Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Tyler TX (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Texas

Best Pizza in Tyler TX (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

109 Views

In my search for the best pizza in Tyler, I’ve tried out no less than twelve establishments, and I’m happy to report that the city definitely has some tasty offerings. With a humorous and lighthearted tone, I’ll share with you my picks for the top three spots to get your fix of pies in this Texas town.

Whether you prefer traditional slices or something more creative and unexpected, this is sure to be the definitive guide to finding the perfect pizza in Tyler TX.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Texas

#1 Pizza Hut

The atmosphere of the restaurant was inviting and warm, with modern decor and a friendly staff. The menu offered an extensive selection of made-to-order pizzas, from classic cheese to more creative options like the Jalapeño Popper Pizza. I opted for the classic cheese pizza with light toppings, and boy was it good! The crust was perfectly crispy yet still soft on the inside, and the sauce was flavorful without being overpowering.

This is also one of the few pizza places that I have seen that offer a “Create Your Own” option. This way, you can customize your pizza to your exact specifications – just be sure not to get too crazy or you might end up with something inedible!

The service at Pizza Hut was top notch as well; they were fast and efficient while still taking time to answer questions about their menu items. Plus, they offer delivery so you don’t have to leave your house if you don’t want to.

Overall, I would highly recommend Pizza Hut if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Tyler TX. Great quality food in a comfortable atmosphere – what more could you ask for?

If you’re willing to go an extra 83 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Rockwall!

#2 Topp’s Pizza

The first time I tried it, I was blown away. The crust was perfectly crisp and chewy, the sauce was a perfect balance of sweet and tangy, and the toppings were top-notch. In particular, the pepperoni was a standout – thick slices that packed a flavorful punch.

I also appreciate the wide variety of toppings available on their menu. They embrace creativity when it comes to topping combinations, making it easy to craft a pizza that’s truly unique. Plus they offer some awesome specialty pies like “The Works” and “Taco Supreme”.

And if that wasn’t enough, they also have a great selection of beer and wine to pair with your pizza. So if you’re looking for a good pairing while indulging in some delicious ‘za (as we food critics call it), Topp’s Pizza is an obvious choice!

All in all – Topp’s Pizza is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Tyler TX – if not THE best! Highly recommended for any true pizza connoisseur!

#3 New York Pizza & Pasta

My experience at New York Pizza & Pasta was superb. As soon as I walked in, I felt like I was back in NYC! The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, and the staff were friendly and welcoming.

The menu had some of the classic pizza varieties from the Big Apple, including margherita, pepperoni, and even a vegan option! To top it off, they had some unique creations like their “Artichoke Delight” that really had my taste buds doing somersaults!

What really made this place stand out though was their mushroom-infused crust that created an unforgettable flavor combination. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside yet still soft enough to provide a great chew.

I also have to mention their garlic knots which were nothing short of heavenly. Soft pillowy puffs of dough-ey goodness drenched with garlic butter. Divine!

Overall, I have to say that New York Pizza & Pasta has earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Tyler TX. The hospitality is second-to-none and you won’t be disappointed by their authentic NYC-style pizzas or delicious sides. Highly recommended!

#4 Top It Off Pizza

From the moment I stepped foot in this outstanding establishment, I could feel how seriously they take their pizza making. The countertops were clean and shiny, giving off an air of supreme tidiness. Plus, the staff was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu items – from traditional pizzas to specialty creations.

It gets even better – the ingredients at Top It Off Pizza are top-notch! They use only fresh herbs, spices and vegetables to create a delicious flavor profile. And their dough is always cooked al dente for maximum crispiness! As I savored my first slice of the classic Margherita variety, I was impressed by its aroma and perfectly balanced taste.

The real highlight though? The atmosphere! There’s something special about enjoying a great pizza in a relaxing environment like Top It Off Pizza. TVs playing music videos add to the atmosphere while guests munch on delicious slices.

All in all, if you’re searching for the best pizza in Tyler TX, look no further than Top It Off Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!

#5 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

From the moment I stepped inside, I knew this was a special place – it had that cozy hometown feel you can only find in Texas. The warm and friendly staff made me feel right at home and were eager to share their pizza knowledge.

The process is super simple, too. You pick out your favorite ingredients and they assemble it fresh right in front of you. Then, all you have to do is take the pizza back home, pop it into the oven and enjoy!

I decided to try Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza’s signature pie – the “Gourmet Veggie.” It was baked to perfection with crispy dough on the bottom, zesty tomatoes, and gooey mozzarella cheese. The flavors blended so perfectly together that I almost felt like I was eating a gourmet meal in Italy!

Overall, I would say that Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is easily one of the best places for pizza in Tyler TX! If you’re looking for a delicious homemade pizza experience without breaking your wallet then this is definitely the spot for you.

#6 Sola Bread Co

Their menu is full of delicious options that will satisfy any palate, from traditional pizzas like Margherita to quirky creations like the Firebird with its spicy spread of jalapenos and bacon. There’s even something for vegetarians and those watching their weight, so everyone can get their fill.

