Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Sebring FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Sebring FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

130 Views

I’ve tasted slices from all over the world, but I’ll admit that I had my doubts about finding offerings to compete with the best of them in this small town. Still, I was determined to find out: What is the best pizza in Sebring FL?

So, for your benefit and mine, I decided it was time for a pizza crawl. Over the course of several days, I sampled slices from 10 different local spots and took notes on my findings.

Want to know who emerged victorious? Stay tuned!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Galati’s Family Restaurant

When I first set foot in Galati’s, I could tell they take pizza seriously. From the quality of ingredients to the cozy atmosphere, it was clear that this is a restaurant dedicated to great pizza.

There are so many benefits to eating at Galati’s! For starters, they serve alcohol, making it the perfect spot for date night or a fun get-together with friends. They even have a kid’s menu, so you can bring the whole family and everyone will be happy. To top it all off, they offer delicious desserts (and who can resist dessert when you’re already eating pizza?).

Honestly, the only downside is that there’s no delivery option – but given all of their other features and benefits, it definitely doesn’t detract from my overall experience. Plus, the restaurant itself is quite nice and makes for a great tourist spot if you’re visiting Sebring FL.

In short: Galati’s Family Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Sebring FL – don’t miss out on trying it during your next visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 45 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Davenport!

#2 Tony’s II Pizzeria

Located in the heart of Sebring, Tony’s II Pizzeria offers up a wide variety of pizzas that range from traditional Italian pies to creative specialty creations. The restaurant has a casual atmosphere with very friendly staff and is my go-to spot for a bite when I’m in town.

I decided to try their signature White Pizza and was not disappointed! The crust had just the perfect crunch without being too soggy or burnt, the sauce was flavorful and had just the right amount of zing, and the cheese was fresh and delicious. Every bite melted away in my mouth, leaving me wanting more!

The prices are also reasonable – you can get an entire pizza pie for only $10. For those watching their pocketbooks, they even offer half-sized pies as well.

Ultimately, I give Tony’s II Pizzeria two thumbs up – it’s definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Sebring FL!

#3 Domino’s Pizza

I’ve been lucky enough to sample some truly exquisite pizzas in the most far-flung parts of the world, and I can confidently say that Domino’s Pizza stands out among them all. Every bite was a flavor explosion!

I started off with the classic cheese pizza and it was divine – the perfect combination of creamy mozzarella and a perfectly proportioned crust. It was so delicious that I ended up eating two whole slices before I even moved onto trying anything else.

The other pizzas I tried didn’t disappoint either – from meat-lovers to vegetarian options, Domino’s Pizza had something for everyone. The veggie pizza was particularly great – the toppings were flavorful without being overpowering, and the crust remained crisp throughout. The sausage pizza also had fantastic texture, with juicy strips of sausage spread throughout the sauce.

Overall, now that I’ve sampled some of the best pizza in Sebring FL at Domino’s Pizza, my travels have been more than worth it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 47 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Lakeland!

#4 Deep South Bar & Grill LLC

I’ve always been a fan of the classic combo of pizza and beer, and Deep South Bar & Grill LLC offers both. They also have a great selection of hard liquor for those looking to switch it up. But that’s not all – they also have some great vegetarian options if you’re into that. Plus, if you’re bringing kids along, they even offer a kid’s menu – perfect for the whole family!

The atmosphere here is just fantastic. They make it the perfect destination spot in Sebring FL, with plenty of tourist attractions nearby. It’s also great place to watch sports with friends while enjoying some pizza and drinks.

My only gripe is that there’s no delivery option – but hey, you can’t have everything! All in all, I’d say that Deep South Bar & Grill LLC has managed to become one of the best pizza places in Sebring FL.

#5 Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a great spot for family and friends to gather. The staff always make you feel welcome, which I love.

Now on to the pizza: WOW! Their homemade pizzas packed with flavor really blew me away. The toppings are fresh and plentiful, and the crust and cheese are perfection.

The grinders are also delicious! They are made with freshly-made Italian sausage, fresh vegetables, melted cheese, and their special in-house marinara sauce. Delicious!

