Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Prospect Heights (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Prospect Heights (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

64 Views

I’ve tasted pizza all around the world, from Naples to New York, but today I’m turning my sights closer to home. The aim of this article is to identify some of the tastiest slices Prospect Heights has to offer. Over the course of 12 reviews, we’ll be assessing a range of places with pizza on the menu. It’s sure to be a journey full of humor and lightheartedness — and lots and lots of cheese!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Fausto’s Italian Kitchen

From the moment I stepped through the door I knew I was in the right place. The aroma of garlic and basil wafted through the air and set my taste buds singing with anticipation. When I finally got a chance to sample Fausto’s mouthwatering pies ,I couldn’t have been more impressed.

The crust was thin, with a perfectly golden-brown color, and it held up to all of the cheese and toppings without getting soggy. As for what went on top, well let’s just say that Fausto has their ingredients finely tuned so that each slice maximizes flavor.

I could go on about how great their pizza is, but you’ll just need to take my word for it: if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Prospect Heights (or anywhere else for that matter), then go no farther than Fausto’s Italian Kitchen!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Palatine!

#2 Piz-zetta Pizzeria

Their menu is quite impressive and varied, with a wide selection of classic flavors complemented by more daring options. I ordered the latest trend – cauliflower-crust pizza – and it was exquisite! The crust was light and airy, making for a deliciously unique experience.

The cheese used is sourced locally and was very cheesy in the best way possible. The ingredients were fresh and flavorful, but not overpowering so that each bite was still full of subtle flavor nuances.

The service staff at Piz-zetta Pizzeria were friendly and efficient, helping to make my dining experience feel like home.

Overall, I would highly recommend anyone looking for the best pizza in Prospect Heights stop by Piz-zetta Pizzeria. You won’t be disappointed!

#3 MOD Pizza

I’m not exaggerating when I say that the pizza here is absolutely delicious. The crust is thin and crisp, like a crunchy cracker, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful; they help you customize your pizza to get it just right. Plus, they have an array of unique sauces to choose from!

But let’s be honest; the real star here is the pizza. Toppings range from classic pepperoni to more exotic choices like roasted artichoke hearts and kale pesto. And don’t get me started on their thick-cut artisanal cheese – it’s creamy and rich in flavor, offering a delightful savory punch in every bite.

MOD Pizza is also incredibly affordable; ordering one of their signature pizzas only sets you back a few dollars. If that’s not tempting enough, there are also plenty of drinks available for purchase as well as some tasty desserts for those with a sweet tooth (the homemade brownies are especially good!).

To sum up my review of MOD Pizza: without question, this place has some of the best pizza around Prospect Heights! The delicious crusts, fresh toppings, variety of sauces, cheap prices – all wrapped up in a cozy atmosphere make it an ideal spot for grabbing lunch or dinner with friends or family. Bon appetit!

#4 Union Ale House

The first thing that struck me about the place was how inviting and warm the atmosphere is, with its cozy seating areas, cool decor and friendly staff. The menu has plenty of delicious offerings, but I had to try their special – a Margherita made with fresh mozzarella, basil and San Marzano tomatoes.

The wait staff were attentive and helpful, taking great care to make sure everyone was comfortable and happy with their meal.

When my pizza arrived it looked absolutely beautiful – perfectly cooked and so flavorful! The basil really shone through and the combination of the fresh mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes gave it an incredible depth of flavor. It was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

I would highly recommend Union Ale House to anyone looking for a place to enjoy some amazing pizza in Prospect Heights. The food is excellent, the atmosphere is relaxed and enjoyable, and the waitstaff are friendly and helpful – they truly make you feel at home. So go ahead: try it out and see if you don’t agree that this is some of the best pizza around!

#5 Lola’s Pizza & Tiki Bar

As soon as I walked in, I noticed the inviting interior and already knew it was going to be a great meal. The staff, from the host to the servers, all had an enthusiasm for pizza that was palpable.

The chefs here really know what they’re doing; their pizzas are spot on! From the classic Margherita to their specialty pies like the “BBQ Brisket Pizza”, they’ve got something for everyone. The slices were deliciously thin and crispy, with just the right amount of cheese and sauce.

To cap off my experience at Lola’s Pizza & Tiki Bar, I indulged in one of their homemade desserts – a Nutella calzone. This heavenly pastry was stuffed with decadent Nutella and topped off with a scoop of gelato. Heaven!

Lola’s Pizza & Tiki Bar is easily some of the best pizza I’ve ever had, and if you’re ever in Prospect Heights you should definitely check it out. Whatever your appetite desires, there’s something for everyone here!

#6 Rosati’s Pizza

My experience at Rosati’s Pizza was top notch. From the moment I stepped in, I immediately noticed the warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was pleasant and attentive, ensuring that my every need was taken care of.

The food itself was delicious! We decided to go with the classic Chicago deep dish pizza and were not disappointed. The crust was crisp yet fluffy and had a nice balance between crunchy exterior and soft interior. The sauce had an intense flavor that complimented the cheese perfectly, resulting in a truly delectable experience.

