Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Poughkeepsie (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Poughkeepsie (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

205 Views

I’ve had a lot of pizza in my time, from Canada to Italy, but few places compare to the dozen restaurants I visited in Poughkeepsie. Whether it was thin-crust or deep-dish style, I tried them all and found some absolute gems.

My search for the best pizza in Poughkeepsie was full of surprises. From old classics to new takes on traditional recipes, there’s something delicious for everyone here. Join me as I review these 12 pizzerias and share my findings!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Dave’s Cucina

The crust is delightfully thin and crispy, and the sauce is full of flavor. The cheese is always perfectly melted and the variety of toppings can’t be beat. My favorite is their signature pie: the Dave Deluxe, which comes loaded with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives and extra cheese.

The atmosphere at Dave’s Cucina is delightful too. It’s a cozy spot with red checkered tablecloths that looks like it hasn’t changed in decades. Their waitstaff are friendly and knowledgeable – they even offer recommendations if you’re feeling overwhelmed by all your topping choices!

No matter how hard I try to resist it, I always end up ordering a slice to go when I leave Dave’s. That crunchy crust and perfect blend of flavors just calls out to me! And no one can deny that their prices are very reasonable.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Poughkeepsie, look no further than Dave’s Cucina – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in New Paltz!

#2 The Dutch Crown

I’m not sure what’s in the secret sauce, but every bite is loaded with flavor! The crust has a perfect crunch and balances out nicely with the toppings. They have a great selection of beers and hard liquors to enjoy with your meal as well, so I can highly recommend it for going out with friends.

The only downside is that they don’t deliver, so you’ll have to dine in or take it to go. But trust me, it’s worth the extra effort – this is some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere!

#3 Dimoran Pizza & Deli

The atmosphere is charmingly retro, with classic black-and-white checkered floors and rustic wood tables. Upon entering, you’re greeted with the smell of freshly cooked pizza and the sight of gleaming ovens cooking up delicious pies. These are combined with a friendly staff that are more than eager to help you choose your perfect pizza.

The selection of pizzas at Dimoran Pizza & Deli is second to none. They have so many pizzas that it was hard for me to decide which one to try first! From Italian classics like marinara and capricciosa, to wilder options like pineapple and prosciutto – there really is something for everyone here.

As for the pizza itself? Outstanding! The crust was light and fluffy yet delightfully crunchy, while the toppings were juicy and flavorful. And the cheese – oh my goodness! It was melted and gooey in all of the right places, giving each bite an unbeatably delicious taste.

Bottom line: If you’re looking for some amazing pizza, then Dimoran Pizza & Deli is definitely worth a visit! Their excellent selection of pizzas, charming atmosphere, and top-notch ingredients make them easily one of the best places for pizza in Poughkeepsie. Trust me when I say that once you’ve tried their pizza, you won’t want to look anywhere else!

#4 A Touch of Naples

The first thing that caught my eye when I walked in was the delicious smell of the pizza. It smelled like a real Italian kitchen! When I finally got to try it, I could tell why all the locals flock here for their pizza fix. The crust was crispy and yet still had a great chewiness, and the toppings were fresh, flavorful and cooked just right.

But it’s not just about the food, as A Touch of Naples really has a great ambience. The décor is modern and inviting, giving you the feeling that you’re really getting an authentic Neapolitan experience. Plus, their staff are friendly and knowledgeable about their menu – always ready to answer any questions you might have.

Overall, A Touch of Naples is without a doubt one of the best pizza places in Poughkeepsie. From its amazing food to its inviting atmosphere, it’s easy to see why locals love this place so much! Highly recommended!

#5 Lolita’s Pizza

The crust was perfectly crispy and the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and they had a great selection to choose from.

But what really stood out to me was the hospitality of Lolita’s staff. From the moment I walked in, I was welcomed with open arms. They took their time showing me around and making sure I felt cared for.

The atmosphere is perfect for a night out with friends or a romantic dinner – even if it doesn’t look like much from the outside. The décor is modern yet cozy, and they have an amazing wine list!

I would highly recommend Lolita’s Pizza to anyone looking for an authentic Italian experience. It may not be the best pizza in the world, but it definitely serves up some of the best pizza in Poughkeepsie!

#6 Hudson & Packard

Everything at Hudson & Packard is cooked to perfection. The thin-crust pizza crust is light and crisp, with just the right amount of charring on the edges. The toppings are always tasty, with freshly-sliced vegetables, robust sauce, and gooey cheese.

The real highlight of the experience is the service! They greet you warmly when you come in and serve up your pizza with a smile. They also make sure to offer recommendations if you’re not sure what kind of toppings you want; after all, who doesn’t appreciate a little extra guidance when it comes to ordering pizza?

In short, Hudson & Packard has been my favorite pizza spot in Poughkeepsie. If you’re looking for great pizza that’s cooked perfectly every time, then I’d highly recommend giving them a try!

