Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in San Mateo (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in San Mateo (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

114 Views

Having tasted pizzas from all over the world, I thought it was high time to bring my expertise to San Mateo. After all, there’s a lot of delicious pizza out there and I wanted to see which places provided the best slices for my taste buds.

So I’ve sampled pies at a dozen different spots in this city to put together a list of the BEST PIZZA IN SAN MATEO! My humorous and lighthearted reviews will let you know exactly which places are worth your time (and your money).

Read on to find out who makes some of the best pies in town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Mountain Mike’s Pizza

When I first stepped into Mountain Mike’s, I was overwhelmed with the delicious smell of freshly cooked pizza. After a few moments of looking around, I realized that they were making their pizza right there in the restaurant in traditional Italian fashion!

My first bite was heavenly – it had a perfect balance of crust and sauce, and the cheese melted just right. The toppings were plentiful but not overwhelming – just how I like it! The staff was friendly and accommodating; they even let me sample a few different pizzas before deciding on my favorite.

I’m happy to say that after trying all sorts of amazing pizza from different restaurants across the world, Mountain Mike’s Pizza is hands-down the best pizza in San Mateo. If you’re ever nearby and have a hankering for some truly delicious pizza, I highly recommend you give them a try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Palo Alto!

#2 Golden Boy Pizza

The atmosphere was exactly what I was expecting: casual, inviting and filled with a variety of people. The staff were friendly and attentive, quickly taking orders and ensuring that everyone had all they needed.

Now, on to the pizza. It’s incredible! The crust was light and fluffy, perhaps the most delicious dough I’ve ever tasted while on my travels – no small feat! The toppings were generous and the flavors blended together perfectly.

I would highly recommend Golden Boy Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in San Mateo – or anywhere else for that matter! No matter who you are or where you come from, this is a must-try spot for any pizza lover. Thanks for a great experience Golden Boy Pizza!

#3 Rainbow Pizza

Upon entering the restaurant, I was overwhelmed by the inviting atmosphere and pleasant staff. The décor is bright and cheerful with a great selection of music playing in the background.

The pizza itself was phenomenal! The freshly baked dough was perfectly crispy and light. The cheese melted perfectly, creating a delicious blend of flavors that complemented every bite. The sauce had a slight sweetness with a hint of spice, making it an ideal balance to the savory toppings. My favorite topping was the combination of mushrooms, peppers, onions and olives. It was like a symphony of flavor that sang in my mouth.

The service at Rainbow Pizza is also top-notch. Our waiter answered all our questions in detail and always had a smile on his face while checking up on us throughout our meal. Plus, they offer many great specials that are worth exploring!

So overall, Rainbow Pizza has truly earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in San Mateo! I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for an enjoyable night out or just a delicious slice of pizza to enjoy at home.

#4 Velo City Pizza

Having sampled pizzas from every corner of the planet, I can confidently say that Velo City Pizza stands out among the rest. The crust was perfectly crunchy and chewy, topped with a generous amount of cheese and flavorful sauce. Their selection of toppings is also spot on – everything from pepperoni to pineapple tasted fresh and delicious!

I especially appreciate their attention to detail when it comes to presentation. Every slice was neatly arranged on the plate, and they made sure to season the crust with oregano for an extra kick in flavor.

Finally, the staff at Velo City Pizza were exceptionally friendly and accommodating. From the moment I walked through the door, I felt welcome and taken care of. They even gave me a few pieces of garlic bread as a parting gift before I left!

All in all, I would highly recommend Velo City Pizza if you’re looking for top-notch pizza in San Mateo. They serve up delicious food with excellent service that can’t be beat!

#5 Curry & Kabab

The atmosphere is great – the staff always has a smile on their face and they make you feel welcomed. The ingredients are top-notch, with freshly made dough, homemade sauces and plenty of delicious toppings. And the prices are unbelievably affordable.

But what really makes Curry & Kabab stand out as one of the best pizza places in San Mateo is their unique flavor combinations. From their classic margherita to their fusion pies like the Hawaiian Curry, you can be sure that you’ll try something new every time.

