Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Stillwater (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Minnesota

Best Pizza in Stillwater (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

145 Views

Pie-ing around this city, I sampled from twelve of the best spots that Stillwater has to offer. Believe me when I say, my taste buds have seen some incredible sights and smells in my search for the best pizza place around here.

I’m here to report on my findings, giving you a lighthearted yet honest review of each restaurant. So sit back and get ready; it’s time to find out who makes the tastiest pizzas in town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Minnesota

#1 Grand Pizza

The restaurant itself is quite impressive – with its old-school décor, cozy atmosphere, and friendly staff. The menu features an array of delicious pizza options – including some creative originals like the BBQ Chicken Pizza and the Mediterranean Pizza.

It was impossible to decide which pizza to try, so I decided to sample all of them! Every single one was amazing – from the classic Margherita to the more adventurous creations. Each bite was filled with cheesy goodness and flavorful toppings. The crust had a perfect crunchy texture that I can only describe as absolute perfection.

The service at Grand Pizza was also top notch. My server was friendly and attentive – offering suggestions on what to sample and how best to enjoy each slice!

All in all, it’s safe to say that Grand Pizza offers the best pizza in Stillwater. I certainly intend to return again soon!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Woodbury!

#2 QuickFire Pizza

The atmosphere was the first thing that I noticed, and it was great. I could just feel the energy in the place! Inside, they have a wood-burning oven so you can actually watch your pizza being made right before your eyes, which makes the whole experience that much more special.

But it’s not just about looks with this place; their food is amazing! They have all sorts of unique combinations of toppings and sauces to choose from and all of them are incredibly delicious. Not to mention, their dough is made fresh every day and is always cooked to perfection in their wood-burning oven.

I also have to give them props for their prices, they’re surprisingly affordable too! And they offer delivery service if you don’t feel like making the trip – although after having this fantastic pizza I can assure you it’ll be worth it!

Overall, QuickFire Pizza has quickly become one of my favorite places for pizza in Stillwater. The atmosphere, food quality, and affordable prices make this my go-to spot for the best pizza around!

#3 Victoriano’s NY Style Pizza

The toppings are plentiful and delicious, the crust is perfectly cooked and their vegetarian options are surprisingly tasty. Best of all, Victoriano’s offers dessert – great for enjoying with a cup of coffee on a hot summer day.

On the downside, they don’t offer delivery, so you’ll have to make your way to Stillwater to try it yourself. But trust me, it’s worth it! So if you’re ever in Stillwater and looking for some of the best pizza around, be sure to visit Victoriano’s NY Style Pizza.

#4 Carbone’s Pizzeria

I had the pleasure of popping into Carbone’s recently and was pleasantly surprised. The staff was super friendly and helpful in finding just what I wanted on their delicious menu. Their selection is impressive with something for everyone – from vegans, to meat lovers, to vegetarians, they’ve got it all.

The best part? They serve alcohol – and not just basic beer and wine either, they have hard liquor as well! So you can enjoy a cold one while chowing down on some of the best pizza in Stillwater. And if you’re bringing kids along, there’s a great kid’s menu too so they can join in on the fun. Plus they’ve got dessert covered as well with amazing options like gelato and more!

The only thing that could be better is if they offered delivery service. But honestly, it doesn’t take away from the amazing experience I had there and would absolutely recommend them to anyone looking for a great pizza spot in Stillwater!

If you’re willing to go an extra 17 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Blaine!

#5 Papa John’s Pizza

Let me tell you my experience: We arrived at Papa John’s, greeted with a cheerful and knowledgeable staff. Immediately we knew we were in for a great time. The decor was nice, warm, and inviting – the perfect place to share pizza with friends.

The pizza itself? Absolutely delicious! We tried a variety of their offerings including the Spinach Alfredo, Sausage & Pepperoni, and Traditional Cheese, each with its own unique flavor profiles. The crust was buttery and crunchy while still giving way to the great toppings. They also had some surprisingly creative toppings like their BBQ Chicken that added depth to their pizzas.

The best part about Papa John’s Pizza is the value – the price is very reasonable for what you get. Not only can you get a large traditional pizza for a few dollars but they offer excellent discounts and deals. You can pick up several delicious pies without breaking the bank!

Overall, I highly recommend Papa John’s Pizza as the best pizza in Stillwater! The quality and value make it stand out above competitors in this area so if you’re looking for quality pizza delivered right to your doorstep, this is definitely your spot!

#6 Pizza Ranch

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with an incredibly friendly staff always ready to help me select the perfect pizza. The menu is full of delicious dishes – from classic pizzas to stuffed crusts and crazy creations – making it easy to find something for everyone.

