Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Petaluma (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in Petaluma (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

137 Views

I’ve had the privilege of tasting pizza all over the world, so I feel uniquely qualified to weigh in on the best pizza this small California town has to offer.

I recently embarked on a mission to sample as many different pizzas as I could find in Petaluma and, after much eating and deliberation, I narrowed it down to my top twelve picks!

What can you expect from this list? A lighthearted review with some humorous anecdotes thrown in for extra flavor. So let’s get started – who makes the best pizza in Petaluma?

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Magdelena’s Savories & Sweets

My taste buds were tantalized by the combination of savory and sweet flavors. The crust was perfectly cooked and had just a hint of sweetness to it. The sauce was delicious; it complemented the other ingredients without overwhelming them. The toppings were top-notch, all freshly prepared with great care.

The dining experience at Magdelena’s was outstanding! The staff was friendly and attentive. I felt welcome from the moment I walked in the door, and they made sure I got what I wanted quickly and efficiently.

To sum it up: Magdelena’s Savories & Sweets has some of the best pizza in Petaluma. If you’re looking for a unique and delicious pizza experience, this is definitely the place to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 33 more pizza places in Sonoma!

#2 Brixx Pizzeria

The atmosphere is fun, relaxed and inviting – perfect for tourists looking for a pizzeria with an edge. Not only do they have all the usual ingredients, but they also offer some vegetarian options and even serve alcohol (including hard liquor!). You can enjoy a beer or cocktail while you wait for your pizza to bake – it’s that fast!

And if you still have room at the end of your meal, they offer delicious desserts too. What more could you want from a pizza place?

The only downside is that there’s no delivery option, but that’s not enough to stop me from coming back again and again. If you’re ever in Petaluma, make sure to check out Brixx Pizzeria … it’ll be the best pizza decision you’ve ever made!

#3 Hector’s Pizza

The atmosphere alone was enough to make me stay. The cozy brick walls and the welcoming staff really made me feel at home. But let’s get to what matters: the pizza.

It was simply divine! The crust was crunchy on the outside, but smooth and fluffy on the inside. Not too much cheese either, so it wasn’t heavy – just perfect. I had a white pizza with peppers and mushrooms, with a sprinkle of oregano, that was an absolute delight!

By far one of my favorite pizzas I’ve ever had in my life (and trust me, that’s saying something). If you’re ever looking for delicious, authentic Italian-style pizza in Petaluma…Hector’s Pizza is your place!

#4 Pinky’s Pizza Parlor

The other night, I stopped in for dinner and was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere is cozy yet upbeat, with plenty of seating and a lively soundtrack to enjoy while you eat.

The service was excellent as well—the employees were friendly, attentive, and quick to bring out our order. But of course, the pizza is what really stole the show!

I ordered the pepperoni pie with extra cheese and was blown away by how delicious it was. The crust had just the right amount of crunch and the cheese was perfectly melted. Every bite was sheer bliss!

If you’ve got a craving for some quality pizza, look no further than Pinky’s Pizza Parlor. It’s definitely my top pick for the best pizza in Petaluma!

#5 Acre Pizza

First and foremost, the crust is unparalleled. It’s perfectly scorched on the outside and chewy on the inside. This balance of texture and flavor is achieved with a unique blend of flour they must have developed in their secret kitchen laboratory.

Then there’s the sauce. I’ve rarely tasted anything like it before: sweet, complex, and bursting with flavor. The cheese is far from run-of-the-mill, too – it’s rich, creamy and utterly moreish. Each topping they put on makes me question why every other pizza joint isn’t doing the same thing!

The atmosphere at Acre Pizza is also worth mentioning; cozy yet vibrant – like being in a friend’s living room but with much better food!

I can safely say that this place serves up some of the best pizza around – a truly great slice of Italy!

#6 The Mad Sicilian

From the moment I stepped foot inside this cozy Petaluma pizza joint, I knew I was in for a treat. The rustic decor and checkered tablecloths transported me right into the heart of Italy.

The pizza itself is nothing short of remarkable. Piled high with cheese and topped with the freshest ingredients, it was clear that the Mad Sicilian put a great deal of care into each pie they serve. After one bite, I realized why they were considered one of the best in town!

In addition to their incredible pizza, they also offer an extensive selection of beer and wine that pairs perfectly with any order. The staff is friendly and attentive to each customer’s needs, constantly keeping an eye on whether you need anything else.

If you’re searching for some of the best pizza in Petaluma, look no further than The Mad Sicilian. Whether you dine-in or take out, you won’t be disappointed by this authentic Italian eatery!

#7 Old Chicago Pizza Delivery & Takeout

When I first arrived, I was skeptical. After all, how could a small pizza delivery joint be better than all the fancy Italian pizzerias I’d tried in Rome and Milan? But when that first pie arrived at my door, it changed my mind.

