Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Prescott Valley (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Arizona

Best Pizza in Prescott Valley (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

120 Views

I’ve tasted pizza in all corners of the world, from NY-style to Neapolitan to Chicago deep dish. But with my latest project, I’ve turned my sights closer to home to find the Best Pizza in Prescott Valley.

Over the past few weeks, I’ve sampled pies from twelve different restaurants around town. Through it all – evenings huddled over a table covered with various pizzas and desserts – I’ve come up with a list of top picks for best pizza in Prescott Valley!

The results are here (spoiler alert: there’s some deliciousness on this list!) and I can’t wait to share them with you. So grab your favorite glass of wine and get comfortable – it’s time to decide who makes the best pizza in Prescott Valley!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arizona

#1 Jackie Boyz Little Italy

I walked in the other day and was greeted with a warm welcome and an aroma that can only be created by freshly made pizza dough. After ordering, I realized why this is often referred to as “Little Italy”. The toppings were so fresh, it could easily pass for being made straight from the Italian countryside.

As if that wasn’t enough, they actually offer desserts afterward! I mean, who doesn’t like having an ice cream sundae or brownie a la mode after a tasty slice? Let me just say this…I most certainly did!

The only downside to this wonderful establishment is that there’s no delivery option. I have to personally pop in whenever I’m around the area. That’s not really a bad thing though; it also makes for a nice tourist spot as well.

Overall, I have to say that Jackie Boyz Little Italy has some of the best pizza around Prescott Valley! If you’re looking for authentic Italian style pizzas, then this place is definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Prescott!

#2 Rosa’s Pizzeria (Prescott)

From the moment I arrived, the friendly staff at Rosa’s made me feel welcome. The restaurant has an inviting atmosphere with dark wood paneling, cozy booths and a brick oven in the corner.

The menu boasts an array of different pizzas made with fresh ingredients, but it was their “signature” pizza that caught my eye. When it arrived at my table, it was piping hot and loaded with toppings like pepperoni, sausage and fresh mozzarella. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and the flavors were simply heavenly!

Overall, I’ve been to some amazing pizza places around the world – but Rosa’s Pizzeria definitely takes the cake as the best pizza in Prescott Valley!

#3 MOD Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting and cozy, making it a great spot to hang out with friends. The staff is always friendly and attentive. Best of all, the pizza itself is truly outstanding!

I was blown away when I tasted their signature pies – the Classic MOD with pesto sauce, garlic, mozzarella and feta, or the Smoky Peach with spicy barbecue sauce, mozzarella, bacon and peaches! Both were delicious but my favorite by far has to be their Firebreather pizza – their unique combination of red sauce, jalapeno peppers, bacon and gorgonzola made for an unforgettable experience.

The one thing that really sets MOD Pizza apart from other pizzas is their crust – it’s definitely among the best I’ve ever had in my travels. It’s a thin crust that’s both crispy and slightly chewy at the same time. Perfect for picking up those tasty toppings!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Prescott Valley, I highly recommend checking out MOD Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Granite Mountain Pizza Company

I walked in to the restaurant and was immediately met with a warm, inviting atmosphere. The staff greeted me like an old friend, which was a nice touch. The pizza was also incredibly delicious – fresh ingredients and perfectly cooked crusts made for a pizza that rivaled some of the best I’ve had around the world.

The service was also great – they took their time with helping me choose what toppings I wanted and walked me through the different options they had available, so I ended up with something that was completely suited to my tastes.

Overall, Granite Mountain Pizza Company is definitely one of the best pizza places in Prescott Valley. If you haven’t been there yet, you owe it to yourself to give them a try!

#5 Limoncello Pizzeria Napoletana

As soon as I walked in, I could tell that this place was special. From the warm, inviting atmosphere to the delightful smells coming from the kitchen, I knew I was in for a unique experience.

The service was excellent! The servers were friendly, accommodating and knowledgeable about their menu items. They even got my order right with no problems!

Now let’s talk food. I tried several of their pizzas and they all had something special going on; a good combination of crust, sauce and toppings that will make your taste buds tingle. The flavors were rich and intense without being overpowering. The crust was thin yet still crunchy and oh so satisfying!

In conclusion, Limoncello Pizzeria Napoletana definitely deserves its spot as one of the best pizza places in Prescott Valley. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience.

#6 Guido’s Pizza

I recently visited this restaurant and was totally blown away by the quality of the pizza. The crust was thin and crispy, yet wonderfully chewy. It was also baked to perfection with a nice golden color. The cheese was rich and creamy, while the sauce had just the right amount of zestiness to add great flavor without overpowering any other elements.

The toppings were big and generous, with each bite giving me a little bit of everything I ordered. Whether it be pepperoni, sausage, peppers or onions, they all harmonized together perfectly in every slice.

The atmosphere at Guido’s Pizza is also worth mentioning as it has a cool and relaxed vibe that makes it easy to stay here for hours chatting with friends over delightful slices of pizza.

