Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Tallahassee FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Tallahassee FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

340 Views

In my years of globetrotting, I’ve sampled some of the best pizza the world has to offer. But with nearly endless choices now available, it can be overwhelming to decide where to go. To make it easier on you, I recently visited 12 different pizza places in Tallahassee and can confidently say that these are the best spots to get your pie fix!

I’m sure your mouth is already watering from all the delicious possibilities – don’t worry, I’m here to help! In this article, I’ll share which pizza joints in Tallahassee actually live up to their reputation as well as a few hidden gems you won’t want to miss out on. So sit back, get ready for a culinary journey and let’s find out what’s cooking around town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Solle’s Pizza

I was immediately hooked on this place when I saw the delicious toppings spread across their menu. There are more than 20 options for any type of pizza-lover looking for something different and exciting.

Their crusts are always baked perfectly and just the right thickness. The tomato sauce is always fresh and flavorful, and their cheese is perfect every single time.

The service at Solle’s Pizza has been top notch too. Every server has been quick to answer my questions and make sure I had everything I needed. They’ve been very knowledgeable about the menu too, which is great!

Overall, I’d highly recommend Solle’s Pizza to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Tallahassee FL! The atmosphere is great, the food is amazing, and the service is incredible – what more can you ask for?

If you’re willing to go an extra 79 miles, you can get to 54 more pizza places in Panama City Beach!

#2 Blaze Pizza

This restaurant has really impressed me. From the delicious Neapolitan-style pizzas to the inviting atmosphere, I felt at home while enjoying my meal. The staff was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, quickly explaining their menu and making sure that my pizza was cooked just the way I wanted it.

In terms of the food, Blaze Pizza is on another level! Not only is their crust perfectly thin and crispy, with a pleasantly charred flavor, but their selection of toppings is vast and varied. Whether you’re looking for traditional Italian options or something more exotic, there’s sure to be something for everyone here. To top it all off (literally!) they also offer a great variety of sauces; from sweet bbq to spicy habanero – each one adding an extra delicious layer of flavor to your pizza.

For me, Blaze Pizza truly lives up to its name; it’s undoubtedly the best pizza in Tallahassee FL!

#3 Parks Twisted Pizzeria and Grill

The first thing that struck me about Parks was the sheer variety of their menu. It took me several minutes to decide on what I wanted, but ultimately I chose an ‘Arancini Twist’ pizza – a delicious combination of arancini, ricotta cheese and garlic sauce.

I then waited in anticipation as my pizza was cooked to perfection in their wood-fired oven. The smell of the smokey oven and the sight of the expertly crafted dough was enough to make my mouth water!

When it arrived at my table, it didn’t disappoint: the crust was perfectly thin and crunchy with a hint of smokiness. The toppings were delicious and well balanced, giving each bite just the right amount of flavor.

I’m not exaggerating when I say this is some of the best pizza I have ever eaten! The texture was perfect and every ingredient tasted truly fresh.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Tallahassee FL, look no further than Parks Twisted Pizzeria and Grill – some would even say it’s the best pizza in town!

#4 Riccardo’s Restaurant

As soon as I walked in and was greeted by the friendly staff, I knew I was in for an amazing experience. Upon ordering their famous pizza, I could tell why it had such a great reputation – the flavor was out of this world!

The menu is extremely varied and the selection of vegetarian options impressed me. Even more impressive were the alcoholic beverages available! Not to mention, there’s also a kid’s menu for my little ones.

Of course no trip to Riccardo’s would be complete without trying one of their delicious desserts – they are insanely good! The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery service.

I highly recommend Riccardo’s Restaurant if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Tallahassee FL!

#5 Tour of Italy

I was impressed with the variety of pizzas they offer, from classic Italian favorites like Margherita and Prosciutto to unique creations like Funghi e Salsicce. The crusts were perfectly crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside. The cheese was nice and melted and their homemade sauces were rich and flavorful. Even their vegetable toppings were fresh, crunchy, and full of flavor!

But what brought me back again and again is the fact that Tour of Italy makes some truly unique pizza creations! I love trying new things and these guys don’t shy away from experimentation. I mean, who else would combine Nutella with banana slices for a delicious dessert pizza? Or mix balsamic vinegar with mushrooms to make a zesty vegetarian option? Crazy stuff like this keeps me coming back time after time!

