Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Palm Harbor (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Palm Harbor (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

195 Views

I’m no stranger to slicing into a gooey pie – I’ve tried pizza from all over the world, so I’m ready to share my thoughts on the twelve places I’ve visited in this small town.

This isn’t meant to be a critical review, so much as it’s meant to be an exploration of options for anyone looking for good pizza in Palm Harbor. Although I’ll be giving some helpful tips along the way, it’s still going to be lighthearted and humorous.

So come join me on my journey as I figure out which restaurant makes the best pizza in Palm Harbor!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Giovannis Pizza

I was pleasantly surprised when I stepped into the restaurant. The atmosphere was so inviting, with classic Italian music playing in the background and a cozy, homey feel.

The pizza menu had so many different options that it was difficult to choose just one! From their classic cheese pizza to the more creative toppings and sauces, all of their pizzas are made with an abundance of care and attention.

As for the pizza itself, it was truly delicious! The crust is perfectly thin and crispy while still managing to be soft on the inside. The flavor combinations that they use were out of this world – none of them too heavy or overwhelming – just right!

My favorite part about my experience here was definitely how friendly the staff were. They always took time to talk to me about their menu items and really showed genuine interest in my feedback. This added an extra bonus to what seemed like already exemplary service.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Palm Harbor, Giovannis Pizza is definitely worth a visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Dunedin!

#2 Pucks&Pizza

The atmosphere is great, with vintage sports memorabilia hanging on the walls and a cool retro vibe. They have plenty of vegetarian options available too, which is the perfect option for me.

Unfortunately they don’t offer delivery, so you have to go there in person to get your pizza fix. But that’s fine with me, because I love their food and atmosphere! The pizza crust is thin and flavorful, with just the right amount of crunch. The cheese is always fresh and gooey and the toppings are generous and quality.

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Palm Harbor then Pucks&Pizza is the place to go!

#3 C&E Fresh Pizza

The dough was cooked perfectly, with a crispy bottom and soft top. The crust was slightly chewy and fragrant, thanks to their special blend of seasonings and herbs. There’s nothing like the flavor combinations that come out of their oven!

The best part about C&E Fresh Pizza is their sauce. It’s lightly sweet with a perfect balance of garlic and spices that infuse deeply into the cheese and toppings. From classic pepperoni to roasted vegetables – all their pies have a savory depth that’s hard to beat.

I’d definitely recommend C&E Fresh Pizza if you’re looking for the best pizza in Palm Harbor. You won’t be disappointed!

#4 Piper’s Scratch Pizza Shop

The shop itself is cozy and inviting, and the owners are always cheerful and welcoming. The pizza chefs really know what they’re doing because each pie was perfectly cooked with a perfectly crisp crust every time I visited.

I also have to mention their selection of toppings—it’s unlike anything I’ve seen before! They’ve got all the classics like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, olives, etc., but then they also have some truly unique options like black olives stuffed with feta cheese or Sriracha-infused tomatoes.

Overall, the prices are incredibly reasonable for what you get (the quality of ingredients is top-notch) and piping hot slices come out in no time. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Palm Harbor, this is it!

#5 DiGiorgio’s Pizzeria

When I stepped into the place, I was pleasantly surprised by the ambiance—the place exuded a cozy, homey feeling that was inviting and warm. The staff were friendly and accommodating, something that I have rarely encountered in my pizza-eating travels.

But what about the pizza? It’s seriously delicious! Their dough is made fresh daily and lightly crunchy on the edges, providing a satisfying texture to any slice. There’s a flavor for everyone—no matter if you’re looking for something simple like classic Margherita or something more adventurous like Hawaiian, DiGiorgio’s has it all! Plus, they offer a variety of vegan options so everyone can enjoy the pizzeria’s offerings.

Overall, DiGiorgio’s Pizzeria provides an excellent experience all around. The atmosphere is great and their pizzas are definitely some of the best in Palm Harbor! Highly recommended for anyone looking for an amazing pizza fix!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Clearwater!

#6 Fireside Pizza Cafe

The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, and it’s a great tourist spot. I’ve been here several times, and the service has always been friendly and attentive.

Their menu offers something for everyone – with alcohol being served, there are plenty of options for adults to choose from. They also have a great kids menu which was much appreciated by my traveling companions. If you’re looking for something healthy, there are some vegetarian options as well!

The pizzas here are some of the best I’ve tried anywhere. The crust is thin and crispy – never soggy – but still full of flavor. Toppings vary from classic meaty combinations to more creative vegetable-based pies. And they also serve dessert, if you have any room left after your meal!

My only complaint about Fireside Pizza Cafe is that they don’t offer delivery: so sadly we can’t enjoy their amazing pizza when at home or on the road. All in all though, Fireside Pizza Cafe is an excellent choice for a delicious pie!