The sauce is tangy and fresh with perfect basil seasoning, the crust is fluffy and slightly chewy, and the mozzarella cheese – well let’s just say that it tastes like it’s been stretched to perfection! The toppings are also excellent – nicely cooked pepperoni, ham, mushrooms and olives perfectly complement each other on top of the pizza.

Not only is their food delicious but they also have great prices. To top it all off, the delivery times are lightning fast! All in all, Old Chicago Pizza Delivery & Takeout has become my go-to pizza place when I’m craving a piping hot slice of cheesy goodness. It’s definitely one of the best pizzas in Petaluma!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Santa Rosa!

#8 New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant

The restaurant itself is a cozy place with great ambiance and excellent service. The first thing that struck me when I entered was the wonderful smell of dough baking in the oven.

I ordered a pepperoni pizza and was not disappointed! The crust had just the right amount of crispiness and the sauce was perfectly seasoned. Every bite was full of flavor and left me wanting more.

For those who want to go beyond the traditional, New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant also offers unique pizzas like their Spinach and Feta Pie or even Vegan Pesto pizza. Other than pizza, they have delicious sandwiches, salads and deserts as well.

Overall, I highly recommend New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant – it really is some of the best pizza in Petaluma!

#9 Red Boy Pizza Petaluma

I must say, I was impressed. The pizza had a perfect thin crust that was nice and crispy. Topped with homemade sauce and fresh, flavorful toppings, the pizza was truly mouth-watering. Plus, it was cooked to perfection!

The atmosphere at Red Boy Pizza Petaluma was just as good as the food. The restaurant had a cozy vibe that made it easy to relax and enjoy a delicious meal with friends. Plus, the staff were friendly and helpful – I felt like I was part of their family!

Overall, Red Boy Pizza Petaluma is definitely worth visiting if you’re craving some of the best pizza in Petaluma. Trust me – this place will leave your taste buds begging for more!

#10 Stefano’s pizza

The first time I visited, I was skeptical – how could a small pizza place in Petaluma possibly compare to big-city pizzerias. But, boy was I wrong! The moment I walked in, it felt like a family-owned Italian restaurant that had been lovingly handed down through generations. The atmosphere was warm and inviting.

I ordered the Meat Lover’s Delight and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly cooked with a wonderful flavor that put many of the big city pizzas to shame. Topped with an amazing selection of meats, it exceeded my expectations and left me wanting more.

The staff at Stefano’s were incredibly friendly and helpful throughout my visit and made sure to check back often to make sure everything was satisfactory. They even offered flavorful suggestions for sides and desserts that added an extra layer of enjoyment to the meal.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Petaluma, Stefano’s is your spot. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, you will definitely enjoy your time here!

#11 Fregene’s Pizza

I was pleasantly surprised by the vast and diverse menu. Not only did Fregene’s have a great selection of classic pizzas, but they also had some vegetarian options for my herbivorous friends. I’m no vegetarian, but I must say that their veggie pizza definitely gave me some interesting and unique flavors.

The atmosphere was fun and welcoming, too. The staff was very friendly and helpful in making sure we got exactly what we wanted. Not to mention it didn’t hurt that the prices at Fregene’s were really reasonable!

The one downside is that unfortunately there’s no delivery option. But if you’re looking for an awesome pizza experience in Petaluma, then I highly recommend Fregene’s Pizza – it’s one of the best around!

#12 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The crust is light and fluffy, loaded with just the right amount of cheese, and topped with perfectly cooked toppings. The secret? They let you choose exactly what goes into your pizza – from fresh-sliced veggies to handmade sauces to premium meats – so you know it’s going to be absolutely delicious. Plus, these guys don’t skimp on the ingredients – your pizza will be fully loaded with only the freshest ingredients each and every time.

I was also impressed by their variety of options. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pepperoni pie or something more adventurous like a Create Your Own pizza, Papa Murphy’s has something to satisfy everyone. And if that wasn’t enough, they have a special gluten-free crust that rivals any chain out there!

But don’t think that I’m just hyping them up because they offer such awesome pizzas – I’m not! Papa Murphy’s offers some of the best customer service around. From their friendly staff to their speedy delivery times, they make sure that each and every customer leaves feeling satisfied. At the end of the day, it’s clear that Papa Murphy’s puts quality over quantity – in this case, it pays off big time!

It’s no exaggeration to say that Papa Murphy’s has some of the best pizza in Petaluma (not to mention the world!). Between their delicious pizzas and outstanding customer service, anyone who eats at Papa Murphy’s is pretty much guaranteed a great experience every time.