Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in The Hamptons (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in The Hamptons (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

251 Views

I’ve been around the world – from Rome to Tokyo to Chicago and back – tasting pizza in my quest to find the best. Luckily, I don’t have to venture any farther this time for a great slice of cheesy goodness. My tastes have been honed over years of searching, so you can trust that when I say something is good, it’s really, really good.

Today, I’m here to review the 12 best pizzerias in The Hamptons and let you know which ones will make your stomach and taste buds the happiest. So sit back with an ice cold drink (and maybe some antipasto), and get ready for my lighthearted yet informed opinion on the best pizza in The Hamptons!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Slice of the Hamptons

Their dough recipe is top notch, crunchy, thin and flavorful. The sauce is delicious with a slight sweetness that really brings out the flavors, and the toppings are fresh, robust and high-quality – all perfectly balanced.

And then there’s the atmosphere – it feels like you’re in your grandma’s house! The warm, cozy ambience is perfect to share with friends while you eat some of the best pizza I’ve had in a long time.

They even have gluten-free options if that’s your thing. I’m not gluten-free but tried them anyway, just to get a sense of what they could do and wow, it was great!

All in all, Slice of the Hamptons is one of my new favorite pizza places. Best pizza in The Hamptons? Absolutely!

If you’re willing to go an extra 26 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Montauk!

#2 La Capannina

I was first struck by the friendly atmosphere of the restaurant, that paired perfectly with my own joyous attitude. The menu was extensive and filled with a variety of pizzas to suit everyone’s palate. I ended up ordering the specialty – the “La Capannina special” – which was everything I had dreamed it would be: tangy sauce, a thin crust, and a generous helping of cheese!

The pizza itself was cooked to perfection. The fresh basil and tomatoes added in gave it an extra something special. I also really enjoyed the garlic-infused olive oil topping that kept me coming back for more.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in The Hamptons, La Capannina should definitely be on your list!

#3 Scotto’s Pork Store

I have to say, I was very impressed with the atmosphere. The pizzeria has a warm and inviting vibe that screams “family time!” It doesn’t feel like an ordinary pizza joint – it’s cozy and rustic, yet very modern. The decor is even more charming and the staff is super friendly.

The food? Absolutely delicious! From the classic margherita pizza to their creative specialty pies, every flavor hits the spot. Each slice is loaded with melted cheese, fresh ingredients, and just the right amount of sauce. Plus they use quality ingredients which really amps up the flavor profile. The crust is also incredible – tender and crisp at the same time.

When it comes to finding some of the best pizza in The Hamptons, you won’t be disappointed by Scotto’s Pork Store. Their Italian-American classics will bring back fond memories of mom’s home cooking on those special occasions!

#4 Sam’s Restaurant

When I visited Sam’s, I was immediately struck by its authentic charm. It’s got a warm, inviting atmosphere and the staff couldn’t have been more welcoming. Plus, they serve alcohol (and hard liquor!), which is perfect for when you want to cut loose after a tough day of exploring.

The food itself was amazing – especially the pizza. Everything I tried was flavorful and cooked to perfection. Plus, Sam’s has some great vegetarian options and even a kids menu, which makes it perfect for bringing your family or a group of friends to dinner. And if that’s not enough, they also offer dessert!

My only complaint would be that Sam’s doesn’t offer delivery – so you’ll have to actually go there if you want their best pizza in The Hamptons! But trust me, it’s worth the trip.

#5 Francesca’s

I visited Francesca’s a few weeks ago to see if the rumors of their delicious pizza were true. When I arrived, the atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a pleasant outdoor seating area for al fresco dining. Their menu was filled with some interesting combinations, like fig and prosciutto pizza, which I had to try.

The fig and prosciutto pizza was cooked to perfection – the crust was perfectly crisp on the outside and soft on the inside, while the toppings were perfectly seasoned with just the right amount of herbs and cheese. The best part was that they used only fresh ingredients; no frozen or processed ingredients here! And what really sets Francesca’s apart from other places is their unique take on traditional Italian flavors. I found myself wanting more than one slice!

Overall, I would highly recommend Francesca’s for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in The Hamptons. Their commitment to quality ingredients, creative flavors, and friendly staff will make you feel like you’re eating at an Italian trattoria! If you’re ever in The Hamptons looking for great pizza, do yourself a favor and go to Francesca’s – it’ll be an experience you won’t soon forget!

#6 103 Bambinos Pizzeria

My recent visit to 103 Bambinos Pizzeria was nothing short of extraordinary. Upon entering the restaurant, I could immediately smell the mouth-watering aromas wafting from the kitchen. The atmosphere in the restaurant is cozy and inviting and the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming.

The menu offers a wide variety of creative topping combinations, so I opted for one of their specialty pies: the all-star with roasted red peppers, anchovies, garlic, mushrooms, and olives. It was absolutely delicious! Every bite was jam-packed with flavor and I savored every last morsel.