And, of course, the pizza itself! Wow! Every single time I’ve visited Pizza Ranch, the pizza has been simply sublime. The crust is crispy and golden-brown on the outside but delightfully chewy on the inside. The toppings are always abundant and flavorful – never sparse or bland. Plus, they offer lots of vegetarian options as well!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Stillwater, look no further than Pizza Ranch – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The store is small and unassuming, but they definitely pack a punch. The staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming, the prices are very reasonable, and the selection of pizzas is varied and diverse.

The pizza itself is one of the best I’ve ever tasted. The crust has just the right thickness, with an amazing balance between crunchy and chewy. The toppings are always fresh and full of flavor. Plus, I love that you can make your own custom pizzas however you want them.

One thing that makes this place stand out from other pizza places is their unique ‘take ‘n’ bake’ concept: You buy a dough ball, then take it home to bake in your oven when it’s convenient for you. This way you get a freshly baked pizza that tastes like it came straight from the oven.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Stillwater, then Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in St Paul!

#8 Domino’s Pizza

Upon entering their establishment, I was impressed to see their modern and inviting dining atmosphere. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful in guiding me through the process of ordering my pizza.

Their selection of pizzas was quite extensive, and I had a difficult time deciding! In the end, I went for the traditional pepperoni and cheese – and boy, was it good! Not only were the toppings fresh and plentiful, but the crust was just as delicious. The flavors certainly did not disappoint.

One thing I found most impressive about Domino’s Pizza is that their delivery service was on-point! My order showed up within 30 minutes of placing it, and it still tasted hot and fresh.

All together, this place is hard to beat when it comes to great pizza in Stillwater. Therefore, if you’re looking for some delicious pies then you should definitely give Domino’s Pizza a try!

#9 Pizza Man

First, the atmosphere was so welcoming as soon as I walked in. The owners and staff were clearly passionate about their craft and excited to introduce me to the delights awaiting my taste buds!

The pizza itself? Absolutely divine. I’m not exaggerating when I say that it tasted like a freshly-baked slice of heaven! The dough had just the right amount of crunch without being overbaked. The cheese was just melted to perfection, with a wonderful blend of spices that made each bite extra flavorful. And the toppings – oh my! They included roasted peppers, mushrooms, spinach, and sundried tomatoes that gave it a delightfully sweet, savory combination.

The other great thing about Pizza Man is their wide selection of menu items. From classic pizzas to salads, calzones and more, they have something for everyone at every price point! Plus, they offer delivery services so you can enjoy your meal wherever you are.

I’ve eaten pizza all over the world but none compare to what I experienced at Pizza Man! If you’re in Stillwater and looking for the best pizza around then make sure you stop by Pizza Man – you won’t regret it!

#10 Mad Capper Saloon & Eatery

I love the atmosphere of this place. It’s perfect for tourists looking to get a taste of Stillwater – and it has a great view too. Plus, they serve alcohol so you can really make an evening out of it! But don’t worry, they also have a kid’s menu which is great for families.

The pizza itself was amazing – I had the Neapolitan style and it was cheesy, savory, and flavorful. Plus, there are plenty of topping combinations to choose from that pair perfectly with the hard liquor options! And after finishing off my meal I was still able to splurge on dessert thanks to their great selection.

The only downside is that there is no delivery option… but trust me, you won’t regret making the trip! Mad Capper Saloon & Eatery serves some of the best pizza in Stillwater – I’m sure you’ll enjoy it just as much as I did.

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Minneapolis!

#11 Joseph’s Family Restaurant

From the moment I walked into Joseph’s, I knew I was in for a real treat. The warm atmosphere, inviting staff and delicious aromas had me salivating before I even ordered my pizza.

The pizza itself was something special. The cheese was flavorful, not greasy like so many other pizzas. The crust was thin yet firm – nearly the perfect texture! And the toppings were a feast for my taste buds – fresh vegetables, flavorful spices and plentiful meats that could satisfy any appetite.

And if you’re looking to cap off your meal with some dessert, they have a very unique offering: deep-fried ice cream! It’s one of those must-try dishes that you’ll never forget (in a good way).

All in all, Joseph’s Family Restaurant is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in Stillwater and craving the best pizza around. In fact, it might just be worth making the trip from wherever you are!

#12 Papa’s

I was thrilled to discover that not only did they serve traditional pizza, but also offered adult beverages like beer and hard liquor – a must for any pizza-loving traveler like myself. Their selection of draft beers is terrific and it’s the perfect accompaniment to their delicious pies.

The pizza at Papa’s is some of the best I’ve ever tasted – cooked just right with gorgeous crust and fantastically flavorful toppings. To top it all off, they offer dessert too which was the cherry on top of my wonderful pizza-tasting experience!

What I did not like about Papa’s however is that they do not offer delivery. While this isn’t always a problem when dining in, sometimes you just don’t feel like leaving the house or going out on a cold night – so it would be nice if they offered delivery service to Stillwater residents.

Overall I highly recommend Papa’s for anyone looking for the best pizza in Stillwater. From their delicious pies to their selection of drafts and hard liquors, there’s something here for everyone!