#7 Big Joe’s Pasta House

The atmosphere at Big Joe’s is absolutely outstanding – it definitely makes you feel like you’re in a cozy Italian restaurant. The staff were so welcoming and gave me an excellent impression of the place.

When it came to the pizza, I was overwhelmed by how delicious it was! The crust was perfectly crisp and light, with just the right amount of crunch when I bit into it. The sauce had a delightful hint of spice that played beautifully against the other flavors. And, let me tell you, they don’t skimp on the toppings! They had every variety imaginable – from classic favorites like pepperoni and olives to some more creative combinations like BBQ chicken pineapple.

Big Joe’s knows how to make one mean pie! As for value for money, it’s hard to beat – definitely worth every penny. All in all, Big Joe’s Pasta House is a must-visit if you’re ever in Palm Harbor looking for a slice of amazing pizza!

#8 Leonardo’s Pizzeria

The dough was perfectly cooked with a hint of garlic and herbs and the cheese was cheesy, but not too cheesy. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, with plenty of options to choose from. And I must say that the marinara sauce is out-of-this-world delicious!

But the best part about Leonardo’s isn’t just their pizza – it’s also their atmosphere. The staff is incredibly friendly and can answer any questions you have about the menu or ingredients. Plus, they have some fun activities for kids on weekends if you’re bringing the family along!

All in all, Leonardo’s Pizzeria is definitely one of my top spots for best pizza in Palm Harbor. Highly recommended!

#9 Three Brothers New York Pizza

Let me start by describing the atmosphere of this charming little pizza joint. The restaurant is small and cozy, with dim lights and soft music playing in the background, giving it a great ambiance.

The service was outstanding: everyone was friendly and welcoming, which put me right at ease. I could tell right away that they took great pride in providing excellent customer service.

Now for the most important part – the pizza! After much deliberation I finally decided to try their signature Three Brothers Supreme Pizza. It was absolutely delicious, made with fresh ingredients on a perfectly crisp crust. The creamy cheese and savory toppings paired well together, as did the sweet and tangy marinara sauce.

I would highly recommend Three Brothers New York Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Palm Harbor! If you’re looking for an authentic Italian-style pie that’s sure to satisfy your cravings, this is one place you won’t want to miss!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Clearwater!

#10 Jet’s Pizza

First of all, the crust was perfect. It had just the right crunch and flavor that you want in a pizza crust. The sauce was made with fresh tomato and herbs, which really added to the distinct flavor. The cheese was also nicely melted on top – not too cheesey, but enough to make it really enjoyable.

But perhaps the best part of Jet’s Pizza is the toppings. They offer a wide selection of flavors (including some unusual options like feta and spinach), each one carefully prepared and served fresh. Even better is their ‘double dough’ option that adds extra crust around the edges for a delicious twist!

Overall, Jet’s Pizza definitely earned its title as “best pizza in Palm Harbor”. If you’re ever in town, be sure to stop by and try it yourself – I promise you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Gino’s New York Style Pizzeria Tampa Rd Location

The first thing that struck me when I walked in was the smell – it was a heady mix of wonderful, savory pizza and doughy goodness. The atmosphere itself was bustling, but friendly – everyone seemed to be having a great time, which put me in the perfect frame of mind to enjoy the pizza.

When it came to ordering, it took all of my willpower not to just order one of everything on the menu – there were so many delicious sounding options! In the end though, I decided to go for their classic Margherita pizza and boy am I glad I did! The crust was thick and crunchy but still manageably thin enough that my fork could still handle it. The cheese was wonderfully stringy and gave off a slight hint of smokiness, while the tomatoes were wonderfully sweet and ripe. It truly ticked all the boxes for me!

To top it all off, Gino’s even had live music playing in the background during my meal. It added an extra element of joy to what already felt like an excellent night out with friends.

All in all, this really is some of the best pizza in Palm Harbor that you can find. If you’re ever in town looking for a great slice make sure you take a trip down to Gino’s!

#12 Joey’s New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant

I have to admit, I was skeptical at first. After all, how could pizza from such a small town measure up to the pizza I’ve had in Italy and New York? But after one bite of Joey’s margherita pizza, I knew I’d found something special. The cheese was perfectly melted, the sauce had an amazing flavor, and the crust was delightfully thin and crunchy.

The service was great too. Our server was friendly and accommodating, even after we asked for extra Parmesan cheese on our pies! He even brought us a complimentary appetizer when he saw us eyeing it longingly while we waited for our meal.

I absolutely loved my experience at Joey’s New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant! It definitely deserves its reputation as the best pizza in Palm Harbor. If you haven’t been there yet, go right now—you won’t regret it!