Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Toms River NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Toms River NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

362 Views

But let’s get right to the heart of the matter: which Toms River pizza places offer the *best* slice of ‘zza? I’m here to answer that question! I’ve traveled all around the world tasting pizza, so you can be sure I have a discerning eye for what makes a great pie. After visiting 12 different locations in Toms River, it’s time to figure out which ones reign supreme. Join me on this surprisingly delicious journey and find out which restaurant wins my stamp of best pizza in Toms River NJ.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 J Leno’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

The first time I stepped foot in this establishment, I was awestruck by the incredible aroma that surrounded me. The strong smell of freshly-baked pizza and warm marinara sauce filled the air, and my mouth began to water!

The restaurant’s decor was cozy yet inviting, with a bright red sign on the door that said “Welcome to J Leno’s Pizzeria”. The servers were friendly, professional and extremely knowledgeable about their menu items.

I decided to try their signature dish – The Supreme Pizza – which consisted of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and onions on top of a perfectly cooked crust. When the pizza arrived at my table, I can honestly say that it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

The crust was golden brown and crispy on the outside with a soft layer underneath for optimal chewy goodness. The toppings were generous portions and perfectly seasoned.

I also had a chance to sample some other menu items, such as their chicken parmigiana sandwich and garlic breadsticks. Both dishes were equally delicious – they had an amazing flavor while still being light enough to still taste good after eating all that pizza!

Overall, J Leno’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for the best pizza in Toms River NJ. Their prices are reasonable and the food is delicious – what more could you ask for?

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Brick Township!

#2 Marie’s Pizza

The crust was perfectly thin and crispy – not the thick, floppy mess you usually get in Jersey. The sauce was the perfect balance of sweet and tangy, and the cheese had just the right amount of stretchiness. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, with no skimping on portions.

Aside from the delicious pizza, there’s something special about Marie’s that sets it apart from other pizzerias: they take pride in their craft. Every pie is made with a care that most places lack. I could tell that every ingredient was lovingly selected and prepared.

I would highly recommend Marie’s Pizza to anyone looking for great pizza in Toms River NJ! It’s hard to beat them when it comes to quality, taste, and value – they definitely have some of the best pizza around!

#3 Mia’s Pizza Toms River NJ

The atmosphere at Mia’s is really what sets it apart from all the other pizza places I’ve visited. The decor focuses on 1980s nostalgia, with arcade machines and a jukebox playing all of the classic hits. It gives a great feeling of comfort and relaxation while dining, as if you’re eating in your own living room!

The pizza itself, however, is what makes Mia’s stand out from the rest. Every single slice is cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of crunch in the crust and gooey cheese blended harmoniously with fresh tomatoes and herbs. Many times I’ve been served pizza that was either over or undercooked; but never at Mia’s!

To top it off, their customer service is second to none; my server was always patient and helpful, ensuring that my experience was enjoyable every time. It’s not often you find a restaurant like this – one that cares about its customers and strives to make each visit special.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Toms River NJ, look no further than Mia’s Pizza! After eating there several times I can confidently say that it really is one of the finest establishments around. Highly recommended!

#4 Pondrelli’s Pizza And Kitchen

Upon entering the restaurant, I was welcomed with a warm and inviting atmosphere—the kind of place where you feel like you’re part of the family. The staff were all exceptionally friendly, which made my experience all the better.

I decided to order the Specialty Pizza: a delicious combination of sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, garlic & basil. To say it was delicious would be an understatement! The crust was thick and crunchy yet light at the same time. The toppings were fresh and flavorful—the perfect balance of sweet and savory.

The details were also noteworthy: each slice was cooked to perfection (not too soft or too crispy), and service was quick despite being busy. It almost felt as if I had somehow stumbled upon some hidden pizza gem in Toms River NJ!

All in all, Pondrelli’s Pizza And Kitchen totally blew me away with its incredible pizza—no wonder they’re considered one of the best pizza places in Toms River NJ! If you happen to find yourself in this neck of the woods, be sure to stop by Pondrelli’s Pizza And Kitchen for an unforgettable pizza experience!

#5 LT’s Pizzeria

I had the opportunity to try their classic pepperoni pizza and it did not disappoint. The crust was cooked to perfection – crisp on the outside and soft and fluffy on the inside. The sauce was flavorful, with just a hint of spice to give it a kick without being overpowering. And the pepperonis were cooked perfectly – crispy around the edges and juicy in the middle.

The service at LT’s Pizzeria was also top-notch. The staff were friendly and accommodating, always making sure that I had everything I needed or wanted. They even gave me some pointers on the best way to enjoy my slice – warming it up in their wood-burning oven for an extra crunch!

Overall, I can confidently say that LT’s Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Toms River NJ, if not all of New Jersey! So if you’re ever looking for a delicious slice of ‘za, stop by LT’s Pizzeria and let them do what they do best.

#6 Schiano’s Pizza Toms River

Let me start off by saying that their pizzas are made from the freshest ingredients and have the most amazing flavor. The crust is perfect – crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside – just how I like it. On top of that, Schiano’s Pizza Toms River has an extensive menu with creative topping combinations that make for some truly unique pizzas.

But what really sets Schiano’s Pizza Toms River apart from other pizza places is the atmosphere. It’s a cozy neighborhood restaurant where everyone knows each other and there’s always a friendly face ready to greet you at the door. Plus, they keep their ovens blazing all day (and night!) so you can be sure to get a hot, fresh pie whenever you’re in the mood for something tasty.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Toms River NJ, look no further than Schiano’s Pizza Toms River! Their delicious pies speak for themselves and their friendly atmosphere makes for a great experience every time. So don’t miss out – treat yourself to a meal at Schiano’s Pizza Toms River!

