Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Simpsonville SC (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in South Carolina

Best Pizza in Simpsonville SC (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

111 Views

I’ve sampled pizza all over the world, from Rome to Madrid, and now I’m here to give you my thoughts on the best pizza in Simpsonville SC. After reviewing 12 different pizza places in town, I’m sure you’ll be as surprised by my findings as I was!

With a lighthearted yet discerning eye, let’s get started on exploring the best of Simpsonville’s pizza scene.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of South Carolina

#1 Pizza Hut Express

When I walked into this quaint corner restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The interior was inviting and the staff was friendly and accommodating. I had decided to try the Pesto Supreme with extra bacon and their signature garlic cheesy bread – my goodness! Both were outstanding, the crust was cooked perfectly and all the toppings worked together in perfect harmony. Absolutely delicious!

The best part about Pizza Hut Express is that it’s a great place for families, friends or even just a solo night out. They have plenty of seating inside and even some outdoor seating as well. Plus, they have large TVs on the walls that feature all kinds of sports events – so if you’re looking for a spot to watch your favorite team play, look no further!

The only downside to Pizza Hut Express though is that they don’t offer delivery services – so you’ll need to come here if you want pizza from them. But believe me, it will be worth it.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza around Simpsonville SC then Pizza Hut Express should definitely be your go-to spot. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Greenville!

#2 Anthony’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Anthony’s is something special. From the warm and inviting dining area to the staff that always has a smile on their face, it’s no wonder why people come from near and far for this pizza experience.

I had the pleasure of trying a variety of pies from Anthony’s Pizzeria. The dough was perfect—light and fluffy with just enough crunch in all the right places. The variety of toppings was excellent—from the classic pepperoni to an array of locally sourced vegetables and cheeses, every bite of pizza I tried had something new and exciting.

Perhaps my favorite part about Anthony’s Pizzeria is that you can customize your pie however you’d like. Italia spices, gluten-free crusts, vegan cheese…the possibilities are endless!

But don’t take my word for it—try Anthony’s Pizzeria yourself and experience some of the best pizza in Simpsonville SC!

#3 Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant

The first thing that struck me was the atmosphere – so cozy and inviting. I almost felt like I was in Italy! Not only that, but they also serve alcohol which is always a nice bonus.

They have a kid’s menu too, and their desserts are insanely good! You might want to leave room for one of those before you devour your pizza. Plus, it’s a great spot for tourists to stop and grab a slice or two.

Unfortunately they don’t offer delivery, but being there in person is so much better anyway. The food just tastes better when you can take in the ambience of the place while you eat. There weren’t any downsides, unless you count having to carry my pizza back to my hotel as a downside…

All in all, Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant is hands-down the best pizza place I’ve ever been to in Simpsonville SC and I highly recommend it for anyone who wants to enjoy an amazing experience with some delicious food!

#4 Olympian Grill

I’m not exaggerating here — the pizza was truly divine. From their perfect crust to their amazing selection of cheeses and toppings, Olympian Grill is mastering the art of pizza making.

The highlight of my visit had to be the classic pepperoni pizza. The dough was a blend of flavorful and crunchy perfection, with just the right amount of sauce — not too much, not too little. As for the toppings, they were cooked to perfection and blended so well together that I was left wanting more.

Overall, Olympian Grill delivers a top-notch experience from start to finish! The staff were incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, and their prices were quite reasonable considering all that deliciousness you get for your money. So if you’re ever in Simpsonville SC, make sure you make a stop at Olympian Grill — it’s definitely some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted!

#5 The Slice

On my visit, I was immediately struck by how lively and inviting the atmosphere was. The staff was friendly, accommodating, and eager to satisfy my pizza cravings.

The food was truly amazing! The thin crust pizza had the perfect amount of chewiness with a hint of crunch – it definitely lived up to its reputation as some of the best pizza in town. As I took my first bite, I could tell that no expense was spared when it came to the quality of ingredients – they were all so fresh and flavorful.

I also sampled some of their salads and sandwiches which were delicious as well! Their Italian Sub was especially noteworthy; the combination of meats and vegetables created an unforgettable taste sensation that left me wanting more.

Overall, I would highly recommend The Slice for anyone looking for some really great pizza in Simpsonville SC. Even after having traveled around the world sampling pizza from different restaurants, I’m still convinced that The Slice serves up some of the best pies around!

#6 Napoli Pizzeria

First, the atmosphere is great. It’s cozy and inviting, and I even saw a few families with children — which was great because they had a kids’ menu!

The service was excellent. Everyone from the hostess to the server was friendly and helpful, ensuring that I would have a wonderful experience. The drink menu also had a wide selection of beer, wine, and cocktails.

Then came the food! Their pizza — wow! Every bite is perfection. They offer both classic pies as well as creative spins on traditional pies like barbecue chicken or Greek pizza. They also have some vegetarian options which were surprisingly delicious.

And if you manage to save room for dessert, their insanely good cakes are reason enough to visit Napoli Pizzeria.

