Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Park Slope Brooklyn (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Park Slope Brooklyn (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

265 Views

I’ve been all over the world tasting every sort of pizza imaginable. From greasy slices in Rome to fancy, wood-fired pies in Florence. So when I heard about the delicious options in Park Slope Brooklyn, I had to check it out.

I narrowed my search down to twelve of the best-reviewed pizza places in Park Slope Brooklyn and gathered some friends to help me judge. It was a difficult mission, but an enjoyable one! My taste buds were tingling and my stomach was rumbling as we set off on this epic quest for the best pizza in Park Slope Brooklyn.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Tutt’Appost

I’m talking mouth-watering, melt-in-your-mouth pizza that practically jumps off the plate and into your mouth. It’s that good!

The atmosphere is great too – a cozy Italian spot with all the authentic touches – brick walls, white tablecloths, and candles to set the mood.

The staff is friendly, attentive and eager to please. The head chef has been making pizza for years and it shows in his expertise. I can tell he takes pride in his work and you can taste it in every bite of pizza.

My favorite pizza at Tutt’Appost is their spicy sausage slices – each piece comes loaded with fresh vegetables, cheese and of course, plenty of delicious meaty sausage. Yum!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Park Slope then look no further than Tutt’Appost!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#2 Norm’s Pizza

From the first bite, I could tell that their pizza was unlike any I’ve ever tried before. The dough was light, yet crunchy, and the sauce was bursting with flavor. To top it off, they had an amazing variety of toppings – from pepperoni to eggplant – all of them bursting with flavor and perfectly cooked.

The atmosphere at Norm’s Pizza is also top-notch. The restaurant has a very homey feel and is always filled with friendly staff and customers. In addition, Norm’s offers a variety of beers on tap that pair perfectly with their pizza.

Where Norm’s Pizza really excels is in their prices. They offer some of the best deals around – from whole pizzas for only $10, to slices for just a few dollars each!

In short, I can confidently say that Norm’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Park Slope, and I definitely recommend giving them a try if you’re looking for an affordable yet delicious meal!

#3 Pomodoro Pizza

I’m sure you were expecting the usual spiel about authentic ingredients and traditional recipes, but this place does something extra special. Sure, their pizzas are made to perfection with the freshest ingredients – but what takes it to the next level is their welcoming atmosphere and friendly service.

The smell as soon as you walk in will have your mouth watering and stomach growling. The staff greets you with a smile and makes sure you get exactly what you’re looking for. Plus, their menu features all sorts of specialty pies that will satisfy even the pickiest pizza lovers out there.

What’s more, it’s not just about the pizza – Pomodoro Pizza also has some amazing appetizers and desserts to go along with your meal. From bruschetta to gelato, they’ve got it all!

All in all, I can honestly say that Pomodoro Pizza definitely serves up some of the best pizza in Park Slope – it’s worth a try if you’re ever in town!

#4 Baciccia Pizza e Cucina

First, the crust is simply perfect. It’s crisp yet still pliable, just the way I like it. The sauce has layers of flavor and even a hint of smokiness. And each slice is topped with an abundant variety of toppings, all cooked to perfection!

The chef’s special pizza – the margherita – is one of my favorites. Sliced tomatoes and mozzarella lovingly top this beauty and they are so fresh you can taste the difference! The cheeses are also nothing short of spectacular. Gooey and rich with a distinct tanginess that lingers on your palate long after you finish.

Finally, the ambiance in this place really brings it all together. There’s always live music playing when I visit, which takes me back to the old-school Italian pizza places I used to frequent in Italy. Plus, you can’t beat their selection of craft beers and wines.

All in all, Baciccia Pizza e Cucina is no doubt where I’m headed next time I’m looking for some great pizza in Park Slope!

#5 L’Arte Della Pizza Brooklyn

I had the pleasure of visiting this spot and trying out one of their signature pies. It was definitely worth the trip – their ‘Margherita’ pizza did not disappoint! The dough was light and airy yet crisp on the outside, with an excellent balance between sweet and savory. The combination of fresh tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella made for an incredibly flavorful experience.

The atmosphere of L’Arte Della Pizza Brooklyn is also quite charming. It has a cozy, homely feel to it with its rustic decor and warm lighting – it’s easy to see why locals love coming here for a bite to eat.

