Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Rochester NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Rochester NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

776 Views

I’ve tried the best pizza from all sorts of places around the world, from fancy Italian restaurants to roadside stands. But now, I’m on a mission to find Rochester’s best slices. I’ve whet my appetite by visiting twelve different pizza places in the area and taking notes on each one.

So join me as I take you through the best pizza Rochester NY has to offer – if you’re anything like me, your mouth will be drooling by the end of this article!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Create A Pizza

It was a pleasant surprise to find such a great pizza place in upstate New York. The atmosphere was inviting and the staff was very friendly.

The restaurant offers an extensive selection of pizzas for you to customize – from the crust to the toppings – with fresh, quality ingredients that make every bite enjoyable. I tried the half pepperoni and half bacon, and it was truly sensational! The thin crust held all the toppings perfectly and had a great crispy texture.

The service at Create A Pizza is also top-notch. They were quick to take my order and serve me my pizza within minutes!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Rochester NY, look no further than Create A Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Rochester!

#2 Nino’s Pizzeria

When I arrived at Nino’s Pizzeria, I was blown away by the atmosphere. It was such a cozy and inviting spot with red and white checked tablecloths, wooden tables, and a warm ambience perfect for enjoying pizza.

The food at Nino’s was simply amazing. I had never tasted pizza so delicious before! The crust was thin and crispy on the outside but still soft in the middle. And the toppings were perfectly balanced – not too much cheese, but just enough to give it that great flavor combination.

The staff at Nino’s was also full of personality. They were friendly and knowledgeable about the menu offerings, offering great suggestions whenever we had questions. Plus, they were always willing to go above and beyond to make sure we had a pleasant experience.

Simply put – if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Rochester NY , Nino’s Pizzeria is your place!

#3 The Pizza Stop

The restaurant was full of locals and tourists, which is always a good sign in my book. The atmosphere was inviting, and the staff were friendly and welcoming.

I’m a big believer that the best way to review pizza is to try it for yourself, so I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza. It arrived at my table piping hot, with generous amounts of toppings, just the way I like it. The crust had a nice crunch to it and the flavor was spot on – something that can’t be said for all pizzas!

Overall, I’d say The Pizza Stop offers one of the best pizzas around. If you’re ever in the Rochester area, be sure to stop by – your taste buds won’t regret it!

#4 Merchants Wood Fired Pizza & Bistro

The pizza here is insanely good and definitely worth trying. Not only are there delicious vegetarian options for those looking for something a bit healthier, but the hard liquor served here really takes it up a level – with both beer and wine available, you can have your favorite beverage of choice with your meal!

But of course, what really blew me away is their dessert. Seriously, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Rochester NY and an amazing sweet treat to end the meal, then look no further – Merchants Wood Fired Pizza & Bistro has got you covered! The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery – but why bother ordering out when it’s so good here?

Simply put, Merchants Wood Fired Pizza & Bistro offers fantastic pizza in a wonderful atmosphere – I highly recommend it!

#5 Pizza Wizard

My experience started off with the warm and inviting atmosphere, which felt like a home away from home. The staff was friendly and had helpful suggestions for what to order. I went with the Tastes-Like-Heaven Supreme pizza and it definitely lived up to its name! It had the perfect combination of ingredients, from pepperoni to mushrooms.

The real highlight of my visit, though, was the crust. Though thin, it still maintained its structure when I took a bite – a sign of true quality. And the flavor was unique yet unmistakably pizza-y – I’ve tasted nothing else like it!

Overall, Pizza Wizard has earned my vote as having some of the best pizza in Rochester NY. Not only is their food exceptional, but their customer service and welcoming atmosphere make this spot even more enjoyable. If you’re in town looking for an amazing slice of pizza, be sure to check out Pizza Wizard!

#6 Galleria Pizza

The crust was incredibly flavorful, with that perfect balance of crunch and chewiness. The sauce was superbly tangy, with just the right amount of spice. Every bite I took had me salivating for more!

The toppings were plentiful and varied. From classic pepperoni and sausage to some unique choices like artichoke hearts, roasted peppers, and even marinated portobellos – there truly was something for everyone.

My absolute favorite part of Galleria Pizza is the cheese. They use a special blend of Italian cheeses which give every bite incredible flavor and a creamy texture that’s absolutely divine.

I simply cannot say enough about this pizza place – it’s definitely one of the best in Rochester NY!

#7 Veneto Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta

The crust is cooked perfectly to give it a wood-fired flavor, and the cheese is creamy and delicious. The pasta is cooked al dente and really brings out the flavors of the sauce. But what really makes this place special are their toppings! From the freshest veggies to premium meats, everything is fresh and flavorful.

I especially love their signature pies like the Rossi, which features house-made sausage, caramelized onions, roasted garlic, and mozzarella. It’s simply heavenly!

The atmosphere at Veneto is great too. I love that it has a rustic charm with its wood-burning ovens, dim lighting, and cozy seating.

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Rochester NY, then look no further than Veneto Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta!

#8 Carbone’s Pizzeria

I was treated to a delicious classic Margherita pizza with fresh tomato sauce and basil, along with a thin-crust pepperoni that was packed with incredible flavor. The dough was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunch.

The service at Carbone’s Pizzeria is top notch – they’re always friendly, helpful and attentive. They really strive to make sure you have an enjoyable experience in their restaurant.

Unfortunately, Carbone’s Pizzeria does not offer delivery, which is a huge downside for me. But it’s worth the trip to their restaurant if you want the best pizza in Rochester NY!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Webster!

#9 Linda’s New York Pizzeria

I had the pleasure of trying their famous ‘Linda’s Special’ and it far exceeded my expectations. The crust was thin, chewy and crisp, with just the right amount of cheese. The sauce was flavorful and well balanced, with plenty of garlic and herbs. To top it all off, the toppings were fresh and really hit the spot.

