Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Plymouth MN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Minnesota

Best Pizza in Plymouth MN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

209 Views

I’ve traveled the world tasting pizza, but I’m always excited to see what the local spots have to offer. And Plymouth MN has a lot of great pizza choices! In fact, I recently spent some time investigating the different pizzerias in town and sampling their pies. After trying 12 different places, I feel confident that I can identify Plymouth’s best pizza.

So if you’re looking for a delicious slice of cheesy goodness or want to order an entire pie, come along with me as I share my experiences at the best pizza joints in Plymouth MN.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Minnesota

#1 ElMar’s NY Pizza

As soon as I stepped in the door, I knew I was in for something special. The sights and smells of traditional New York-style pizza were intoxicating. From the big, bold ovens to the bubbling cheese on the pies, I wanted it all!

The crust was just the right mix of crunchy and chewy – not too thick or thin. The sauce had a perfect balance of sweet and tangy that complemented whatever topping choices you made. There were some delicious combinations like pepperoni and onion with a hint of garlic oil for an incredible burst of flavor.

But let’s talk about the star of ElMar’s NY Pizza: their cheese! It was deliciously gooey with a unique texture that could only be achieved through slow simmering. This is definitely some of the best pizza cheese I’ve ever had!

All in all, ElMar’s NY Pizza is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking to get your hands on some seriously good pizza. Their combination of traditional ingredients, classic techniques, and great atmosphere will make you feel like you’re at home in their kitchen. So what are you waiting for? Get yourself over to ElMar’s NY Pizza and treat yourself to the best pizza in Plymouth MN!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Maple Grove!

#2 Jet’s Pizza

The atmosphere is unbeatable – with square-shaped slices, and a wide variety of toppings and crusts to choose from, I’m sure there’s something for everyone. The staff are friendly and attentive too, which is always nice when you’ve traveled the world to taste pizza.

The pizza was cooked perfectly, and it was incredibly tasty! It was packed with flavor, melted in my mouth, and had an amazing crunchy texture. The sauce had a great balance of sweet and savory that made me feel like I was on cloud nine. And of course, the cheese was plenty and just melted in your mouth as well.

I would highly recommend Jet’s Pizza to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Plymouth MN – it’s worth every penny!

#3 Punch Pizza Wayzata

I visited Punch Pizza with my family and we were not disappointed. We started off with a couple COLD beers, which was a nice surprise! Not all pizza places offer that, but we enjoyed it. Then, for the kids, they have an awesome kid’s menu that kept my nieces busy coloring while they waited for their food.

Moving on to the actual food, Punch Pizza has some fantastic options whether you are vegetarian or like me, an omnivore! They had some delicious veggie toppings and I opted for some classic pepperoni, sausage and onion. The pies were cooked perfectly in their wood-fired oven and the crust was just crunchy enough.

For dessert we split a sweet nutella calzone (I know what you’re thinking: as if it wasn’t already heavenly enough!) It was so good that I almost forgot to mention that sadly they do not offer delivery service. However, they make up for it with other amazing offers like being a great tourist spot if you’re in Plymouth!

All-in-all this place is definitely worth checking out for anyone looking for the best pizza in Plymouth MN!

#4 Hometowne Pizza

When I arrived at Hometowne Pizza, I immediately noticed the cozy atmosphere and good energy. The interior was inviting and had a homey feel, which made me think I was in for something special.

I ordered my pizza and waited with anticipation as it cooked in their wood-fired oven. Finally, it emerged fresh and glistening with cheesy goodness. A bite of the pizza was enough to confirm my suspicions–this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside but delightfully chewy in the middle. The sauce was flavorful yet not too acidic, and there were plenty of delicious toppings to choose from.

I’m quite confident that Hometowne Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Plymouth MN–and maybe even beyond! Floor staff were attentive throughout my visit, further boosting its score with me. If you’re ever looking for a great slice of pie, be sure to stop by Hometowne Pizza–you won’t regret it!

#5 Maggie’s Restaurant

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting; the wait staff are courteous, friendly, and knowledgeable. It’s easy to get comfortable here!

The menu has something for everyone with a wide selection of classic pizzas including pepperoni, sausage and cheese, and vegetarian options. I recommend the Maggie’s Deluxe which has all of your favorites piled on top of a thin crust. It was delicious!

The pizza itself is cooked perfectly – the crust is chewy and flavorful, the cheese is gooey, and the toppings are fresh and plentiful. The combination makes for an unforgettable pizza experience that you won’t find anywhere else in town.

I’m convinced that Maggie’s Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Plymouth MN! From the top-notch ingredients to their friendly hospitality, a visit to Maggie’s is sure to be an enjoyable one!

#6 Gina Maria’s Pizza

To say I was impressed with my experience would be an understatement. The pizza had a crisp and delicious crust, the perfect blend of flavors in the cheese and toppings, and it was cooked to perfection. It felt like every bite was better than the last!

The service was also top-notch. Everyone working at Gina Maria’s Pizza was incredibly friendly and accommodating – they took the time to make sure we were happy with our order. Plus, they were super helpful when we asked for recommendations on what other items to try – the garlic breadsticks ended up being a huge hit!

