Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Pagosa Springs (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Colorado

Best Pizza in Pagosa Springs (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

74 Views

I’ve been around the world to experience pizza from all sorts of places, so it’s only fitting that I now turn my attention to the best pizza in Pagosa Springs. In this article, I’ll review 8 different pizza places and share my honest thoughts on each one with a lighthearted and humorous tone. So let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Colorado

#1 Rosie’s Pizzeria

Their crust is perfectly thin and crispy, while their sauce is perfectly balanced – not too sweet or too acidic. The toppings are generously applied and include a wide variety of high-quality options.

The staff at Rosie’s is exceptionally friendly and helpful, whether you’re ordering for dine in or take out. The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and inviting, with soft lighting and Italian music playing in the background.

The highlight of my experience at Rosie’s was certainly the pizza itself – it was delicious down to the very last bite! I’d highly recommend stopping by this pizzeria if you’re in Pagosa Springs; you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 40 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Durango!

#2 Mountain Pizza and Taproom

The atmosphere inside the restaurant is lively and inviting, with plenty of options for everyone. There’s a great selection of beers on tap as well as a kid’s menu for the little ones. The vegetarian options are quite good, too, and there’s even a dessert menu if you want to satisfy your sweet tooth.

My experience at Mountain Pizza and Taproom was nothing short of extraordinary. The pizza was cooked to perfection, with perfectly melted mozzarella cheese, succulent meats, and tasty vegetables all coming together in one heavenly bite! With each bite, I had more energy than before and could feel the greatness of this pizza place coursing through my veins!

The only downside I could find from this wonderful establishment is that they don’t offer delivery services. But with such good pizza being served at the restaurant itself, why would you want it delivered? You’d be missing out on so much!

Overall, I’d highly recommend Mountain Pizza and Taproom to anyone looking for an unforgettable experience when it comes to pizza in Pagosa Springs! It is certainly one of the best places around for pizza lovers like myself.

#3 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The restaurant is located close to downtown, so it’s easy to get there. And the staff is helpful and friendly.

The menu offers some great options for vegetarians – I particularly enjoyed the Veggie Delight! And their pizzas are all made with fresh ingredients, giving them a delicious flavor.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery – you have to take your pizza and bake it yourself at home. But hey, sometimes you just want the experience of baking your own pizza while listening to some good music! That said, they do offer carry-out options which make getting your pizza much easier.

Overall, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is a great place for anyone looking for the best pizza in Pagosa Springs! I’d definitely recommend it if you’re in the area.

If you’re willing to go an extra 62 miles, you can get to 6 more pizza places in Telluride!

#4 The Break Room Brewing Company

I’ve been to countless places, trying out every kind of pizza imaginable. But this place takes the cake!

First off, their beer selection is fantastic. After sampling a few different types of brews, I can attest that The Break Room Brewing Company knows how to make a good beer.

Second, their pizza. Wow! It’s like they put love into every bite. The crust is thin and flavorful, the toppings are fresh and there isn’t too much sauce to overwhelm each slice. They have some creative topping combos that have me coming back for more.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery, so it’s best to go in person if you want the full experience. But that’s not such a big deal as it’s less than 15 minutes away from my hotel anyway.

All in all, The Break Room Brewing Company is definitely one of the best places to get pizza in Pagosa Springs!

#5 Pagosa Brewing & Grill

From the moment I walked in, it felt like a great tourist spot to spend the evening. They’ve got a wide selection of beer and hard liquor for adults, and a fun kids’ menu for the youngsters. The atmosphere was perfect for watching sports events with friends and family.

But what made this place stand out from your average pizza joint is the quality of their food. Their pizzas are cooked to perfection, with all kinds of delicious toppings and sauces. The dough is light and fluffy and the cheese is melted and gooey in all the right ways. Add to that a generous helping of fresh veggies and meats, you get an experience that’s sure to please!

And if pizza isn’t enough (as if it could be!), they also have some insanely good desserts. From tiramisu to creme brulee, they really know how to satisfy your sweet tooth!

My only complaint is that Pagosa Brewing & Grill doesn’t offer delivery – but I understand why. I’d rather sit down at one of their tables anyway to really savor my meal! If you’re ever in Pagosa Springs, make sure you give them a try – they won’t let you down!

If you’re willing to go an extra 103 miles, you can get to 9 more pizza places in Taos!

#6 Talisman Pizza

The smell of the oven and freshly baked pizza greeted me as soon as I walked in. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting. The waiter, Mark, gave me a warm welcome and was extremely attentive and friendly throughout my visit.

I opted for a simple margherita pizza and it exceeded all expectations. From the first bite, I knew that Talisman Pizza uses only the freshest, most flavorful ingredients for their pizzas. From the crisp crust to the melted cheese to the tangy marinara sauce, every single component was delicious! And no pizza experience is complete without garlic bread – which thoroughly impressed me with its perfectly crunchy exterior and tasty seasoning.

I must say that Talisman Pizza is definitely worthy of its reputation as serving some of the best pizza in Pagosa Springs! After eating here felt like my taste buds got transported to heaven! Highly recommend this gem to all pizza lovers out there.

#7 Papa Johns Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The staff was friendly and helpful, and the restaurant itself had a comfortable, welcoming atmosphere.

The pizza! Oh my goodness…I’ve never tasted anything like it before! The crust was perfectly crispy and topped with just the right amount of cheese and fresh toppings. Every bite was pure bliss, and I can honestly say that Papa Johns pizza is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had.

In addition to their delicious food, they also provide great customer service. They were quick to respond to any requests we made and were always there with a smile on their face.

Overall, Papa Johns pizza is definitely one of the best pizzas in Pagosa Springs. Their combination of great atmosphere, delicious food and excellent customer service makes them stand out from other establishments in town. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience then take my advice: head to Papa John’s!

If you’re willing to go an extra 125 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Santa Fe!

#8 Gustoso Italian Restaurant

I had to make the trek all the way here, and let me tell you – it was worth it!

First, let me talk about their alcohol selection. It’s not just beer and wine – they have hard liquor too! I usually don’t drink while eating pizza, but when I do, Gustoso Italian Restaurant has got my back.

If you’re bringing the kids along to eat here, there’s a special menu just for them. So even the pickiest of eaters will find something they like here. Plus, there are vegetarian options as well!

But what really took me by surprise was their insanely good dessert menu. I’ve never tasted a better tiramisu in my life!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery service. But hey, making an effort to dine at this great spot is worth it if you’re looking for the best pizza in Pagosa Springs.