Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Port Charlotte (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Port Charlotte (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

363 Views

After tasting pizza all over the world, I can tell you that Port Charlotte serves up some truly delicious pies. I’ve tried 12 different pizza places and narrowed it down to the best of the best.

So grab a slice and join me on this humorous and lighthearted journey to see which pizzeria deserves bragging rights as serving up the best slice in town. Let’s get started, shall we?

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Pioneers Pizza Port Charlotte

The first thing that struck me was how quickly the pizza came. It only took minutes to have the pie at my table, and let me tell you, it was worth the wait. The crust was perfectly crisp and had a great flavor, while the sauce and melted cheese blended in harmony.

The toppings set Pioneers Pizza apart from the competition. I tried the Pepperoni Supreme, which included pepperoni slices arranged artfully over a sea of sausage, mushrooms and olives. Everything tasted incredibly fresh and flavorful – an impressive feat for any pizza parlor!

I’d recommend Pioneers Pizza Port Charlotte to anyone looking for a delicious slice of pizza in town. With fast service, great-tasting pies, and creative topping combinations, it’s no wonder this place is one of the best around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Punta Gorda!

#2 Uncle Nick’s Pizza

When I walked into Uncle Nick’s Pizza, I was taken aback by how the atmosphere immediately put me at ease. The interior design was warm and inviting with its rustic wall decor and soft lighting. Immediately, I knew I had stepped into a special place that would provide me with a unique dining experience.

The menu offered an impressive selection of traditional pizzas, plus a few creative variations. Every dish looked delicious and full of flavor. For my pizza, I went with the classic margherita topped with tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and fresh basil. This pizza was truly remarkable! The crust was crisp on the outside while being perfectly fluffy in the center, and every bite was full of decadent tomato sauce and melted cheese goodness!

Uncle Nick’s Pizza also offers some interesting sides to accompany your meal including garlic breadsticks, stuffed mushrooms and mac & cheese bites that are simply irresistible. On top of that, their desserts are out of this world! They make their own gelato in house along with sumptuous brownies – both perfect for finishing off a delicious dinner.

I have to say that Uncle Nick’s Pizza has done an excellent job at creating one of the best pizzas in Port Charlotte. With friendly staff, welcoming atmosphere, amazing food – it’s no wonder why this eatery is so popular among locals as well as tourists alike!

#3 Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza

Walking into the restaurant, I was struck by the beautiful aromas of freshly made pizza. The atmosphere was rustic, with the perfect balance of old and new.

The staff were welcoming and knew exactly what kind of pizza I wanted – their special New York-style pizza. It didn’t disappoint! Every bite was moist, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. The way the dough was kneaded together created a crunchy but soft texture that melted in your mouth – it had just the right amount of flavor without being too greasy or salty.

I’m usually not one for sides, but Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza has some really delicious options as well. Their garlic knots were fantastic – crispy on the outside and fluffy inside, with just enough garlic buttery goodness to elevate them from ordinary to extraordinary!

All in all, my experience at Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza was nothing less than amazing. From start to finish, there was no doubt that I had just experienced one of the best pizzas in Port Charlotte. If you’re looking for great pizza, it doesn’t get much better than this!

#4 Bocca Lupo Coal Fired Pizza Port Charlotte

I went there to try their pizza for the first time, and I was blown away. The atmosphere was great – it’s a really nice tourist spot, a great place to watch sports, and they even serve alcohol (including hard liquor)! Plus, they have some amazing vegetarian options, a kid’s menu if you’re bringing little ones with you, and let me tell you – their desserts are insanely good!

The pizza was cooked perfectly in a coal oven and had exactly the right amount of cheese and sauce. It probably could’ve been served with some more topping choices, but the taste alone made up for it. In my opinion, Bocca Lupo Coal Fired Pizza Port Charlotte has some of the best pizza in Port Charlotte!

The only downside I can think of is that they don’t offer delivery – so if you’re feeling lazy about going out for dinner, you’ll have to settle for something else. But if you do make the trip to Bocca Lupo Coal Fired Pizza Port Charlotte you won’t regret it!

#5 Bella Napoli Pizzeria & Restaurant

I visited the restaurant on a warm summer evening, and I was immediately impressed by the inviting atmosphere. The tables were adorned with classic Italian colors, photos of pizza-makers lined the walls, and the smell of dough and spices filled the air.

The waiter was friendly, professional, and knowledgeable about all of their dishes. He guided us through the extensive menu, recommending some of their house specialties that we definitely weren’t disappointed by. We sampled a few appetizers – their garlic knots and fried calamari were delicious! – before moving on to build our own customized pizzas.

The toppings selection was huge; I thought there must have been just about every topping imaginable available! After careful consideration (and several trips to the salad bar), we created some truly unique combinations that tasted amazing. We finished with an indulgent Nutella dessert pizza – need I say more?

In conclusion, Bella Napoli Pizzeria & Restaurant is truly one of the best pizza joints in Port Charlotte. Everything from their attentive staff to their inventive topping combinations make them well worth checking out if you ever find yourself in town!

#6 Captain Phantasy’s Pizzeria

On entering the restaurant, I was greeted enthusiastically by Captain Phantasy himself and his wonderful staff. The atmosphere was welcoming, with a variety of music playing in the background.

The menu had so many delicious pizzas to choose from that it took me awhile to settle on one. In the end, I chose the ‘International Pizza’, which was topped off with a generous helping of meats, vegetables and cheeses from around the world. It was truly amazing!

