Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Sheboygan (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Wisconsin

Best Pizza in Sheboygan (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

206 Views

After touring the town, I’ve sampled the pies from 12 different pizzerias and ranked them based on their overall taste.

I must warn you – my palette is quite picky. So, no matter who you are, if you’re looking for a delicious slice in Sheboygan, make sure to check out these places. I can promise that my rankings will help you find the tastiest pizza in town.

Let’s get cheesy!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin

#1 Il Ritrovo

The food is insane and I’m particularly delighted by their hard liquor selection. No matter what kind of pizza you like, they’ve got something for everyone, even vegetarian options! Not to mention, they even have the most insanely good desserts.

The only downside I’ve experienced at Il Ritrovo is that there’s no delivery, but if you’re looking for a great pizza spot to take your friends or family, this place makes for a great tourist spot.

Trust me when I say that Il Ritrovo has the best pizza in Sheboygan – it’s definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 37 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Fond du Lac!

#2 Frank’s Place

It’s not your typical pizza joint – they serve alcohol, including hard liquor! So, if you’re looking for a place to watch the game and have a cold one while eating delicious pizza, Frank’s Place is definitely worth checking out.

The pizza itself is amazing – it’s incredibly flavorful and cooked to perfection. The sauce is just the right amount of savory and the toppings are always fresh and full of flavor. There’s something for everyone in their selection of creative topping combinations.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery. Considering how good the food is, though, it’s worth taking a short trip to Frank’s Place. All in all, I highly recommend this joint as one of Sheboygan’s best pizza spots!

#3 Faye’s Pizza

I walked into Faye’s and was immediately impressed by the amazing atmosphere. It was lively, modern and the staff were friendly. I then noticed they had a wide selection of pizzas on their menu that I just couldn’t resist!

I ordered one of the ‘signature’ pizzas and it certainly lived up to its name. The dough was perfectly cooked, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and most importantly: the cheese was ooey-gooey goodness you could only find at Faye’s Pizza.

I also tried one of their sides, which were delicious as well. They had calzones that can rival any Italian restaurant in Sheboygan!

Overall, I would highly recommend Faye’s Pizza for anyone looking for a great pizza experience in Sheboygan. The flavors are unique and delicious; you won’t regret giving it a try!

#4 Harry’s Prohibition Bistro

Tucked away in a corner of Sheboygan, this unassuming bistro serves up some of the tastiest pies I’ve ever eaten. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious slice.

The menu has something for everyone with a variety of classic pizzas as well as options with innovative toppings. It’s no wonder why people come from all over town to get their hands on one of these mouthwatering pies.

But what truly sets Harry’s Prohibition Bistro apart is their dedication to quality ingredients and preparations. Everything is made from scratch and you can taste the care that goes into each dish. The flavors are bold and distinct for every single topping, completely removing any risk of flavor fatigue like other restaurants might have.

If you haven’t experienced the glorious pizza from Harry’s Prohibition Bistro yet, go now! In my opinion it’s the best pizza in Sheboygan and I would be surprised if you don’t agree after trying it for yourself!

#5 Theo’s Pizza & Catering

I arrived at the restaurant with high expectations. After all, everybody in town was raving about it! I stepped through the doors and was welcomed by a friendly staff who were eager to show me the menu.

The pizzas at Theo’s are amazing. They come in all shapes, sizes and flavors – from classic margherita to creative seafood varieties. The crust is perfectly cooked, the sauce is flavorful, and the toppings are plentiful and fresh.

Their other food items like sandwiches, salads and sides also impressed me – especially their homemade desserts. They definitely have something for everyone!

But perhaps what makes Theo’s Pizza & Catering truly special is its atmosphere. It feels like a home away from home – warm and welcoming – where you can enjoy the best pizza in Sheboygan without ever having to leave your seat. The owners are always greeting customers with a friendly smile, so you know you’re in good hands here.

Overall, if you’re looking for delicious pizza in Sheboygan (or just really good food) then make sure to visit Theo’s Pizza & Catering as soon as possible!

#6 Luigi’s Italian Restaurant

From their hand-tossed crusts to their generous helpings of cheese and toppings, I was blown away by the quality. The margherita pizza in particular, with delicious basil and mozzarella, was a real showstopper. The flavors were truly amazing!

My absolute favorite part of Luigi’s Italian Restaurant has to be the atmosphere. It’s like being in an Italian village inside a cozy restaurant! All of the staff are friendly and welcoming and make you feel right at home.

I would highly recommend Luigi’s Italian Restaurant if you’re looking for the best pizza in Sheboygan. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 47 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Oshkosh!

#7 Falls Firehouse Pizza

The first bite of a slice from Falls Firehouse Pizza is one that transports you to an amazing place. The crust is perfectly baked with just the right amount of crunchiness and flavor. The cheese is melted to perfection, and the toppings have the freshest ingredients available.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting. People come in all walks of life, ranging from families, touristic groups and even locals. They all leave with one thing in common – they all had an enjoyable experience!

