Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Sandusky OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Sandusky OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

211 Views

Having sampled pizza from all corners of the globe, I know a thing or two about delicious pies. So, I decided to take a trip to Sandusky OH and try out the best pizzas it had to offer. After eating my way through 12 different establishments in the area, I declared a winner – but you’ll have to keep reading to find out which one!

I’ll guide you through the good, the bad, and the mediocre slices so you’ll have all the information you need to make your own decision when it comes time for pizza night. My review will be funny, lighthearted, and hopefully helpful if you’re ever looking for a good pie in Sandusky OH.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 Sandtown Munchies

Believe me, I know my pizza! After eating pizza in every major city on 3 continents, I’m sure that Sandtown Munchies has nailed the perfect pizza. The crust is light and fluffy, yet still manages to hold all of that delicious topping you can never seem to get enough of. The toppings are fresh and the flavor combination is just right.

The atmosphere at Sandtown Munchies definitely adds to the experience; it’s lively and inviting. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable about what they’re serving up, which really makes a huge difference.

Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or an evening out with friends, check out Sandtown Munchies for some of the best pizzain Sandusky!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Port Clinton!

#2 Brick Oven Bistro

Let’s start with the basics: The dough is spot-on! It’s just thick enough that you don’t feel like you’re eating a cracker but thin enough to be crispy and delicious. Then the sauce! Full of flavorful tomatoes, fresh herbs, and spices.

Next up are the toppings. They have an amazing selection, from classic pepperoni to unique mixtures like jalapeno and pineapple. Every topping is cooked to perfection and adds tons of flavor without overpowering the other ingredients. Plus, their cheese…oh my goodness! It’s shredded in-house using a blend of cheeses that really tie everything together in one satisfying bite.

Of course, no restaurant review would be complete without mentioning the atmosphere. Brick Oven Bistro has a charming outdoor patio where you can enjoy your meal while enjoying a pleasant evening breeze. Inside there’s cozy seating and brick walls adding to its homey feel, not to mention friendly staff who always make sure you’re taken care of.

And that’s why I can confidently say that Brick Oven Bistro has some of the best pizza in Sandusky—a claim I am willing to put my reputation on the line for!

#3 Cameo Pizza

On my most recent visit, I took a bite of the pepperoni pizza and I was virtually speechless. It had just the right amount of sauce and the cheese was perfectly melted. The crust was light and fluffy yet crispy with the perfect hint of seasoning.

I also had the chance to sample some of their specialty items, like their buffalo chicken pizza. The buffalo sauce had just the right kick that wasn’t overbearing and combined with their hand-tossed dough made it one of the best pizzas I’ve ever eaten.

The atmosphere at Cameo Pizza was inviting and comfortable, making it one of my favorite places to grab a slice in Sandusky. Their staff is friendly and welcoming, which really adds to your overall experience.

If you’re looking for delicious pizza in Sandusky, look no further than Cameo Pizza! You won’t be disappointed by their excellent flavors and quality ingredients!

#4 Chet & Matt’s Pizza

The atmosphere here is so inviting. I was immediately transported back to the pizzerias of my youth – complete with red and white checkered tablecloths and bright, cheerful colors. The decor has just the right touch of nostalgia, but with a modern twist.

When it came to the food, I was not disappointed in the least! The pizza here was truly delicious – a perfect balance of crust and toppings that melted in my mouth. I chose the margherita pizza for my meal and it was one of the best things I’ve ever tasted! Every bite was packed with flavor.

The service at Chet & Matt’s Pizza is top-notch as well; while they move quickly, they still take their time to get your order right. Whether you’re ordering take-out or enjoying a meal inside, you’ll be given prompt attention and friendly smiles.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Sandusky then look no further than Chet & Matt’s Pizza!

#5 Capizzi’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere is definitely top-notch with their classic red and white checkered table cloths and old school vibe. And when it comes to the pizza, it’s simply divine. Nothing compares to the perfectly cooked dough and delicious toppings, especially the pepperoni which is out of this world!

If you’re looking for something sweet, Capizzi’s has got you covered with a wide selection of desserts including tiramisu and gelato. Trust me, it’s worth the visit just for the dessert alone!

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery so if you live close by you’ll have to pick up your food to get your hands on this incredible pizza pie. But trust me-it’s worth every moment that goes into driving there! No matter what time of day it is or how far away you are-Capizzi’s Pizza will hit all the right spots every time.

#6 Danny Boys

I was really impressed with the topping choices. You could get standard favorites like pepperoni, sausage and green peppers, or mix things up with pineapple, ham, and even bacon! I went for a classic – pepperoni and mushrooms – and it was fantastic.

The crust was definitely my favorite part. It was light and fluffy, so it held up nicely to the toppings without being too greasy. Plus, they cook it to a perfect golden brown that added a ton of flavor.

