I’ve sampled twelve different pizzas across the town, and want to let you in on where to get the very best. After much deliberation (and after many tasty slices!), I’m ready to reveal my findings.
While pizza snobbery can be serious business, I’m keeping things light and humorous here. So buckle up for a wild ride of flavor as I take you through my quest for the best pizza in Somerset NJ!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 G’s Famous Pizza 3
The restaurant itself is unassuming but don’t let that fool you. The pizza here is truly special. I’ve never tasted anything like it before! They make their pizzas with the freshest of ingredients, from the breadiest crust to the most flavorful sauce.
The toppings are creative and unique, and each pie is cooked to perfection in a brick oven. As a result, the pizza definitely delivers when it comes to flavor and texture.
I’d recommend G’s Famous Pizza 3 if you’re looking for an unforgettable experience. Get ready for some truly delicious pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in New Brunswick!
#2 Piazza Orsillo
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
The atmosphere at this charming little restaurant is absolutely lovely. The decor is modern yet cozy which makes for a great dining experience.
As for the pizza- it was simply divine! It was cooked to perfection, with the perfect ratio of crispy to doughy crust. The sauce was full of flavor and the cheese melted in my mouth. The toppings were fresh, flavorful, and plentiful- everything you would want from a high quality pizza!
The best part? Piazza Orsillo offers a wide variety of unique pizzas that are all delicious. From their creative gourmet pizzas to their classic Italian pizza, they have something special for everyone!
If you’re ever in Somerset NJ, I would definitely recommend taking a trip to Piazza Orsillo for some of the best pizza around!
#3 Galore Fried Chicken & Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
Upon my arrival, I could smell the aroma of delicious pizza coming from the kitchen. The restaurant itself was very inviting, with a cozy atmosphere that made me feel right at home.
The service was prompt and friendly. The waitress quickly took my order and delivered her recommendations for the best pizza in town. I decided to go with her suggestion of the double pepperoni and extra cheese option, and it did not disappoint! They must have used freshly picked peppers and melted cheese over an unforgettable crust; it absolutely hit the spot.
Overall, Galore Fried Chicken & Pizza is truly one of the best places for pizza in Somerset NJ! The fresh ingredients, good service, and great atmosphere make this an ideal spot for a night out with friends or family. Highly recommend!
#4 Ferraro’s Pizzeria & Pub
- Has insanely good dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Great place to watch sports
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
The thin crust is perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside and just the right amount of chewiness on the inside. Plus, it’s topped with a generous portion of delicious toppings. The Garden Veggie pizza is my personal favorite; you can really taste the freshness of each vegetable.
The atmosphere at Ferraro’s is also top-notch. Between the beer selection, arcade games, and friendly staff, I felt right at home! The open kitchen concept allows you to watch as your pizza is prepared with love, which makes it even more enjoyable.
In short, Ferraro’s Pizzeria & Pub makes some of the best pizzas in Somerset NJ – if you haven’t been there yet, make sure to check it out soon!
#5 Maya’s Pizzeria Restaurant
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere is cozy and inviting – perfect for an intimate dinner with friends, or even just a quick lunch solo. The staff are all friendly and knowledgeable about their pizzas, helping to make any decision you may have easier.
The pizza itself is out of this world! They make fresh dough every day and the crust is always perfect. The toppings are always fresh, flavorful and abundant – never skimpy! As far as I’m concerned, they have mastered the art of pizza making.
I’m also in love with their signature sauce – it’s not too sweet or too salty, but just right to complement the delicious toppings. Plus, they offer a wide range of unique pizzas like their mango-habanero and Thai chicken pizzas that will excite your taste buds.
Overall, Maya’s Pizzeria Restaurant goes beyond mediocre pizza places and truly delivers a fantastic experience that rivals any other restaurant around town. For the best pizza in Somerset NJ (and beyond) definitely give Maya’s Pizzeria Restaurant a try!
#6 King’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting and comfortable, making it a great spot to grab a bite with friends. I particularly love their mix of old-school Italian décor and modern accents—it’s the perfect blend!
As for the pizza itself, it was one of the best pies I’ve had in some time. The crust was thin but with a perfect crunch that held up to the toppings without going soggy. Complimenting this was a combination of flavorful ingredients, ranging from classic combinations like pepperoni and cheese to more adventurous options like artichoke hearts or pineapple. The sauce was perfectly balanced—neither too sweet nor too acidic—and each slice melted away in my mouth.
In short, King’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant serves up some of the best pizza in Somerset NJ! If you’re looking for an Italian feast with friends or family, you won’t be disappointed. I definitely recommend giving it a try!
