Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Redlands (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in Redlands (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

152 Views

I’ve been around the world trying pizza, and I’m always looking for a slice that stands out from the rest. My search has led me to Redlands, where I recently sampled twelve of the finest pizzerias in town.

My aim is to find delicious slices that make my taste buds dance with joy. I’m looking for pies topped with quality ingredients and cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. And of course, a little bit of lightheartedness can go a long way too when it comes to judging pizza!

With this article, I’ll be taking you on an epic journey through Redlands to uncover the best pizza around. Join me as we explore the cheese-filled landscape and find out who comes out on top!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Donatos Pizza

I visited Donatos Pizza recently, and what a treat it was! The crust was incredibly light and fluffy – nothing like the soggy mess I’ve tried elsewhere. It was cooked to perfection and had just the right amount of crunch.

The toppings were top-notch too. They used only fresh ingredients that were perfectly balanced in each pie. The pepperoni had a nice zing to it, while the cheese blended perfectly with the sauce to give it a delicious flavor.

The staff at Donatos Pizza was super friendly and helpful. When I asked for some recommendations, they recommended their signature pies and even tossed in one of those cheesy stuffed crusts for free! They also gave me some complimentary garlic knots which were out of this world.

In my opinion, Donatos Pizza is definitely at the top of the list when it comes to finding the best pizza in Redlands! Highly recommend if you’re ever in town looking for some good ‘za!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in San Bernardino!

#2 MOD Pizza

On my recent trip I decided to stop in at MOD Pizza, located conveniently on Redlands Boulevard, to grab a slice. The atmosphere was inviting and comfortable, with friendly staff to greet me upon entry.

Their selection of pizzas is great! They have a wide variety of toppings, ranging from traditional favorites like pepperoni and reduced-fat mozzarella, to more exotic options like gorgonzola and artichoke hearts. I decided on the “Reggio” Pizza, which included an array of fresh vegetables such as zucchini, red pepper and mushrooms – it was absolutely delicious!

The prices were great too. For just $7.50, you can get your own “Create Your Own” pizza which includes unlimited toppings – you do the math! Plus every 12” pizza comes with two free pieces of garlic Parmesan crust. Now that’s a bargain!

The service here was also outstanding. My order took no more than five minutes from the time I placed it until it arrived steaming hot at my table. That’s quick by any standard!

All in all, my experience at MOD Pizza was quite enjoyable and I would not hesitate to recommend it to anyone looking for quality pizza in Redlands. In fact, if I ever find myself passing through Redlands again, MOD Pizza will certainly be my first choice for the best pizza in town.

#3 The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe

The atmosphere at The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe is inviting, with lots of options whether you’re looking to have a romantic evening or just take the kids out. Not only do they serve alcohol but they also have a kid’s menu, vegetarian options and dessert, which means everyone can find something to enjoy.

The highlight of my experience was definitely the pizza. Thick-crust, cheesy with all the toppings you could ask for? What more could I (or anyone else) want! I was especially impressed by the variety of pies available. From pepperoni and sausage to supreme, I recommend giving them all a try!

My only suggestion for improvement would be that The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe offer delivery service as well as dine in – but then again, who doesn’t love tourist spots?! So don’t let that stop you from trying them out.

All in all, The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe lives up to its name of being some of the best pizza in Redlands!

#4 Pizza Xpress

From the moment I walked in, I knew this was a special place. The staff was friendly, the restaurant had a cozy atmosphere and smelled amazing.

The pizza itself is like nothing I’ve ever tasted before. They use only the freshest ingredients – their dough is light and fluffy, the sauce is zesty, and they top it off with generous amounts of cheese. Every bite was as fantastic as the last.

I’d have to say my favorite thing about Pizza Xpress is that they offer so many unique topping combinations. From all-meat pizzas, to mushrooms and olives, there’s something for everyone here!

At the end of the day, Pizza Xpress has some of the best pizza in Redlands – it just can’t be beat! If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, then Pizza Xpress is definitely worth checking out.

#5 La Volata Pizzeria

I wasn’t sure what to expect from La Volata Pizzeria, but I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the pizza. The crust is just perfect – not too thick and not too thin. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, and the cheese melts so nicely that it’s almost a work of art.

I also really appreciate that La Volata Pizzeria offers some vegetarian options for those who don’t eat meat. But even if you are a meat lover, they have some truly delicious combinations available.

The service here is great, too. They were very accommodating when we had questions about the menu, and they always greet customers with a friendly smile.

On top of all that, La Volata Pizzeria serves alcohol – something I didn’t expect in a pizza place! The best part is that they offer dessert as well, which made my meal complete.

Unfortunately they don’t offer delivery service here, so if you’re looking to get your hands on some of this delicious pizza you’ll have to come pick it up yourself or order take-out! But trust me – it’s worth it! La Volata Pizzeria brings Italy straight to Redlands with their incredible pizzas.

#6 Pizza Shack

I must admit, I was skeptical at first. I had heard about this little hole-in-the-wall that some locals were raving about, but it looked like nothing more than an unassuming pizza joint. Boy, was I wrong!

When I first tasted the pizza at Pizza Shack, my taste buds performed a symphony of approval. The crust was perfectly balanced between crunchy and chewy, and the sauce managed to capture all of the wood-fired oven’s smoky flavor with just the right combination of spices.