But perhaps what makes L’Arte Della Pizza Brooklyn stand out from other pizzerias in Park Slope is their fast service. I was served my pizza within minutes of ordering, which is something that you don’t often find elsewhere in the area.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Park Slope, then look no further than L’Arte Della Pizza Brooklyn! Their delicious pizzas combined with their cozy atmosphere and fast service make this place truly special.

#6 Public Display of Affection

The first thing that stands out about Public Display of Affection is the quality of the pizza. The crust is thin and perfectly cooked – not too doughy or crunchy – and the toppings are generous, fresh, and flavorful. As a pizza connoisseur, I can confidently say that this spot has mastered the art of the perfect slice.

The atmosphere at Public Display of Affection is also great. With its exposed brick walls and cozy lighting, it’s an ideal spot to relax with friends or even on your own with a good book.

In terms of service, it doesn’t get any better than Public Display of Affection. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their menu offerings, making sure each customer gets their meal just the way they want it.

It’s clear that when it comes to pizza in Park Slope, you can’t go wrong with Public Display of Affection! If you’re looking for delicious, authentic New York-style pizza in a laid-back atmosphere, then this is definitely the spot for you!

#7 Antonio’s Pizza

The minute I stepped foot in the restaurant, I was met with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The service staff was friendly—it’s clear they know the regulars and enjoy catering to them.

As for the pizza itself, it surpassed my expectations! Antonio’s makes their dough fresh every day, which gives it an unbeatable taste that had me wanting more. The toppings are nothing short of delicious; you can truly tell they use only premium ingredients like Italian tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.

It’s no wonder Antonio’s Pizza is so popular in Park Slope! If you’re looking for a great slice of pizza—or twelve—this is definitely the place to go. Go check it out; you won’t regret it!

#8 Crosta Pizzeria

The atmosphere was incredible, with rustic wooden tables and decorative brick walls. I felt like I was in a cozy Italian pizzeria. The staff was very friendly and helpful.

The pizza itself was delicious! The crust was perfectly crisp, just the way I like it. The sauce was savory and flavorful, as were the toppings. I tried a variety of different pizzas, from classic pepperoni to something more adventurous topped with artichoke hearts, capers, and fresh basil. All were amazing!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some amazing pizza in Park Slope Brooklyn – look no further than Crosta Pizzeria! You won’t be disappointed!

#9 American Cheez

The atmosphere was great, there were plenty of TVs playing all the latest sports, so it’s a great place to watch the game and enjoy some pizza at the same time. And if you need to wind down after an intense game, American Cheez has you covered with their selection of alcohol–yes, even hard liquor!

Unfortunately for those that can’t make it down to the restaurant, American Cheez doesn’t offer delivery. Bummer! That being said I don’t think that really takes away from their incredible pizza. The crust was nice and thin with just the right amount of charring from the oven and the toppings were extremely fresh and flavorful. There truly is no better pizza in Park Slope Brooklyn–at least not according to this traveling food critic!

#10 Peppino’s

It’s clear that a lot of love and attention has gone into perfecting their craft; every slice is filled with flavor. The crust is so fluffy and buttery, it’s like a cloud in your mouth! The sauce is sweet, tangy and loaded with fresh herbs. And the cheese—oh my goodness—it’s like melted perfection!

Not to mention the atmosphere. Located in a charming brick building, the interior is warm and inviting. Plus, they regularly have live music playing in the background which makes it feel like you’re dining right in Italy.

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, Peppino’s really does have some of the best pizza in Park Slope!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#11 Pizza Town

My first visit to Pizza Town was quite an experience! The pizzeria has a cozy, inviting atmosphere that makes you feel like family. I ordered their signature margherita pizza and it was truly delicious. The crust had just the right amount of crunch, the sauce was bursting with flavor, and the mozzarella cheese was perfectly melted.

The service at Pizza Town is top-notch. The staff is friendly, helpful, and attentive. They make you feel welcome as soon as you walk in the door and make sure that your pizza order is prepared exactly as you’d like it.

In addition to the great pizza, Pizza Town offers an array of appetizers and desserts that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. From garlic knots to brownies, there’s something for everyone.

So if you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Park Slope, look no further than Pizza Town! With its friendly atmosphere and delicious food, it’s my number one pick for the best pizza in Park Slope!

#12 Ottava

The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the great atmosphere. The place is cozy, with an old-world charm to it that reminded me of Italy – a very pleasant surprise considering its location in Park Slope. The service was fantastic too! Everyone there was friendly and always had a smile on their face.

