Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Stuart FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Stuart FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

153 Views

Having been to over 50 countries, I understand what goes into making a good pizza, and I’m ready to share my top 12 pizza places in the area. If you’re like me and take your pizza seriously, then listen up. I’m about to discuss the best of the best.

That said, keep an open mind — this list isn’t all cheese and tomato sauce. You’ll find wood-fired ovens, delicious toppings, and some real interesting takes on classic pies. Let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Vesuvio’s Pizzeria

I decided to take a break from the usual Italian-style pizzas that I usually try and give Vesuvio’s a chance. From the moment I stepped inside, I was impressed. The interior of the restaurant is stylish and modern, with just the right touches of traditional Italian flair.

The menu features all sorts of different toppings and styles of pizza – everything from classic margherita to more adventurous combinations like pesto, shrimp, and feta cheese. But don’t worry – their classic recipes are done right too!

Once I had ordered my pizza (it was their 4 cheese blend special), it didn’t take long until it arrived at my table. As soon as I tasted the gooey cheese and crispy crust, I knew it was love! The combination of flavors was just perfect – just the right amount of tomatoes, garlic, oregano, basil, cheeses… It was truly heavenly!

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Stuart FL, then look no further than Vesuvio’s Pizzeria! Their delicious pizzas never fail to hit the spot – seriously, this place is an absolute must-try for any pizza lover!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Port St. Lucie!

#2 Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza

The place is always bustling with happy customers, and the atmosphere is lively. I love to see a pizza place that has so much enthusiasm!

Their menu offers a variety of delicious options from classic Chicago-style deep dish to thin crust varieties and even build-your-own pizzas. The toppings are fresh and abundant, making for a tasty treat no matter what you decide to order.

The service here is friendly and attentive, not to mention quick. I never have to wait too long for my order! Plus, their prices are very reasonable which makes it easy for me to enjoy their amazing food without breaking the bank.

All in all, Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza has earned its reputation as one of the best places for pizza in Stuart FL. The next time I’m in town, I’ll definitely be returning!

#3 Original Anna’s Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting. You almost feel like you’re getting a slice at your grandmother’s kitchen table, with the smell of delicious pies wafting through the air. The staff is friendly, making sure all my questions were answered and offering great recommendations.

When it comes to the pizza itself, I can honestly say that Original Anna’s Pizza rivals some of the best pizzas I’ve had in Italy! From their classic New York-style slices to their creative specialty pies, every bite was bursting with flavor. The thick crust was flavorful and slightly crispy while the cheese was melted to perfection. The fresh toppings added layers of flavor and texture to every slice – what more could you ask for?

In short, Original Anna’s Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza places around! If you’re ever looking for an amazing pie in Stuart FL, this is where you should go!

#4 Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza

When I first stepped in the door, I was greeted by warm, inviting aromas of tomato sauce, cheese, and freshly baked crust. The atmosphere is cozy and upbeat – just the kind of setting you’d want before diving into a delicious pizza.

The menu features several classic pizzas like pepperoni and cheese plus some more unique combinations that all looked incredible. I opted for their signature Brooklyn Joe’s Special with pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage and banana peppers. It was cooked to perfection with a golden crispy base and the perfect amount of sauce – definitely a cut above your average frozen pizzas!

To top it all off, the service is top-notch! The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that my experience at Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza was one to remember.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Stuart FL then look no further than Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza!

#5 Uncle Giuseppe’s Lil Bit A Brooklyn

The atmosphere here is great, with dark wood paneling and vintage beer signs adorning the walls. But it’s the pizza that really stands out. The thin-crust pies are out of this world, with a perfect balance of crunchy and soft textures. The toppings are generous, fresh, and flavorful.

The service here is also top notch; friendly and fast. I love how they let me choose whatever toppings I want – from classic pepperoni to exotic pineapple – so that I can make my own custom pizzas! They even had a gluten-free crust available, which was a nice surprise.

Uncle Giuseppe’s Lil Bit A Brooklyn is definitely my top pick for the best pizza in Stuart FL! I highly recommend you give it a try if you’re ever in town!

#6 Nancy’s Italian Restaurant

Sure, there’s pizzas with fusion flavors and those with unique toppings, but good ‘ol cheese pizza is where Nancy’s really shines. The crust is crispy and chewy at the same time: the perfect combination for an amazing bite. And their sauce? It’s to die for! I don’t know what kind of secret herbs and spices she puts in her marinara sauce, but it has a flavor that will keep you coming back for more.

