Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Stl (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Missouri

Best Pizza in Stl (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

415 Views

I’ve been on a quest to find the best pizza in Stl, and I think I’ve found it. After spending days sampling pizzas from 12 different places, my taste buds have finally settled.

Through all of the cheese pulling, dough stretching and sauce tasting, one pizza rose above the rest. It was an experience that left me surprised and amused at the same time.

This wasn’t just about finding out what tastes good; it was about finding out what tastes great. So come along with me on my search for the Best Pizza in STL!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Missouri

#1 Pizzeoli Wood Fired Pizza

Beginning with their unique wood fired flavor, Pizzeoli Wood Fired Pizza is truly a pizza-lover’s paradise. Hot and fast, the thin, yet crunchy crusts are everything you could dream of and more. The toppings are fresh and varied – you have your pick of all the traditional favorites like pepperoni or sausage, as well as exciting new spins on classic recipes. I especially love their out of the ordinary creations like their spicy BBQ pork pizza or the prosciutto fig goat cheese option – divine!

And let us not forget about the atmosphere – it makes for a great night out with family and friends in a relaxed setting. Plus, takeout is available if you’re looking to enjoy a cozy night in.

Overall, Pizzeoli Wood Fired Pizza is one of the best places to get pizza in Stl. Great flavors, diverse options, and an enjoyable atmosphere make this local favorite hard to beat. Try it out for yourself; I’m sure you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 20 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Chesterfield!

#2 Pie Guy Pizza

From the moment I stepped into Pie Guy Pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. The cozy atmosphere, the mouth-watering smell of freshly cooked pizza, and the friendly staff were all welcoming amenities.

The pizza itself was amazing! The dough was light and fluffy with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was bright and full of flavor, and there were plenty of topping options to choose from. My favorite topping combination has to be the classic pepperoni; it had a spicy kick that complemented the dough perfectly!

What really sets Pie Guy Pizza apart is their unique twist on toppings–they have an extensive list of unusual options like pineapples, jalapenos, fried chicken wings, and more. They seem to think outside of pizza box when it comes to their ingredients and it definitely pays off!

All in all, Pie Guy Pizza is definitely one of the best places to get a slice in Stl! They offer delicious pizza with lots of interesting toppings at reasonable prices–what’s not to love?

#3 Pizzeria da Gloria

I’ve never encountered a more authentic Italian pizza experience. Not only are the toppings fresh, but the dough is made with an old-world Italian recipe that can’t be beat!

The ambience is also perfect – plenty of quaint tables and chairs perfect for long conversations and families alike. Don’t forget to check out their extensive wine list as well!

Most importantly, though, I highly recommend their signature Margherita pizza. It has all the classic ingredients: a delectable base of tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, fresh basil leaves, and a few slices of San Marzano tomatoes. It’s so delicious that it may make you believe you’re in Italy!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Stl – look no further than Pizzeria da Gloria!

#4 Failoni’s Restaurant

Upon arriving at Failoni’s, I was met with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff were friendly and helpful, offering advice on which pies to try. The menu was expansive, with something for everyone.

I decided to go with the classic slice of cheese pizza. When it arrived, boy was I in for a treat! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the cheese was beautifully melted atop a generous helping of delicious tomato sauce.

The flavors were robust and complex, yet still balanced. Each bite offered an ever-changing mix of textures and tastes that left me wanting more! As if that wasn’t enough, I also got to try some of their specialty pies – including their world-famous Italian sausage pizza!

It’s no wonder why Failoni’s has been around since 1957; they truly have mastered the art of making the best pizza in Stl! If you’re ever in the area looking for a great slice of pie, make sure you stop by Failoni’s for an experience that won’t soon be forgotten.

#5 Pizza-A-Go-Go

I was truly impressed by the quality of their pizzas. From the thin-crust options to the deep-dish creations, each slice is cooked perfectly and packed full of delicious toppings. The vegetarian options were especially impressive – they really know their stuff!

The atmosphere at Pizza-A-Go-Go is also great. It’s a friendly and relaxed place with excellent staff that are more than happy to chat about pizza with you. Plus, there’s usually some great live music playing too!

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery service, so if you want to sample what they have to offer, you’ll have to visit their restaurant in person. But trust me – it’s worth the effort! So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Stl, Pizza-A-Go-Go is definitely where you should go.

#6 Eni’s Pizzeria

My first experience at Eni’s was nothing short of amazing. When I walked in, the warm and inviting atmosphere instantly made me feel right at home. The staff were friendly, helpful and very knowledgeable about their menu offerings.

