Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Portage MI (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Michigan

Best Pizza in Portage MI (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

79 Views

I’ve traveled all over the world for the tastiest pizzas, and while I was in Portage MI I decided to search out the best pizza this town has to offer. After sampling pizza from 12 places, I think it’s now safe to say that I know where to get the tastiest slices.

My mission was serious business, but don’t expect my review to be too stiff. After all, food, especially pizza, should be fun! So get ready for a humorous and lighthearted look at the best pizza spots in Portage MI. Let’s dig in!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Michigan

#1 A Pizza Yen

The pizza here is cooked to perfection, with a perfect blend of crunchy crust, cheesy toppings and tangy tomato sauce. Plus, the portions are generous – you get your money’s worth!

In terms of atmosphere, the restaurant itself is quite cozy and inviting. You can bring friends or family, or just come to relax after a long day at work. Plus, the staff here is incredibly friendly, making it even more enjoyable.

My favorite part of A Pizza Yen though was their signature pizzas – they were amazing! I had a Hawaiian-style Pizza with ham and pineapple that was delicious. I also got some cheese slices which were fabulous too.

Overall, A Pizza Yen has spoiled me for any other pizza joint ever again! The best part? They deliver so you don’t have to leave the comfort of your own home for an amazing meal. Highly recommended for anyone in Portage MI looking for the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Kalamazoo!

#2 Chicago Style Pizza

I’ve had pizza in Rome, Chicago, and even Italy, but nothing compares to the delicious flavors I experienced at Chicago Style Pizza. From their House Speciality to their deep dish creations and creative toppings, every inch of my pizza pie was delectable.

My favorite topping was the house-made sausage that added a unique flavor profile. The combination of the sausage, pepperoni, and cheese mixed perfectly with the spices and herbs used in the crust recipe. A great experience all around!

The atmosphere is friendly and inviting, which adds to the experience. The staff all make you feel at home while they whip up some mouthwatering creations right before your eyes! It’s definitely worth going out of your way for this tasty treat.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience in Portage MI then look no further than Chicago Style Pizza. Without a doubt they serve up some of the best pizza in town!

#3 Franco’s Italian Pizzeria (Sub Station)

The first time I visited Franco’s, the smells of freshly-baked pizza and decadent cheese filled the air like a heavenly aroma. The restaurant was bustling with activity, as customers enjoyed everything from traditional pepperoni pies to specialty items such as the ‘Mediterranean Supreme’.

My favorite part of Franco’s is their signature crust. It’s a perfect balance of chewy and crunchy, with just the right amount of flavor. Their tomato sauce is also something to be admired – it’s creamy and fragrant, almost velvety on the palate. As for their toppings, they use only top-notch ingredients that truly make their pizzas stand out against any competition.

If you’re looking for an enjoyable experience with amazing food, then I highly recommend you head over to Franco’s Italian Pizzeria (Sub Station). In my opinion, they’re serving up some of the best pizza in Portage MI!

#4 Pizza King of Portage

The first thing I noticed when walking into this cozy little pizza joint was the delicious aroma of fresh-baked pizza. Then, I noticed the smile on the face of the friendly staff, which put me in an immediate good mood.

When it came time to order, I had a hard time deciding between all of the tasty options Pizza King has to offer. They have a wide variety of toppings from traditional favorites like pepperoni and mushrooms to more exotic selections such as pineapple and roasted red peppers. After much deliberation, I ultimately went with their “King’s Supreme” featuring mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers, and onions – definitely a crowd pleaser!

When my pizza arrived at my table steaming hot out of the oven, it looked like something right out of a magazine! The flavor was even better than it looked; each bite was bursting with flavor and melted in my mouth. As soon as I finished my first slice, I wanted another one (or three!).

To sum it up: if you’re looking for the best pizza in Portage MI look no further than Pizza King! Not only is their food top-notch but they also have great customer service and an atmosphere that will keep you coming back again and again.

#5 Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders

I was immediately struck by the inviting atmosphere of this pizza joint, with its bright and cheery decor. The staff were friendly, upbeat and eager to help with anything I needed. It felt like the kind of place you’d want to stay for lunch or dinner – even if it’s just for a slice.

The menu selection was fantastic, offering a variety of classic flavors as well as some unique offerings that really caught my eye. I decided on the Mega Meat Deluxe Grinder and it did not disappoint! Generous amounts of premium meats and cheese were piled high atop an Italian-style roll. The sauce was flavorful and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. I washed it all down with an ice cold root beer – which they also serve here!

I’m so glad I made a stop at Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders during my travels in Portage MI – it may just go down in history as one of my favorite pizzerias ever! Whether you’re looking for classic Italian favorites or something truly unique, this is definitely one spot where you’ll get your fill of great pizza.

#6 Monelli’s Italian Grill & Sports Bar

As soon as I walked in, the inviting atmosphere of the bar immediately caught my attention. The walls were lined with sports memorabilia and dozens of flat-screen TVs that were tuned to sports games. After being seated, I quickly noticed their extensive selection of craft beers on tap – clearly a great place for sports fans and pizza lovers alike!