But the most impressive part of my experience at Rosati’s Pizza had to be their selection of toppings. Every topping we tried was cooked to perfection – whether it be traditional pepperoni or something more exotic like jalapenos – everything was cooked to perfection!

Overall, my experience at Rosati’s Pizza convinced me that they have some of the best pizza in Prospect Heights. I would highly recommend trying out this restaurant if you ever find yourself in town!

#7 Table 87

I mean, talk about a life-changing experience. For starters, the atmosphere was absolutely amazing. It was cozy and inviting, with a nice outdoor seating area for those warm summer nights.

The staff was also incredibly friendly, always willing to answer any question I had or give me recommendations. This really set the tone for a great eating experience!

Now let’s get to the food — the star of the show. When it comes to pizza, Table 87 has perfected their craft and it shows in every bite. The crust was perfectly crispy and chewy with just the right amount of char on it. All of their toppings were fresh and flavorful, making each slice truly unique and delicious.

I think what makes Table 87 stand out from other places is not only its amazing pizza but also its variety of options as well. They have tons of classic pizzas like margherita as well as creative gourmet pies like truffle mushroom or tomato basil pesto. Every time I visit I find something new to try!

Without a doubt, Table 87 is one of my favorite places to get pizza in Prospect Heights — if not the best! Everyone should definitely pay them a visit if they’re ever in town!

#8 Giuseppina’s

I’ll admit that I was skeptical at first, and thought that no pizza joint in a small Brooklyn neighborhood could compete with the pies I’d sampled in Italy, but boy was I wrong.

The crust of each pizza is perfectly crisp and buttery, yet still soft and chewy. The sauce is a sweet-yet-tangy blend of tomatoes and herbs that will make you want to keep coming back for more!

The toppings were where Giuseppina’s truly shined. Not only are their signature combinations creative and delicious, their selection of vegan options is unparalleled! Ranging from roasted garlic mushrooms to vegan pepperoni, there’s something for everyone.

The atmosphere at Giuseppina’s was also top-notch. The quaint Italian vibe added an extra bit of charm to the already perfect experience. Plus, the servers were incredibly friendly and accommodating.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Prospect Heights – look no further than Giuseppina’s!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Des Plaines!

#9 Mt Prospect – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

As soon as I walked in the door I was wowed by the decor and atmosphere of this place. The walls are covered with classic posters and there’s a traditional Italian vibe that permeates throughout.

The pizza itself is nothing short of exquisite. The crust is light and airy, with just enough crispness on the bottom. The cheesy topping is quite generous, and each bite offers a delightful combination of flavors from the classic tomato sauce to the fresh vegetables.

But don’t let me tell you about it—you have to experience it for yourself! Mt Prospect – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria is truly an exceptional pizza spot and I highly recommend giving them a try if you’re ever in Prospect Heights looking for the best pizza in town!

#10 Garibaldi’s Italian Eatery

I was instantly charmed by the cozy, inviting atmosphere of the restaurant. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, which I really appreciated when I couldn’t decide which pizza to try first! As a pizza connoisseur, I appreciate the variety on offer. They have all my favorite classics but also offer some exciting new flavor combinations that really made me sit up and take notice.

The pizzas we tried were simply divine – perfectly cooked every time with meltingly delicious cheeses and fresh toppings. On top of that, they have a great selection of locally brewed craft beers that pair perfectly with their pies.

My only complaint is that I didn’t get to stay longer! Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite on your lunch break or settling in for a night out with friends, Garibaldi’s Italian Eatery offers something for everyone – including some of the best pizza in Prospect Heights!

#11 Brooklyn Pizza Crew

I’ve had a lot of pizza. I’ve been to Italy, France, Brazil, and all over the US trying different kinds of pies. But I do have to say that the pizza at Brooklyn Pizza Crew is something special!

The crust was crisp yet fluffy with the perfect amount of char. The cheese was gooey and creamy – not greasy or too salty. And their homemade tomato sauce was so flavorful and fragrant that I could smell it from across the room.

Plus, on top of all this deliciousness, they also offer some unique flavor combinations. Everything from pineapple with chili flakes to mushrooms and truffle oil – you won’t be disappointed!

To sum it up, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Prospect Heights – look no further than Brooklyn Pizza Crew!

#12 Nostrand Ave Pizza

Their pies are always cooked to perfection – just the right amount of crunch. The cheese is always fresh and the toppings are generous, making each bite a flavor explosion! And if you’re looking for something special, there are always unique specials on the menu like ‘jalapeno pesto’ or ‘the truffle shroom.’

The staff here is incredibly friendly and helpful – they always make sure that you get exactly what you ordered, no matter how unusual. They even remember my name every time I come in! What’s even more impressive is that they work together as if they were a well-oiled machine – a testament to their team spirit.

Along with amazing pizza, Nostrand Ave Pizza also serves up great sides like garlic knots and fries. All in all, it’s definitely worth checking out this place for the best pizza in Prospect Heights. You won’t be disappointed!