Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Riverview FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Riverview FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

105 Views

After scouring the city and sampling 12 local pizza places, I’m here to share my findings of the absolute best pizza in this charming little Florida town.

My journey has taken me all over the world testing pizza from many unique places. From Italy to New York and even some wilder flavors like Chitlins Pizza in North Carolina – there isn’t much I haven’t tried! Now, I’m ready to share my verdict on Riverview FL’s offerings.

So grab a slice of your favorite pie and follow me as we find out who serves up the best pizza in Riverview FL!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Tuva Food Hall (Jeremiah’s Italian Ice, Capital Tacos) Shell Gas Station

The pizza here has a unique flavor that sets it apart from the typical pizzas you find elsewhere. The crust is thin and crispy and the toppings are savory, combining for an unforgettable taste. There’s a variety of topping combinations available so everyone will be able to find something they like.

I was also pleasantly surprised by their friendly staff. Everyone I encountered was eager to answer questions and help me make the best decisions when it came to my order.

The downside is that Tuva Food Hall does not offer delivery, which is unfortunate for those who can’t make it out to the restaurant. But if you’re in the area, don’t hesitate to pay them a visit – it won’t be a disappointing experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Brandon!

#2 Cappy’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Cappy’s Pizza is great. It’s a cozy, family-friendly restaurant that makes you feel right at home. The staff is welcoming and knowledgeable, so they always make great recommendations if you’re looking for something new.

I’ve been to the restaurant numerous times and the quality of the pizza never fails to impress me. With their thin, crisp crust and abundance of fresh ingredients, it’s one of the tastiest pizzas I’ve ever had! Their menu features an array of options ranging from classic combinations to unique gourmet creations.

Cappy’s Pizza also offers a wide variety of side dishes including garlic breadsticks, salads, and desserts like tiramisu. They even have vegan and gluten-free options available! So no matter what your dietary needs are, there’s sure to be something for everyone at Cappy’s Pizza.

In conclusion, Cappy’s Pizza is undoubtedly one of the best pizza places in Riverview FL. Whether you’re looking for a delicious dinner or just want a slice on the go, their offerings can’t be beat!

#3 Your Pie Pizza

First off, their crust is to die for – hand-tossed and thin like a New York style but with a unique flavor that’s all their own. When it comes to toppings, they have something for everyone – from the classic pepperoni to their signature white pies and specialty pizzas, there’s something delicious here for everyone.

But what really sets Your Pie Pizza apart is their creative sauces. Their garlic butter base is out of this world! They also have some amazing high-end choices like fig & balsamic drizzle or barbecue sauce – whatever your craving, they have you covered.

Finally, their customer service doesn’t disappoint either. They’re friendly and attentive; they know the menu inside and out and make great suggestions based on what you’re in the mood for. The prices are also great – no need to break the bank here!

To sum up: Your Pie Pizza has some of the best pizza around Riverview FL (and beyond!). If you’re looking for good food with exceptional customer service at an affordable price point, this is your spot. Check it out!

#4 PizzaVola Express

The pizza is just as flavorful, cheesy, and fragrant as it looks. The crust is perfectly thin, yet sturdy enough to hold up whatever amazing toppings you decide to top the pizza with. I had a classic pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and it was deliciously crispy and flavorsome!

I was also pleasantly surprised at how quickly my order was ready! PizzaVola Express must really know what they’re doing in their kitchen for every slice to come out of that oven so fast! Plus, their delivery is speedy too – no more waiting hours for a great pizza.

Overall, I highly recommend PizzaVola Express. It’s easily the best pizza in Riverview FL! So if you’re looking for great flavor with quick delivery time, look no further – this place has got you covered!

#5 Justin’s Pizza

I’m not exaggerating here, either. From the moment I stepped into their cozy and unassuming pizzeria, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was warm and inviting—just like an old Italian restaurant should be.

The pizza itself was fabulous! The crust was light, fluffy, and slightly crispy thanks to their secret recipe. The toppings were fresh and flavorful—no skimping on quality here! And the sauce? It was out of this world! Sweet yet tangy with just the right hint of herbs. Yum!

The price also made my wallet smile–just as much as my stomach did. Justin’s Pizza offers large pizzas at a great value—without compromising on taste or ingredients.

All in all, Justin’s Pizza is hands-down one of the best pizza places in Riverview FL! If you’re looking for amazing pizza that won’t break the bank, Justin’s Pizza is a must-try!

#6 Mellow Mushroom Brandon

Their pizza crust is light and slightly crunchy with a hint of sweetness, and they offer a wide variety of topping options that never fail to impress. The Spicy Thai Pie is my personal favorite: it’s got a perfect balance between sweet and heat, and the flavor combinations are always spot on.

The atmosphere at Mellow Mushroom Brandon has an inviting, laid back vibe that makes you feel at home – there’s even live music on the weekends! Service is always friendly and knowledgeable – you’ll know exactly what to order before you’ve even looked at the menu.

