Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in South Bend IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in South Bend IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

281 Views

You name it, I’ve probably sampled it! From the Italian-style pizza in Italy, to deep-dish pizzas from Chicago, and even Detroit-style pies. But South Bend IN has some pretty stellar pizzerias that really are a cut above the rest.

I recently conducted a 12-stop pizza tour of South Bend IN and I’m about to reveal what might be my favorite pizza yet! It’s time to have some fun and find out who serves up the best pie. So stick around for a funny and lighthearted review of the Best Pizza in South Bend IN!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Macri’s Italian Bakery

I arrived at Macri’s Italian Bakery, eager to find out what all the fuss was about. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and sat down with high expectations. What I tasted next was nothing short of amazing. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy – not too crunchy, but still enough crunch to make it enjoyable. The sauce had just the right mix of both sweet and savory flavors. When it came to the toppings, they weren’t messing around! Every bite included a generous helping of cheese and pepperoni.

The atmosphere at Macri’s Italian Bakery is also one worth talking about. It’s cozy and quaint, yet energetic and alive – no doubt because everyone in there knows that their taste buds are about to be treated to some seriously delicious pizza!

All in all, Macri’s Italian Bakery has earned its title as the best pizza in South Bend IN – something I can attest to after my own experience there. If you’re ever in town, be sure to put this place on your list of must-try places; you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Mishawaka!

#2 Rocco’s Restaurant

When I first arrived at Rocco’s, my mouth started watering. The smell of the oven-fresh pizza baking in the oven was incredible!

The atmosphere of Rocco’s was also wonderful. It had a warm and friendly vibe that made me want to come back again and again.

I ordered a Cheese Lover’s Pizza and it did not disappoint. The cheesy goodness was out of this world! Every bite was full of flavor and had just the right amount of sauce. If you like pizza that is loaded with cheese, then Rocco’s is the place for you.

In addition to their delicious pizza, Rocco’s also offers other great menu items. The calzones are particularly noteworthy—they are definitely worth trying!

To top it off, the service at Rocco’s is great too; the wait staff is attentive and helpful, making sure every customer gets exactly what they want.

All in all, I’d highly recommend visiting Rocco’s Restaurant if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in South Bend IN!

#3 Chivo’s Pizza

The decor is a little outdated, but that’s okay. Who cares about decorations when the pizza tastes so good? The pizzas have a fantastic variety of toppings – ranging from classic pepperoni to pineapple and even vegan options. No matter what you’re craving, Chivo’s has something for everyone!

The crust is just the right combination of thin and crispy. Every bite is full of flavor, yet still light enough that it won’t weigh you down. The sauce has a wonderful mix of spices and tomatoes that will tantalize your taste buds!

But what really sets this place apart from others are their specialties. Their “Meatzilla” pizza is downright legendary in South Bend IN – it’s packed with pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, bacon, ham and salami. And if you like cheese, then their mac n’ cheese pizza is definitely worth trying – it comes with four kinds of cheeses sure to make your mouth water.

In summary, I can’t say enough good things about Chivo’s Pizza – they really put the extra effort into crafting amazing pizzas every time! If you’re ever in South Bend IN looking for great pizza, I highly recommend stopping by Chivo’s for some of the best pizza around!

#4 Starlite Pizza

My visit to this pizza restaurant was an unforgettable experience. From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by a friendly waiter who immediately seated me at a table with a wonderful view of the outdoor patio.

The atmosphere at Starlite Pizza was nothing short of amazing! The warm and cozy ambiance paired with the romantic lighting made me feel like I was really in Italy.

But it gets better – the food! After browsing through the menu, I decided to try out their signature dish – The Ultimate Supreme Pizza. It had all my favorite toppings: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and oodles of cheese.

I have to say that this pizza truly lived up to its name! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy on the outside while still being light and airy on the inside. And they weren’t skimpy on any of their toppings either – each bite was filled with delicious flavors exploding in my mouth!

All in all, Starlite Pizza definitely stands out above the rest when it comes to finding great pizza in South Bend IN. If you’re ever looking for something delicious without having to travel far away from home, Starlite Pizza has got you covered.

#5 Barnaby’s South Bend

I couldn’t believe the variety of toppings and sauces that are available. From anchovies to artichokes and from pesto to marinara, Barnaby’s has it all. The crust was perfect – not too crunchy and not too soft, with just the right amount of char.

The best part about Barnaby’s South Bend pizza is that they use fresh ingredients for each pie. The tomatoes were ripe, the onions were sweet, and the cheese absolutely melted in my mouth! There wasn’t a single ingredient I didn’t enjoy.

The atmosphere at Barnaby’s South Bend is lively yet cozy. You can dine in or take out your pies which makes them great for any occasion – whether it’s an intimate date night or a large family gathering. The staff was friendly and accommodating as well – they even let me sample a few of their signature pies before I made up my mind!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in South Bend IN then look no further than Barnaby’s South Bend. I highly recommend that you try it out!

#6 Bruno’s Pizza Downtown

As soon as I stepped inside, the amazing smell of fresh ingredients filled my nostrils. I knew right away that this was going to be a great pizza experience!

I chose the Bruno’s Special: tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms and onions. The pizza arrived just as I expected; the crust was perfectly crunchy yet still soft and chewy. The generous amounts of toppings were evenly spread across the pizza for an even distribution in every bite. What can I say? Absolutely delicious!

I was also pleased with the service at Bruno’s Pizza Downtown. My order came quickly and all staff members paid attention to what I asked for and made sure I got my meal just how I wanted it. Not to mention, they were all friendly and inviting too.