I asked for one of their signature pizzas, a classic cheese pizza done with their special blend of herbs, sauces and cheeses. The moment it arrived I knew this was going to be something special – the colors and aromas made my mouth water!

The crust was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crunchiness and the toppings were cooked to perfection. A true testament to the skill of Eni’s Pizzeria! I washed everything down with a craft beer from their extensive selection and savored every bite.

Overall, if you’re looking for a slice of pizza that will transport you back to your childhood then head on over to Eni’s Pizzeria – they really do have some of the best pizza in Stl!

#7 Pizza Head

First off, their crust is extra crispy and delicious. It’s perfectly cooked each time and it’s definitely a cut above other pizzas I’ve had around the world.

Second, their selection of toppings is out of this world. From classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage to more creative options such as bbq chicken and pineapple, Pizza Head has something for everyone.

The pies here have plenty of cheese and the sauce is flavorful without being too overpowering. All in all, Pizza Head serves some of the best pizza in Stl!

I wasn’t sure what to expect when I first walked in but I must say that I was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was casual and inviting with an overall comfortable vibe. The service was excellent and the staff were attentive to our needs.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Stl, look no further than Pizza Head!

#8 Onesto Pizza & Trattoria

Onesto offers the typical classic pizza combinations, but they also have some unique topping options that make their pizzas stand out from the crowd. But what really sets them apart is their range of alcoholic beverages, including hard liquor! Not many restaurants offer that, let alone a pizza joint.

This place also has something for everyone: there’s a kid’s menu for the little ones, some vegetarian options for those who prefer plant-based dishes, and a dessert menu for those with a sweet tooth.

The only downside to this place is that they don’t do delivery. You’ll have to come in and visit them to enjoy their delicious creations (which I highly recommend).

All in all, Onesto Pizza & Trattoria is the best spot in Stl for pizza lovers who love a good drink too. And if you’re looking to get your kids fed or just searching for some vegetarian options, you won’t be disappointed either.

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in St Charles!

#9 Slice Pizzeria & Pasta

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately struck by the classic Italian decor, which made me feel like I was in a pizzeria in Rome. The aroma of freshly baked pizza soon filled the room and my mouth began to water.

When it came time to order, I was met with friendly and knowledgeable staff members who knew exactly what kind of pizza I wanted. After several choices of delicious options, I decided on the signature “Slice Special”, a combination of mozzarella cheese, sausage, pepperoni, peppers and mushrooms that left me wanting more!

The pizza arrived steaming hot from the oven and I loved that it had a slight charring on one side which added to its flavor. The thick crust added just the right crispness while the toppings inside were cooked perfectly – not too crunchy or chewy. Every bite was better than the last!

Overall, Slice Pizzeria & Pasta is truly amazing and definitely offers some of the best pizza in Stl. It’s great for families or groups looking for an unforgettable dining experience. Just don’t forget to bring your appetite because you won’t want to miss out on any slice!

#10 Pizzeria Tivoli

I walked into Pizzeria Tivoli and the welcoming atmosphere made me feel right at home. The decor was cozy, the music was just the right volume, and the staff were incredibly friendly.

When it came to ordering my pizza I knew that I had to try their signature dish – a deep dish pizza with fresh spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, garlic and herbs. It was cooked to perfection and every bite oozed with deliciousness!

The toppings were generous yet not overwhelming and the dough was hand-tossed to perfection. The crust had a nice crunch but still maintained itself as being flaky and light. Every single ingredient added something special to each bite and all of that combined created an unbelievable flavor profile.

In conclusion, Pizzeria Tivoli has some of the best pizza in Stl! for anyone looking for a wonderful dining experience I highly recommend this place – you won’t regret it!

#11 Guido’s Pizzeria & Tapas

Let me start off by saying that all the ingredients are fresh and delicious. The crust is perfectly crisp and the sauce has just the right amount of zest to make it sublime. Seriously, their sauce rivals that of some of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever visited.

The toppings here are where Guido’s really shines. I had the must-try combination of pepperoni, mushrooms and onions and it was amazing. The pepperoni practically melted in my mouth! And usually when you order these types of pizzas at other places they skimp on the cheese, not here! Their pizzas come loaded with lots and lots of yummy cheesy goodness.

And if pizza isn’t your thing, they also have a fabulous selection of tapas that are sure to please any palate. Everything from classic Spanish dishes to modern fusion cuisine – they have it all!