But what really sealed the deal was the menu. The variety of pizza styles they offered was nothing short of impressive, plus they had vegetarian options that looked amazing. I opted for a classic cheese pizza and it was one of the best pizzas I have ever tasted! It was cooked perfectly, with just the right amount of cheese and seasoning.

To top it all off, it wasn’t too expensive – which is always a plus in my book. My experience at Monelli’s Italian Grill & Sports Bar was delightful and I highly recommend it for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in town!

#7 Maestro’s Pizza

Upon walking in, I was immediately blown away by the gracious hospitality of the staff. They were so attentive and made sure that I felt truly welcomed.

When I looked around the restaurant, I noticed that Maestro’s Pizza seemed to be quite popular with the locals. From their top-notch service to their delicious pizza, it was clear why this place is highly praised!

The pizza menu at Maestro’s Pizza is simply out of this world. Whatever toppings you fancy, I’m sure you’ll find something on their menu that will tantalize your taste buds! Plus, they also offer interesting specialty pizzas like the “Taco Pie”, which is a must-try for any pizza enthusiast!

Of course, when it comes to great pizza, one must consider the crust! And boy oh boy did Maestro’s not disappoint! The crust is perfectly thin yet crunchy and tastes just as great when reheated as it does when fresh out of the oven. The dough has a light sweetness that nicely complements each topping combination.

All in all, if you’re looking for a fantastic pizza experience in Portage MI – look no further than Maestro’s Pizza! Trust me – it’s some of the best pizza around and you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Battle Creek!

#8 Buddy’s Pizza

Let me start by saying that the atmosphere was perfect. I stepped into Buddy’s Pizza and immediately felt like I was at home. The cozy chairs and rustic decor were warm and inviting, while the brick oven fired up with delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza only enhanced the experience.

The pizza itself was absolutely divine! The crust had just the right balance of crunchiness, yet also wonderfully doughy. The seasonings used on top were spot-on, delivering an explosion of flavors that made my mouth water. And don’t even get me started on the cheese – a mix of mozzarella and provolone that was creamy, melty perfection!

I’d definitely recommend anyone in Portage MI to stop by Buddy’s Pizza for a meal they won’t soon forget! All in all, a fantastic experience that proves why Buddy’s is hands down the best pizza in town.

#9 Erbelli’s Gourmet Pizzeria, Italian Bistro & PUB!

I had heard great things about the restaurant before I arrived, but I was still blown away. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting – they even had a full-sized pub where I could enjoy a pint of beer while waiting for my meal!

The pizza was definitely the highlight, though. I opted for the classic Margherita, which came out perfectly cooked with just the right amount of cheese. The crust was thin but not too crunchy, and there was plenty of sauce to top it off. Absolutely delicious!

I also sampled some of their other food items, including their garlic breadsticks and salads. Everything else was great too – especially the drinks! They have an impressive selection of craft cocktails that I highly recommend trying.

All in all, Erbelli’s Gourmet Pizzeria, Italian Bistro & PUB! is easily one of the best pizza restaurants in Portage MI – if not the best. Highly recommended if you’re looking for a great pie!

#10 Jac’s Cekola’s Pizza – Portage

I had the pleasure of staying in town for a few weeks, and a local told me I absolutely had to try out Jac’s Cekola’s. From that first bite, I was hooked! The pizza is cooked perfectly in their wood-fired ovens and has the most amazing cheesy flavor.

The crust held up surprisingly well through the entire experience. I found it to be incredibly light and fluffy with just the right amount of crunch around the edges. The toppings were well balanced and provided an amazing flavor that was truly unique to this particular place.

Overall, I must say my experience at Jac’s Cekola’s Pizza – Portage was definitely worth my time! If you ever find yourself in Portage MI looking for some of the best pizza around, then look no further than Jac’s Cekola’s!

#11 Angelo’s

I recently had a chance to sample some of Angelo’s delicious creations, and let me tell you – it was an experience I won’t soon forget. From the moment I stepped through the door, I felt like a kid in a candy store! The delightful smell of pizza and spices greeted my senses as I took in the cozy atmosphere.

The pizza crust was remarkable; it had just the right amount of crunch without being too chewy or hard. The cheese was perfectly melted, and their signature pepperoni slices were each delectably crispy. Even better were all the other toppings available for crafting your own custom masterpiece – from artichokes to sun-dried tomatoes, there’s something for everyone on their extensive topping list!

But perhaps what truly sets Angelo’s apart is their incredible customer service. The staff are always friendly and attentive, which goes a long way towards making your dining experience even more enjoyable. Whether you’re looking for dine-in or takeout options, they cater to all your needs with a smile!

In short, if you’re ever in Portage MI looking for some outstanding pizza – make sure you look no further than Angelo’s!

#12 Domino’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed when walking in was the amazing aroma of pizza dough and sauce. And let me tell you, the smell is not deceiving. The pizza is mouth-watering!

I decided to try a classic cheese pizza with pepperoni toppings, and wow, what flavor! The crust was crispy, yet soft and chewy at the same time. The sauce has just the right balance of sweetness and acidity, while the cheese melted perfectly. Toppings were generous but not overwhelming.

But my favorite thing about this place is how fast their delivery service is. In less than 30 minutes I had a hot and delicious pizza on my doorstep. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Portage MI, Domino’s Pizza is your spot!