Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Paterson NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Paterson NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

132 Views

But which one’s the best? To find out, I decided to sample every single pizza place in Paterson – all twelve of them! After days eating my way through this vibrant city, I’m ready to give you my verdict on the best pizza in Paterson NJ.

Sure, there were plenty of yummy slices – some even with interesting toppings like crickets and jellybeans (it’s a thing!). But only one place really made me say “wow.” So read on for my top pick – and the rest of my rankings from bad to great.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Lefty’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

When I first stepped into Lefty’s, my taste buds were overwhelmed with the mouth-watering aroma of freshly baked pepperoni and cheese. The restaurant itself is a charming establishment with its warm decor featuring playful pictures of the owners, who are left-handed!

As for the pizza itself, it was amazing. The perfect crust had just the right amount of crunch and was topped with delicious sauce, tasty mozzarella cheese, and freshly chopped veggies straight from the local farmers market. The flavor combinations were unbeatable!

But here’s what really sets Lefty’s apart: their signature “Lefty’s Special” – a unique combination of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and jalapenos. It was truly a masterpiece – no other pizza place in Paterson NJ can compare.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Paterson NJ then look no further than Lefty’s Pizzeria and Restaurant. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Paterson!

#2 Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant

As a serious pizza aficionado, I must say that Patsy’s is the place to go when you’re craving something special. The menu has a great selection of pizzas that range from traditional favorites to unique creations. Plus, they have alcoholic beverages and hard liquor if you need an extra kick in your slice!

But maybe the best part about Patsy’s is their kid’s menu. Kids can get their own mini pies (and parents can keep them from stealing off of the adult’s plates!) And for those with a sweet tooth, there are also desserts to top it all off.

The only downside is that Patsy’s doesn’t offer delivery, so you’ll have to eat your pizza inside the restaurant. But if you want some of the best pizza in Paterson NJ, Patsy’s is definitely worth a visit!

#3 Ellison Pizza & Deli

The crust is perfectly cooked and has a delightful crunchy texture. The cheese they use melts in your mouth and provides an extra layer of flavor in each bite. Additionally, the toppings they offer are fresh and flavorful.

But what really sets Ellison Pizza & Deli apart from the competition is their incredible sauce! It’s zesty and has just the right amount of sweetness. I found myself wanting more and more with each bite!

Overall, this pizza place ranks high on my list for best pizza in Paterson NJ. The staff is friendly, the atmosphere cozy, and the pizza…well let’s just say I will be coming back for more.

#4 Taormina

The first thing that strikes you about Taormina is the atmosphere. It’s a friendly and welcoming restaurant with homey decor, comfortable seating, and a warm feeling when you walk in.

The pizza at Taormina is incredible! The crust is perfectly thin, crispy on the outside and chewy inside. The toppings are generous and flavorful. They offer a wide variety of classic Italian-style pies, as well as some creative options like their popular Eggplant Parmesan Pie.

On top of great food, Taormina also offers excellent service! We were seated right away and served quickly by a helpful staff member who talked us through the menu options. Every question we had was answered promptly with a smile.

Overall, Taormina has to be one of the best pizza places in Paterson NJ! I’d recommend it to anyone looking for an authentic Italian-style pizza experience without having to leave town.

#5 Joe’s Pizzeria

The crust was so perfectly crisp. Even after traveling for hours, it didn’t lose its crunch. The sauce was sweet and had just the right amount of spice. And the cheese—oh my goodness, it was the perfect combination of creamy and salty.

Let’s talk about toppings now! They were fresh and flavorful; the pepperoni were especially tasty. I heard they make their own sausage too! It adds a special touch to their pizza that other places just don’t have.

But what really put this place over the top? Their customer service! The owner Joe is so passionate about his craft; he takes time to explain each pizza’s process and ingredients before serving it up — definitely something special.

At the end of the day, Joe’s Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in Paterson NJ, with quality ingredients prepared to perfection and excellent customer service. Highly recommend!

#6 Giovanni’s Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, the service is friendly and attentive, and the pizza itself? Absolutely delicious!

I had the classic margherita with extra pepperoni, and it was mouthwateringly good. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the sauce was just right – not too sweet or tangy – and the cheese melted perfectly on top. I could barely contain myself when I took my first bite.

As for toppings, Giovanni’s Pizza has something for everyone: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions… you name it! They also offer a wide range of specialty pizzas if you’re feeling adventurous.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Paterson NJ, look no further than Giovanni’s Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

#7 Tony’s Pizza

The first thing that you notice when you enter Tony’s Pizza is the mouth-watering aroma of freshly made pizza. The decor of the restaurant is simple and inviting, and it isn’t overly crowded.

The menu at Tony’s Pizza includes all sorts of classic toppings as well as some unique creations like the goat cheese and arugula pizza. Prices are very reasonable and they offer delivery services too.

I was impressed with the quality of the pizza at Tony’s Pizza. The crust was perfectly cooked, not too thick or thin, and had a great flavor. The sauces were flavorful and balanced, while their toppings were fresh and full of flavor. The best part was their generous portions – I could barely finish one slice!

Overall, my experience at Tony’s Pizza was great! Their amazing pizzas make them the best pizza place in Paterson NJ without a doubt. If you’re ever in town looking for a delicious pie, definitely give Tony’s Pizza a try!

