Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Salem MA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Massachusetts

Best Pizza in Salem MA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

196 Views

I’ve been around the world tasting pizza, so I feel like I’m in a pretty good position to provide feedback on where to find the best in Salem.

I visited twelve pizza places and can guarantee that there is something for everyone here – whether you’re looking for traditional slices, creative combinations, or vegan options.

I know great pizza is subjective, but I found some delicious pies during my visits. Read on to see which places were the standouts!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Massachusetts

#1 Georgia’s Pizza

The atmosphere is inviting and cheerful with its bright green walls decorated with life-sized posters of pizza slices. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, helping me to choose a number of delicious options. From the classic pepperoni to the signature Georgia Pie which comes with a special garlic-infused tomato sauce, I was spoiled for choice!

The pizza crust was cooked just right – crispy on the outside but with a soft center. The toppings were generous and flavorful, with plenty of cheese and other toppings like mushrooms, onions, olives and more.

Overall, my experience at Georgia’s Pizza was top-notch! The food was delicious, the staff helpful and friendly and the atmosphere fun and enjoyable. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Salem MA then definitely check out Georgia’s Pizza. Trust me – you will not be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Beverly!

#2 Plum Tomatoes Brick Oven Pizza

The thin crust Neapolitan-style pizzas are truly fantastic, with a wide variety of toppings to choose from. There’s even a few vegetarian options available which is great for herbivores like me! The atmosphere in the restaurant is relaxed and it seems like the perfect spot for a casual night out with friends.

However, it does have one downside – there’s no delivery option. So if you want to get your hands on some of this delicious pizza you’re going to have to move your feet and pick it up yourself. But trust me, it’s worth it!

If you haven’t tried Plum Tomatoes Brick Oven Pizza yet then what are you waiting for? I guarantee that by the time you finish your first slice, you’ll be hooked!

#3 Prime Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and casual. The staff are friendly and welcoming, which adds to the overall experience.

Once I’d settled in, it was time to get down to business – tasting the pizza! Prime Pizza has a wide variety of options that are sure to please everyone’s pizza cravings. I personally enjoyed the ‘Pepperoni & Sausage’ pizza. The ingredients were fresh and flavorsome with a perfect blend of spices that brought out all the unique flavors of each topping.

I also tried the ‘BBQ Chicken’ pizza and was equally impressed. The golden, flaky crust was delightful and complimented the creamy BBQ sauce perfectly.

Overall, Prime Pizza was truly an amazing experience. It easily serves up some of the best pizza in Salem MA – no doubt about it! If you’re ever in town, don’t miss out on this place – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Peter’s Bella Pizza

The first time I visited Peter’s Bella Pizza, I was apprehensive. After all, the best pizza places are usually off the beaten path. But as soon as I walked in, I knew this was going to be special.

The smells of freshly baked pizza dough wafted through the air, and my mouth started watering before we even reached the counter. We ordered a Pepperoni Deluxe and a Cheese Calzone, and both were perfection on a plate (or rather, in a box). The crust was perfectly thin and crisp, with just the right amount of charring from the oven. The pepperoni was flavorful and juicy, while the cheese calzone oozed with gooey deliciousness.

And that’s not even mentioning their exemplary customer service – when we had trouble deciding between two pizzas (who knew you could get overwhelmed by too much choice?), our server quickly stepped in and helped us make an informed decision – something that goes beyond mere customer service!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Salem MA – or anywhere – look no further than Peter’s Bella Pizza!

#5 Bambolina

I popped into Bambolina on a whim, and I was so surprised by how delicious their pizza tasted. The restaurant also serves alcohol which is great for when you want to grab a drink with your slice! Plus, they have some great vegetarian options too.

But what really blew me away were the desserts; they were insanely good! If you’re looking for a nice spot to take tourists or just want to treat yourself well then Bambolina is definitely worth checking out.

The only thing that I wasn’t too happy with was that they don’t offer delivery. But if you can make it there in person then I can assure you that it’s worth the journey — this is hands-down the best pizza in Salem MA!

#6 Flying Saucer Pizza Company

From the moment I stepped in the door, I was impressed by the extraordinary atmosphere. It felt like a cozy Italian tavern with its warm lighting and vibrant energy from guests enjoying their meals. I sampled just about every type of pizza on the menu and was blown away by the flavors and quality.

The thin-crust pizzas were some of my favorite, especially the Four Cheese Pizza – it had just the right mix of mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, and Asiago cheeses that made each bite a unique experience. The BBQ Chicken pizza was my other top pick; it had just enough zest to give a nice kick without being overpowering and featured large pieces of juicy chicken in every slice.