Overall Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz is a great place to go when you want some of the best pizza in Sebring FL. From the warm hospitality of the staff to the amazing flavors in their food, this place has become one of my favorite pizza places around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 53 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Port Charlotte!

#6 Hungry Howie’s Pizza and Subs

When I walked in the door, I was immediately impressed. The decor was inviting and the staff was so friendly. They knew why I had come, and happily solved my pizza cravings.

The menu offered everything I could want from a pizza joint. They had classic pies with all kinds of yummy toppings, specialty pizzas with interesting ingredients, and they even had some veggie options that looked delicious! After much deliberation (because it was a tough decision!), I settled on the onion bacon ranch pizza and I’m glad that I did because it proved to be an amazing choice.

The crust was perfectly crispy and buttery, yet still had a good chewy bite to it. The sauce was slightly sweet and spiced just right – not too spicy but still flavorful. And the combination of onions bacon and ranch? Now that’s what food dreams are made of! Every bite took me to happy pizza heaven!

After eating my fill of that delectable dish, I made sure to get a few garlic cheese breads for the road as well – which were also divine.

Honestly, Hungry Howie’s Pizza and Subs has earned its rightful spot as one of the best pizzerias in Sebring FL! If you haven’t tried it yet, you’re missing out!

#7 Pizza Hut

My first experience at Pizza Hut was nothing but exceptional. Not only did they offer a diverse selection of pizza toppings, but their freshly made dough was delicious. The Mediterranean-style crust had a slight crunch to it, which added the perfect texture to the pizza.

I then tried the classic pepperoni pizza, and it did not disappoint! The sauce was perfectly balanced with just enough flavor to make my taste buds tingle. The combination of pepperoni and cheese was cooked just right – crispy on the outside, yet soft and gooey on the inside.

The staff at Pizza Hut were friendly and helpful throughout my visit, making sure I had all that I needed for a memorable experience. They were also quick to provide refills on beverages whenever needed – something I highly appreciate after a long day touring Sebring’s attractions.

From ingredients to service, I give Pizza Hut two thumbs up for having some of the best pizza in Sebring FL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 54 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Punta Gorda!

#8 Papa Johns Pizza

My most recent visit to Papa Johns was everything I was expecting and more! The restaurant itself is not only inviting, but quite modern and chic. The staff were all friendly and knowledgeable, making my dining experience even better.

When it came to the pizza, wow! I must say that it exceeded expectations. The dough was perfectly cooked, light and fluffy with just the right amount of charring – truly the best crust I have ever had! The cheese was melted to perfection; the toppings fresh and flavorful. From classic pepperoni to veggie pies, their menu has something for everyone!

Overall, my recent visit to Papa Johns Pizza in Sebring FL has convinced me that they have some of the best pizza around. Whether you’re a fan of classic pies or looking for something a bit more daring, Papa Johns can deliver on every level.

#9 Little Caesars Pizza

The crust was crispy and had the perfect ratio of crunch to chew. The sauce wasn’t too sweet or too spicy, and the cheese was melted to perfection. I’m talking about a pizza that is so good, you don’t even need extra toppings.

But, if you’re looking for more than just cheese and sauce, Little Caesars Pizza has plenty of topping options – from mushrooms to pineapple. Basically, if it can go on a pizza, they have it!

I also liked the customer service at Little Caesars Pizza. Everyone is always friendly and knowledgeable about their products. Plus, they always make sure to follow food safety protocols, which is something I always appreciate when it comes to restaurants.

All in all, Little Caesars Pizza has some of the best pizza in all of Sebring FL. If you’re ever in town, I’d highly recommend checking them out!

#10 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

The pizza dough is light, crispy and golden brown on the outside. The toppings are plentiful and flavorful – you can get traditional Italian classics like pepperoni and sausage or something a little different, like spinach and artichoke.

What really sets Olive Garden apart from other pizza places is the atmosphere! Every time I visit, I’m surrounded by beautiful decor and rich tones of Italy. Plus, the staff are incredibly friendly and attentive, ensuring that I’m always taken care of whenever I come in.

Overall, even after visiting some of the best pizza restaurants around the world, Olive Garden gives me an unforgettable experience every time! It’s definitely my go-to spot for the best pizza in Sebring FL.