To top it all off, the staff at Tour of Italy is friendly, helpful, and always up for a laugh. They make it easy to visit this place regularly without feeling overwhelmed or bored with the same old choices. All in all, it’s why I recommend Tour of Italy as having some of the best pizza in Tallahassee FL – it’s unbeatable!

#6 Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana

From the second I stepped through their doors, I could tell this place was special. The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting, just what you would expect from a pizzeria. But then there is the pizza… Oh my, it’s delicious!

I started off with their Margherita pizza and it blew me away. The flavor was absolutely outstanding – the crust thin and perfectly charred around the edges. The sauce had a delicate sweetness that balanced beautifully with the tangy cheese. And the basil added an extra spark of freshness that really brought it all together.

Next up was one of their specialty pies, the Funghi e Salsiccia. This one definitely won me over too! The topping combination was unique and flavorful, complimenting each other perfectly. The mushrooms were roasted to perfection while the sausage added enough spice to take it to another level. Overall, it was an absolute delight!

If you’re ever in Tallahassee FL looking for a great slice of pizza, Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana is where you should go! Their commitment to quality ingredients and delicious recipes make them one of the best places in town for authentic Neapolitan-style pizza. Trust me – this place will not let you down!

#7 Momo’s Pizza – Tennessee Street

This place is great; from the moment you arrive, the inviting aromas of Italian spices waft up your nose and get your mouth watering. The interior decor is bright and welcoming, with a fun and vibrant atmosphere – it’s clear that customer satisfaction is a priority here!

I had the pleasure of sampling their signature ‘Momo’s Special’ pizza. This drool-worthy dish combines pepperoni, mushrooms, peppers, sausage and mozzarella cheese. It was cooked to perfection; the crust was perfectly crisp on the outside while still being soft and airy in the center. The toppings were fresh, flavorful and generously portioned – this certainly isn’t your typical pizza joint!

For dessert I decided to try their delicious chocolate brownie topped with Nutella ice cream. Nowhere else will you find such a decadent sweet treat!

Overall my experience at Momo’s Pizza – Tennessee Street was outstanding. The quality of their pizza rivals that of any world-class pizzeria I have visited before. With expertly crafted pies and incredible desserts, this restaurant has earned its title as the best pizza in Tallahassee FL!

#8 Uncle Maddio’s Pizza – Mahan

I was pleasantly surprised at the wide variety of toppings, none of which seemed like a typical “filler” topping. I decided to go with the classic margherita pizza and it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the tomatoes and cheese provided a delightful flavor combination.

The service was also top-notch. From the time I stepped in the door until my pizza arrived, I felt well taken care of. The staff were friendly and attentive, which made for the perfect little Italian experience!

I’m happy to report that this restaurant lived up to its name as one of Tallahassee’s best pizzerias. From the fresh ingredients to the fast service, Uncle Maddio’s Pizza – Mahan is definitely worth checking out for anyone looking for an authentic Italian experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 87 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Panama City Beach!

#9 Brickyard Pizzeria

I’m not sure what kind of magic I encountered during my visit, but the pizza here was truly exquisite. As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I was met with the smell of fresh ingredients and a warm atmosphere. The staff greeted me with enthusiasm and made sure my experience was top-notch – who knew pizza could be so luxurious?

The pizzas here are surprisingly unique, featuring some custom toppings that you won’t find anywhere else. From their signature pan-style creations to their classic thin-crust masterpieces, they had it all. The ingredients were always fresh and the combinations were always tantalizing.

Even though this place is a little pricier than other pizzerias in town, you definitely get what you pay for. Each bite is worth every penny; Brickyard Pizzeria’s pies will take you on a journey full of flavor and experience that can’t be found elsewhere!

If you’re looking for one of the best pizzas around Tallahassee FL, then Brickyard Pizzeria should definitely be your go-to spot! The food is out of this world and guaranteed to satisfy any pizza lovers out there!

#10 Uncle Maddio’s Pizza – Apalachee Parkway

I was taken back by the variety of options Uncle Maddio’s offers. You can pick from 48 different toppings to build your own pizza, and they have a wide selection of pre-made pizzas too! To top it off, you have the option to make your pizza with vegan, gluten-free, or ancient grain dough. What more could one ask for?!

The pizza itself was delicious! The crust was perfectly crispy and not at all greasy. We sampled some of the specialty pizzas – BBQ Chicken & Bacon Pizza, the Green Monster Veggie Pizza and the Four Cheese White Pizza. Every bite was like an explosion of flavor in my mouth!