The atmosphere in Linda’s New York Pizzeria felt like an old-fashioned pizzeria from NYC – without all the hustle and bustle! The staff were friendly and attentive, while still staying busy creating amazing pies.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Rochester NY then look no further than Linda’s New York Pizzeria! Their pies are delicious and you won’t be disappointed – so what are you waiting for? Get your pizza fix now!

#10 Rhino’s Pizzeria

From the moment I walked in and smelled the garlic and oregano, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with jazz playing softly in the background. The staff were friendly and helpful, which made my experience even more enjoyable.

Now let’s talk about the pizza! My favorite was their classic cheese pizza – it had a delicious crispy crust, topped with freshly grated mozzarella cheese and a savory tomato sauce. The toppings were fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. The flavor was amazing!

But they also offer other menu items like calzones, strombolis, salads, wings, subs and more. You could eat here several times over without getting bored of their menu options.

All in all, Rhino’s Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for the best pizza in Rochester NY! I’m sure you will find something to satisfy your cravings!

#11 OTR Woodfire Tavern

The restaurant is cozy and inviting, and the staff are knowledgeable and friendly. The pizza here is cooked in a wood-fired oven, giving it a unique flavor that can’t be found anywhere else!

To start off my meal, I sampled their garlic knots – an absolute must for any pizza connoisseur. They were delectable, with the perfect balance of crunchy outside and soft inside. The garlic was definitely key in making them so delicious!

For my actual meal, I tried a classic Neapolitan-style Margherita pizza. It was mouthwateringly good – the flavor of the homemade tomato sauce jumped out at me first, then followed by the sweet basil and creamy mozzarella topping it off perfectly. What made this pizza stand out for me though was the delicious taste of the crust – it had a nice char on it from being cooked in that wood-fired oven, but still had its classic chewy texture.

Last but not least was dessert – they have some amazing cannolis! Crispy shells filled with ricotta cheese and dusted with powdered sugar make these an ideal end to any meal at OTR Woodfire Tavern.

Overall I’m very impressed with what OTR Woodfire Tavern has to offer! From their incredible pizzas to their exquisite desserts, they certainly have earned their spot as one of Rochester’s best pizzerias!

#12 Pudgie’s Pizzeria

My first visit to Pudgie’s was an eye-opening experience. From the moment I stepped in the door, it felt like coming home. The atmosphere is charming but unpretentious , like a classic neighborhood pizzeria should be.

The pizza itself is amazing! It has that beautiful, crisp crust that’s made with a secret blend of seasonings – the best part! And they top it off with a generous helping of fresh vegetables and delicious cheese. Every slice I took was bursting with flavor – no skimping here!

And the service? Outstanding! The staff always go above and beyond to make sure you get exactly what you want. They’ll even customize your pizza order if you want something unique. Plus they have great deals and discounts.

If you want the best pizza in Rochester NY, look no further than Pudgie’s Pizzeria – it definitely receives my highest recommendation!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Pizza Wizard

Now, before I get into the details, I have to say that this place is a real wizardry of flavors. As soon as I entered, I was greeted by the aroma of freshly baked pizza and the sound of laughter from the lively crowd. But here’s the kicker – I could also smell the tantalizing scent of garlic knots and the enchanting fragrance of a perfectly brewed beer. Yes, my friends, this place serves alcohol!

Now, as a vegetarian, finding good pizza options can sometimes be as challenging as battling a dragon. Thankfully, Pizza Wizard has some vegetarian options that even a herbivorous wizard like myself can enjoy. Their Margherita pizza was like a spellbinding dance of flavors, with perfectly melted cheese, fresh basil, and the most exquisite tomato sauce. It was pure magic on a crust!

Now, let’s talk about the downside – they don’t accept reservations. I mean, come on, we’re wizards in the 21st century! We have wands that do incredible things, yet we can’t reserve a table? Oh well, I guess I’ll just have to wave my wand and make a little reservation charm of my own.

But honestly, my fellow food enthusiasts, this place is a must-visit. Besides the fantastic pizza and the fact that they serve alcohol, it’s also a great tourist spot. The ambiance is charming, and the staff is as friendly as a house elf. So, grab your broomstick, your appetite, and head on over to Pizza Wizard for a truly magical pizza experience. Expecto deliciousum!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Merchants Wood Fired Pizza & Bistro

Upon entering the restaurant, my eyes immediately darted to the bar, where I was pleasantly surprised to see they serve alcohol, and not just your run-of-the-mill beer and wine. Oh no, they have the hard stuff too! As a traveling food critic, sometimes I need a little something to take the edge off, and Merchants provides just that.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. The wood-fired oven that they use is truly a magical contraption. It creates a perfectly crisp and charred crust that is basically impossible to resist. It’s like a siren’s call, leading you straight to pizza heaven. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, and you can tell that they take pride in using high-quality ingredients. Plus, they even have a few vegetarian options, perfect for all my herbivore friends out there.

But here’s the real kicker: the dessert. Oh my sweet tooth, you have been satisfied at Merchants. They have some of the most insanely good desserts I have ever had the pleasure of devouring. From the sinfully rich chocolate lava cake to the delicate and delightful fruit tarts, they know how to end a meal on a sweet note.

Now, let’s address the elephant in the room: no delivery. I get it, they want you to experience their pizza fresh out of the oven, but sometimes a lazy night in demands pizza at your doorstep. Alas, it’s a small price to pay for such delectable pizza.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best wood fired pizza in rochester ny, look no further than Merchants Wood Fired Pizza & Bistro. Just be prepared for a lack of delivery and a whole lot of deliciousness.