Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Salem NH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Hampshire

Best Pizza in Salem NH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

155 Views

I’ve been to 12 pizza places around the Salem area and know first-hand what it takes to make a delicious pie. With my experience from all over the world, I’m ready to give you my opinion on the best pizza in town.

I’m taking a lighthearted and humorous approach as I review each place, so expect some fun insights along the way! Get ready for an entertaining journey while we search for what I believe is the tastiest slice of pizza that Salem has to offer.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Hampshire

#1 Amore Pizza Restaurant

The atmosphere at this restaurant was overwhelmingly inviting and warm. Not to mention it had a great view of the city – you could even see the Statue of Liberty in the background.

The food was even more impressive! I tried everything from their classic margherita pizza to their unique recipes like the ‘Amatriciana’ pizza with bacon and onions, and every single bite was pure perfection. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside yet still tender, and the sauce was sweet and savory with just the right amount of herbs. The toppings were fresh, flavorful and plentiful; everything was cooked to perfection.

Speaking of “perfection”, let’s talk about service. The staff at Amore Pizza Restaurant went above and beyond to make my experience enjoyable. From taking my order, to delivering my pizza to understanding all my questions, they were incredibly helpful, friendly and informative.

In conclusion, Amore Pizza Restaurant is definitely up there as one of the best pizzeria in Salem NH! I strongly recommend it for anyone looking for delicious pizza or an unforgettable dining experience.

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Haverhill!

#2 NH Beach Pizza

On my recent visit, I have to say that the pizza didn’t disappoint. From the fresh and soft doughy crust to the savory and delectable toppings, each bite was truly heavenly. The classic pepperoni slices balanced perfectly against the creamy yet tangy tomato sauce.

The cheese was absolutely top-notch – a perfect blend of creaminess and sharpness, not too greasy and not too dry. The final product was a rich flavor experience that left me wanting more each time!

Service-wise, NH Beach Pizza’s staff were friendly and accommodating – always willing to answer any questions or take special orders if necessary. Definitely a plus for anyone that likes their pizza customized.

Overall, this is definitely the best pizza in Salem NH – no question about it! Highly recommended for those who are looking for some delicious Italian flavors!

#3 Romano’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Romano’s Pizzeria was incredibly inviting, with a cozy family atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The staff were friendly and helpful, and the pizza was truly amazing. From the thin and crispy crust to the generous toppings, I couldn’t get enough of their pizza.

The pizzas are served piping hot, with a variety of flavors and styles to choose from. Whether you like your pizza topped with classic ingredients or creative flavor combinations, there’s something for everyone here. The Sicilian style is particularly delicious – it’s thick, cheesy and cooked to perfection!

I’m so glad I stopped in at Romano’s Pizzeria – it definitely goes down as one of the best places for pizza in Salem NH! Highly recommended for those looking for quality pizza in this area.

#4 Suppa’s Pizza

The atmosphere of this little pizza joint is cozy and inviting, and the staff are friendly and accommodating. The pizza itself is truly delicious; it’s made with the freshest ingredients and cooked to perfection. The crust is crispy yet fluffy at the same time, and the toppings are abundant without being overpowering.

What really stands out about Suppa’s Pizza is that they offer so many different types of pizzas–from classic pepperoni to unusual combos like mac n cheese pizza–so no matter what your tastes, you’re sure to find something that hits the spot.

In conclusion, I’d highly recommend Suppa’s Pizza for anyone looking for a great pie in Salem NH. It may not be the fanciest place but it certainly has some of the best pizza around.

#5 Franny Subs & Pasta

The atmosphere in the restaurant was so inviting and upbeat. The staff was friendly, accommodating, and eager to make sure we had the best experience!

The pizza itself was nothing short of remarkable. It was cooked perfectly and every bite was full of flavor. The crust was crispy yet not too thick, which is always a plus. The sauce that they use is unique and really brought the whole pizza together.

To top it all off, the prices here are surprisingly affordable! For a place with such great quality food and atmosphere, I’m happy to report that Franny Subs & Pasta won’t break your wallet – it’s an absolute steal!

In short, if you’re ever in Salem NH looking for some seriously delicious pizza, Franny Subs & Pasta is where you want to be! This place truly makes some of the best pizza in Salem NH – don’t miss out!

#6 Salem Kabob & Pizzeria

When I first arrived, I was pleasantly surprised to see that the restaurant had a nice atmosphere. The walls were decorated with colorful artwork, and the seating was comfortable.

My pizza experience started with the classic Cheesy Pepperoni. The crusty dough was perfectly cooked, and it was topped with a generous amount of mozzarella cheese and the freshest pepperoni I’ve ever tasted. It really hit the spot!

The next time around, I tried their Margherita Pizza which featured classic tomato sauce, basil leaves, and slices of juicy tomatoes on top. This pizza had a pleasant balance of flavors that left me wanting more!

If you’re in Salem NH looking for some delicious pizza, Salem Kabob & Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out. They offer some of the best pizza in town, and their friendly staff always make sure you’re enjoying your meal. Go ahead and give them a visit – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Michael’s Flatbread Bar & Grill

Right away when you walk into the restaurant, it’s easy to tell that this place knows what they’re doing. From the classic brick oven pizzas to the hard liquor selection, this place has no shortage of options. Plus, if you have kids in tow, they’ve got an amazing Kids Menu so everyone is taken care of.

