Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Old Town Alexandria (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Virginia

Best Pizza in Old Town Alexandria (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

281 Views

But if I had to pick my favorite pizza place—the one I would return to again and again—there can be only one winner.

After devouring twelve different pizza places in Old Town Alexandria, I have finally made the call on the best of the best. It’s time to find out who reigns supreme when it comes to pizza in a town known for its food!

I’m taking this taste test seriously but with plenty of humor and lightheartedness as we rank each of these dozen delicious pies. So here we go – let’s find the best pizza in Old Town Alexandria!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Virginia

#1 Andy’s Pizza Old Town

The atmosphere is friendly and inviting, with a quaint and cozy environment. The staff are super welcoming and helpful in making sure you get the best pizza experience possible — they even let me try a few different pies just to find the perfect one!

The pizza was simply amazing. They use fresh ingredients and bakes their pies in traditional wood-burning ovens, ensuring the crispness of the crust and flavor of each bite. I had a white pizza that was especially delicious, but everything I sampled was top-notch.

All-in-all, Andy’s Pizza Old Town really delivers on its promise of being the best pizza in Old Town Alexandria. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, then this is definitely the place to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Alexandria!

#2 &pizza – Carlyle

The atmosphere is friendly and inviting, with nods to classic rock bands throughout the interior.

I had their signature Old Town pizza, which was an amazing blend of sweet, salty, and savory flavors. The crust was perfectly cooked and just the right amount of chewy. The toppings were fresh and generous – I could taste all the individual flavors blending together to create a symphony of deliciousness in my mouth!

The staff were attentive and helpful – some even sang along to the classic rock tunes playing in the background!

Overall, I would highly recommend &pizza – Carlyle for anyone looking for the best pizza in Old Town Alexandria. It’s truly worth the visit!

#3 Handover By The Slice

Eating there is always a pleasure – the atmosphere is cozy and inviting. Not to mention, the decor is truly unique – you can almost imagine yourself in Florence or Rome.

The pizza itself is out of this world! It’s the perfect combination of crispy yet soft crust, with flavorful toppings that pop in your mouth. And the sauce? Don’t even get me started! It’s so wonderfully balanced – not too sweet, not too salty, just right.

But what really sets Handover By The Slice apart from other pizza places are the special ingredients they use. Aromatic herbs like oregano and basil mix with garlic oil and cheese to create something totally unique. You won’t find these flavors anywhere else!

Overall, I would highly recommend Handover By The Slice for anyone looking for a delicious slice of pizza in Old Town Alexandria. Bon appetite!

#4 Lost Dog Cafe – Alexandria

The atmosphere is great – they have a cozy outdoor patio that is perfect for enjoying the summer evenings. Inside, it’s spacious and filled with vibrant art on the walls. It really provides an inviting backdrop to enjoy your meal.

The pizza was AMAZING! The crust was crispy but not too crunchy. The toppings were generous and made with fresh ingredients – you can tell that they don’t skimp out in this department! Plus, their signature sauces are delicious and give each pizza its own unique flavor.

All in all, I would highly recommend Lost Dog Cafe – Alexandria to anyone looking for a great slice of pie! With its cozy atmosphere, generous toppings, and delicious sauces, it’s no wonder why it’s been winning awards for best pizza in Old Town Alexandria for years!

#5 The Perfect Pita

The welcoming atmosphere and the homemade dough make for a special experience. The crust was crispy, not too thick or too thin, just right!

The toppings are top notch. The pepperoni is hearty and flavorful, the mushrooms are fresh and flavorful, and the cheese is just melted to perfection.

The staff is very friendly and accommodating—always willing to make suggestions if you’re not sure what to order. They really make you feel at home.

I especially love that they offer a variety of artisanal beers to pair with your pizza—the perfect touch!

The prices are fair and I’d definitely recommend this place if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Old Town Alexandria. Make sure to try the house specialty…you won’t regret it!

#6 Belle Haven Pizzeria

Their pizzas are crafted with the perfect combination of traditional flavor and modern innovation. From the classic Margherita to the more adventurous Fig and Prosciutto, their selection covers all the bases.

The atmosphere at Belle Haven Pizzeria left me speechless. They provide a cozy atmosphere that’s just perfect for pizza night. Plus, they have some of the friendliest staff in town!

But, hands down, it was their pizza that really made this place stand out to me. It was light yet filling, and every single bite was full of flavor. Even after eating an entire pie by myself (don’t judge me!), I wanted more! I’m convinced that Belle Haven Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Old Town Alexandria!