Overall, Guido’s Pizzeria & Tapas is a hidden gem that you should definitely check out if you’re looking for some truly amazing pizza in Stl. So what are you waiting for? Get out there and give them a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Monte Bello Pizzeria

When I walked in, the nostalgia of a classic Italian pizzeria was overwhelming. The atmosphere was warm and inviting with red and white checkered tablecloths, vibrant murals on the walls and a lovely outdoor patio under twinkle lights.

I decided to go for it all and try their signature “Monte Bello” pie, made with fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and roasted garlic. It was truly a flavor explosion! The crust was light and crispy while still being chewy in texture. The cheese was perfectly melted and the toppings were savory but fresh.

But that wasn’t the best of it – the service here was top-notch too! Our pizza arrived quickly after we ordered it (which doesn’t often happen at larger restaurants) and our server was friendly and attentive. They even brought out complimentary breadsticks with dipping sauces as an extra surprise!

All in all, Monte Bello Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for amazing Italian cuisine. You won’t be disappointed by this gem in Stl!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Pi Pizzeria – Central West End

I stumbled upon this gem while wandering the streets of the Central West End, on a mission to satisfy my insatiable pizza cravings. As I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me, and I knew I was about to embark on a pizza adventure like no other.

The first thing that caught my eye was the sheer size of their deep dish pizzas. These things are massive! It’s like they took a regular pizza and put it on steroids. I had to do some warm-up stretches just to prepare my stomach for what was about to come.

But let’s talk about the taste. Oh my cheesy goodness! The crust was flaky and buttery, reminding me of a grandma’s love-filled pie. The toppings were plentiful and perfectly balanced, with just the right amount of cheese that stretched like a yoga master. It was a symphony of flavors inside my mouth.

The service at Pi Pizzeria was fantastic too. The staff was friendly and accommodating, willing to fulfill even my most bizarre pizza requests. I may have asked for pineapple on my deep dish, and they didn’t bat an eye.

Sure, eating a slice of deep dish at Pi Pizzeria is like running a marathon for your taste buds, but it’s totally worth it. So whether you’re a local St. Louisan or a visitor like me, make sure to check out Pi Pizzeria – Central West End. You won’t be disappointed. Just remember to bring your stretchy pants and a hearty appetite.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Pi Pizzeria – Central West End

From the moment I walked through the door, I sensed a slice of pizza paradise awaiting me. The staff, as warm and inviting as a fresh pizza out of the oven, greeted me with a smile that could rival the Mona Lisa. I knew right then and there that this was going to be a pizza experience for the books.

Now let’s talk about the pizza itself. Oh mama mia, where do I even begin? The thin crust was so thin, I could practically see through it! It was like a delicate, crispy blanket, perfectly encasing the heavenly toppings. The flavors were just as impressive as the crust – a symphony of tangy tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and a harmonious combination of toppings that danced on my taste buds like a well-choreographed salsa.

And the variety! They had toppings I never even thought could grace a pizza. I mean, who would have thought that figs and prosciutto could be such a tantalizing pairing? Pi Pizzeria knows how to push the boundaries and make pizza a work of edible art.

The ambiance of this place is just as captivating. The rustic brick walls and cozy booths make you feel like you’re dining in a classic New York pizzeria, but with a touch of Midwestern charm. The staff’s attire, complete with chef hats resembling miniature pizzas, added a touch of whimsy that had me chuckling throughout my meal.

In conclusion, if you’re a pizza lover like me, do yourself a favor and head straight to Pi Pizzeria – Central West End. Your taste buds will thank you, and you’ll be singing Mama mia, that’s some good pizza! all the way home.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Pizzeoli Wood Fired Pizza

From the moment I stepped foot into this pizza joint, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of the burning wood instantly transported me to a small Italian village, where pizza is a way of life. As I approached the counter, I could see the pizza chefs tossing dough in the air with the precision of acrobats. It was a sight to behold!

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. The crust, oh the crust! It was perfectly charred and had just the right amount of crunch. It was like biting into a cloud of pizza perfection. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the cheese was ooey-gooey deliciousness. Each bite was a symphony of flavors dancing on my taste buds.

And let’s not forget about the variety! Pizzeoli offers a wide range of toppings, from the classic margherita to more adventurous options like prosciutto and arugula. Whether you’re a traditionalist or a risk-taker, there’s something for everyone.

But what really sets Pizzeoli apart is the friendly and entertaining staff. They’re always ready with a joke or a funny story to make your dining experience even more enjoyable. It’s like having a pizza party with your best friends!

So if you’re in the mood for a wood fired pizza that will make your taste buds sing and your belly happy, head on over to Pizzeoli. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. And don’t forget to save room for their mouthwatering desserts. The Nutella pizza is out of this world!