The pizza is cooked to perfection – crispy edges, soft crumb and just enough char! It’s truly a treat to savor after a long day of sightseeing or work.

If you’re ever in San Mateo and looking for some great pizza, give Curry & Kabab a shot – it might just be the best pizza you’ve ever had!

#6 New York Pizza

I started out with their famous “Pizza of the Day”, a delicious blend of fresh ingredients on a delectable crust. What surprised me was that each slice was as good as the last! I continued to indulge myself with the menu’s offerings, including classic New York style pepperoni pizza, white pizza with chicken and garlic, and the Hawaiian specialty. Every single one was cooked to perfection – not too crispy, not too soggy – making it impossible to pick a favorite.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting; it has an old-school New York feel that really made me feel at home. The waitstaff were also friendly and attentive, quickly refilling my drinks and offering recommendations on pizzas I might like.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in San Mateo – or anywhere else for that matter – look no further than New York Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!

#7 Rise Woodfire San Mateo

I arrived at the pizzeria with high expectations and I wasn’t disappointed. Their wood-fired oven creates a perfectly crisp, yet soft crust and the fresh ingredients melt in your mouth. The sauce is perfectly seasoned with herbs and spices that give it a unique flavor that lingers on your palate.

Their service is top notch as well. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable and willing to share their pizza making secrets with customers if you ask – which I did! They also allow customers to create their own custom pies from a variety of toppings, so there’s something for everyone.

The atmosphere is lively and fun with outdoor seating, live music on the weekends and an array of local craft beers on tap. I had great conversations with other diners as we all enjoyed our meals together.

Overall, Rise Woodfire San Mateo is by far one of the best pizza joints in San Mateo – not just because of their amazing food, but also because of their exceptional hospitality. Highly recommended!

#8 Aldo’s Pizza

The first thing that struck me when I went to Aldo’s was the sheer variety of pizzas on the menu – from traditional Margherita and Pepperoni to unique combinations like Chorizo and Manchego, there was something for everyone! The dough is fresh, the ingredients are top-notch, and the atmosphere of the restaurant is welcoming and inviting.

The pizza itself is cooked to perfection. The crust is nice and crispy with just enough char, while still being chewy and flavorful. The sauce is perfectly balanced between sweet and tangy, providing an occasional burst of flavor in every bite. Toppings range from classic pepperoni to creative mixtures like mushroom, garlic, and pesto – all cooked perfectly with each topping playing its own role in creating an amazing flavor profile.

But what really makes Aldo’s stand out from other pizza places in San Mateo is their commitment to quality: They only use the freshest ingredients sourced from local purveyors around the area and make sure that everything on the menu meets their high standards for excellence.

In short: If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in San Mateo, then Aldo’s Pizza should be at the top of your list!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Daly City!

#9 North Beach Pizza – Online Order Best Pizza Near San Mateo – Top Delivery

I’m a pizza connoisseur, so I know a great slice when I see one. North Beach Pizza definitely delivers. From the first bite, I could tell that this was some serious pizzeria worthy pizza. The crust had a perfect texture – crispy on the outside but still chewy on the inside – and it was loaded with flavor. The toppings were freshly-prepared with an array of flavors and textures that tantalized my tastebuds.

Not only does North Beach Pizza make excellent pizza, their delivery is spot-on too! The order always arrives hot, fresh, and quickly – which is a huge plus in my book. Plus, their prices are incredibly reasonable for such high-quality cuisine.

In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in San Mateo then your search should end at North Beach Pizza – Online Order Best Pizza Near San Mateo – Top Delivery!

#10 Seniore’s Pizza

I remember walking into the place and feeling a sense of nostalgia. It was the same pizza I remembered eating back when I was a kid. As soon as my eyes met the menu, I knew that it was going to be a great experience.

The crust of the pizza is definitely worth mentioning too! It’s crunchy yet chewy, and has just the right amount of seasoning. And what can i say about their toppings? Delicious! Whether you’re looking for a traditional pepperoni or something more creative like artichoke, they have whatever you need!