Overall, I can honestly say that Guido’s Pizza has to be some of the best pizza in Prescott Valley!

#7 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

On my recent visit to the location near Glassford Hill and Highway 69 I was more than impressed. The atmosphere was relaxed and welcoming, but the real star of the show here is the pizza. I got their Italiano Signature Pizza with a thin crust and bold Italian flavors, like fresh basil, pepperoni, sausage and tomatoes.

I love that they let you have control over your pizza experience and let you assemble it yourself. I’m always a little hesitant when someone else makes something I’m about to eat, so this approach really appealed to me! Plus, with Papa Murphy’s signature dough you can trust that your pizza will come out perfect every time.

The great part about these pizzas is that you can choose to cook it immediately in their ovens or “take ‘n’ bake” at home. For me, baking at home was both more convenient and enjoyable. I love to cook so there’s something satisfying about making my own pizza from scratch…almost as satisfying as eating it! And speaking of eating it, the end result was absolutely delicious! The crust had just the right amount of crunch on the outside while still being delightfully light on the inside. And all the toppings were cooked perfectly with melted cheese oozing into each bite!

All in all this was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had, not just in Prescott Valley but throughout my travels! If you’re looking for great pizza (and an equally great overall experience) then Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza should be at the top of your list – it can’t be beat!

If you’re willing to go an extra 36 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Sedona!

#8 Rusty’s Subs, Pizza & Wings

When I first stepped inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza was irresistible. The decor was nothing special–just a few posters on the wall and some TVs playing sports–but I think that’s part of the charm.

I opted for their classic cheese pizza, and it was absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly crunchy and the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess. The cheese was flavorful, gooey, and melted in my mouth. Truly divine!

The wings weren’t bad either. They were juicy and seasoned with just the right amount of spice. I also had a shot of their house-made alcoholic beverage which went great with the food.

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery service, so if you don’t feel like making a trip out to Prescott Valley you’re out of luck. But trust me, it’s worth it! Rusty’s Subs, Pizza & Wings is definitely one of the best places for pizza in town and will leave you feeling satisfied every time!

#9 Guido’s Pizza

The first thing that struck me upon entering Guido’s was the welcoming atmosphere. Everyone from the staff to the customers were friendly, making it an enjoyable experience for all. The restaurant itself was cozy and inviting, with soft lighting adding to the already inviting ambiance.

When it came time to order the pizza, I decided to go with a classic cheese pizza. I was not disappointed! Guido’s uses only top-quality ingredients in their pies, creating a pie that is full of depth and flavor. The dough was light and crispy, providing a perfect base for the flavorful toppings. What really made this pizza stand out for me was its sauce – an irresistible blend of herbs and spices that had my taste buds singing!

Overall, Guido’s Pizza provides some of the best pizza in Prescott Valley. I would recommend them to any pizza lover looking for a delicious slice!

#10 Tailgaters & IL Primo Prescott Valley

The pizza at Tailgaters & IL Primo Prescott Valley comes with an array of topping options from classic pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms to more complex options like anchovies, eggplant, and artichoke hearts. No matter what toppings you select, you can be sure each slice will be flavorful and cooked to perfection.

The atmosphere at Tailgaters & IL Primo Prescott Valley is great for a casual dinner among friends or a date night out. There’s plenty of seating, TVs for sports fans (Go Cowboys!), and a friendly staff that makes you feel right at home. Plus, they offer outdoor seating on the patio if you want to enjoy the beautiful Arizona weather while dining.

All in all, Tailgaters & IL Primo Prescott Valley has some of the best pizza I’ve ever had – hands down! Whether you’re looking for an intimate dinner or a fun night out with friends, this place is sure to hit the spot!

#11 Peter Piper Pizza

The moment I walked in, I was blown away by the aroma of freshly baked pizza. It made my mouth water and my stomach rumble in anticipation. The decor is cheerful and inviting, which only added to the experience.

When it came time to sample the pizza, I was certainly not disappointed! The crust had a perfect crunch and the cheese was perfectly melted. The toppings were fresh, flavorful and plentiful — just what you’d want from a great pizza joint!

To top off my experience, the service at Peter Piper Pizza was great! All of the employees were friendly and attentive to my needs. They made me feel like a VIP, which would ensure that I’d return for more delicious slices soon.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Prescott Valley, then definitely check out Peter Piper Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

#12 Streets of New York

I had the pleasure of trying a few different pies here, ranging from the standard Margherita to the innovative BBQ Chicken. Every slice was cooked to perfection and loaded with flavor. The crust was perfectly crisp and slightly chewy – just how I like it!

The service at Streets of New York was top-notch as well. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. My waiter went out of his way to make sure I got exactly what I wanted, and even suggested some of their signature pies that I had never tried before.

But what really made me come back for more? The prices were unbelievably reasonable for such high quality pizza! With large pies starting at under $15, Streets of New York has quickly become my go-to spot for a great night out in Prescott Valley.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Prescott Valley, look no further than Streets of New York!