To top it all off, the price is just right – definitely one of the best value-for-money pizzas I’ve ever had. So if you’re in Stuart FL looking for some great pizza that won’t empty your wallet, look no further than Nancy’s Italian Restaurant!

#7 Fantini’s ‘New Haven Style’ Apizza Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar

The owner, James Fantini, has perfected the New Haven-style pizza that seems to be everywhere in this area. The thin crust is perfectly cooked and slightly charred, making it crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, with a perfect balance of crunch to chew.

Toppings are fresh and plentiful – I opted for some of my favorites: sausage and mushrooms. Their house special Italian red sauce was sweet but tangy – just enough to bring out the flavors without overpowering them. To top it off, the robust flavors of their signature mozzarella cheese made for a delicious combination that left me wanting more!

I also enjoyed their wine selection, which included something for everyone – from white wines to robust reds. And if you’re feeling adventurous, you can always go for one of their specialty cocktails – I tried their Fig Martini and loved it!

So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Stuart FL, look no further than Fantini’s ‘New Haven Style’ Apizza Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Jupiter!

#8 Salerno Pizza

The first thing that impressed me was the décor, which was cozy and inviting. The staff were friendly and helpful, which made me feel right at home.

When it came to the pizza itself, I was blown away by the flavor. The sauce had just the right amount of spice and the cheese melted perfectly over the crunchy crust. The toppings were fresh and flavorful too, making every bite delicious!

The atmosphere at Salerno Pizza is lively and fun but still family-friendly. I can definitely see myself coming back time and time again for their scrumptious pizza! I have yet to find a better place for the best pizza in Stuart FL; Salerno Pizza comes highly recommended from this foodie!

#9 Roma Pizzeria & Restaurant

On my recent visit to Roma, I was instantly impressed with the quality of their pizza. Not only was the crust perfectly cooked and crispy, but the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It almost felt like I was in Italy, enjoying a slice of authentic Italian pizza!

The overall atmosphere at Roma is great as well. The place is small and quaint, yet still comfortable. The staff are friendly and helpful – they made sure to accommodate all of my requests as well.

In summary, I can confidently say that Roma Pizzeria & Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Stuart FL. If you’re ever looking for an amazing slice of pizza while in town, look no further than Roma!

#10 Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

The pizza here is cooked in an 800-degree coal burning oven, which creates a unique smoked flavor that I’ve never experienced before. Every time I’ve ordered the pizzas have been cooked to perfection – with just the right amount of crunchiness on the outside and softness in the middle.

The toppings are also outstanding! They use fresh ingredients like parmesan cheese and soppressata which add another level of flavor to this already delicious pizza.

And of course, the wings! Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings specializes in wings, and for good reason — they’re some of the best I’ve ever had! The crispy skin paired with their secret sauces creates an amazing combination that really has to be tasted to be believed.

If you’re looking for great pizza and want to experience something truly unique, head over to Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings — you won’t regret it!

#11 Blaze Pizza

From the moment I stepped into the cozy restaurant, I was floored by the ambiance. Everything from the smell of fresh dough in the air to the upbeat music playing, the restaurant just had a great vibe.

The pizza itself was even better! With delicious thin crust and amazing toppings, it sure was a treat. They give you plenty of options to customize your own pie or select one of their signature pizzas, but honestly what stood out most to me was how fresh everything tasted. The combination of perfectly crisp crust and juicy toppings made for an unforgettable dining experience.

The staff were friendly and very helpful in helping decide what kind of pizza would be best for me – they know their stuff! Even better? The prices are totally reasonable, so it won’t break your budget.

Overall, I can proudly say that Blaze Pizza is one of the absolute best pizza places in Stuart FL – if not THE best place! So if you’re looking for a great slice (or two) while in town, definitely stop by Blaze Pizza and thank me later!

#12 Casa Giuseppe’s Italian Grill

I had heard so much about their pizza before visiting that I knew I had to try it for myself. As soon as I opened the door, I was hit with a delicious smell of freshly baked dough. The restaurant itself is very cozy and inviting, and the staff are incredibly friendly.

The pizza is truly something special. It has a light, fluffy crust and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Every bite is full of flavor. For those looking for something a bit spicier, they have an amazing selection of specialty pizzas that take things up a notch.

My favorite part? The prices! You get an incredible meal at an even better price. It’s hard to find this level of quality at such a low cost in Stuart FL.

Overall, Casa Giuseppe’s Italian Grill is a must-visit destination for any pizza lover in need of some seriously delicious pie!