I’ve traveled near and far, tasted pizza around the world, and I’m happy to report that the San Gabriel Valley has several highly rated pizzerias. From classic Italian-style pies to creative new takes on old favorites, this valley is overflowing with delicious options.
In this article, I’ll review 12 of the very best pizza places in San Gabriel Valley in a lighthearted and humorous way. So grab a slice (or two!), sit back, and enjoy!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California
#1 The Original Pizza Presto
- Has some vegetarian options
From the moment I walked into the restaurant, the warm and friendly atmosphere made me feel right at home. The smell of freshly baked pizza in the air was a magical experience.
The pizza was unlike anything I’ve ever tasted before! The crust had a perfect crunchy texture, while still having a nice chewiness inside. The cheese was so creamy and flavorful and the sauce really brought out all of the flavors in each bite.
The toppings were top notch as well – fresh and flavorful with just enough seasoning to make them stand out. All this combined together created an incredible pizza experience that I won’t soon forget.
Overall, The Original Pizza Presto is hands down the best pizza in San Gabriel Valley bar none. If you’re ever in town, be sure to stop by for an amazing experience that you won’t forget!
If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Whittier!
#2 Pizza Cart
Let me start by saying the pizzas here are fantastic. The dough is perfect – light and crunchy, not too thick or thin. The toppings are fresh and flavorful and their tomatoes are some of the juiciest I’ve ever had. Plus, they have a great selection of gourmet toppings that you won’t find anywhere else.
The atmosphere is also great. It’s a small family-run establishment with lots of character. The staff is friendly and always ready to help you choose the perfect pizza. They even let me sample some toppings so I’d be sure which ones I liked before ordering!
But what really made me keep coming back was the price – Pizza Cart offers some of the best value for money around! Their huge pizzas are very reasonably priced, but they also offer smaller personalized versions at a fraction of the price. So whether you’re looking for a quick snack or an elaborate meal, there’s something for everyone!
Overall, Pizza Cart deserves my highest recommendation for best pizza in San Gabriel Valley – it’s simply delicious!
#3 Two Sal’s Pizza
I visited this restaurant with high expectations, as I had heard so many good things about it. When I arrived, the warm and inviting atmosphere of Two Sal’s Pizza immediately put me in a great mood. From the friendly staff to the relaxed seating area, it was clear that this was an excellent spot for pizza-lovers!
The moment I had my first bite of a slice from Two Sal’s Pizza, I knew why everyone raves about it. The crispy yet chewy crust combined with the perfectly spicy tomato sauce and choice ingredients gave me a taste sensation like no other. All of their pizzas are made with only fresh, quality toppings and you can really taste the difference!
I also noticed that Two Sal’s Pizza has several vegan options for those looking for something different. Even though my stomach couldn’t handle all of their delicious creations in one sitting, the vegan pizzas were just as tasty as the classic ones.
When it comes to pizza places in San Gabriel Valley, Two Sal’s Pizza is definitely top notch! With its delicious food and cozy atmosphere, there’s nothing like it. If you’re ever in town, be sure to pay them a visit – you won’t be disappointed!
#4 Zelo
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
I’m sure you’re asking yourself – how can a mere pizzeria stand up to the standards of an international pizza critic? Well, let me tell you! The pies at Zelo are thin-crust masterpieces. The crust is made from scratch with the perfect combination of flavours and textures. Every bite is heavenly and bursting with flavour.
The toppings are where Zelo really shines. They use only the freshest ingredients and make all their sauces in-house. From classic pepperoni to unique creations like chicken alfredo or bacon cheeseburger, there’s something for everyone here. The cheese is always melted perfectly and the portion sizes are generous enough that two people can share one slice easily.
I could go on and on about how great the pizza here is, but why not just try it for yourself? I guarantee that your taste buds will thank me later! If you’re looking for a truly unforgettable pizza experience, then head on over to Zelo – they have some of the best pizza in San Gabriel Valley!
#5 Di Pilla’s Italian Restaurant
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
I was delighted by the array of delicious pizzas offered on the menu. From their classic margherita to their unique Mediterranean-style pies made with olives, feta, and tomato sauce, there truly is something for everyone. The flavors were bold and intense and every bite was an absolute delight!
The staff at Di Pilla’s were also incredibly friendly and helpful. They went out of their way to make sure I had a great experience – from recommending the perfect pizza for me to refilling my drinks whenever they could. It was simply amazing!
The atmosphere is also fantastic – it’s quaint, cozy, and has lots of vintage charm that makes it a great spot for family gatherings or date nights.
Overall, I highly recommend Di Pilla’s Italian Restaurant if you’re in the San Gabriel Valley looking for the best pizza around. You won’t be disappointed!
#6 El Monte Pizza Co
Everything about this place screams “pizza paradise” – from the delightful smell of freshly baked crust to the bright, family-friendly atmosphere.
I started my meal with a classic slice of pepperoni pizza. The flavor was deep and complex, with just the right amount of spice. The topping to cheese ratio was spot on, giving me an enjoyable mix of flavors in every bite. I’m not one to typically eat the crust, but their crust was so good that I couldn’t help myself.
Next up was a Mushroom Margherita Pie. This pie was loaded with rich, earthy flavors that made it hard to stop eating. The mushrooms were cooked perfectly and complemented the creamy mozzarella cheese wonderfully!