The best thing about Mellow Mushroom Brandon? They have some of the best pizza around. If you’re ever in Riverview FL, make sure to stop by Mellow Mushroom Brandon for an unforgettable pizza experience!

#7 Olde Town Pizzeria & Pasta Co.

I was really pleased to find out that there were plenty of vegetarian options, so I got the veggie-lovers pizza. The amount of toppings was really impressive and it tasted even better than it looked.

The atmosphere is great for watching sports games because there are several big-screen TVs around and the staff dutifully keeps them tuned in to the best games. Plus, they serve alcohol – another plus in my book!

If you’ve got kids with you, there’s a special kid’s menu featuring a variety of items. Even more impressive: they have dessert, too!

On the downside, Olde Town Pizzeria & Pasta Co. doesn’t offer delivery service – which is really a shame since their pizza is so amazing. So unfortunately you have to go to them if you want to try it out for yourself. But trust me – it’s worth the trip!

#8 East Coast Pizza

I was recently in town and gave East Coast Pizza a try. I have to say, their pizza exceeded my expectations! The crust was just the right thickness, and it had a nice crispness to it without being burnt. The sauce was flavorful and had just the right amount of tanginess and sweetness. And the cheese – well let me tell you, it was some of the creamiest and most delicious cheese I’ve ever tasted on a pizza!

The best part about my visit though had to be the atmosphere at East Coast Pizza. It felt like walking into an old-fashioned Italian pizzeria – from the hearty aromas wafting through the air, to their friendly staff. They didn’t just make me feel welcome; they made me feel like family!

Plus, East Coast Pizza has some great additional toppings that you can add to your order. Everything from mushrooms and peppers to olives and jalapenos – you name it and they probably got it!

At the end of my meal I walked away with a full belly but also a huge smile on my face knowing that I experienced some of the best pizza in Riverview FL! If you’re ever in town looking for a slice or two, be sure to check out East Coast Pizza – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Tampa!

#9 Bloomingdale Pizza Valrico

The pizza is genuine, authentic Italian with real Italian ingredients and the signature homemade sauce. The crust of the pizza was delightfully thin – crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The cheese was freshly grated and flavorful, melting perfectly into every bite.

The toppings are always fresh, never frozen. The variety of toppings allows me to get something different each time I visit this pizzeria! Some of my favorite combinations have included mushrooms, sausage, spinach, olives, pepperoni and onions. Even if you’re not a fan of traditional toppings there’s something for everyone here: they have exotic topping combinations that offer an unparalleled experience!

Overall, the quality of Bloomingdale Pizza Valrico cannot be denied – it comes as no surprise that their pizza has been voted the best in Riverview FL! Whether it’s a family gathering or a business lunch, this spot serves up some mouth-watering pizza everytime. If you’re in search of good pizza in Riverview FL – look no further than Bloomingdale Pizza Valrico!

#10 Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

The atmosphere was great and had some cool wood-fired ovens that just screamed authentic Italian pizza. I had the classic Margherita Pizza with house-made mozzarella and fresh basil, and it was superb. The crust was perfectly cooked, the flavor was robust but not overpowering, and the pizza was so big you could barely fit it in your mouth!

The wings were also spectacularly delicious. They had a sweet and savory marinade that kept your taste buds dancing. The wings were crispy on the outside and tender on the inside — how do they do it?!

On top of all this greatness, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings is also very fairly priced, making it an ideal place to grab a quick bite with friends or family. All in all, I would recommend this spot to anyone who wants to experience some of the best pizza in Riverview FL!

#11 Times Square Pizza Co

The atmosphere was lively and fun – a great place to grab a quick bite before strolling around Times Square. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure our order was both correct and satisfying.

And the pizza… wow! It was perfect – delicious, chewy crust that wasn’t too thick or thin, with generous amounts of flavourful sauce and cheese. I loved how nothing felt over-cooked or under-cooked, it all just melted together nicely in my mouth.

I normally go for something a bit off the beaten path when it comes to pizza toppings, but this time I decided to try their classic pepperoni – it did not disappoint! It had the perfect balance of salty and sweet flavours, plus a nice crunchy texture. To top it off (literally), they had an excellent selection of fresh herbs to choose from; I added some oregano for an extra special touch.

Overall, Times Square Pizza Co has become my go-to spot for pizza in Riverview FL – hands down, the best pizza in town!

#12 Joia Fabulous Pizza & Martini Bar

The atmosphere is great – the restaurant itself is beautiful and brightly lit, making it easy to take in the amazing architecture. I also appreciated the cozy seating area by the window, perfect for enjoying a nice martini in between slices of pizza.

When it comes to the pizza itself, what can I say? It’s absolutely delicious! The crust was cooked perfectly – not too crunchy or too doughy – and all my toppings were fresh and flavorful. The bartenders even recommended some delicious drinks that complemented my pizza perfectly!

Overall, Joia Fabulous Pizza & Martini Bar has definitely earned its place as one of the best pizza places in Riverview FL. From its atmosphere to its delicious food, Joia will provide an enjoyable experience and plenty of tasty pizzas to choose from!