The toppings were also top notch. Every single topping offered a unique flavor that blended together for an unforgettable taste experience. And the portions? Let me tell you–they are generous! A single slice can easily fill up most people’s stomachs, making it perfect for large gatherings or a late night snack.

At Pizza Shack, they really know what they’re doing when it comes to crafting great pizza. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Redlands, look no further than Pizza Shack–you won’t be disappointed!

#7 New York Pizza of Redlands

The atmosphere was inviting and the staff was friendly and welcoming. After looking over the menu I settled on a classic Pepperoni pizza – it didn’t disappoint! The sauce was savory and flavorful, the crust was thin and crispy, and the cheese melted perfectly.

I’m sure all the pizza lovers out there will appreciate the variety of topping options they offer and how they cater to those with dietary restrictions by offering vegan, vegetarian, gluten free options.

The highlight of my visit though had to be their homemade garlic knots! These savory little morsels were so delicious that I couldn’t stop myself from ordering more! My fellow diners were also impressed with their other sides like Garlic Bread Sticks and Onion Rings – all equally tasty.

Overall, New York Pizza of Redlands is a great choice for anyone looking for some top-notch pizza in Redlands!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Moreno Valley!

#8 Surfer Joe’s Eatery Redlands

The first thing that struck me when I walked in was the old-school surf decor. It’s a real treat, and a great way to set the tone of an enjoyable pizza experience.

The menu has something for all tastes, so I decided to trust their judgement and order one of their specialty pizzas – the Grilled Veggie Delight. The minute it arrived at my table, I knew I had made the right decision. It was just bursting with flavor, from the chunky grilled veggies to the perfectly cooked crust.

Even more impressive than the taste is that this pizza was huge! Most pizzas this size would require far too much dough, but not this one! Somehow it manages to be substantial while also lightweight and airy.

Overall, my experience at Surfer Joe’s Eatery Redlands confirms what I already knew: they are making some of the best pizza in Redlands! Next time you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, don’t hesitate to check them out!

#9 Jerseys Pizza of Redlands

The atmosphere here is perfect for a pizza night out with friends. The restaurant has a cozy, inviting feel with plenty of space to enjoy your meal.

The service at Jerseys Pizza was great and the staff were friendly and knowledgeable. They had recommendations for every type of pizza lover!

As far as the pizza goes, I’m a fan of no-frills pies, so I had to try their classic cheese pizza. It was cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, with an ideal amount of cheese and sauce. It really hit the spot!

I also tasted one of their more creative offerings – a white garlic-parmesan pie. It had delicious chunks of garlic spread across it, accompanied by ooey gooey mozzarella and parmesan cheeses. Yum!

All in all, I highly recommend Jerseys Pizza for anyone looking for the best pizza in Redlands. Their pies are sure to satisfy every type of pizza craving you could have!

#10 Pieology Pizzeria Redlands

I have to admit, I was a bit skeptical of their claim initially; pizza is my passion, and I take it very seriously. But after tasting their pies, I’m here to report: they really delivered on their promise.

The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, yet with just the right amount of flakiness. The sauce was simple and flavorful without being overpowering. And the toppings were fresh and delicious—a combination that’s hard to top!

Their vegetarian options are also excellent. Their artichoke hearts were especially good and their vegan cheese alternative is surprisingly good—as a non-vegan pizza lover, even I enjoyed it!

Overall, Pieology Pizzeria Redlands has some of the best pizza in Redlands. If you’re looking for a truly delicious pie that you won’t soon forget, be sure to pay them a visit!

#11 Bricks and Birch

The atmosphere of Bricks and Birch is cozy yet welcoming. As soon as I stepped in, I could tell that this place was a local favorite. The decor is stylish and the staff friendly, so I knew I was in for a good meal.

I ordered one of their signature pies, the Bianca Bianco: it’s topped with mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, and fresh basil. From the first bite, I knew that this was something special. The crust was perfectly crispy and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It definitely lived up to its reputation as some of the best pizza in Redlands!

I’d recommend Bricks and Birch to anyone looking for a great quality pizza experience. They serve up some of the highest quality pizzas around, plus they’re reasonably priced too! So if you’re ever in Redlands, stop by Bricks and Birch for an amazing pizza experience — you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Shakey’s Pizza Parlor

My experience began with a cold beer, something that’s hard to find at a pizza place, and the atmosphere was amazing. The folks there were so welcoming and accommodating – even offering up their kid’s menu for my young dining companion!

The pizza itself blew me away. It had the perfect balance of crunchy crust and gooey cheese, and was just the right mix of flavors. The toppings really took it over the top – everything from pepperoni to artichokes. I savored every bite!

For dessert, they had a selection of pies that were so delicious – I recommend their peach-mango pie! It was topped with creamy ice cream that melted in my mouth.

I’m also sure to come back here when football season rolls around. Not only do they have some tasty food, but they also have televisions all over for sports lovers like me. In fact, Shakey’s Pizza Parlor is definitely becoming one of my favorite tourist spots!

The only downside is that Shakey’s doesn’t offer delivery service. Of course, this didn’t stop me from savoring what might be best pizza in Redlands!