To finish off my meal, I had a Spinach & Artichoke Calzone. The filling inside was just delicious: plenty of spinach and artichokes layered with gooey mozzarella cheese and tangy red sauce. The dough was cooked perfectly golden brown and had a nice crunch when bitten into.
Overall, El Monte Pizza Co offers some of the best pizza in San Gabriel Valley! If you’re ever in the area be sure to give them a try! You won’t regret it!
#7 Tony’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The ambiance at Tony’s Pizza is always a delight – the waitstaff are friendly and welcoming, and the pizza ovens give a warm, inviting glow to the room. But it’s the pizza that really stands out. Every time I come here, the crust is perfectly crunchy and the flavors are spot on. Whether I’m getting a classic Margherita or something a bit more adventurous, I know that Tony’s Pizza will deliver a delicious pie every single time.
And let’ not forget about their signature dish – the Tony Pie. It has everything you could want from a pizza – fresh tomatoes, savory Italian sausage, tasty mushrooms, some extra-special cheese blend, and then they top it off with pepperoni! Talk about flavor overload!
You can tell that Tony’s Pizza takes great pride in making their pizzas, which is why I always make sure to come back whenever I’m in town. The best pizza in San Gabriel Valley? Without any doubt – Tony’s Pizza!
#8 Super Pizza Veloz
The atmosphere is inviting and relaxed, and the service from the staff is top-notch. You can tell they have a passion for pizza that matches mine.
In terms of the food itself, Super Pizza Veloz does not disappoint. The pizzas are freshly made with quality ingredients, giving them a delicious crunch and a memorable flavor. Even better, they offer a wide selection of options so everyone in your party can find something they like.
I’d recommend trying their signature pies – the ‘Super Veloz’ and ‘Firebird’. Both were absolutely outstanding! The crusts were slightly crispy with small amounts of charring, but still light enough to make it easy to finish off a slice without feeling weighed down. The toppings were fresh and tasty too – they really enhanced all the other flavors in the pizza.
Overall, my experience at Super Pizza Veloz left me wanting more! It’s definitely one of the best pizza restaurants I’ve been to in San Gabriel Valley – and if you’re ever looking for a great pizza, this is definitely your spot!
If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Baldwin Park!
#9 Pie Life Pizza
My visit began with a warm welcome – the chef even came out of the kitchen to greet me personally. To say I was impressed is an understatement.
We kicked off my meal with their signature garlic knots, which were hands-down the best I have ever tasted. The dough was perfectly cooked, and the flavor was just right – not too much garlic, but enough to make it a yummy treat.
After we ordered our pies, I couldn’t stop myself from checking out all the delicious topping choices at the counter. The toppings selection was simply amazing! You could tell that these folks took pride in their ingredients – from fresh vegetables to quality meats, there was something for everyone.
The pizza itself lived up to its hype – it had the perfect amount of crispy crust and gooey cheese. Plus, you can really taste the difference in quality when you bite into one of these pies.
Overall, Pie Life Pizza gets five stars from me for their outstanding hospitality and delicious food. If you’re looking for some of San Gabriel’s best pizza, this is definitely your spot!
#10 Jay’s Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
From the minute I walked in, I was in foodie heaven. The restaurant had a cozy and inviting atmosphere, and the aroma of freshly baked pies filled the air.
The pies here are made with only the freshest ingredients, baked to perfection in a wood-fired brick oven. Every bite was packed with flavor. The crust was crispy on the outside and perfectly chewy inside, while the toppings were generous and delicious. Jay’s Pizza is truly a pizza lover’s paradise!
I also tried one of their specialty pizzas, loaded with all kinds of meats and vegetables smothered in cheese – it was mouthwatering! Even their dessert pizzas were tasty – from classic choices like Nutella to unique combinations that surprised my palette in all the right ways.
All in all, Jay’s Pizza is worth every penny you’ll spend for these masterpieces, and hands down it has some of the best pizza you’ll find anywhere in San Gabriel Valley!
#11 Ravello Osteria
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
The dough was perfectly cooked, not too thin and not too thick, with the perfect amount of charring and a beautiful crunch on the outside. The sauce had a delightful sweetness and the right amount of tang that made each bite as delicious as the last. And as for their topping selection – let’s just say I was in heaven! From Italian sausage to gorgonzola cheese to caramelized onions, they really know how to take their pizza-making seriously.
But that’s not even the best part! I found myself repeatedly unable to resist going back for just one more slice because simply put, their pizza is just that good. The atmosphere is also top-notch; it’s cozy yet modern and always has a lively buzz. Plus, the staff are incredibly friendly – they’ll make sure you have everything you need for an enjoyable night out eating some of the best pizza in San Gabriel Valley.
I can honestly say that Ravello Osteria is one pizza restaurant you definitely don’t want to miss – trust me, it’ll be worth every bite!
#12 Tomato Pie Pizza Joint
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
I had the pleasure of trying several of their freshly made pizzas and they were all hands down delicious. One of my favorites was their classic Margherita pizza with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil – it was to die for!
The restaurant itself is really fun and cozy. It has a very homey feel which makes you want to come back again and again. The staff are super friendly and welcoming. They even let me sample some of their other pies before I ordered!
The atmosphere feels like your own backyard pizza party — great music, great people, and an amazing pizza selection that’s sure to please everyone in your group. I must say that Tomato Pie Pizza Joint is definitely worth the trip out to San Gabriel Valley for a taste of the best pizza around!