But what really sets Sola Bread Co apart is that they serve alcohol. What’s there not to love? Whether you’re in the mood for a lager or some wine, Sola has got you covered. They have a wide selection of brews and wines so you can enjoy your meal with a cold beverage.

What I didn’t love was that they don’t offer delivery. Living on the road, it’s hard to get out to eat at an actual restaurant every night! But let me tell you: if you’re ever in Tyler TX, it’s worth taking the time to stop by Sola Bread Co for some delicious pizza and drinks. They definitely beat out any other pizza joint in town — this place is an absolute must-try for pizza lovers!

#7 Bruno’s Pizza

This fantastic restaurant has been a staple in the Tyler food scene for decades, and it has always been a must-visit spot for me whenever I’m in town. The pizza here is some of the best I’ve ever had, with a delicious sauce that complements the perfectly cooked crust.

The toppings are top-notch as well, with an array of fresh vegetables and high-quality meats. Plus, they’ve got something for everyone–from cheese lovers to pepperoni fans. My personal favorite is the Western Cowboy pizza, which features sausage, bacon, jalapeno peppers and BBQ sauce. It’s simply divine!

Not to mention the atmosphere at Bruno’s Pizza is lively and welcoming, making it a great place to spend time with friends or family over dinner. The service is efficient and friendly, too–you can’t ask for more!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Tyler TX, I highly recommend you check out Bruno’s Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 89 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Shreveport!

#8 Bruno’s | Pizza & Pasta

I had the opportunity to sample their amazing Cheese Pizza, which was perfectly cooked and had a delicious crunch. The cheese was creamy and flavorful, and the crust was lightly crispy. I also tried one of their specialty pies, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza – an absolutely delicious combination of chicken, buffalo sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Needless to say, it was incredible!

The atmosphere at Bruno’s | Pizza & Pasta is also great – they have a cozy dining room with comfortable seating and a pleasant décor. Plus they offer delivery and takeout options if you don’t have time to sit down for a meal.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Tyler TX, be sure to check out Bruno’s | Pizza & Pasta. Their incredible pies will have your taste buds singing!

#9 Rotolo’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere is great – it’s a casual, laid-back spot that really adds to the overall dining experience. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, so I didn’t have to worry about ordering something that I wouldn’t enjoy.

As for the pizza itself, it was incredible! It was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The crust was crispy yet fluffy – definitely one of my favorites! I also sampled some of their specialty items like the Sicilian Pizza and the Chicken Parmigiana Pizza, which were both amazing.

In conclusion, I highly recommend Rotolo’s Pizzeria – it’s definitely one of Tyler TX’s best pizzerias!

#10 Marco’s Pizza

When I first walked through the doors of Marco’s Pizza, I was skeptical. The decor was simple, and the place didn’t have much atmosphere. But as soon as I smelled that delicious, freshly made pizza, I knew I had come to the right place!

The pizzas are cooked to perfection – thin, crispy crusts with just the right amount of tangy tomato sauce and a combination of flavorful cheeses. Every bite is filled with amazing flavor and texture. The toppings are carefully selected and cooked to perfection too – no soggy pepperonis or overcooked sausage here!

The staff at Marco’s Pizza are friendly and helpful; they always have great advice on what combination of toppings you should try. They also offer delivery options so you can enjoy their delicious pizza from the comfort of your own home.

I think it’s safe to say that Marco’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Tyler TX! It consistently delivers fresh, delicious pizzas with an array of flavorful toppings that keep me coming back for more. If you’re ever in Tyler TX and craving a really good pizza, Marco’s is definitely worth checking out!

#11 Rounder’s Pizza

Let’s start with the crust. It’s thin and crispy, yet sturdy enough to hold all of the delicious toppings. The sauce is rich and flavorful, and the cheese is just the right amount of cheesy goodness.

I’m also impressed with the variety of topping options they offer. I especially liked their speciality options like the chicken parmesan pizza!

The atmosphere is really relaxed and inviting. The staff was friendly and attentive to our needs, which always makes for a great dining experience.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Tyler TX then look no further than Rounder’s Pizza! Their quality ingredients and tasty recipes make it worth every penny!

#12 Domino’s Pizza

The crust was perfectly cooked so that it was both crispy and fluffy. I love the fact that they offer lots of different toppings, including meats, vegetables, and cheeses. The sauce was a delicious combination of sweet and savory. My favorite part about the pizza was definitely the cheese – it was cheesy yet somehow light and airy.

I also appreciate their fast service. As soon as I stepped in the door, they had my order ready for me in just minutes. I ordered a large pizza with double cheese which came out piping hot and ready to eat!

To top off my meal, I got some delicious garlic knots that were perfectly fried with a nice crunch on the outside. They come with a side of marinara sauce which adds a nice touch to an already amazing dish!

Domino’s Pizza has been able to deliver some of the best pizza that I’ve ever tried – anywhere! If you’re ever in Tyler TX looking for great pizza then you need to give Domino’s Pizza a try.