Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in San Clemente (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in San Clemente (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

252 Views

I’ve been around the world tasting pizza, and it’s a tough job – but somebody’s got to do it! I’m here to tell you about the best pizza places in San Clemente, after reviewing 12 of them.

You’ll find my list of recommendations full of unique toppings, artisanal doughs, and delicious sauces – all rated with my typical humorous and lighthearted style. So get ready and grab a slice; let’s go find the best pizza in San Clemente!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Gibroni’s Pizza

Not only is the pizza delicious, the atmosphere of Gibroni’s Pizza is second to none. The decor is bright and inviting, with a cheery orange and yellow motif that always puts me in a good mood. From the moment I walk in the door, it just feels like coming home.

The pizza itself is really something special; from thin crust to thick crust, there’s something for everyone here. Every topping is perfectly cooked and seasoned to perfection. Not only that, but the size of their personal pizzas are generous enough to feed at least two people! Talk about great value for your money!

The true masterpiece though, has got to be their deep dish pizza – it’s one of the best pies I’ve ever had! The sauce and cheese combination work together like a dream; every bite is an explosion of flavor.

If you’re looking for some top-notch pizza in San Clemente, then look no further than Gibroni’s Pizza – they have truly earned their reputation as having some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Dana Point!

#2 Pizza Port San Clemente

I tried the pepperoni pizza and it was absolutely delicious. The sauce had the perfect balance of sweet and savory, and the cheese was so fresh and gooey that I could barely take a bite without it all sliding off my slice!

The atmosphere of Pizza Port San Clemente is also spot on with board games available to play while you eat, a great selection of beer to choose from, and even live music some nights.

My only complaint is that they don’t stay open late. But that’s okay — it just means I need to get there early enough to make sure I can get a table before they close!

Overall, if you’re in San Clemente looking for a great pizza then Pizza Port San Clemente is your spot. You won’t regret it!

#3 Sonny’s Pizza & Pasta

At first glance, it looks like any other pizzeria in town, but upon further inspection I could immediately tell that Sonny’s was something special. The menu has all the classics plus some unique specials that impressed even this seasoned food critic.

I had to order the “signature” pizza. You can certainly taste why it’s called that! The perfect ratio of cheese and sauce and a unique combination of toppings give this pie a flavor you won’t find anywhere else. It wasn’t too heavy or greasy – just the way I like it.

The pasta dishes were also quite delicious! We ordered their famous garlic Alfredo and it lived up to its reputation for sure. The flavors blended together nicely making for an enjoyable dining experience overall.

However, what really stands out at Sonny’s is the atmosphere. It feels like being in an Italian family kitchen with bright red-and-white checkered table cloths, friendly staff, and just enough buzzing conversation to remind you that you’re visiting a real Italian joint.

Overall, Sonny’s Pizza & Pasta is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for the best pizza in San Clemente! Whether you come here for a slice or a meal, you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Surfside Pizza – San Clemente, California

I had the pleasure of trying a slice of their famous pepperoni pizza and it was out of this world. The crust was perfectly crisp and slightly charred, with the right amount of chewiness at its base. The sauce was flavorful and not too spicy, providing the perfect balance between sweet and savory. And good lord, that cheese! It was stringy as hell, just like I like it.

But what really sets Surfside apart from other pizza joints is their commitment to freshness and quality. They only use the finest ingredients—from locally sourced meats and cheeses to vine-ripened tomatoes for their sauce. Plus, everything is made to order with no shortcuts in sight – you can definitely taste the difference!

All in all, Surfside Pizza offers an amazing dining experience. The atmosphere is lively yet relaxed (watch out for some wild karaoke nights!) and the staff are incredibly friendly. If you’re looking for the best pizza in San Clemente—look no further than Surfside Pizza!

#5 TJ’s Woodfire Pizza

My recent visit there was the best pizza experience I’ve ever had. The atmosphere of the place was quaint and inviting, and their staff were always kind and friendly.

The pizzas at TJ’s are cooked in a woodfire oven, giving them that perfect, smoky flavor. My favorite was the deluxe which comes with pepperoni, ham, extra cheese, mushrooms, and olives. The ingredients were so fresh that each bite felt like I was biting into a little slice of heaven! Every time I’d take a bite, I couldn’t help but think “this is the best pizza in San Clemente!”

Finally, you can’t beat the prices at TJ’s Woodfire Pizza. They offer large pizza pies for only $10! It’s hard to find such an amazing deal anywhere else.

To sum it up, if you’re ever in San Clemente looking for great pizza – look no further than TJ’s Woodfire Pizza! You won’t regret it.

#6 Brick Restaurant

I’ve had the pleasure of trying their signature Margherita Pizza and let me tell you, it’s sheer perfection. The crust is nicely cooked with a slight char around the edges – giving it a nice crunch in every bite. The mozzarella is as flavorful as ever and the tomatoes are fresh, juicy and full of flavor.