Overall, Bruno’s Pizza Downtown definitely hit the spot when it comes to finding great pizza. If you’re ever in South Bend IN looking for some of the best pizza around, you should definitely check out Bruno’s Pizza Downtown!

#7 Lacopo’s Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped into Lacopo’s Pizzeria I knew that I was in for an amazing culinary experience. The atmosphere was buzzing with welcoming fellow pizza enthusiasts, and there was an unmistakable scent of freshly cooked pizza in the air – a wonderful welcome after my long journey!

Upon further exploration, I quickly realized why this restaurant has been winning awards year after year. Their menu is extensive and offers options to satisfy everyone’s taste buds. After much deliberation (the decisions were tough!), I decided to go with their signature dish – The Grandma-style Sicilian Pizza.

It didn’t take long for this masterpiece to arrive at my table and as soon as it did my stomach started rumbling. The combination of flavors perfectly blended together making every bite a decadent treat! There was no doubt in my mind that this pizza would have any other pizzeria shaking in its crusts.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery – meaning you have to come to their location if you want a piece of this delectable treat. But in all fairness, it would be criminal to deliver anything less than perfection so driving out here is worth every second!

If you are looking for some truly great pizza then look no further than Lacopo’s Pizzeria! Trust me, you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Elkhart!

#8 Luigi’s Pizza

When I arrived, I was immediately impressed by the authentic Italian atmosphere. From the chef in a tall white hat shouting orders to the regular customers giving him ribbing, it felt like I had been transported to a pizzeria in Milan.

Speaking of the pizza, my taste buds were treated to some of the most delicious slices imaginable. The crust was light and chewy, yet still crunchy with just the perfect amount of char for that extra flavor. The cheese was gooey and stringy, not too greasy but still full of flavor. And don’t even get me started on the sauce! Freshly made with succulent tomatoes and fragrant herbs – simply divine!

I haven’t even mentioned their signature pies yet either – from classic pepperoni to inventive combinations like barbecue chicken and pesto – Luigi’s Pizza is sure to satisfy your craving for great-tasting pizza!

If you’re ever in South Bend IN and looking for an incredible pizza experience, don’t miss out on Luigi’s Pizza! This place is hands-down one of the best pizzas around town and I’m sure it won’t disappoint.

#9 Sunny Italy Cafe

I’m not joking. The place is awesome, and I have to say the alcohol selection definitely adds to the experience. Not only can you enjoy great Italian wines, but they also serve hard liquor, which really takes things up a notch.

The pizza itself is insanely good. From the toppings to the dough, they get it just right every time – no small feat! Plus, the desserts are ridiculously delicious. And honestly, sometimes that’s even better than the pizza itself!

However, I must make note of one downside here: Sunny Italy Cafe does not deliver. So if you want to take advantage of this great establishment, make sure you plan ahead! That being said, it’s well worth the effort – trust me.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in South Bend IN, Sunny Italy Cafe should be your first stop!

#10 Hall’s Kitchen Pizza and Subs

I was pleasantly surprised by the deliciousness of the pizza here. It has a nice, slightly crunchy crust that’s made from scratch, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. My personal favorite is the pepperoni and mushroom slices – it’s simply delightful!

The staff at Hall’s Kitchen Pizza and Subs is also quite friendly and accommodating. They don’t seem to mind when I ask for my pizza extra-spicy or loaded with extra toppings. What’s more, they’re happy to answer any questions I may have about their menu offerings.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in South Bend IN, Hall’s Kitchen Pizza and Subs should definitely be high on your list of places to check out!

#11 Macri’s Italian Kitchen & Catering

The allure of this pizza joint is palpable the moment you step inside the door. From the rustic decor to the aromas wafting from the kitchen, it’s clear that you’re in for a treat. If you have kids, they’ll love the kid’s menu, and adults won’t be disappointed either–they even serve alcohol!

The pizza here is insane. I’m talking about crispy crusts that are perfectly balanced with sweet-tangy sauce and melty cheese. They offer a variety of toppings so you can really make your own masterpiece. The best part is, no matter what kind of pizza you order, it will be delicious.

But Macri’s Italian Kitchen & Catering isn’t just known for their incredible pizza – they also have some of the best desserts in town. From ice cream to cakes, there’s something for everyone here. And don’t forget about their tantalizing tiramisu!

My only complaint about Macri’s Italian Kitchen & Catering is that they don’t offer delivery services. But if you’re looking for one of the best pizzas in South Bend IN, then this spot is definitely worth a visit!

#12 Hungry Howie’s Pizza

At first glance, the restaurant looks like any other generic pizza joint; but the moment your eyes catch a glimpse of their signature pies, you know you’re in for a treat. The crust is thin and perfectly crispy, and the generous portions of cheese and toppings are just enough to make it savory without being overwhelming.

But what really sets Hungry Howie’s apart from the competition is their wide variety of specialty pizzas. From their “Howie Special” (a delicious blend of pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, green peppers and onions) to their veggie-friendly options like the “Veggie Delight” (with fresh spinach, tomatoes, mushrooms and more), there’s something for everyone!

One thing I’ve noticed about Hungry Howie’s Pizza is that they go out of their way to make sure every order is perfect. Every time I pick up an order from them, it’s cooked perfectly – neither overdone nor underdone.

If you’re looking for great pizza at a great price – Hungry Howie’s Pizza is definitely your best bet in South Bend IN!