Not only is their pizza good, but the prices can’t be beat either! With slices ranging from $1 to $2 apiece, you won’t break the bank eating here – even if you eat more than one piece! Even still, they manage to make money off of us pizza fanatics by selling specialty pizzas at higher prices.

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Sandusky, look no further than Danny Boys!

#7 Fazoli’s

I’m not sure what kind of magic they put in their dough but it’s simply divine. The crust is perfectly crisp, really holding up the heaps upon heaps of toppings that come with each pizza. It almost feels like an Italian grandmother is lovingly pouring her heart and soul into every slice—it’s that good!

The staff at Fazoli’s are also top-notch, always ready with a smile and more than happy to answer any questions I have about their ingredients or cooking methods. Plus, the prices are excellent which means you can stretch your budget further for a real Italian feast!

It would be remiss of me to not mention the sides either. The garlic bread sticks and marinara sauce alone make me want to go back again and again. Overall, Fazoli’s comes highly recommended from this worldwide pizza enthusiast!

If you’re willing to go an extra 27 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Lorain!

#8 Saucy Brew Works – Sandusky

As soon as I walked into the restaurant, I was greeted by a friendly staff and the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pizza. The atmosphere is lively and the vibe was great.

The menu offers a wide selection of pizzas which are made with fresh ingredients. They have some classic options like pepperoni, cheese and veggie pizza that are sure to please everyone, but they also have some unique creations such as their smoked gouda & poblano pizza that really stands out from other pizzas I’ve had before.

The pizza itself was cooked perfectly with just the right amount of char on the crust to give it great flavor. The toppings were flavorful and well balanced so you could taste each individual flavor without any one overpowering another. Even better, all their pizzas come in large sizes that are sure to satisfy even the hungriest group!

Overall, it’s safe to say that if you’re looking for delicious pizza in Sandusky OH, Saucy Brew Works – Sandusky is definitely your best option!

#9 Pizza House East

The first time I visited this pizzeria, I was blown away by the sheer variety of pizza options. Every possible topping combination you can think of? Check! Dozens of specialty pies to choose from? Check! Not to mention their amazing custom-made pizzas.

I even had the opportunity to watch their chefs in action as they carefully crafted each pizza with love and attention to detail. The crust is crispy and delicious, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. It’s no wonder that Pizza House East has become a local favorite!

The atmosphere at Pizza House East is inviting and cozy – it really felt like home away from home. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, always ready with a smile or a joke (especially when my order was taking too long).

Overall, I’m confident in saying that Pizza House East has some of the best pizza in Sandusky! If you’re ever looking for a great slice (or two), be sure to give them a try – you won’t regret it!

#10 Pizza House West

Their signature pies featuring the freshest ingredients tickled my taste buds and made me say a silent wow. The crust was crunchy on the outside but light and fresh on the inside, making it so enjoyable. From their deep dish to their thin crust, it’s no wonder why they are always busy – every slice is cooked to perfection.

The staff at Pizza House West were also friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, so it was easy for me to make an informed decision when choosing what I wanted to eat. And boy did I pick the right pies! Their classic pepperoni with extra cheese combo was delicious, while their veggie lovers’ pizza had burst of flavor in every bite!

I’d rate Pizza House West five stars out of five and recommend it to anyone looking for great pizza in Sandusky. It truly is one of the best pizzerias I’ve ever tried!

#11 Sortino’s Italian Kitchen

First off, they have something for everyone. From a kid’s menu to alcoholic drinks (including hard liquor!), there’s something here that most any pizza-lover would enjoy.

The pizza itself blew me away. It was fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The toppings are just right – not too much or too little – and the crust is delicious. I’m confident in declaring Sortino’s pizza to be one of the best I’ve had anywhere around the world!

And lastly, Sortino’s has an insanely good dessert selection. From homemade tiramisu to cannoli to gelato, my sweet tooth was totally satisfied after my meal.

The only downside is that Sortino’s doesn’t offer delivery service; you’ll have to dine in or take out if you want to get your hands on this amazing pizza! But fortunately, it is a nice tourist spot and close enough for anyone around town to try it out if they haven’t already done so! All in all, I declare Sortino’s Italian Kitchen the best pizza in Sandusky!

#12 Mama B’s Pizza

I had the opportunity to try several of their signature pizzas and I wasn’t disappointed. The crust was cooked perfectly with a slight crunch that left me wanting more. It was truly mouth-watering!

The toppings were also top notch. From succulent sausage to flavorful pepperoni, Mama B’s Pizza had it all! You can even customize your pizza from the huge selection of ingredients available.

The staff was friendly and accommodating too, which added to my overall experience. They made sure I had everything I needed and were full of cheerful advice about what pizzas to try next.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for great pizza in Sandusky – look no further than Mama B’s Pizza! It’s definitely the best around!