Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Pawleys Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in South Carolina

Best Pizza in Pawleys Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

96 Views

After sampling pizza all over the world, I’ve come to Pawleys Island to see how it stacks up in the global rankings. To find out where the best pizza is, I visited eight of the town’s top establishments. It was delicious work! In my lighthearted and humorous review, I’ll tell you which places are worthy of their reputation and which ones need to step up their game. So buckle up – let’s go on a journey through the deliciousness that is Pawleys Island pizza!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of South Carolina

#1 Rosies Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Rosies is warm and inviting – perfect for a family dinner or a night out with friends. On top of that, they serve a variety of alcoholic drinks, have a kids menu, and even offer dessert!

The pizza itself was delicious! The crust was just the right amount of crunchy and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Every bite was pure perfection.

Despite all its charms, the only downside to Rosies is that they don’t offer delivery – which means you’ll have to make your way to Pawleys Island if you want to enjoy their amazing pies. But I think it’s worth it! Rosies really does have some of the best pizza in town.

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Murrells Inlet!

#2 Landolfi’s Italian Bakery

I was enchanted by the cozy atmosphere and casual setting at Landolfi’s. The staff is friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable – they always have great recommendations when you’re not sure what to order.

The pizza itself is absolutely divine! Their thin crust brick oven pies are bursting with flavor, and the balance of their sauces and toppings is spot-on. Toppings include favorites like Italian sausage, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, spinach, pepperoni and more – each slice offers a unique combination that never gets old.

The only downside I can think of for Landolfi’s Italian Bakery is that it can get quite busy during peak times – but fortunately the waitstaff does an excellent job at keeping everyone served in a timely manner.

Ultimately, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Pawleys Island – look no further than Landolfi’s Italian Bakery! I’m already planning my next trip there – I just know it won’t disappoint!

#3 R’Way Pizza and Family Tavern

I arrived at this unassuming restaurant expecting standard pizza, but I was in for a much more remarkable experience. The staff welcomed me with open arms, served up some delicious free samples of their signature recipes, and then made sure my pizza order was perfect.

The pizza itself was incredible! It had the perfect combination of crispy crust, tangy sauce, salty cheese, and flavorful toppings. I especially loved their signature pepperoni slices which were perfectly cooked with just the right amount of char from the oven. In addition to that mouth-watering flavor combination, the portions are generous and you won’t leave hungry!

Overall, R’Way Pizza is a must-try for anyone looking for great pizza in Pawleys Island. Not only does it have an impressive selection of authentic Italian pizzas, but their friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it a great all around experience. My visit here has convinced me that R’Way Pizza is definitely the best pizza in Pawleys Island!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Murrells Inlet!

#4 Deroma’s Pizzeria

My experience started the moment I stepped in the door. I was immediately drawn to the cozy atmosphere that made me feel as if I had stepped into an Italian villa. The owner, Deroma, greeted us with a warm smile and took us to our table.

The menu was impressive with delicious pizzas made from only the freshest ingredients. But what really caught my eye were the unique toppings like artichoke hearts, kalamata olives, fire-roasted peppers, and prosciutto – all of which give the pizza a distinctive flavor.

But it’s not just about looks or interesting ingredients; it’s also about flavor. The pizza dough is perfectly cooked and has just enough crunch when you bite into it. The sauce is also incredibly fresh and flavorful, adding a nice balance to the individual ingredients on top.

And finally, presentation matters! Deroma knows how to ensure that each slice looks as beautiful as it tastes – every detail of its appearance is taken into account to make sure that you get the best pizza in Pawleys Island!

I highly recommend Deroma’s Pizzeria for anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience. If you’re visiting Pawleys Island soon, I guarantee that you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Massey’s Pizza Pawleys Island

The atmosphere of Massey’s is fantastic, the staff are very friendly and make you feel like you’re at home. The restaurant itself looks like a cozy little Italian pizzeria and they have over sixty different pizzas to choose from!

The pizza was delicious, with fresh ingredients and lots of flavorful toppings. The crust was perfectly crispy and not too thick which I really appreciate in a great pizza. I had the special of the day—a Mexican-style pizza with chorizo, jalapenos, and cilantro—and it was flavorful without being too spicy for my palate.

I also had one of their famous calzones which were to die for. The cheese oozed out from every corner and the sauce was amazing. If you’re looking for something a little bit more interesting than your traditional pizza, then this is definitely worth a try!

Overall, Massey’s Pizza Pawleys Island is simply the best when it comes to pizza in Pawleys Island. From their selection of delicious pizzas to their warm atmosphere, it’s an absolute must-try if you’re in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Surfside Beach!

#6 Domino’s Pizza

The first thing that stands out at Domino’s Pizza is the smell – it’s appetizing and tantalizing. The aroma of fresh dough being baked with all the delicious toppings fills your senses as soon as you walk in the door.

The pizza here is quite unique and will satisfy even the most discerning palate. With dozens of delicious combinations to choose from, you’re sure to find something that fits your tastes. Plus, they offer great deals on large orders so you can really get your money’s worth!

I was quite impressed with their commitment to quality and customer service during my visit. Every employee was friendly and helpful, taking time to answer any questions I had about their pizzas and specials. And, the pizzas were cooked to order and came out piping hot!

To top it off, I had a chance to sample some of their side dishes and desserts as well – all delicious! From creamy macaroni & cheese to crunchy garlic knots and decadent chocolate cake, I think Domino’s has put together a menu full of yummy treats.

All in all, my experience at Domino’s Pizza was one that I won’t soon forget. They have definitely earned the title of having the best pizza in Pawleys Island!

#7 Gios Italian Kitchen Pawleys Island

On my recent visit, I was impressed by the quality of the food and service. The pizza crust was thin, but not too thin, and cooked to perfection – absolutely delicious! And it didn’t hurt that I could wash it down with a cold beer or hard liquor from their bar.

The great thing about Gios is that they have something for everyone. Kids can enjoy the kid’s menu which has enough options to please even the pickiest eater. For those who are looking for something different than pizza, there are plenty of vegetarian options on the menu as well. Lastly, if you’re looking for an insane dessert after your meal then you won’t be disappointed either!

Of course there is one downside to Gios – no delivery service! But with all the other benefits, it’s worth making the trip out to Pawleys Island and checking this place out. After being around the world looking for great pizza, I can honestly say Gios Italian Kitchen Pawleys Island has some of the best pizza in Pawleys Island!

If you’re willing to go an extra 26 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Conway!

#8 Caffe Piccolo

My visit started with the crispy and delicious house-made crust. It was bursting with flavor and had just the right amount of crunch. The toppings were all fresh and you can tell they put a lot of thought into building each pie.

The benefit to dining at Caffe Piccolo is the unique atmosphere it offers. Not only can you enjoy their incredible pizza, but they also serve alcohol (including hard liquor!), which makes your dinner experience even more enjoyable. They also have some great vegetarian options, so everyone in your party can feel satisfied. And then there’s dessert – it’s insanely good! So make sure you save room for something sweet after dinner.

The only downside to Caffe Piccolo is that there’s no delivery option available, so if you want to get their amazing pizza you’ll have to venture out for it – but trust me when I say: it’s worth it! This is not only one of the best places for pizza in Pawleys Island, but it’s also a nice tourist spot. So enjoy a bit of sightseeing before enjoying their pies!