The pizza selections are out of this world! My favorite was the margarita pizza – it was cooked to perfection and packed with flavor. Not only that but the restaurant even offers desserts for those of us who love something sweet after dinner.

On top of all that, Michael’s Flatbread Bar & Grill has a great atmosphere, perfect for date nights and family gatherings alike. However, I do have one suggestion: add delivery! That would make this already fantastic restaurant a true standout!

All in all, if you want some of the best pizza in Salem NH, look no further than Michael’s Flatbread Bar & Grill!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Lowell!

#8 Balducci’s Wood Fired Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and the pizza truly lived up to its name. I had the margherita pizza, which was cooked in a classic wood-fired oven, giving it an amazing taste that can’t be found anywhere else.

I must say, the staff here are very friendly and accommodating. They even took additional time to explain the different kinds of doughs used for their pizzas, as well as what toppings would best match each one. Their knowledge and passion for pizza is impressive!

The crust was incredible – perfectly crispy on the outside yet still soft and chewy on the inside. The wood-fired flavor gave this pizza a unique touch that set it apart from other pizzas I’ve had before. The ingredients were all fresh, flavorful and plentiful – exactly how I like my pizza!

Overall, Balducci’s Wood Fired Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Salem NH! From the delicious crust to the flavorful toppings, you won’t be disappointed here. I definitely recommend adding this restaurant to your must-visit list!

#9 Blue House Family Pizza Salem

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Blue House Family Pizza Salem and am happy to report that it exceeded all my expectations. The restaurant was cozy, the staff was friendly and accommodating, and the pizza just melted in my mouth!

The crust was crunchy yet fluffy, with the perfect balance of oiliness. Plus, their signature family-style sauce was delicious; it had a hint of sweetness that rounded out all the flavors perfectly. I also sampled their classic cheese pizza which was amazing – fresh mozzarella and basil sprinkled over a flavorful tomato sauce.

For dessert, I opted for one of their homemade tiramisu creations – you have to try this! The combination of creamy mascarpone and sweet espresso was heavenly.

My overall experience at Blue House Family Pizza Salem was excellent. I highly recommend this place if you’re looking for some top-notch pizza in Salem NH!

#10 Granfanallys

When I stepped into Granfanallys, I was immediately impressed by their friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant had a cozy and inviting feel that made me want to stay for hours sampling all of the delicious offerings.

The pizza options at Granfanallys were extensive, and I spent a good amount of time pondering my selection. In the end, I settled on the classic: pepperoni and cheese. However, when it arrived at my table it looked more like a work of art than just a pizza.

The presentation was perfect with beautifully arranged pepperonis sprinkled across the top in an almost-perfect pattern. But presentation isn’t everything—the taste is where it’s at! And boy did Granfanallys deliver!

The crust was perfectly crispy yet still chewy–exactly how I like it! The sauce was flavorful and rich, while the cheese melted luxuriously over the entire pie. The pepperonis added just enough salty flavor to make this pizza truly delectable.

I’ve had pizza all around the world—from Italy to America—and Granfanallys stands amongst the best of them! If you’re ever in Salem NH and looking for a delicious pizza experience, then look no further than Granfanallys!

#11 Route 97 House of Pizza

The atmosphere is inviting and the staff are helpful and friendly. The pizza dough is perfectly cooked with just the right proportion of crunch on the outside and soft on the inside. Their signature cheese blend is rich and creamy and their fresh-made tomato sauce is full of flavor, and never too sour or too sweet.

I ordered the classic pepperoni pizza, which was loaded with juicy slices of pepperoni that were cooked to perfection. There were plenty of mushrooms and onions as well, making it a flavor explosion in my mouth!

But what really sealed the deal for me was their house-specialty: garlic knots covered in garlic butter and parmesan cheese. I don’t think I could even say how amazing this dish was – it was hands down one of the best things I’ve ever eaten!

All in all, Route 97 House of Pizza has earned its rightful place among Salem NH’s best pizzerias. If you’re looking for a delicious pie or some tasty sides, this place definitely won’t disappoint!

#12 Giovanni’s Roast Beef & Pizza

When I first walked into the restaurant, I was already impressed by how inviting it was. The atmosphere was cozy and the staff were all friendly and welcoming. It definitely set the tone for a great experience!

Once I sat down at my table, it was time to sample the pizza. From my very first bite I knew this pizza was something special! The crust was just right – nicely crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside – and they used only top-quality ingredients in their sauce and cheeses.

I decided to try a couple of different pizzas from their menu, but what really got me excited about Giovanni’s was how creative their topping combinations were. One of my favorites was their Lombardi Special – pepperoni, salami, ground beef, onions, bell peppers, mushrooms and black olives – which perfectly combined different flavors to create an unforgettable pizza experience!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Salem NH, you have to check out Giovanni’s Roast Beef & Pizza. They’ve definitely earned my seal of approval!