The only thing lacking here is delivery service; however, if you’re willing to make the drive and pick up your order in-person it’s definitely worth it. All-in-all I’d give them five stars out of five for their amazing pizzas!

#7 Frankie’s NY Pizza Five Forks

I’m not sure how they do it, but the crust is to die for. It’s crispy around the edges yet soft and chewy in the middle – a perfect balance! The tomato sauce has just the right amount of sweetness and zing, without being overbearing. Plus, their toppings are always fresh, delicious and generous.

I could go on about all their great flavors, but what really makes Frankie’s stand out is their staff. From the second I walk in, I’m greeted with a warm smile from the friendly crew behind the counter. They always know what pizza I want before I even tell them!

Their service is top-notch and they have a great selection of beers to pair with your pizza. Frankies NY Pizza Five Forks definitely lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizzerias in Simpsonville SC – if you haven’t been there already, get yourself there soon!

If you’re willing to go an extra 22 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Spartanburg!

#8 Hot Pie (Frank’s Pizza)

I mean, this place is amazing! They make their own dough from scratch and you can really taste the difference in every slice. Plus, the toppings are incredibly fresh – I had pepperoni, mushrooms and olives that still had that lovely crunch.

The atmosphere in Hot Pie (Frank’s Pizza) is also a real treat. It has a cozy yet fun vibe – perfect for those Saturday night pizza dates with family or friends. And if you’re looking for something unique, they even serve pies topped with macaroni and cheese!

All in all, it’s pretty clear that Hot Pie (Frank’s Pizza) knows what they’re doing when it comes to pizza. So if you’re ever in Simpsonville SC, don’t miss out on the chance to grab a slice of the best pizza around!

#9 Frank’s House Of Pizza

When I first arrived, I was excited to see the quaint building, with its classic brick exterior and a checkered tablecloth sign outside. The atmosphere inside was warm and inviting, perfect for a cozy dinner. The staff were friendly and attentive, offering me lots of helpful advice on which pizzas to try and how best to order.

The pizzas were truly amazing! The crust had just the right amount of crunch, with a light and delicious flavor that melted in my mouth. The sauce was flavorful and robust without being overly sweet or salty — it was the perfect complement for the toppings I chose.

I ordered several types of pizza to sample, from classic cheese to unique creations like roasted garlic and brie. Each one was uniquely crafted, with an exquisite blend of ingredients that together created an unforgettable flavor experience.

To top it off, Frank’s House Of Pizza also offers some great sides such as garlic knots and salads, along with some incredible desserts like cannoli custard!

In short, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Simpsonville SC, head on over to Frank’s House Of Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

#10 Romeo’s Pizza

My visit to Romeo’s was everything I had hoped for and more! From the moment I stepped in the door, I knew I was in for a unique experience. The atmosphere was warm and inviting – the perfect place to enjoy a slice of pizza.

The selection of pies was amazing, with something for everyone. From classic cheese and pepperoni to specialty options like vegan spinach artichoke and eggplant parmesan, there was an abundance of choices.

But the true test of a great pizza is how it tastes, and that’s where Romeo’s really shined! Every single bite was filled with flavour – the crust was crispy and the sauces were delicious. There wasn’t one single slice that didn’t pass my taste test!

And if you’re looking for something more than just pizza, Romeo’s has you covered as well – their salads are fresh and crunchy, their sides are hearty, and their desserts are out of this world!

When it comes to pizza in Simpsonville SC, none can compare to Romeo’s Pizza. If you’re ever looking for a place to enjoy delicious food in a great atmosphere, make sure that Romeo’s Pizza is your destination!

#11 Bertolo’s Pizza

It was the first place I tried when I arrived in town, and boy, was I impressed. From the moment I stepped into Bertolo’s, the atmosphere was warm and inviting. The staff were friendly and eager to help me choose the perfect pizza for my taste.

When it came to the pizza itself, wow! It was simply amazing – a true work of art. The crust tasted like it had been freshly made that day, and the cheese was like no other – so ooey-gooey good! The toppings were fresh and flavorful, especially their signature premium pepperoni which added a delicious perfect zing. Even though I’m more of a classic cheese lover, Bertolo’s really won me over with their unique creations.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Simpsonville SC (or anywhere else!), then look no further than Bertolo’s Pizza! You won’t regret it!

#12 Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders

No matter what kind of pizza you’re in the mood for, this place has it all. Whether it’s a classic pepperoni and cheese or something a bit more adventurous like buffalo chicken with blue cheese, Bellacino’s has got you covered.

And as an added bonus for those who want to turn dinner into a night out, Bellacino’s serves alcohol! So you can have your favorite beer, wine, or cocktail while enjoying your meal. Plus they also offer a kids’ menu so everyone can enjoy their visit together.

If that wasn’t enough, this restaurant even offers dessert! So if you’ve still got some room left after devouring one of Bellacino’s delicious pizzas then you can get yourself some ice cream or cheesecake to finish off the meal.

The only downside I noticed was that there is no delivery option. But honestly, that’s not too bad considering everything else this place has going on.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Simpsonville SC then look no further than Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders!