In my attempts to find the very best, I visited 12 places in town. The reviews were humorous and light-hearted, while still keeping my standards high for a pizza that will knock your socks off!
I’ve been all over the world eating pizza, from Italy to New York City, so I’m confident that whatever I recommend is truly among the greatest. Let’s get ready to see which Jersey City pizzerias made it into my personal top rankings.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Holy Tomato
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- No delivery
The atmosphere is cozy and comfortable. The staff are friendly and attentive, making sure that every customer’s experience is nothing short of exceptional.
I’ve tried many pies from Holy Tomato and they have never disappointed. From the classic cheese or pepperoni slices to creative toppings like steak and ricotta, they never fail to impress with their flavorful ingredients. I was thrilled to find out that they even offer some vegetarian options!
As if this place couldn’t get any better, the desserts here are insanely good. Whether it’s their cheesecakes or their cinnamon buns, you’re sure to leave happy and satisfied.
My only major complaint was that there isn’t an option for delivery, which would make it a lot easier to get my hands on these delicious pizzas. Other than that, I’d recommend Holy Tomato to anyone looking for tasty pizza in South Jersey!
If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Cherry Hill!
#2 Tiga’s Artisan Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
I had heard great things about Tiga’s, so I was excited to try it out. Let me tell you, they did not disappoint! The pizza crust was crunchy and flavorful with a perfect combination of sauce and cheese. Every bite was pure perfection!
The service at Tiga’s Artisan Pizzeria was also outstanding. The staff were friendly and helpful, and even asked for my opinion on what toppings would make the perfect pie!
When it comes to taste, Tiga’s Artisan Pizzeria is second to none! Their recipes have been developed over time by their master pizza chefs, resulting in a savory experience that will leave your tastebuds begging for more.
In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in South Jersey then you’ve got to try Tiga’s Artisan Pizzeria. With great prices, amazing food, and superb service, this is one pizza place that you won’t want to miss out on!
#3 Joe’s Pizza
The crust was lightly crispy and packed full of flavor. The sauce was deliciously tangy and the cheese wasstringy and delicious. The toppings were fresh and added an extra layer of flavor to the whole thing.
I think what really sets Joe’s Pizza apart is their focus on sustainability. All their ingredients are sourced locally so you can feel good about what you’re eating! Not only that, but they use eco-friendly materials for their takeout orders too, which I appreciate.
But what really blew me away was their customer service – they truly want to make sure each order is perfect before it leaves the kitchen! And trust me, every single thing I tried here lives up to that promise. Joe’s Pizza really knows how to deliver the best pizza in South Jersey!
#4 Bruni’s Pizzeria
- Nice tourist spot
This little pizzeria is a hidden gem. The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the comforting aroma of fresh, handmade pizza that had been baking in the ovens. The second thing I noticed was the friendly service and down-to-earth atmosphere that made me feel right at home.
The menu offers plenty of traditional Italian dishes, but true to its name, Bruni’s is all about the pizza. Each one is handcrafted with care by the pizza makers and loaded with quality ingredients like top-notch mozzarella cheese and crisp vegetables. For me, it was hard to decide between the delectable Margherita Pizza or the unique Wild Mushroom Pie, so I opted for both!
The results were nothing short of spectacular. Every bite was incredibly flavorful, with just enough zing from fresh herbs. The crust had a delicious crunch and perfect chewiness – it only added to my overall experience.
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in South Jersey, then you must try Bruni’s Pizzeria! With unbeatable taste, outstanding service, an inviting atmosphere and reasonable prices, this place certainly doesn’t disappoint!
#5 Brooklyn Original Pizzeria
When I first visited the small pizzeria, I noticed that the atmosphere was cozy but vibrant. The restaurant had a welcoming vibe and the staff were extremely friendly and eager to please.
I tried out several of their specialty pies,including the Brooklyn Original Supreme and the Sicily All Meat. Each slice was loaded with flavor and cooked to perfection – not too crunchy or overly oily. Plus, they offer a great selection of toppings so you can really customize your pie.
The service was swift and attentive; my order arrived piping hot in no time at all. The whole experience was worth every penny – if you’re looking for delicious pizza then look no further than Brooklyn Original Pizzeria! I give them two thumbs up – without a doubt they make some of the best pizza in South Jersey!
#6 Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
When I arrived at Del Ponte’s, I was pleasantly surprised by the casual and comfortable atmosphere. The menu was stacked with delicious options, but I chose to try their classic Margherita pizza. Their coal-fired oven heated to a perfect, golden brown crust that was easy on the teeth but still had a nice crunch.
The toppings were top-notch—the tomatoes were sweet and juicy, and the cheese bubbly and flavorful. But the best part? The creative topping combinations they offer! My favorite was their Artichoke Gorgonzola pie that was bursting with flavor and had just the right amount of heat from the pepperoncini.
Overall, Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza exceeded my expectations. With its flavorful pies, cozy atmosphere, and attentive service staff, it definitely is my go-to for some of the best pizza in Jersey!
#7 Pizzeria Las Americas
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
To start off, let me say that their crust is phenomenal. They use a unique blend of flour and herbs that they import direct from Italy. The result is a crunchy, flavorful crust which is complemented by wonderfully tangy tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
The toppings are also top notch. I’m talking about freshly sliced pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and other classic toppings. And if you’re feeling adventurous there are more exotic types such as jalapeños or even shrimp! Plus, the portions are generous enough to give both vegetarians and meat-lovers something to chew on.
The overall atmosphere of the place also adds to the experience. It has an old-school vibe combined with a modern touch, making it a great place for both family gatherings and fun dates nights out. The staff was very welcoming too, which definitely makes a difference in my opinion!
In conclusion, I must say that Pizzeria Las Americas serves one of the best pizzas in Jersey City NJ! If you’re looking for great food at an affordable price then this is definitely the place to go!
#8 Tacconelli’s Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- No delivery
I recently visited Tacconelli’s and couldn’t have been more impressed. From the wide selection of different pizzas, to the fresh mozzarella and homemade tomato sauce, I could tell that a lot of time and effort goes into making the perfect pizza here. Even my pickiest friends were satisfied with their choice!
Not only do they offer great pizza, but also dessert! Who doesn’t love that? You can even buy it by the slice, if you don’t feel like committing to a full order. And did I mention how beautiful the place is? It’s definitely a great spot for tourists to visit while in Jersey.
The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery – so if you’re looking for pizza to go, you’ll have to look elsewhere! But if you want to make sure you get the best pizza in jersey – Tacconelli’s Pizzeria should be your go-to spot. Trust me, you won’t regret it!
#9 Gia Nina’s Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has insanely good dessert
The moment I stepped inside the door, I knew this wasn’t your typical pizza joint. The decor was warm and inviting, with an Old-World charm that left me feeling relaxed and at home.
The staff were friendly and generous with their time, answering my questions about the different dishes available. They also provided some excellent recommendations which all tasted great!
The food itself was out of this world. Each slice was cooked to perfection and topped with delicious mozzarella cheese and fresh vegetables. And the crust! Oh my goodness! It was mind-blowing — crispy on the outside yet wonderfully fluffy on the inside. Even the sauce had a unique flavor that really heightened my experience with each bite.
To top it off, they have an extensive selection of craft beers to choose from too; perfect for washing down every savory slice of pizza!
In conclusion, Gia Nina’s Pizza definitely ranks among my favorite places to get a great pie in South Jersey — if not the best!
#10 Back Door Pizza
The first thing that struck me about this pizza place was the back door – literally! It’s a unique way to get your slice, but it certainly adds to the charm.
When I walked in, I was immediately taken aback by the smell of delicious pizza baking in the oven. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, which made for a great dining experience.
The pizza itself was out of this world! The crust was cooked to perfection and had just the right amount of crispiness. The toppings were all fresh and full of flavor, and watching them prepare my pizza in an old-fashioned brick oven added a romantic touch.
Not only did Back Door Pizza serve up some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted, but they also provided excellent service. Everyone there was friendly and accommodating and even offered me samples when I asked what their best pizzas were.
Overall, if you’re looking for a delicious slice of pizza in South Jersey then look no further than Back Door Pizza!
#11 Nostra Pizza & Italian Eatery
- Offers dessert
I was immediately impressed with this place. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, and the staff was friendly and helpful. The pizza itself was delicious, cooked to perfection in their brick oven. The crust was thin and crisp, the sauce flavorful, and the toppings generous. I especially enjoyed the pepperoni slices – spiced just right!
The menu boasted so many mouthwatering options that I had a difficult time deciding what to order. I ended up ordering the signature Nostra Pie, a delicious combination of creamy ricotta and mozzarella cheeses layered with prosciutto and pepperoni slices. It far exceeded my expectations – it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!
Other highlights included their pasta dishes, salads, calzones, paninis and desserts. Their tiramisu was heavenly! No matter what you order at Nostra Pizza & Italian Eatery you can expect delicious food made with fresh ingredients in an inviting atmosphere. Highly recommend!
#12 Vesuvio Ristorante
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
Their crust is so light and fluffy, it practically melts in your mouth. But don’t mistake that for lack of crunch – the outer edge offers the perfect crunchy texture. And for those who like to pile on the toppings, they offer an impressive range of options, from classic pepperoni to a variety of vegetables.
The atmosphere at Vesuvio Ristorante is warm and inviting; you can almost smell the Italian influence in the air! I’m also impressed with their commitment to fresh ingredients – they source all of their produce locally, which means that each pizza tastes like it was crafted by an Italian grandmother. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable too, which really adds to the whole experience.
But what sets Vesuvio Ristorante apart from other pizza restaurants? Definitely their selection of craft beers! Not only do they have a great selection, but they also pair them perfectly with different pizzas. So whether you’re looking to sit down for a romantic dinner or grab a quick slice on your lunch break, Vesuvio Ristorante has something for everyone.
In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in South Jersey, look no further than Vesuvio Ristorante!
Best Thin Crust Pizza – Bricco Coal Fired Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Nice tourist spot
- Does not accept reservations
This place is a tourist spot that not only serves mouth-watering pizza but also has the added benefit of serving alcohol. Because let’s be honest, what goes better with pizza than a nice, cold beer?
Now, I should mention that I am a vegetarian, so I always appreciate when a pizza joint has some options for us herbivores. Bricco Coal Fired Pizza does not disappoint in this department. They have a variety of flavorful veggie toppings to choose from, ensuring that even us non-meat eaters can indulge in their delicious pies.
And let’s not forget about dessert! Bricco offers a range of delectable sweet treats to satisfy your post-pizza cravings. From their heavenly Nutella pizza to their decadent tiramisu, these desserts are the perfect ending to a pizza-filled feast.
Now, here’s the downside. Bricco Coal Fired Pizza does not accept reservations. So if you’re planning on stopping by during peak hours, be prepared to wait. But believe me, it’s worth it. Just use that time wisely and start planning what pizza masterpiece you’re going to devour once you get a table.
In conclusion, if you find yourself in south jersey and in need of some exceptional thin crust pizza, look no further than Bricco Coal Fired Pizza. It’s a great spot for tourists, offers vegetarian options, serves alcohol, and will leave you begging for more. Bon appétit!