But what really sets this pizza apart is the delicious pesto sauce. It really adds an extra layer of flavor that truly elevates the dish. I’m not exaggerating when I say this is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

The atmosphere at Brick Restaurant is great too. It’s casual enough to hang out with friends for dinner, but also upscale enough for a romantic dinner for two. Plus, they have some great wines to pair with your pizza if you want to take it up a notch!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in San Clemente, look no further than Brick Restaurant! Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Laguna Niguel!

#7 Pronto Italian Deli

As soon as I walked in the door, I was struck by the inviting and delicious aroma of perfectly-cooked pizza. My senses were on full alert, and I knew I was in for a treat.

The staff were friendly and helpful, guiding me to the best options on their menu. After much deliberation, I decided to try the Pronto Deluxe Pizza. It came out piping hot and smothered in fresh toppings like tomatoes, mushrooms, onion and peppers. The crust was soft yet crunchy and cooked to perfection. Needless to say, it was an unforgettable experience!

I’m so glad that I discovered Pronto Italian Deli on my culinary journey – it’s definitely the best place to get pizza in San Clemente!

#8 Romanos Pasta & Pizzeria

Let’s start with the sauce. It’s made from a combination of fresh herbs and spices – it’s flavorful and robust, yet creamy and smooth at the same time. I could taste the tomatoes and garlic in every bite!

The pizza dough is also top-notch. The crust was perfectly cooked to just the right golden brown color and had the perfect amount of crispiness. Not too chewy, not too crunchy.

The toppings are out of this world! Each pie I tried was packed with fresh ingredients like roasted bell peppers, zucchini, onions, mushrooms, olives and more. They used quality meats like salami, pepperoni and sausage that really rounded out the flavor profile.

Overall, Romanos Pasta & Pizzeria is an excellent place for pizza lovers in San Clemente! They have something for everyone – great vegan options as well as hearty meat pies that will please any carnivore. Not to mention their reasonable prices and prompt delivery service make them a standout in the area! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in San Clemente – look no further than Romanos Pasta & Pizzeria – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Cassano’s

The first thing that struck me about Cassano’s was the atmosphere. It was lively, inviting, and filled with laughter – it almost felt like I had stepped into an Italian family gathering!

But, of course, it’s all about the pizza. And Cassano’s did not disappoint. The freshly made dough was perfectly thin and crispy on the edges, while still having a soft center. Toppings were generous, fresh, and flavorful – they really know their way around the kitchen! Every bite made me feel like I’m back in Italy indulging in one of my favorite dishes.

In conclusion, I’d have to say that Cassano’s has definitely earned its title as having some of the best pizza in San Clemente – it certainly did for me!

#10 Cosentino’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped through their doors, it was clear that Cosentino’s takes pizza seriously. Their ovens were blazing hot and the cooks were artfully arranging fresh ingredients on the pizzas. The smell of fresh cheese and savory sauce made my mouth water.

When my pizza arrived, I was immediately taken aback by its sheer deliciousness. The crust was light and crisp, loaded with just the perfect amount of gooey cheese and flavorful sauce. All of their specialty toppings offered an abundance of flavor combinations for me to try. Every bite was even better than the last!

The staff at Cosentino’s were incredibly friendly and accommodating as well. They had some great recommendations that made my meal even more enjoyable—I definitely suggest trying their signature dipping sauces!

Cosentino’s Pizza truly is one of the best in San Clemente, if not all of California! Have no doubt, if you’re looking for a quality pizza experience, this is where you should be headed!

#11 Blaze Pizza

Upon entering the restaurant, the first thing I noticed was the modern, urban vibe and lively atmosphere – I’ve been to pizza restaurants all over the world but this one seemed special.

The staff were very friendly and knowledgeable about their products, guiding me through the custom-made pizzas they had available. With such a diverse selection of ingredients, it was hard to choose just one! In the end, I settled on an oven-roasted vegetable pizza with some freshly made dough from their kitchen.

To say that it was delicious would be an understatement – the flavors were out of this world! The crust had just enough crunch, while the vegetables were cooked perfectly and gave the pizza a great texture. All in all, Blaze Pizza really delivered on its promise of providing exceptional quality food!

I know I can speak on behalf of any pizza lover when I say that Blaze Pizza is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in San Clemente – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Mission Viejo!

#12 Italian Cravings

I expected high-quality ingredients, and that’s exactly what I got. The pizza crust was thin and crispy on the outside, but still had a nice chew on the inside. The sauce was perfectly seasoned with herbs and spices, while the toppings were generous yet still balanced.

The best part of Italian Cravings, however, is the atmosphere. Upon entering you’re hit with an intoxicating aroma of baking pizzas and melted cheese that will make your mouth water. Add to that the shiny red checkered tablecloths and you feel like you’ve been transported back in time to an old-timey Italian restaurant.

I’m usually pretty critical about pizza places, but I have to admit – Italian Cravings exceeded my expectations! It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in San Clemente.