#7 Sal’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped through the door, I could tell that this place was something special. The interior had an inviting atmosphere, and the staff were friendly and helpful.

When my pizza arrived, it was a thing of beauty! It was perfectly cooked with an amazing crust, delicious toppings and just the right amount of cheese. Every bite was full of flavor and left me wanting more.

I’m not usually swayed by words or fancy decor, but Sal’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria certainly impressed me! Not only is the pizza some of the best in Toms River NJ, but the atmosphere is friendly and inviting. This restaurant is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

#8 Italy’s Best III

My taste buds were instantly tantalized as soon as I stepped into the restaurant. The aroma of pizza dough and toppings wafted through the air, inviting me to sit down and dig in. As I looked at the menu, I couldn’t help but notice all of the delicious options that they offered; from classic cheese pizzas to more exotic creations, they had a wide variety of options to choose from.

After careful deliberation, I finally decided on a specialty pizza that included artichokes, fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic and italian sausage. When my food arrived at the table, my eyelids almost rolled back in delight. The pizza was cooked perfectly – not too hard or too soft – and each bite left me wanting more. The slight crunch of the crust paired perfectly with the creamy flavors of the cheese and toppings.

In summary, Italy’s Best III has some of the best pizza in Toms River NJ! Their amazing pies are made with quality ingredients that give them an unforgettable flavor every single time. If you’re looking for great pizza in this area, look no further than Italy’s Best III!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Seaside Heights!

#9 Capone’s Gourmet Pizza & Pasta

The atmosphere at Capone’s was perfect for a casual meal out with friends. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that our experience was enjoyable from start to finish.

Now onto the food! I sampled a few of their pies, and they were each amazing in their own way. Their Thin Crust Sicilian is light, airy, and cheesy – all the characteristics of a great pie! Then there’s their classic Deep Dish: robustly flavorful and generously topped with cheese and other toppings of your choice. And let me tell you, I definitely made the right decisions by opting for the pepperoni and extra cheese!

Their other menu items were also delicious, like wings, paninis, subs and salads. But nothing quite beats the pies at Capone’s Gourmet Pizza & Pasta. Truly worthy of being dubbed “the best pizza in Toms River NJ”!

#10 Naples Pizza & Restaurant

The atmosphere of the restaurant was cozy and inviting, I immediately felt at home. The staff were attentive and accommodating, asking how they could make my experience even better.

The pizza itself was exceptional. The crust was just the right balance of crispy and chewy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The margherita pizza with fresh basil leaves that I had was delicious!

But the real star of the show has to be the ranch dipping sauce – trust me when I say you’ll want to slather your crust in it! It’s one of the best things about Naples Pizza & Restaurant, hands down.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Toms River NJ, look no further than Naples Pizza & Restaurant!

#11 Johnny G’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

As soon as I stepped inside, I could smell the waft of fresh dough and tomato sauce that was enough to make my mouth water. The decor was a nice mix of old-school Italian charm and modern vibes – definitely a place locals would feel comfortable.

The pizza is nothing short of amazing – you can tell it’s made with love! There’s something special about their unique dough which captures the perfect combination of crunchy crust and chewy center. On top, they use high quality ingredients like cheese, pepperoni and other delicious toppings. Every bite is absolutely filled with flavor and texture!

I have to say that Johnny G’s is one of the best pizzerias I’ve ever visited – truly living up to its tagline: “Nothing Compares To The Best Pizza In Toms River NJ!”

#12 Rosato’s Pub & Pizzeria

I have to admit, I was skeptical when I arrived. The restaurant had a charming atmosphere, but the pizza looked so ordinary that I thought there was no way it could be as good as everyone said. Boy, was I wrong!

The crust was perfectly crispy and held together under the weight of its toppings. And those toppings were glorious! Each bite was filled with a variety of flavors that left me wanting more. From the cheese to the sauce to the meats and vegetables, each ingredient added something special to my pizza – like a culinary masterpiece in every slice.

But what makes Rosato’s Pub & Pizzeria stand out from the other pizza joints is how fresh their ingredients are. There’s nothing like biting into a hot slice of freshly prepared pizza that melts in your mouth.

Overall, this place offers some of the best pizza around. It’s definitely worth making the trip out here if you’re looking for an impressive pie!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Mangia Brick Oven Pizza – Toms River, NJ

Upon entering this joint, I was greeted by the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked dough and simmering tomato sauce. I swear, the scent alone made my mouth water like a leaky faucet. I rushed to a table like a kid on Christmas morning, already salivating at the thought of sinking my teeth into their legendary thin crust.

As I admired the cozy atmosphere, I couldn’t help but notice the friendly staff, who were eager to guide me through their extensive menu. They seemed genuinely thrilled to have a connoisseur like me in their midst. I asked them what made their thin crust stand out, and they whispered an ancient, pizza-making secret that had been passed down through generations. If I told you, I’d have to eat you.

Finally, my pizza arrived, and it looked like a masterpiece. The thin crust was so thin that I could see through it, just like my excuses for skipping the gym. I took a bite, and it was love at first taste. The crust was perfectly crisp, like biting into a cloud that had been bronzed to perfection. The toppings were fresh, bursting with flavor, and the cheese was stretchier than a yoga instructor on a rubber band.

I devoured the entire pizza within minutes, leaving no evidence behind except a satisfied grin and a trail of crumbs. Mangia Brick Oven Pizza has officially stolen a fat slice of my heart. If you’re ever in Toms River, NJ and craving the best thin crust pizza in town, don’t waste your time anywhere else. Go straight to Mangia. Your taste buds will thank you, and your waistline will curse you, but it’ll be worth every bite.