The crust was thin and crispy and cooked perfectly. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and there was just enough of them on each slice. The sauce added a nice zing and tied everything together perfectly.

Overall, my experience at Captain Phantasy’s Pizzeria can only be described as absolutely delightful! If you’re ever in Port Charlotte looking for a great pizza experience, then this is the place for you – no doubt about it!

#7 Luigi’s Pizzeria of swfl

From the moment I stepped through their door, there was a warm and inviting vibe. The staff was friendly, the décor was quaint, and I could smell the aroma of fresh pizza baking in the ovens.

When it came time to order, I couldn’t decide between two specialty pizzas – so I ended up ordering both! My first selection was Luigi’s signature “Four Cheese” pie. It had a delicious combination of mozzarella, cheddar, parmesan, and Swiss cheeses along with a thin yet perfectly crunchy crust.

My other selection was a classic Margherita-style pizza. This one also boasted an incredibly thin and crisp crust topped with simple but flavorful ingredients like fresh tomato sauce, basil, and mozzarella cheese – plus garlic and oregano for some extra kick! Delicious!!

The folks at Luigi’s were kind enough to box up my leftovers so that I could enjoy them later. What a treat! From start to finish this experience exceeded my expectations. In my humble opinion, Luigi’s Pizzeria of swfl deserves recognition as having some of the best pizza in Port Charlotte!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in North Port!

#8 Jet’s Pizza

I had the 8 corner pizza and it was delicious! The crust was light and airy, with just the right amount of crunch. It was cooked to perfection, and I’m sure that with any heat lamp this pizza would not have gotten soggy.

The toppings were also delicious. The pepperoni had a nice spiciness to it, and the cheese perfectly melted on top. The veggies were fresh and crisp as well. All in all, it was a flavor sensation!

The service at Jet’s Pizza was great too. My order arrived quickly, and I didn’t have to wait around long at all before I could dig into my pizza.

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Port Charlotte then Jet’s Pizza is your place! You won’t regret trying out this wonderful establishment!

#9 Mamma Lilla Pizzeria & Restaurant

The restaurant was cozy and inviting, with a warm atmosphere that made me feel right at home. To start my meal, I ordered the Margherita Pizza, which was loaded with fresh tomatoes, basil, and mozzarella cheese. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and the flavors were balanced nicely – definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve tasted!

The next pizza I sampled was the Prosciutto e Funghi – a delicious combination of prosciutto, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, and tomato sauce. Again, the quality of ingredients used here was top-notch. The pizza had an amazing flavor profile that you won’t find anywhere else!

For my final course, I decided to try their specialty Pizza alla Romana—a unique blend of ricotta cheese mixed with roasted red peppers, capers and olives on a thin but hearty crust. Wow! This pizza had an explosion of flavors in every bite!

Overall, I’m happy to report that Mamma Lilla Pizzeria & Restaurant is living up to its reputation of serving some of the best pizza in Port Charlotte. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience that’s both delicious and authentically Italian—look no further than Mamma Lilla Pizzeria & Restaurant!

#10 Marco’s Pizza

I have to admit, I’m a bit of a pizza snob. But when I stepped into Marco’s Pizza, I was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere. The place had an old-world charm that you can’t find in any other pizza joint these days.

The menu at Marco’s had something for everyone with classic Italian pizzas, Buffalo-style pies and unique creations like their “Green Monster” – layered with spinach and feta cheese. The crust was thin and crunchy, the toppings were fresh, and each bite was just packed with flavor.

It would be remiss not to mention the real star of the show: the owner himself! Marco always takes time to greet his customers and he takes pride in ensuring that they are satisfied. His enthusiasm for great pizza is contagious and it shows in every hand-crafted pie he makes.

The bottom line? If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Port Charlotte, look no further than Marco’s Pizza!

#11 Hungry Howie’s Pizza

I’m talking about topping combinations you can only dream of. Each bite is a pizza party in my mouth. If you’re looking for the classic pepperoni and cheese combo, those flavors are cooked to perfection. But if you’re feeling more adventurous, the variety of specialty pies are sure to blow your mind.

The restaurant itself is cozy and unpretentious – it’s a great place for everyone from families to couples to friends who are just out for a night on the town. The staff is friendly and accommodating, which makes ordering easy and, more importantly, eating even easier!

When I say Hungry Howie’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Port Charlotte, I mean it. I’ve tasted amazing pizza all over the world, so trust me when I say this is an absolute must-try spot!

#12 Joe’s Pizza

Upon entering Joe’s Pizza, I was immediately hit with the delicious smell of baking pizza. The cozy atmosphere and checkered tablecloths reminded me of old Italian restaurants.

The best part about Joe’s Pizza is their extensive menu. Whether you like a classic cheese pizza, or something a little more exotic like their special “Seafood Delight” or the ever-popular “Fiesta Fun,” there’s something for everyone. Their crusts are always cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of crunch and flavor. Not to mention, they use only the freshest ingredients!

One experience that stands out from my visit to Joe’s Pizza was when I ordered the sausage and mushroom pizza…the aroma just made my mouth water! When it arrived at our table, I could tell this wasn’t your average pizza. The flavors exploded in my mouth with every bite—it was simply divine!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Port Charlotte, look no further than Joe’s Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!