One of my favorite things about Seniore’s Pizza is their customer service. Everyone seemed to genuinely care whether or not I had an enjoyable experience.

So if you’re in San Mateo, be sure to stop by Seniore’s Pizza and get your fill of mouthwatering pizza! You won’t regret it!

#11 Round Table Pizza

When I first stepped into the restaurant, I was impressed by how spotless and inviting the place was. The staff was super friendly and knowledgeable, and they really made me feel welcome.

The pizza itself is out of this world, with a thin yet crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and generous topping selection. Their sauce has just the right amount of sweetness and tanginess, making it so addictive! My favorite is their pepperoni; it’s always cooked to perfection with a nice char that isn’t overly crisp!

What I appreciate most about Round Table Pizza is their attention to detail. Every time my order is ready, I can practically taste the love that goes into it. There’s nothing like biting into a hot piece of freshly made Round Table pizza for comfort and satisfaction!

Overall, I highly recommend Round Table Pizza for anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience in San Mateo. With fresh ingredients and impeccable service, you can be sure you’re getting the best pizza in town.

#12 Round Table Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I was overwhelmed with excitement. The smell of freshly baking pizzas filled the air and my mouth was watering in anticipation. The atmosphere was upbeat and friendly – definitely a welcoming environment.

The service here is quick and everyone is always so friendly which really added to the experience. As for the food, it’s absolutely delicious! Every bite is super flavorful and honestly better than any other pizza place I’ve been to around San Mateo. They have a wide selection of toppings, all of which are fresh, flavorful and just make every bite extra yummy.

I can confidently say that Round Table Pizza has some of the best pizza in San Mateo! Highly recommend stopping by whenever you’re craving a delicious slice of pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – New York Pizza

I stepped into the restaurant and was immediately greeted by the tantalizing aroma of cheese and garlic wafting through the air. My taste buds were dancing with anticipation as I glanced at the menu, which boasted a mouthwatering selection of pizzas.

I decided to go all in and order their famous deep dish pizza. Let me tell you, this pizza was as deep as the Grand Canyon! When the steaming hot pie arrived at my table, I couldn’t help but marvel at its cheesy perfection. The crust was thick and doughy, like a fluffy cloud of deliciousness. Each bite was a divine combination of gooey cheese, tangy tomato sauce, and a symphony of toppings.

But what truly set New York Pizza apart was their unique sense of humor. As I devoured my slices, I noticed the walls covered in hilarious pizza-related jokes. It was like I was on a stand-up comedy show, but with a pizza twist. Who knew cheesy one-liners could make a dining experience even more enjoyable?

The staff was incredibly friendly, treating me like a long-lost friend. Their laughs were contagious, making the atmosphere warm and inviting. It felt like a pizza party with a side of laughter.

So, if you’re in search of the best deep dish pizza in san mateo, look no further than New York Pizza. With their delectable pies and infectious humor, you’re sure to leave with a full belly and a smile on your face. Trust me, this place is a slice above the rest!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – California Pizza Kitchen at San Mateo

Picture this: you walk into the California Pizza Kitchen and you’re immediately hit with the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pizzas. The sight of those perfectly crispy thin crusts is enough to make any pizza lover weak at the knees. I know I was.

I decided to go with the classic Margherita pizza, because you can’t go wrong with a traditional favorite. And boy, let me tell you, it was a slice out of heaven! The crust was thin and crispy, just the way I like it. The tangy tomato sauce was perfectly balanced with the creamy mozzarella cheese. And those fresh basil leaves added a pop of color and flavor that took the whole experience to another level.

The best part? The size of the pizza! It was huge! The slices were as big as my face. As a food critic, I’ve seen my fair share of small, stingy portions, but this was definitely not the case here. I left with a full belly and still had leftovers for the next day. Who doesn’t love a good pizza coma?

Now, I know what you’re thinking. California Pizza Kitchen? Don’t they serve other stuff besides pizza? Yes, they do. But when they make thin crust pizza this good, why bother with anything else? Trust me, this place is a must-visit for all pizza enthusiasts. Plus, the friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it the perfect spot to sit back, relax, and indulge in some cheesy goodness.