The staff at Uncle Maddio’s were also delightful. They were incredibly friendly and went out of their way to make sure we had a great experience. Plus, their prices are quite reasonable considering the quality of their product.

It’s safe to say that I am thoroughly impressed with my experience at Uncle Maddio’s Pizza – Apalachee Parkway! If you’re looking for excellent pizza in Tallahassee FL, look no further than this restaurant!

#11 Midtown Pies

The first thing that drew me in was the atmosphere. The place had a great energy and the staff was incredibly friendly. I felt like I had stepped into an old-fashioned Italian pizzeria.

The pizza selection is impressive – they have all of your favorites as well as unique creations that are sure to please even the most discerning pizza lover. My favorite is the Margherita – it’s savory, cheesy, and just the right amount of spicy!

I also have to mention their amazing homemade crusts: crispy yet chewy – perfection! And if you’re feeling creative, you can always build your own pie with whatever toppings you choose.

Overall, Midtown Pies has really nailed pizza perfection. From the friendly service to the delicious pies, every visit is a new experience and I can’t wait to come back soon!

#12 Blaze Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant was very inviting and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. The pizza ovens in the open kitchen gave it a great look and feel, plus you can watch them make your pizza right in from of you – which I always enjoy.

The pizza itself was delicious! They give you a wide selection of toppings to choose from and the crust had just the right amount of crispiness. I also really liked that they have vegan options as well, so everyone can find something they like.

My favorite part about Blaze Pizza is that everything is customizable – you can make your own personal pizza from scratch and they’ll make it for you. It’s like having a little piece of Italy right here in Tallahassee!

I highly recommend Blaze Pizza for anyone looking for some great tasting pizza. In my opinion, it’s definitely the best pizza in town!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Munchies Pizza

First of all, let’s talk about the size of these pizzas. They aren’t kidding when they say deep dish. I mean, this thing is deeper than a conversation about taxes with my accountant. I almost had to scale it with a rope and harness to conquer this beast. But hey, I’m Edward the food critic, and I fear no pizza!

Now, let’s move on to the flavors. Munchies Pizza doesn’t hold back when it comes to toppings. They stack them high like a game of Jenga played by a madman. The cheese stretches as far as the eye can see, and each bite is an adventure into pizza paradise. And don’t even get me started on the tomato sauce. It’s so perfectly balanced that it’s like Shakespeare wrote a poem just for my taste buds.

The crust deserves its own paragraph, or maybe even its own symphony. It’s crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside. It’s like the versatility of a chameleon, adapting to the flavor of each bite like a culinary superhero. One moment you’re tasting the herbs and spices infused in the dough, and the next you’re transported to a world where crust reigns supreme.

In conclusion, Munchies Pizza offers the best deep dish pizza in tallahassee, and possibly the universe. The flavors are out of this world, the size is jaw-dropping, and the crust is simply magical. So, if you’re in the mood for an unforgettable pizza experience that will leave you stuffed and smiling like a Cheshire cat, head on over to Munchies Pizza and thank me later.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Decent Pizza

First off, let’s talk about the fact that this place serves alcohol. I mean, what’s better than washing down a slice of pizza with a cold beer? It’s the perfect combination of carbs and liquid courage. And if you prefer something a little stronger, they’ve got you covered with their cocktail menu. Pizza and a martini? Sign me up!

Now, I’m not a vegetarian myself, but I do appreciate when a pizza place offers some veggie options. Decent Pizza definitely does not disappoint in this area. They have a whole range of delicious vegetarian toppings that even carnivores like myself can’t resist. It’s like they’re sneaking veggies into my diet, and I’m not even mad about it.

What’s a good meal without dessert, am I right? Decent Pizza knows that a meal isn’t complete without a sweet ending, so they offer a variety of desserts to satisfy your sweet tooth. From gooey chocolate lava cake to creamy tiramisu, they’ve got it all. I don’t know about you, but I’ll take dessert with my pizza any day.

Now, here comes the downside. Decent Pizza, despite its name, does not accept reservations. So if you’re planning on going during peak hours, be prepared to wait. But hey, that just means more time to enjoy the tourist spot that Decent Pizza is. Strike up a conversation with the locals or play a game of I Spy with the funky decor. Trust me, the wait is totally worth it.

So there you have it, folks. If you’re in tallahassee and looking for the best thin crust pizza, look no further than Decent Pizza. You won’t be disappointed, unless you’re disappointed by having too much fun while waiting for a table. But hey, at least you’ll have a tasty slice to comfort you.