For dessert, I had their classic pepperoni pizza dipped in hot fudge sauce – talk about divine! This decadent treat really put an exclamation mark on an already amazing meal.

In summary, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in The Hamptons then look no further than 103 Bambinos Pizzeria!

#7 Pellegrino’s Pizza Bar & Restaurant

The pizza itself is divine – perfectly cooked with just the right amount of cheese, sauce, and toppings. And if you want somethign a bit different, there are some great vegetarian options as well!

Add to that the fact that Pellegrino’s serves alcohol (and hard liquors too!), and you’ve got yourself a perfect night out. The chocolate lava cake is insanely good for dessert – it’s like heaven on a plate!

The only downside to Pellegrino’s is that they don’t offer delivery. But honestly, who needs delivery when the restaurant itself is such an amazing tourist spot in The Hamptons?

All in all, I highly recommend Pellegrino’s Pizza Bar & Restaurant for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in The Hamptons. You won’t be disappointed!

#8 Brunetti Pizza Westhampton Beach

The pizza here is made with top notch ingredients, and you can really taste the quality in every bite. Plus, they have some tasty vegetarian options that are sure to please even the most dedicated carnivores.

In terms of atmosphere, I was pleased to see that they offer alcohol (and hard liquor!) which makes it a great spot for a night out with friends. And their indoor decor gives it a nice tourist spot feel – perfect for when friends come to visit.

One downside? Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery, but this isn’t really a problem since their pizzas are so delicious you won’t want to wait to get your hands on them!

And lastly, Brunetti Pizza Westhampton Beach offers dessert – so if you’re still looking for something sweet after indulging in their delectable pies – this is definitely the place for you!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in The Hamptons then look no further than Brunetti Pizza Westhampton Beach – I can guarantee that it’ll exceed your expectations!

If you’re willing to go an extra 34 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in New London!

#9 Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza

My experience here was one for the books. From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for something special. The place had a great atmosphere and a warm, inviting ambience that made me feel right at home.

The pizza itself is out-of-this-world amazing. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, while the toppings are incredibly fresh and flavorful. The marinara sauce is both zesty and aromatic – just how it should be.

And let’s not forget about the cheese! It’s gooey, melty, and downright indulgent. It’s no surprise why this place has become so popular with locals and tourists alike.

My only gripe? The wait can be quite long during peak hours, but that’s to be expected with any great pizza joint like this one.

Overall, Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza has won my heart as far as best pizza in The Hamptons goes. I’m already looking forward to my next visit!

#10 Tonino’s Pizza

I couldn’t believe how delicious the slices were! The crust was perfectly thin, yet still had a crisp crunch. The sauce was homemade and the cheese was flavorful and well-distributed around the entire slice.

The slices were large enough that I could share with friends, but small enough that I could eat it all by myself! Plus, their selection of toppings were top-notch. From pepperoni to mushrooms, there’s something for everyone.

The best part of my experience at Tonino’s Pizza? The staff! Everyone greeted me with a smile and made sure that my order was tailored to my liking. They went out of their way to make sure that I had an enjoyable experience – from start to finish!

Overall, Tonino’s Pizza lives up to its reputation as some of the best pizza in The Hamptons. Highly recommended for anyone in the area looking for a great slice of pizza!

#11 East Quogue Pizza & Deli

The pizza was absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked, just the right amount of crunch, and the ingredients were all fresh. I loved that they put extra love in their dough and sauce—it really made it stand out.

I also had the chance to try some of their specialty pies and they certainly did not disappoint! From the Quogue Supreme to the Primavera, every single pie was packed with flavor and absolutely delicious.

What I found truly enjoyable about my visit is that the atmosphere matched that of a traditional Italian deli – complete with old-school arcade games in the corner. It reminded me of the classic family dinner experience that’s so hard to come by these days.

Finally, the service here was top-notch. Everyone from the cashier to our waitstaff was friendly and accommodating. We were well taken care of throughout our meal and felt like we genuinely mattered to them as customers – which made it all worth it in the end!

To sum it up, East Quogue Pizza & Deli is definitely one of my favorite pizza restaurants in The Hamptons and well worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

#12 Uncle Joe’s

The moment I stepped inside Uncle Joe’s, I knew this place would be special. The atmosphere was inviting, the staff friendly and welcoming, and the smell of fresh-baked pizza teased my nose.

When it came time to try the pizza, I was not disappointed! The crust had a perfect crunch that gave way to an avalanche of savory toppings. The sauce was tangy and flavorful without overpowering the other flavors. As for toppings, I sampled several different types and each one was delicious in its own way. Whether you like classic pepperoni or something more exotic like pineapple and ham, there’s something on Uncle Joe’s menu for everyone.

To top it all off, Uncle Joe himself stopped by to greet me at my table with a friendly smile! It was clear he had put a lot of care and thought into creating great pizza experiences for his customers.

In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in The Hamptons then look no further than Uncle Joe’s!