#7 Mel’s Pizza Pasta & More

I was amazed by how many incredible flavors were available. It seemed like they had something for everyone – from traditional pepperoni and cheese to more adventurous white pizza with spinach and feta cheese. The crust was the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy, and the sauce was surprisingly flavorful.

But what really sets Mel’s Pizza apart is their pasta dishes. I tried the lasagna and it was out of this world! The layers of pasta were cooked to perfection, filled with layers of cheese and blanketed in a rich marinara sauce. It’s honestly some of the best lasagna I’ve tasted anywhere.

If you’re ever in Poughkeepsie looking for a great pizza or pasta dish, look no further than Mel’s Pizza Pasta & More! This is definitely one place that will not disappoint!

#8 Vera Pizzeria

The crust is perfectly thin and crisp with a savory oven-baked flavor. The sauce is fresh and flavorful, making for an incredibly delicious pizza experience. The cheese is plentiful and never greasy; it’s the perfect way to top off every slice.

The ingredients are always top notch – they don’t skimp on quality or quantity at Vera Pizzeria. With generous toppings like spicy Italian sausage, mushrooms, bell pepper, pepperoni, and black olives, you won’t be disappointed.

On top of having amazing pizza, the staff at Vera Pizzeria are super friendly and make everyone feel welcome. I have had nothing but positive experiences dining in the restaurant – there’s a great atmosphere that just makes me smile.

Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or a full meal with friends and family, Vera Pizzeria always delivers with the best pizza in Poughkeepsie!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 37 more pizza places in Hudson!

#9 Emiliano’s Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant was inviting and full of energy. I savored the delicious aroma of the freshly made dough in the air as I took my seat at a cozy booth.

I ordered their famous pie and it was amazing! The crust was light, golden-brown and crispy; every bite tasted like perfection! Needless to say, the pizza itself was divine. The toppings were all fresh, flavorful and plentiful, with just enough sauce and cheese to bring out the incredible flavors.

Overall, Emiliano’s Pizza is an absolute must for any pizza lover looking for an exceptional experience. From the friendly staff to their delicious pies, I definitely recommend this place for anyone wanting to get the best pizza in Poughkeepsie!

#10 Mike and Joe’s Brick Oven Pizza and Italian Restaurant

I had the pleasure of visiting this iconic restaurant on a recent trip to Poughkeepsie and I was more than pleasantly surprised. The pizza is cooked in a brick oven, which creates a crispy, perfectly cooked crust. The cheese was creamy and flavorful, the sauce fresh and well-seasoned, and the toppings of choice were plentiful – just the way I like it!

The staff at Mike and Joe’s is friendly yet professional, making for an enjoyable dining experience. The atmosphere is casual with Italian-inspired decor that adds to the overall ambiance.

Overall, I’d have to say that Mike and Joe’s Brick Oven Pizza and Italian Restaurant serves up some of the best pizza in Poughkeepsie (if not beyond). They have mastered the art of creating an outrageously delicious pie that will leave your taste buds singing! If you’re ever in Poughkeepsie looking for some great pizza, be sure to check out Mike and Joe’s Brick Oven Pizza and Italian Restaurant – you won’t regret it!

#11 Pizza E Birra

The atmosphere is energetic and inviting, with really great vibes. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, which makes my experience even better. As for the food – oh boy! It’s amazing!

Their pizzas are freshly made and delicious, with an array of toppings to choose from. My favorite is their classic Margherita pizza with a little extra cheese. The crust is perfectly crispy and the flavor combinations are simply divine. It’s truly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

Not only that but they also have a fantastic selection of beers to pair with your meal. They have something for everyone from lagers to IPAs, so you can find something you like no matter what your preferences are.

All in all, Pizza E Birra scores high in my book for quality food and great service – definitely worth checking out if you’re in Poughkeepsie!

#12 Bronx Pie Pizza

From the moment you step in, you can tell the staff takes great pride in what they do. The place is always full of chefs crafting each pie to perfection. Every ingredient is carefully chosen and prepared with care.

The pizza here is truly spectacular. They have all the traditional favorites, like pepperoni and cheese, but they also offer some great gourmet options as well. My personal favorite was the ‘Bronx Pie’ which comes with spicy sausage, roasted peppers, and mozzarella cheese – it was delicious!

The atmosphere at Bronx Pie Pizza is also wonderful. The walls are decorated with local artwork and there’s always a lively smile on everyone’s face. Plus, their outdoor seating area makes for a perfect spot to sip some wine or beer while you wait for your order.

In conclusion, I can easily say that Bronx Pie Pizza deserves its title as being the best pizza in Poughkeepsie! Their attention to detail paired with their unique recipes make them stand out from other pizza restaurants around town – boy am I glad I got to try this amazing establishment!