Of course, no pizza is complete without an ice cold beer to go with it! Flying Saucer Pizza Co had plenty of brews on tap that paired perfectly with our meal.

The real star here is the service, though – our waitress was always quick to bring us refills and friendly conversation while we ate, which really added to our overall dining experience.

At Flying Saucer Pizza Company you can count on great food, good drinks, and an enjoyable atmosphere all in one place! In my opinion this is easily some of the best pizza in Salem MA.

#7 Gallo Nero

I have a strict policy of only eating pizza at Italian restaurants, and Gallo Nero is no exception. They use top-notch ingredients that always give their pizza a unique, delicious flavor. Their mozzarella cheese has a unique tang, while their red sauce is especially flavorful. The crust is to die for – it’s perfectly crunchy without being too thick or too thin.

The atmosphere in the restaurant was great. It had an old school Italian feel with wooden tables, checkered tablecloths, and pictures of Italian celebrities on the walls. The service was friendly and efficient – my order was served fast, which was appreciated since I was short on time!

Overall, I would highly recommend Gallo Nero as one of the best places to get pizza in Salem MA! If you’re looking for delicious Italian food with excellent service, then you should definitely stop by Gallo Nero and sample their amazing pizzas!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Lynn!

#8 Essex’s N.Y. Pizza & Deli

The atmosphere of the restaurant is great. It has a cozy, homey feel with its brick walls and rich wood accents. As you walk in, you are welcomed by the warm aroma of fresh-baked pizza.

The pizza itself is amazing! The crust is thin and perfectly cooked every time and it’s perfectly seasoned. The toppings are fresh and full of flavor, making every bite delicious. One of my personal favorites is the Margherita Pizza with extra cheese – it’s simply mouthwatering.

If you’re looking for something other than pizza, there’s also a delicious selection of subs and salads on the menu that are worth trying. I especially recommend the Italian Sub; it’s overflowing with savory meats, cheeses, and vegetables that create an unforgettable flavor combination.

Overall, I highly recommend Essex’s N.Y. Pizza & Deli for anyone searching for some of the best pizza in Salem MA!

#9 Mandee’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Mandee’s Pizza is lively and fun, with a big screen TV playing sports games so you can cheer on your favorite team while enjoying a piping hot pizza. The service was friendly and attentive, which made the experience even more enjoyable.

Now down to what matters most: the pizza. I had the pepperoni pizza and it was simply delicious! The dough was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, with just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni for an amazing taste. It was definitely one of the most flavorful pizzas I’ve ever had!

I definitely recommend Mandee’s Pizza if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Salem MA. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Dina’s Roast Beef & Seafood

When I visited, I was immediately captivated by the atmosphere of the restaurant. The walls were filled with art and the music playing in the background made for an enjoyable dining experience.

I’m not sure what kind of magic Dina used to make her pizza so tasty, but it was truly one of a kind! The crust had just the right amount of crunchiness and the topping tasted like a real gourmet meal. Plus the portion size was perfect for my appetite – not too little, but also not too much.

My favorite part about eating at Dina’s Roast Beef & Seafood however, was that they offered great customer service. Everyone working there seemed so friendly and helpful, which really added to my overall experience.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Salem MA then look no further than Dina’s Roast Beef & Seafood! Not only will you get to enjoy an amazing slice (or two!) of pizza but you’ll also get to experience great customer service as well. Highly recommended!

#11 North House of Pizza

The service here was top notch. Everyone was extremely welcoming and friendly, and they treated us like family! The pizza itself was simply divine. You could taste the freshness of the ingredients in every bite!

The selection was great too – there were several specialty pies that I hadn’t seen anywhere else. The seafood one in particular stood out as a particularly innovative offering.

But the real star of the show? The crust! It was perfection – crunchy on the outside but soft and chewy on the inside. Bravo North House of Pizza!

All in all, if you’re looking for some truly exceptional pizza, North House of Pizza should be at the top of your list!

#12 Christina’s Pizza

When I stepped into the restaurant, I was immediately assaulted by the smell of fresh pizza and my mouth started to water. I could see that they had a wide variety of pizzas on their menu with something for everyone, so I decided to start with a classic Pepperoni Pizza.

The crust was perfect – not too thick, but still with enough substance to carry the sauce and toppings. The sauce had just the right amount of sweetness and spice which blended perfectly with the cheese and pepperoni. Every bite was an explosion of flavor!

I also tried their Hawaiian Pizza which was equally delicious. The pineapple chunks were absolutely divine – no canned stuff here – all fresh ingredients! The crust stayed nice and crisp throughout, even after I took it home for lunch the next day!

To sum it up: if you’re in Salem MA and looking for some of the best pizza you’ll ever try, look no further than Christina’s Pizza!