with lots of warm colors and inviting decor. The music was upbeat yet mellow – a perfect environment for enjoying a delicious pizza feast!
When it came time to order, I went for their signature dish – the Old Forge Special. It consists of crumbled sausage, bell peppers, onions, and mozzarella cheese on a crispy crust. The flavor combination was amazing – every bite had its own unique taste that kept me coming back for more!
As if that wasn’t enough, they also offer an array of side dishes and desserts that complimented the pizza perfectly. The price was right too – even though it’s one of the best in Old Forge PA, you won’t have to break your bank account to enjoy this restaurant!
In conclusion, Augustine’s Club 17 is definitely one of my top picks for pizza places in Old Forge PA. Go check out this place today – you won’t be disappointed!
#12 Gourmet Slice
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere here is cozy and inviting. The owners, Mario and Lisa, are always warm, friendly, and more than happy to answer any questions I have about the menu. The service is prompt and very welcoming.
The food here is exceptional! The pizzas here are made with the freshest ingredients available – high quality cheese, awesome homemade sauce, unique toppings such as sun-dried tomatoes and pepperoni on hand-stretched dough. Every time I visit Gourmet Slice I’m pleasantly surprised by their innovative recipes. They also offer a variety of salads and sides that compliment their pizzas perfectly.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Old Forge PA, Gourmet Slice is the place to go! You won’t be disappointed!
