Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Tuscaloosa (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Alabama

Best Pizza in Tuscaloosa (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

138 Views

I’ve eaten pizza in some of the most renowned cities around the world, from Italy to Chicago, and now I’m back in Alabama looking for a slice of success.

I set out on a mission to find the best pizza in Tuscaloosa—a daunting task that led me to 12 different pizza places. What I found was an array of intriguing flavors, unexpected ingredients, and creative takes on classic Italian dishes.

Come along with me as I take you on my journey through Tuscaloosa’s delicious slice of heaven!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Alabama

#1 Zee Delight Pizza

I was blown away by the incredible atmosphere. The restaurant had a relaxed vibe, with classic pizza-joint music playing on the radio. The staff also made me feel like family, as if I was eating at a friend’s house instead of a restaurant.

The food itself is truly delightful. They have an impressive selection of pizzas, ranging from classic cheese to more adventurous topping combinations such as barbecue chicken and jalapeno peppers. The crust is thin and crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful.

To top it all off, they offer generous portions at reasonable prices. Whether you’re dining in or ordering out, you won’t be disappointed.

In short, Zee Delight Pizza has some of the best pizza in Tuscaloosa — no two ways about it! If you haven’t had the pleasure yet, do yourself a favor and stop by soon!

If you’re willing to go an extra 47 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Birmingham!

#2 Mellow Mushroom Tuscaloosa

It’s a great tourist spot, with its lively atmosphere and fantastic menu. The pizza is made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection, which has become a signature of the Mellow Mushroom brand. Plus, they don’t skimp on toppings, so you’ll get your money’s worth!

Their menu is comprehensive, with something for everyone. There are vegetarian options for those that don’t eat meat, as well as a kid’s menu, so no one gets left out. Plus the fact that they serve alcoholic beverages (including hard liquor) is just the icing on top of the pizza!

Unfortunately, there’s no delivery service from this particular location. But that’s really my only gripe – it’s too bad that I can’t have their delicious pizzas delivered straight to my door!

But if you’re ever in Tuscaloosa and looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than Mellow Mushroom Tuscaloosa!

#3 PYRO’s Fire Fresh Pizza

As soon as I stepped into PYRO’s, I could tell this place was something special. The atmosphere was alive with excitement and the aromas coming out of the kitchen were tantalizing!

The pizza didn’t disappoint either. Every slice was cooked to perfection and loaded with delicious toppings. The crust was a perfect balance of crispy and chewy, and the sauces had just the right kick of spice.

I’d heard a lot about their signature “blade pie” – a thin-crust pizza that’s cut into narrow strips – and it definitely lived up to its reputation! It was light, crisp, and full of flavor.

Every time I visited PYRO’s, I left feeling satisfied and content. Their staff are friendly and welcoming, making sure every guest has a great experience.

If you’re in Tuscaloosa looking for some amazing pizza, then look no further than PYRO’s Fire Fresh Pizza – it’s undoubtedly some of the best pizza in town!

#4 Heat Pizza Bar

My favorite pie was the Chicken Parmesan pizza. Every bite was loaded with just the right amount of gooey mozzarella cheese and juicy chicken, making it a memorable culinary experience. The crust was perfectly cooked, with a delightful crispiness that had me wanting more.

The toppings bar is also worth mentioning as you can get creative and customize your order just the way you like it. From jalapenos to pepperoni, you’re sure to find something to satisfy your unique cravings!

Overall, I would highly recommend Heat Pizza Bar if you’re ever looking for great pizza in Tuscaloosa. I’d say they have some of the best pies around and I’m definitely coming back for more!

#5 DePalma’s Italian Cafe

I’ve been lucky enough to try pizza in Rome, Chicago and even Tokyo, but nothing compares to the classic Italian pies served up at DePalma’s. Their crust is always perfectly crunchy on the outside and nice and fluffy inside. The toppings are all fresh ingredients, with each pie never failing to delight my taste buds.

But it doesn’t stop there – their sauces are out of this world! They have a traditional marinara sauce that is packed with flavor, as well as unique variations like an herb-infused garlic-chili oil. Yum!

The atmosphere at DePalma’s also adds to its charm – it’s eclectic and cozy, complete with wooden chairs and an old-fashioned bar in the back. Plus, they have a great selection of craft beers and wines to pair your slice with.

I would highly recommend anyone looking for the best pizza in Tuscaloosa make a stop at DePalma’s Italian Cafe – you won’ t be disappointed!

#6 Blaze Pizza

The pizza here is very tasty, with a delicious combination of flavors and an amazing crust. The toppings are always fresh and the portions are generous. You can also get creative with your order, as they offer lots of great topping options.

The ambiance at Blaze Pizza adds to the experience. They have an open kitchen, so you can watch your pizza being prepared, which I find very entertaining! Plus, their pizzas cook pretty quickly in their blazing hot ovens -you’ll be able to enjoy your meal in no time!

Last but not least, their prices are quite reasonable for the quality of food you get. I’ve been all over the world tasting pizza, and Blaze Pizza is definitely among the best when it comes to value for money.