#8 Silk City Pizza

I’m pretty sure I was a pizza-eating champ in a past life, so when people ask me for the best place to get pizza near Paterson NJ, Silk City Pizza is my go-to spot every time.

The atmosphere at Silk City Pizza is like an old-school Italian pizzeria. Dark wood booths, red and white checkered table clothes, and even some classic Italian music streaming in the background.

The pizza itself was phenomenal! The dough was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crunch and the toppings were flavorful without being overpowering. But most importantly, the sauce! It had incredible depth of flavor with just enough spice that never left you feeling heavy or weighed down after eating it.

The service was top-notch too! The servers were attentive and knowledgeable about their menu offerings, which made ordering easy. Plus they have carryout available if you don’t feel like waiting or sitting in their restaurant.

After all my travels, I can confidently say that Silk City Pizza has some of the best pizza around Paterson NJ. I highly recommend this place if you ever find yourself looking for a great slice of pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Clifton!

#9 Sam’s Pizza by City Catering

When I first walked into this pizza joint, I was pleasantly surprised. It only took a few minutes to realize why it’s known as one of the best in town. The restaurant is so inviting and decorated in classic Italian style. From the red-and-white striped tablecloths to the old-fashioned ceramic dishes, everything about this place exudes nostalgia and charm.

As for the pizza itself, oh boy! Whether you like your pizza thin or thick crust, Sam’s Pizza by City Catering has something for everyone. My favorite is their signature “Sammy Special” – a mix of pepperoni, sausage, garlic, olives and cheese piled up on top of a perfectly cooked dough. The flavors here are out of this world!

The service at Sam’s Pizza by City Catering was also impressive. They are always so friendly and willing to go above and beyond to make sure each customer leaves happy with their order. This made my experience that much more enjoyable!

With all that being said, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza in Paterson NJ then look no further than Sam’s Pizza by City Catering – they’ve got some of the best pizza around!

#10 Prima Pizzeria

The restaurant has a casual atmosphere and the staff is always friendly and welcoming. Despite being located in a shady part of town, I felt safe entering Prima Pizzeria, where I was warmly greeted by the owner.

The menu had a wide variety of options – from traditional margherita to more experimental creations like chorizo and pineapple. After making my selection, the pizza arrived quickly and the presentation was impressive. The crust was perfectly charred and crisp while the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

I couldn’t resist tasting more than one of their pizzas and all were delicious! My favorite might have been the Italian-style sausage with fennel pollen – it melted in my mouth.

Overall, Prima Pizzeria is hands down the best pizza place in Paterson NJ that I’ve ever been to! If you’re looking for an authentic Italian pizzeria experience then Prima Pizzeria is your spot!

#11 Frank & Joe’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Frank & Joe’s is reminiscent of a small Italian pizzeria, complete with red and white checkered tablecloths. The smell of fresh dough and melted cheese permeates the air, making it hard not to order one of their signature pies as soon as you walk through the door.

When I took my first bite, it was like a flavor explosion in my mouth! The crust had a nice crispiness that gave way to a rich and creamy cheese layer. From the finest mozzarella to freshly cooked vegetables, every topping added something special to the pizza.

But what really made this pizza stand out was the sauce—it was by far the best part! It had just the right amount of tang and spice, but still let the flavors of each topping come through.

Overall, Frank & Joe’s Pizza is a must-visit spot for anyone looking for some delicious pizza in Paterson NJ! If you’re ever in town, be sure to give it a try—I promise you won’t regret it!

#12 Broadway Pizza

The first thing that struck me when I arrived was the aroma. It was like a heavenly mix of melted cheese and tangy tomato sauce. The pizza itself was absolutely delicious! The thin, crisp crust was cooked to perfection, and complimented the flavourful toppings perfectly.

The staff were also extremely welcoming and attentive, ensuring my dining experience was nothing short of excellent.

Overall, I’m happy to say that Broadway Pizza has been the best pizza I’ve had in Paterson NJ! If you’re ever in town, make sure you stop by for a slice!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant

Let me tell you – this place is a hidden gem tucked away in the heart of the Garden State. As soon as I walked through the door, I was hit with the mouthwatering smell of bubbling cheese and crispy crust. My taste buds were practically doing cartwheels in anticipation!

As a traveling food critic, I’ve had my fair share of pizza. From the streets of Naples to the bustling pizzerias of New York City, I thought I had seen it all. But let me tell you, Patsy’s knows how to make a pizza that’ll make you weak at the knees.

The crust is thin, delicate, and perfectly crispy. I could have sworn I heard angels singing as I took my first bite. And the toppings? Oh, don’t even get me started. They piled on the fresh mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and an array of delicious toppings that made my taste buds do a happy dance.

But what really sets Patsy’s apart is their attention to detail. The staff is not only friendly but also incredibly efficient. They take your order with a smile and have your piping hot pizza on your table in no time. And the ambience? It’s like stepping into an Italian grandmother’s kitchen – cozy, warm, and filled with love.

So, if you find yourself in north jersey and craving a perfectly thin crust pizza, head on over to Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you, and you’ll be planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your last slice.