#7 Lubrano’s Pizzeria
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
At Lubrano’s Pizzeria, the pizza is cooked to perfection. With perfectly cooked dough and generous amounts of cheese, this pizzeria has certainly mastered their craft.
The atmosphere at Lubrano’s Pizzeria is wonderfully cozy and comfortable. The waitstaff are always friendly and attentive, making any dining experience here a true pleasure.
As for the toppings, there’s something for everyone here. From pepperoni to jalapenos to pesto and more, the selection of toppings is sure to impress even the pickiest of eaters.
I’ve got to say that out of all the places I’ve been, Lubrano’s Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in Somerset NJ! I’d definitely recommend a visit here if you’re ever in town and looking for a good pie.
If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Hillsborough Township!
#8 P J’s Grill & Pizza – Food delivery in the New Brunswick area. Call or order online.
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
The pizza here is cooked to perfection. The crust and sauce are just the right blend of flavors that ensure each bite is even more delicious than the last. They also have a wide variety of toppings, so you can be sure to find something for everyone’s taste.
The service here was second-to-none; from the moment I placed my order, I felt like I was dealing with old friends. Everyone was courteous, friendly and eager to help me get my order ready quickly and accurately.
To top it all off, the prices at P J’s Grill & Pizza were super affordable! I definitely feel like I got my money’s worth after enjoying such delicious pizza – plus it made my wallet happy as well!
Overall, I highly recommend P J’s Grill & Pizza – Food delivery in the New Brunswick area. Call or order online. if you’re looking for great food at an even better price! Trust me when I say this place has the best pizza in Somerset NJ – you won’t regret it!
#9 Cristo’s Pizza and Grill
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The pizza here is simply amazing! From the signature specialty pizzas to the fresh and tasty ingredients, it’s hard to find anything wrong with this place. Everything was cooked to perfection, the crust was crispy and light, and the cheese was gooey and flavorful.
Aside from the delicious pizza, I also enjoyed the atmosphere of Cristo’s Pizza and Grill. The restaurant has a relaxed feel to it, and all of the staff were friendly and welcoming. It was great sitting on comfortable couches with some friends enjoying a few beers along with our pizza.
Overall, I would highly recommend trying out Cristo’s Pizza and Grill if you’re ever in Somerset NJ looking for some of the best pizza around!
#10 Cafe Amici
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
Everything from the ambiance to the quality of ingredients was top notch. I felt so at home being surrounded by friends, family and other pizza lovers in the restaurant.
The classic Margherita Pizza that they serve is worth its weight in gold! The crust is perfectly crispy and chewy and the tomato sauce has a delectable sweetness balanced with a touch of garlic. The mozzarella cheese melts right into the dough and adds an extra layer of flavor.
I also had a chance to sample their more inventive offerings like the Sausage and Mushroom Pizza, which was stuffed with luscious sausage and a generous helping of mushrooms – all brought together wonderfully by a delicate white sauce.
It’s no wonder why this place is beloved by locals! Everyone deserves to try Cafe Amici for themselves and experience what might be the best pizza in Somerset NJ!
#11 Douglass Pizza & Grill
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The atmosphere is inviting, with a bit of a retro vibe. The waiters are friendly and attentive, and the decor features Italian-themed art. It’s clear from the moment you walk in that this place truly cares about giving customers an enjoyable experience.
As for the food itself, Douglass Pizza & Grill does not disappoint! Their pizzas are loaded with fresh toppings and cooked to perfect thin-crust perfection. Their menu offers plenty of delicious topping combinations as well as specialty pizzas like their white pizza – yum! Craft beers, salads and sandwiches round out the offerings so there is something on the menu for everyone.
I highly recommend checking out Douglass Pizza & Grill if you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Somerset NJ. They have some of the best pies I’ve ever had – not only in NJ, but in my travels around the world!
#12 Luigi’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The atmosphere is classic Italian, complete with red and white checked tablecloths and the smell of garlic and cheese in the air. But the real star of the show is their pizza. Their thin-crust pizzas are simply divine – they are made with fresh ingredients that really bring out the flavor. I had a pepperoni and mushroom pizza, and each bite was like a little slice of heaven!
I also got to sample some of their other Italian dishes, which were incredibly flavorful. The lasagna was so hearty and cheesy, it could turn any ordinary weeknight into an authentic Italian feast.
The staff at Luigi’s are top notch; they provide great service with friendly smiles. They even have specials running through out the week that make their already affordable prices even lower.
In my opinion, Luigi’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Somerset NJ! It’s worth a visit if you’re ever in town!