To sum up my experience at Blaze Pizza – if you’re looking for great pizza in Tuscaloosa, this is the place to go!

#7 Broadway Pizzeria South

I can honestly say I was hooked from the moment I stepped inside. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, and you can definitely tell that it’s a popular spot! The customer service was also top notch – everyone was friendly and accommodating.

As for the pizza itself, oh man, it was amazing! The dough was so light and fluffy, with just the right amount of crunch when you bit into it. The toppings were perfectly balanced between savory and sweet – no ingredient overpowered another. Plus, they offer tons of variations in their menu so there’s something for everyone!

To put it simply, Broadway Pizzeria South has earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Tuscaloosa – and I’m glad I finally got to try it for myself!

If you’re willing to go an extra 95 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Montgomery!

#8 Hunt’s brother pizza

From the moment I stepped into Hunt’s brother pizza, I knew it was different. The restaurant has an old-school vibe with a Tuscan-style interior and wood-fired ovens that leave their signature smoky flavor on each slice.

The crust is perfectly made: crispy on the outside and pillowy on the inside. It literally melts in your mouth! Every bite of pizza comes with a thick layer of gooey mozzarella cheese that’s flavorful enough to taste without being overwhelming. And topped off with lots of fresh toppings that add some crunchy texture and tons of flavor.

I’m happy to report that Hunt’s brother pizza not only serves up some of the best pizza in Tuscaloosa, but it also offers a great dining experience. The service was friendly and efficient and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. Plus, the prices are surprisingly affordable for such high-quality food – win win!

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Tuscaloosa, Hunt’s brother pizza should definitely be at the top of your list.

#9 Chuck E. Cheese

When I first stepped into Chuck E. Cheese, I was impressed with the atmosphere. The pizza place was decorated like a classic carnival that transported me to a childlike state of wonder. Everything from the bright colors to the lively arcade games were enthralling and gave me an instant smile on my face.

But I didn’t come here for ambiance, I came for pizza – and boy did they deliver! The pizzas were cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crunchy crust and gooey cheese. Toppings ranged from classic pepperoni to more creative flavors like pineapple and feta cheese – something for everyone!

What really stands out about Chuck E. Cheese is their portion sizes. Not only are their pizzas generously sized, but there are also incredible deals that make it even easier to enjoy a delicious meal without breaking the bank. Plus, if you’re looking for a lunchtime treat, they offer slices at incredibly affordable prices.

Overall, Chuck E. Cheese has some of the best pizza in Tuscaloosa as well as unbeatable prices – making it an excellent choice for anyone looking for an enjoyable dining experience!.

#10 Hunt Brothers Pizza

I’ve heard great things about Hunt Brothers Pizza, so I decided to visit this iconic restaurant during my time in Tuscaloosa. Located in a tourist-friendly area of town, I could tell right away that it was a popular spot.

The pizza was amazing: perfectly cooked, flavorful crust and lots of cheese! I especially enjoyed the Pepperoni Lover’s Dream, which had more pepperoni than I ever thought fit on one pie. The servings were pleasingly large too – one slice was more than enough to satiate my hunger.

The atmosphere was great too – people crowded around the counter talking and laughing as they waited for their pizzas to be served up fresh. Being a visitors’ spot, there were also plenty of options for souvenirs or local delicacies for sale!

The only downside is that Hunt Brothers does not offer delivery so if you want their fantastic pizza you have to head over there yourself. But trust me, it’s worth the trip! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Tuscaloosa, go to Hunt Brothers Pizza – you won’t regret it!

#11 Stewart’s Corner

This place really knocks it out of the park – their crust is light, fluffy, and just the right amount of crunchy. Toppings are plentiful and fresh and never skimped on. The sauce is bold and flavorful without being too spicy. And they always put a perfect amount of cheese, making this pizza simply divine!

The atmosphere at Stewart’s Corner is great as well. You can find a variety of seating options, whether you want to enjoy your meal on-site or take it with you for an impromptu picnic. There’s also some delicious side dishes, like their irresistible garlic bread sticks and cheesy bread.

The only downside I’ve noticed about Stewart’s Corner is that they don’t offer delivery. But that’s more than made up for by dine-in or takeout options – so you’re sure to find something to satisfy your pizza craving here! All in all, Stewart’s Corner has definitely earned its title as the best pizza restaurant in Tuscaloosa. Go give them a try!

#12 Domino’s Pizza

From the moment I walked through the doors, I knew I was in for a treat. The staff were friendly and made me feel welcomed. After scanning the menu, I settled on their cheese pizza and it did not disappoint! The sauce was perfectly balanced with the right amount of spice, and their cheese was melted to perfection.

Their crust is certainly what makes Domino’s stand out from other pizza places. It’s thin enough that you can pick it up and still have a great bite without it getting soggy or falling apart in your hands.

Overall, my experience at Domino’s Pizza was fantastic! While there are many choices for pizza in Tuscaloosa, this place definitely stands out among the rest as having some of the best pizza around town.