#7 Lena’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Tap

The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting and cozy. The wood-fired oven gives off an aroma of fresh ingredients that will make your mouth water! And even though the pizzeria is located in a busy area, you won’t feel overwhelmed by the hustle and bustle inside. It’s just the right amount of lively.

The highlight of my experience at Lena’s was, of course, the pizza itself! As soon as I took my first bite, I was simply blown away. The crust was thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char. The sauce was tangy and flavorful with a hint of sweetness, while the toppings were exquisitely cooked to perfection. You can definitely taste each ingredient working together like they’re all part of one big symphony!

What really sets Lena’s apart from other pizza places is their incredible selection of craft beers on tap. They have something for everyone; whether you like hoppy IPAs or sweet stouts–Lena’s has it! Plus, it pairs wonderfully with their delicious pies.

So if you’re ever looking for a great place to grab some amazing pizza in Old Town Alexandria, be sure to check out Lena’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Tap! Trust me – you won’t regret it.

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Springfield!

#8 RedRocks Old Town

From the moment I stepped inside, I knew this place was special. The interior of the restaurant is pure pizza perfection – it’s quaint and cozy, with brick walls and brick ovens in every corner. The staff are friendly and attentive, making sure every customer has a great experience.

When it comes to the pizza itself, RedRocks Old Town exceeded all expectations. From their signature Neapolitan pies to signature specialty pizzas like their Chicken Bacon BBQ – each slice is perfectly cooked in the wood-fired oven, giving it an unparalleled flavor that you won’t find anywhere else.

Overall, my visit to RedRocks Old Town was an amazing experience that left me wanting more! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Old Town Alexandria – look no further than RedRocks Old Town!

#9 Bugsy’s Pizza Restaurant and Sports Bar

The service was outstanding, as I was immediately seated and had a server explain the menu options. My server made excellent suggestions for what to try and it was clear that his pizza knowledge was top notch.

The atmosphere in Bugsy’s is upbeat and fun. There are lots of large TVs playing sports so you feel like you’re at a game, plus there were plenty of pool tables and pinball machines to keep everyone entertained.

But most importantly, the pizzas were delicious! The crust was buttery and light with just the right amount of charring. The toppings were fresh and plentiful, with just enough seasoning to really bring out all the flavors.

Bugsy’s has definitely earned its place among the best pizza restaurants in Old Town Alexandria. Whether you’re looking for a classic pie or something more adventurous, this spot is sure to please any pizza fan!

#10 Faccia Luna (Alexandria,VA)

I recently had the opportunity to experience this amazing pizza place, and I’m hooked. From the plethora of topping options to the alcohol served (and hard liquor too!) it’s clear that Faccia Luna really goes above and beyond to make sure their customers have an unforgettable experience.

The atmosphere is perfect for any occasion; they even have a kids menu! If you’re looking for some vegetarian options, Faccia Luna has those as well, so everyone can enjoy the deliciousness. But their dessert selection truly takes the cake; it’s insanely good! The flavors were out of this world.

The only downside I encountered was that there’s no delivery, so I had to pick up my order myself. But for me, it was completely worth it.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Old Town Alexandria, Faccia Luna is definitely worth a visit—you won’t be disappointed.

#11 Delia’s

The atmosphere was very inviting, and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. I chose to sit at one of the long communal tables, which made for an enjoyable experience.

When it came to the pizza itself, wow! The crust was surprisingly light and flaky, with just the perfect amount of crunch. The tomato sauce had a wonderful balance of flavors that wasn’t too sweet or too acidic. And let’s not even get into the cheese – it’s melted perfection!

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Old Town Alexandria, then Delia’s is definitely worth checking out. The atmosphere is fantastic, and the pizza is delicious. It’s no wonder they’ve been around so long – they make some of the best pizza around!

#12 Rustico

I arrived at the cozy restaurant eager to try their pizza. I was immediately taken aback by the aromas of fresh dough and mouthwatering sauces wafting through the air. The atmosphere of Rustico was unpretentious and inviting.

I ordered a classic Margherita pizza with extra toppings, and it did not disappoint! The tasty sauce was perfectly balanced and complemented by the crispy edges of the wood-fired crust. I’ve never tasted better mozzarella cheese than what came on my Rustico pizza; it was stringy, flavorful, and absolutely delicious.

The toppings were also top-shelf: flavorful mushrooms that had just been sautéed in olive oil, juicy tomatoes that had been grown locally, and fragrant herbs that brought out all of the flavors of my pizza. It really was the perfect combination!