The staff at Falls Firehouse Pizza are friendly and always have a smile on their faces as they serve you up some delicious pizza. The service is always prompt and attentive without fail!

All things considered, when I’m looking for a great slice of pizza in Sheboygan, I don’t look any further than Falls Firehouse Pizza. Without a doubt, it’s some of the best pizza in town!

#8 Marco’s Pizza

I can’t emphasize enough how much I enjoyed the pizza here. The crust was perfectly balanced, with a delicious crunch to it and not too much flop. The sauce was nicely seasoned and flavorful, and the cheese was perfectly melted and just cheesy enough. As for the toppings—oh my! Fresh vegetables and meats with great flavor combinations that melded together in total harmony.

The atmosphere at Marco’s Pizza is definitely worth noting as well—cozy yet modern, with lots of natural light coming into the restaurant during dinner hours. Not to mention all of the friendly staff – they were always quick to get refills and make sure everyone had what they needed, even during their busiest hours!

In short, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Sheboygan, Marco’s Pizza is a must-visit. Highly recommended!

#9 Parker John’s BBQ & Pizza – Sheboygan

The crust on their pizzas is thin and crispy, just the way I like it. The barbecue sauce on their BBQ pies is sweet and savory, with a hint of smokiness that really brings out the flavor of the wood-fired pizza in the best way possible.

I’m especially impressed by their specialty pies. The cheesesteak pie has excellent portions of steak and sautéed onions topped with melted cheese that make for an amazing combination with the hand-tossed dough. The pepperoni ranch pie is also a treat, featuring classic pepperoni and zesty ranch dressing – it’s like two of my favorite things combined into one delicious pizza!

The staff at Parker John’s are friendly and knowledgeable about their pizza, so if you’re not sure what to order they can help you out with recommendations. They also have some great sides and deserts – try the garlic knots to kick off your meal or get a few different pieces of their signature Italian cream cake to finish off your dinner.

All in all, it’s easy to see why Parker John’s BBQ & Pizza is one of the best pizza places in Sheboygan. Their pizzas are perfection – no wonder they won “Best Pizza in Sheboygan” at this year’s food festival! You won’t be disappointed when you pay them a visit – trust me, it’ll be well worth it!

#10 Pop’s Burger & Pizza House

Now, I know what you’re thinking–Sheboygan? Is that really where I should be looking for the best pizza? Well, let me tell you–this place is legit.

The pizza was cooked to perfection with a thin and crispy crust. And the topping combinations were unlike anything I’ve ever tasted before! From the classic pepperoni, to their signature “Hail Caesar” (featuring Caesar salad toppings on the pie) there’s something for everyone!

Plus, their prices are very reasonable considering how delicious it is. Not only will you leave feeling full and satisfied, but your wallet won’t be empty either!

Overall, Pop’s Burger & Pizza House is an absolute must-try for anyone in Sheboygan or visiting who wants to have a truly unique pizza experience. As someone who has tasted millions of pizzas around the world, I can confirm that this place has earned its reputation as being one of the best in town.

#11 Peabody’s Pizza Company

The first thing I noticed when I walked in the door was the fantastic smell of freshly made pizza. The aroma was almost too strong to resist!

I ordered a classic pepperoni pie and I’m glad I did. It was cooked to perfection- it had just the right amount of crispiness to it, with a thin and chewy crust that wasn’t too thick. The sauce was flavourful yet not too heavy, and the toppings were fresh without being overwhelming.

The service was also top notch! The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, and they even suggested some interesting specialty pies that sounded delicious.

In short, Peabody’s Pizza Company is definitely worth a visit for anyone looking for an exceptional pizza experience in Sheboygan!

If you’re willing to go an extra 47 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Appleton!

#12 Domino’s Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I was transported to a pizza heaven. The smell of freshly baked dough and melted cheese filled my nostrils and made me instantly hungry. The staff were friendly and welcoming, which only added to the cozy atmosphere.

When it came time to order, I knew had to try one of their specialty pies. That’s when I saw ‘The Sheboygan Special’ – a mouthwatering combination of pepperoni, onions, sausage and green peppers topped with a generous helping of cheese. After taking just one bite, I knew that Domino’s Pizza had earned its reputation for serving some of the best pizza around Sheboygan.

The crust was light and crispy yet still fluffy on the inside and the perfect thickness for holding all the toppings without getting soggy. The rich sauce was perfectly seasoned and blended harmoniously with all the other flavors on the pizza. The different meats all tasted fresh and juicy while the veggies were crisp and vibrant in color – they must have been cooked up right before being placed atop my pie!

I’d highly recommend this place if you’re ever looking for great pizza in Sheboygan – it really is some of the best around!