I highly recommend stopping by Gina Maria’s Pizza for a great meal if you’re ever in Plymouth MN – trust me, it’ll be well worth the visit! You’ll leave full and feeling satisfied that you just enjoyed some of the best pizza in town.

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Eden Prairie!

#7 Latuff’s Pizzeria

I’ve had my fair share of pizzas in my day, but Latuff’s really brought it to a whole new level. The crust was perfectly cooked and just the right thickness – not too thin, not too thick. The cheese was gooey and flavorful – definitely some of the best I’ve ever eaten. And the toppings were fresh and plentiful – definitely not skimpy on the portion size!

The staff at Latuff’s was also top-notch. They were friendly and welcoming, always offering helpful suggestions when I wasn’t sure what to order. In fact, even though I’d been to plenty of pizza places before coming to Latuff’s, I must admit they helped me find something unique that left me feeling like I’d truly experienced something special.

In short, Latuff’s is one of the best pizza joints around and if you’re ever in Plymouth MN make sure you stop by for a slice! You won’t regret it!

#8 Station Pizzeria

I’m a firm believer that you don’t have to go all the way to Italy or New York City to find great pizza. Station Pizzeria proved me right. From their signature thin crusts to their signature sauces, they had the perfect balance of flavors and textures.

The cheese was delightfully gooey and the toppings were cooked perfectly crisp. The crust was so light and fluffy it almost seemed like they were doing something special with it! Even though I stuffed myself full, I still found my way back a few days later for more delicious pizza!

It wasn’t just the food though. The atmosphere was also quite pleasant. There was a nice mix of music playing in the background and everyone there seemed to be having a good time.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Plymouth MN (or even beyond), look no further than Station Pizzeria!

#9 Davanni’s Pizza & Hot Hoagies

When I stepped through the door, the first thing I noticed was that Davanni’s is not just any old pizza place. The interior had a modern twist on Italian-style décor, making it feel more like you were entering an upscale Italian pizzeria than a casual eatery.

The service was great: friendly and attentive. But that wasn’t the best part! The pizza at Davanni’s did not disappoint. The selection is top-notch, with an impressive array of classic flavors like pepperoni and cheese as well as more adventurous toppings such as jalapeño poppers. Each slice was perfectly cooked with a delightfully crisp crust and oozing with cheese and flavor.

And for those who prefer hoagies to pizza, don’t worry – Davanni’s does not disappoint in this category either. With their signature hot hoagies packed full of freshly-grilled meats and vegetables, you won’t be disappointed with your sandwich either!

All in all, my experience at Davanni’s was definitely worth leaving my homeland for; after all this time searching for great pizza around the globe, I can confidently say that I have found some of the best pizza in Plymouth MN!

#10 Broadway Bar & Pizza

From the moment I stepped through their doors, I knew it was going to be an unforgettable experience. The atmosphere was inviting and the staff was friendly.

The pizza? An absolute masterpiece. It’s as if each one is made with love! The dough is perfectly crisp, the cheese is gooey and flavourful, and all the toppings are incredibly fresh and delicious. Plus, there are plenty of interesting options that you won’t find anywhere else.

Of course, no great pizza experience can be complete without wonderful service. The staff at Broadway Bar & Pizza goes above and beyond to make sure everything from ordering to delivery is smooth sailing. They even give out sweet little discounts for regulars!

So if you’re ever in Plymouth MN, don’t pass up an opportunity to get a slice from Broadway Bar & Pizza – you’ll definitely be glad you did!

#11 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

First off, the dough is always fresh – as it’s made in-house daily. That makes a huge difference in the flavor and texture of the pizza. The toppings are always high quality, whether you opt for classic pepperoni or something more creative like feta cheese and olives.

But what really sets Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza apart from the competition is their innovative ‘take and bake’ concept. You don’t have to wait for your pizza to be cooked – you just take it home and bake it whenever you’re ready! This is perfect for those busy nights when you still want a delicious homemade meal but don’t have the time or energy to cook.

Overall, I would rate Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza a solid 10/10! They give you all the convenience of a take-out place, with all the deliciousness of an authentically prepared pizza. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Plymouth MN, this is definitely where I’d recommend going.

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Minneapolis!

#12 Marco’s Pizza

As soon as I walked in, I was instantly impressed with the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff. Plus, the unbeatable smell of freshly baked pizza filled the air. It was hard to contain my excitement!

The menu had all of my favorites—thin crust, deep dish, a selection of classic and creative topping options. But after tasting a few slices from different pies, I can confidently say that their specialty is the classic cheese pizza. The freshness of the dough combined with their secret blend of marinara and cheese created something truly spectacular. Even compared to some of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted from much more expensive restaurants abroad—Marco’s Pizza takes the cake!

To top it off, Marco’s Pizza has some great deals for large orders that make it an even better value for your dollar. So if you’re in Plymouth MN looking for the best pizza around—look no further than Marco’s Pizza!