If you’re in Old Town Alexandria looking for a great slice, Rustico is definitely your spot. I can guarantee you won’t be disappointed – it’s truly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had in my travels around the world!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Bugsy’s Pizza Restaurant and Sports Bar

From the moment I stepped foot into this quirky joint, I knew I was in for a treat. The walls were plastered with sports memorabilia, and the aroma of melted cheese and crispy dough wafted through the air, making my stomach grumble in anticipation.

I decided to start with their famous cheese-loaded deep dish pizza, and boy, was I blown away. The crust was so thick and buttery, it could double as a pillow. The cheese, oh the cheese! It was oozing out from every nook and cranny, making me question if I had stumbled into a cheese lover’s dream. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, with the tangy tomato sauce perfectly complementing the creamy mozzarella. And let’s not forget about the toppings! They piled on everything from savory pepperoni to juicy sausage, creating a pizza masterpiece that even Leonardo da Vinci would envy.

As I devoured slice after slice, I couldn’t help but notice the sheer generosity of Bugsy’s portion size. One slice was practically the size of my head! I couldn’t fathom how anyone could finish a whole pizza by themselves, but I was determined to give it my best shot for the sake of culinary research, of course.

The staff at Bugsy’s were just as impressive as their pizza. The waiter had a wit as sharp as a pizza cutter and had me chuckling throughout the entire meal. He even had a few pizza jokes up his sleeve, which only added to the jovial atmosphere.

So, if you find yourself in Alexandria and in dire need of some lip-smacking, deep dish pizza, Bugsy’s Pizza Restaurant and Sports Bar is the place to be. Trust me, I’ve tasted pizza all over the world, and this place definitely takes the cheesecake (or should I say, cheese-pizza)!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Lena’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Tap

Let me start by saying that Lena’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Tap is a hidden gem tucked away in the charming streets of Alexandria. From the moment I entered, I felt like I was transported straight to Italy, or at least a really convincing Italian-themed movie set. The ambiance was rustic and warm, complete with wood-fired ovens and a menu that made my taste buds tingle with excitement.

Now onto the pizza. Ahhh, the pizza! The thin crust at Lena’s is so thin that you practically need a magnifying glass to find it. But trust me, it’s there, hiding like Waldo amidst a sea of delicious toppings. One bite and I was hooked. The crust was perfectly crispy, like biting into a delicate cloud of carb-y goodness. It was so thin that I even began to contemplate opening a Lena’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Tap pizza crust fashion line – the ultimate in stylish weight loss wear!

But it wasn’t just the crust that made my taste buds dance a happy jig, it was the toppings too. Lena’s offers a wide variety, from the classic margherita to the more adventurous prosciutto and arugula combination. Each bite was an explosion of flavors in my mouth, causing me to close my eyes and mutter incomprehensible sounds of pleasure. My fellow diners must have thought I was auditioning for an avant-garde opera!

So if you find yourself in Alexandria, VA, don’t miss the opportunity to experience the best thin crust pizza at Lena’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Tap. Just be prepared for a life-changing pizza experience that may leave you contemplating a career in crust couture. Bon appétit!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Lena’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Tap

Walking into Lena’s was like stepping into a pizza wonderland. The aroma of freshly baked dough and melting cheese hit me like a punch in the face, in the best possible way. The place was buzzing with excitement, filled with people eagerly awaiting their pizza fix. I knew I was in for a treat.

I started off with their signature wood-fired margherita pizza. The first bite was like a symphony of flavors dancing on my tongue. The crust was perfectly charred and chewy, the tomato sauce was tangy and robust, and the buffalo mozzarella was creamy and decadent. It was love at first bite.

But the magic didn’t stop there. Lena’s menu boasted an array of creative and mouthwatering toppings. I couldn’t resist trying their Fungi Fun pizza, topped with a variety of wild mushrooms and truffle oil. Let me tell you, it was like taking a magical journey through a forest of flavor. Each bite was a whimsical explosion of earthy goodness.

What truly sets Lena’s apart is their commitment to quality ingredients. They source their produce locally, ensuring that every bite is bursting with freshness. And let’s not forget about their impeccable service. The staff at Lena’s are as warm and friendly as the wood-fired oven itself, making you feel right at home.

If you’re in Washington D.C. and craving pizza, do yourself a favor and head to Lena’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Tap. Trust me, it’s a pizza experience that will have you coming back for more.