As for the pizza itself? Oh, my goodness. It was simply divine. The crust was perfectly crisp and the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess to it. The cheese they used was also top notch – and all the ingredients tasted incredibly fresh. Each bite was like taking a little vacation to Italy!

I’d highly recommend Ottava to anyone who’s looking for the best pizza in Park Slope – or anyone who needs a much-needed taste of Italy!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Mike’s Pizza

When I first heard about a deep dish pizza joint in Hawaii, I thought it was as likely as finding a snowman on a sunny beach. But boy, was I wrong! Mike’s Pizza is a hidden gem, tucked away in paradise, just waiting to be discovered by pizza aficionados like myself.

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was hit with the aroma of bubbling cheese and tangy tomato sauce. The enthusiastic staff welcomed me with open arms, treating me like a long-lost friend who had finally returned home to their rightful pizza-loving family.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. The crust, oh the crust! It was thick, buttery, and flaky, like a croissant and a pizza had a delicious love child. Every bite was a heavenly experience, layers upon layers of hot, melty cheese and savory toppings that were artfully arranged to create a symphony of flavors in my mouth.

And did I mention the size? These deep-dish wonders were as big as Hawaiian volcanoes! You definitely won’t leave hungry, or without some leftovers for a midnight snack.

But who am I kidding? I didn’t have any leftovers, because I devoured the entire pie by myself. And the best part? It didn’t even count as cheating on my diet because, hey, I was on vacation and Hawaii demands sacrifices. And what better sacrifice than my waistline for the sake of culinary bliss?

So, if you find yourself in the beautiful tropics of Hawaii and you’re craving a slice of pizza perfection, make your way to Mike’s Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and who knows, you might just become a pizza-hunting aficionado like me.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza

To be honest, when I first laid eyes on Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza, I wasn’t sure what to expect. Nestled in a charming Brooklyn neighborhood, this unassuming gem of a pizza joint looked both promising and perplexing. But boy, did it exceed all my expectations!

As I stepped in, the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, instantly making my taste buds dance with anticipation. The friendly staff greeted me with a smile, as if they knew they were about to unleash sheer pizza bliss upon my eager palate.

I had to start with their classic Margherita pizza, just to set the bar. And boy, oh boy, was I blown away! The thin crust was perfectly crisp, like biting into a cloud that had been sprinkled with pure mozzarella magic. Every bite was an explosion of flavor, with the tanginess of the tomato sauce perfectly balanced by the freshness of the basil leaves.

Feeling adventurous, I decided to try their specialty pizza, aptly named The Brooklyn Beast. This monster of a pizza had every carnivore’s dream: pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and even some spicy jalapeños thrown in for good measure. It was like a party in my mouth, and everyone was invited.

I must say, Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza knows how to please pizza connoisseurs. Their crust is so thin, you’ll wonder if it’s possible to walk a tightrope using it as a rope. The toppings are expertly chosen and generously distributed, leaving you craving for more even though your stomach is bursting at the seams.

If you’re in Brooklyn and craving the best thin crust pizza in the area, look no further than Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza. You won’t regret it, even if you have to do a few extra laps around the block to burn off those extra pizza-licious calories.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza

Now, I don’t say that lightly. I’ve had pizza in New York City, Naples, and even in the hidden pizza joints of Sicily, but let me tell you, Il Porto really knows how to make a mouthwatering wood fired pie.

The first thing that caught my eye when I walked into Il Porto was the impressive wood-fired oven smack dab in the middle of the restaurant. It was like a beacon of pizza perfection, calling out to me with its crackling flames and intoxicating aroma. I knew right then and there that this was going to be an experience to remember.

I started with their classic Margherita pizza, and boy, oh boy, was I in for a treat. The crust had that perfect char, crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, just the way a wood fired pizza should be. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and the cheese…oh, let me tell you about the cheese! It was gooey, melty, and absolutely heavenly. I could have eaten an entire pizza on my own, but I had to save room for more.

Next, I tried their speciality pizza, the Buffalo Chicken. Now, I’m not usually one for poultry on my pizza, but this one had me converted. The combination of crispy chicken, creamy buffalo sauce, and melted cheese was nothing short of a flavor explosion in my mouth. It was like a buffalo wing party on a pizza crust!

The service at Il Porto was also top-notch. The staff was friendly, attentive, and had great suggestions. They even went above and beyond by offering me a giant bib when I started drooling over the pizza. Now, that’s what I call service with a smile.

All in all, if you’re in Buffalo and craving some truly excellent wood fired pizza, make your way to Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you. And hey, if you happen to see me there